historicism
A mode of thinking that interprets events as products of their specific historical context and emphasizes the unfolding of history, often associated with German thought.
As defined in Niall Ferguson
Other definitions
The philosophical view that truth is revealed through history and historical processes, as opposed to the view that truth can be eternally concealed through esoteric means.
Peter Thiel on "The Straussian Moment"
Where it comes up · 6
- Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences5 claims
- George Will on the Conservative Sensibility2 claims
- Niall Ferguson1 claim
- Dostoevsky and Nietzsche1 claim
- 74 | Stephen Greenblatt on Stories, History, and Cultural Poetics1 claim
- Husserl: Phenomenology and the Life World1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “historicism” →
- Progressivism succeeded because its proponents built an intellectual infrastructure in academia, much of it derived from German graduate education in the late 19th century, importing a Hegelian mysticism about History as an autonomous unfolding force with a capital H and an admiration for Bismarck's bureaucracy as administrator of history's wisdom.George Will on the Conservative Sensibility
- The historicist tradition's preoccupation with great-man leadership is partly driven by 19th-century publishing economics, since biographies sold well, creating an incentive to write them; thinkers like Meinecke who transcended great men were less commercially successful.Niall Ferguson
- Traditional ('old') historicism tried to recreate the cultural and historical circumstances that produced works of art, but it tended to suppress the weird fact that we can still be powerfully reached by these works without any contextual understanding—like finding a yellowed letter addressed to us by someone dead for hundreds of years.74 | Stephen Greenblatt on Stories, History, and Cultural Poetics
- A hard rule is one like a grammatical rule (every English sentence must have a verb—no exceptions); a soft or slippery rule is like the rule that a good essay should be broken into paragraphs—real and important but not precisely defined; we should not say that if a rule isn't well-defined it isn't really a rule, which would be the positivist mistake, nor should we say soft rules aren't knowledge, which would be the historicist mistake.Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences
- Hans-Georg Gadamer's hermeneutic project attempts to find a set of unifying principles that connect the soft sciences and escape the paradigms of historicism and positivism which he believed threatened Western philosophical tradition.Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences
- The great and demoralizing modern error is treating History as a proper noun—a force with its own autonomous inward logic, an idea Marx vulgarized from Hegel and Lenin weaponized into a vanguard party deserving dictatorial power 'on the side of history'; reading actual history cures this historicism by revealing how little people ever knew about what was coming next, and believing history has sides puts you in trouble immediately.George Will on the Conservative Sensibility
- Positivism and historicism both threaten the development of phronesis (judgment and practical wisdom) because positivism restricts knowledge to univocal, precisely defined rules while historicism, by emphasizing complete historical relativism, denies the possibility of any stable interpretive principles.Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences
- Hegel's historicism holds that philosophy is always 'its own time raised to the level of thought,' expressing how things appear from a particular society or culture at a particular historical moment, though he believes he can still identify universal absolute laws at a meta-level describing historical progressions of thought.Dostoevsky and Nietzsche
- Truth and Method is Gadamer's greatest work, published in 1960, as a reaction to dominant schools of thought particularly positivism and historicism; by the end of the book, having undermined both, he establishes the new discipline of hermeneutics.Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences
- At the time Gadamer was writing Truth and Method, methodological concerns, particularly the methodology of science, were central to philosophers, and the hope of positivists was that once the method of natural science was established beyond question, results of natural science would not be in doubt and we could move toward a unified science; Gadamer's response is that there may be a choice between truth or method.Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences