What this covers

This is a single-speaker lecture by Michael Sugrue on Hans-Georg Gadamer's Truth and Method (1960). It reads the book as a reaction against two dominant schools, positivism and historicism, and as an attempt to found hermeneutics as a unified account of interpretation across the "soft" sciences. Sugrue begins with the German sense of Wissenschaft, an organized body of knowledge that takes in theology and literary criticism as well as physics. He then sets out the background: Wilhelm Dilthey's split between law-generating and image-generating knowledge, the move from reason to Verstehen (Situated Understanding)), and Martin Heidegger's contributions of Dasein (Being-in-the-World)) and the Hermeneutic Circle.

The middle of the lecture is about what counts as knowledge. Drawing on Aristotle's point that one should not demand more precision than a subject allows, Sugrue presents Gadamer's distinction between hard rules, like grammar, and soft rules, like the advice to break an essay into paragraphs. Positivism errs by dismissing the soft kind, and historicism errs by denying that it yields knowledge. The argument that art discloses truth is flagged as contested: if Shakespeare teaches us anything, some knowledge must lie outside formulaic method. Gadamer's answer is Phronesis (Practical Wisdom)), a rule-governed judgment resembling tact. Sugrue also covers the aesthetics of play and language games.

The final stretch concerns temporality. Because we live in time, we are always drifting from our traditions and must reabsorb them, much as one rereads Plato at forty differently than at twenty. The Oedipus example shows a modern, Freud-inflected reading still constrained by continuity with ancient ones. Sugrue notes Gadamer's history of the concept of language from Plato through scholasticism, and ends with the unmentioned influence of this tradition on communitarian political philosophy, set against rights-based theories like those of Rawls and Dworkin.

Sharpest takeaway

Hans-Georg Gadamer's hermeneutic project offers a unified theory of interpretation across the soft sciences by establishing that knowledge need not be methodologically formulaic to be legitimate, recovering judgment and wisdom as valid forms of understanding that connect individual and collective cultural horizons through language.

  • Hermeneutics provides a 'skeleton key' to interpretation across all domains (art, psychoanalysis, literary criticism, law) by identifying the principle of transparency—knowledge is valid when the interpreter disappears and the thing itself is disclosed
  • Gadamer's framework of 'soft rules' escapes the false dichotomy between positivism's rigid certainty and historicism's radical relativism by showing that fuzzy, context-dependent rules can still generate legitimate knowledge
  • Gadamer's effective historical consciousness grounds knowledge in temporality and language, requiring constant reinterpretation of cultural traditions across generations rather than progress toward a final truth or eschaton

The claims · ranked36 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.84

Gadamer seeks to connect individual persons' horizons with the overall collective horizon of a culture as a whole, where both individual and collective horizons are constructed in language and within a culture's symbol system.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“what he's hoping to do is connect individuals the persons that get these this effective historical consciousness to enlarge their horizon of thought enlarge their horizon the domain of their experiences and then connect their individual horizon up with the overall general collective horizon of the culture as a whole the horizon and he uses that terms explicitly the horizon of a person or of a culture is constructed in language it's constructed within the domain of their symbol system”

0.80

Effective historical consciousness (Wirkungsgeschichte Bewusstsein) brings a person to a level of understanding that is not entirely consistent with univocal reason, but rather resembles phronesis—judgment that is rule-governed yet not precisely formulaic, involving tact, proportion, and what Aristotle called practical wisdom.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“Gadamer intends in his hermeneutic project to unify the soft sciences with the intention of bringing the person who is adopting this hermeneutic perspective into what's called veerkung chichlichus bervustein what that is it translates into english as historical effective consciousness or effective historical consciousness the idea is that it brings the person to a level of understanding or comprehension which is not entirely consistent or doesn't perfectly overlap the idea of reason univocal reason”

0.80

Gadamer reappropriates cultural traditions from Western intellectual history while altering them to be consistent with changes in the overall gestalt of knowledge produced by historical development.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“most of his intellectual project involves the careful reappropriation of cultural traditions but altering these cultural traditions so they are consistent with the changes in the overall gestalt of knowledge that is a product of historical development”

0.80

Hermeneutics is the science (Wissenschaft—organized body of knowledge) of interpretation; in German, 'science' refers to an organized body of knowledge that includes physics, theology, and literary criticism, whereas in English, 'science' refers almost exclusively to natural science such as physics, chemistry, or biology.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“hermeneutics might be defined as the science of interpretation now here we have to be very careful about the difference between german and english in german the idea of a science is a vicin shaft right an organized body of knowledge or statements whereas in english the domain of knowledge of science is more truncated it refers almost exclusively to natural science usually when we in english talk about science we're talking about physics or chemistry or biology or something like that in german when they talk about science they use the word vissenshoft and they just mean an organized body of knowledge which allows in the domain of physics but also includes things like theology literary criticism right”

0.80

A final, often-unmentioned influence of Gadamer and the hermeneutic tradition is communitarianism, a political philosophy movement that emphasizes the historical embeddedness of human communities, the common good, and appropriation of agreed-upon or consensually accepted historical traditions as an alternative to rights-based political philosophy (characteristic of theorists like Rawls and Dworkin).

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“a final influence for gotomer and this whole hermeneutic tradition and this is a one that is not often mentioned but i noticed it when i was reading contemporary political philosophy last couple of months is that a there's been a movement called communitarianism which is an alternative to the rights based political philosophy so characteristic of guys like i know rawls or dworkin or any of the the current legal thinkers or the most important mainstream legal thinkers and communitarianism here i'm thinking of people like golf ner sandel what they want to do is emphasize the embeddedness historically of human communities emphasize the common good and the appropriation of agreed upon or consensually accepted historical traditions”

0.80

The result Gadamer aims for is effective historical consciousness guided by language; by adopting this perspective, we make an ontological shift in our concerns from nature to man and from object to subject, corresponding to the move from Vernunft (reason) to Verstehen (understanding), from looking at the world from the outside to contemplating it from the inside.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“this uh effective historical consciousness will be a hermeneutics guided by language and what we will do if we adopt this perspective is move uh make an ontological shift in our concerns from nature to man and from object to subject this corresponds to the move from fernund to festan from reason to understanding from under from looking at the world from the outside to contemplating it from the inside”

0.80

Because human beings live in temporality (Dasein), they are constantly alienated from cultural traditions; the cultural traditions of last year have altered slightly and humans have moved away from them; this is why people must constantly reinvent and reabsorb cultural traditions to keep them alive.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Speaker

“we have to live in temporality and one of the results of that is that we are constantly because of the movement of time constantly alienated from cultural traditions in other words the cultural traditions of last year have altered slightly and we have moved away from them slightly in other words there's a line of in gertes faust where he says if you would inherit what you're from your forefathers you must win it again and new well what he is saying essentially is that if we wish to inherit the cultural traditions from our forefathers we must earn them ourselves anew”

0.74

Heidegger, Gadamer's teacher, introduces into Western philosophy the idea of Dasein—that being, time, temporality, and human existence are inextricably bound up; that language is caught up with being; and that being only exists in language (an overlap between the two); and the hermeneutic circle, which is essential to Gadamer's project.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“and this all leads up to gottamer's teacher and this makes all the difference in the world heidegger was gottammer's teacher and design is what gotomer's hermeneutics is all about in other words um heidegger introduces into western philosophy the idea of design that being and time temporality and human existence are inextricably bound up that language is caught up with being and that being only exists in language is sort of an overlap between the two and the final idea that he offers is what he is what uh heidegger calls the hermeneutic circle”

0.73

Dilthey and Windelbrand argue there are two kinds of knowledge: nomothetic knowledge that generates laws (like physics' f=ma), and idiographic knowledge that generates pictures or images characteristic of hermeneutic and soft sciences; hermeneutic sciences require Verstehen (understanding) rather than Vernunft (reason)—understanding from a human perspective rather than disembodied rationality.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“diltai was a late 19th century german writer who emphasized the idea that there were two kinds of knowledge he works with a guy named windowbond when he works this out but there are two kinds of knowledge according to vindlebond and uh diltai and what they say is that that one knowledge generates what he calls uh nomathetic results nomathetic means creation of laws so something like physics f equals ma there's a nomathetic result we see things moving around and then we talk about their force and their acceleration and we come up with f equals ma an alternative kind of thinking is what he calls idiographic something that generates pictures or images and the hermeneutic sciences the soft sciences are idiographic in this sense there's a big dual distinction between our knowledge of the external world which is nomathetic and our knowledge of the internal world of the psyche or the internal world of cultural symbolism that we know in a different way from the way we know natural science and what he says is that these ideographic disciplines require ferstein instead is the german idea of reason or the german term for reason but fair stan is the german word for under understanding and what we do when we understand something is understand it from the perspective of a human being”

0.73

A hard rule is one like a grammatical rule (every English sentence must have a verb—no exceptions); a soft or slippery rule is like the rule that a good essay should be broken into paragraphs—real and important but not precisely defined; we should not say that if a rule isn't well-defined it isn't really a rule, which would be the positivist mistake, nor should we say soft rules aren't knowledge, which would be the historicist mistake.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“we might think of this in some ways as being analogous to uh what i'll call soft and hard rules a hard rule is something like a grammatical rule for example every english sentence has to have a verb in it there's no doubt about that if it wants to be an english sense it has to have a verb in it there's no exceptions to the rule think about another rule which is equally real but much fuzzier much more slippery think about the rule that i often tell my students when i'm teaching them to write their compositions that a good essay should be broken up into paragraphs i mean all of you know that one with hope right there's a rule for paragraphing but the rule for the construction of grammatical sentences which tells us that every sentence must have a verb is much more precise and well-defined than the rule for paragraphs now i think it would be a mistake for us to say well then if it's not a well-defined rule it really isn't a rule i will mark down any paper that doesn't have paragraphs in it on the other hand if called upon to states specifically and precisely in the sense that grammar is stated what exactly is the rule for paragraphing i got to admit it's a fuzzy rule it's a soft rule it's a slippery rule doesn't define as precisely as grammatical or arithmetic rules well you might want to say then that hermeneutics this hermeneutics that's guided by language is a science of soft rules which says don't throw the baby out with the bath water all rules aren't hard that's the big mistake of positivism don't think that soft rules aren't really a kind of knowledge that's the mistake of historicism”

0.73

We go into texts or the domain of human culture with certain expectations; when our expectations are thwarted, we renew our interpretation and create a new set of expectations, then examine the text or world of culture again; eventually we renew our interpretation again in a process called the hermeneutic circle that is the logic of question and answer and goes on forever.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“what emerges is a sort of dialectical relationship between a text or the whole domain of human culture we go we go into that with certain expectations and eventually we find these expectations thwarted when our expectations are thwarted we renew our interpretation we come back we create a new set of expectations and we carry those around and examine the text of the world or the text of culture it gets toward it eventually we come back and we renew our interpretation this is called the hermeneutic circle it is the logic of question and answer it goes on forever we interrogate our culture we get a set of answers when we get a new or novel or surprising answer we have to reformulate our questions reformulate our background knowledge and then go back to work again”

0.73

The hermeneutic circle is not vicious but rather the normal human condition when we interrogate the realm of human symbols as opposed to knowledge of nature when that becomes our primary concern; it is the human condition, not a problem to be solved.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“so the hermeneutic circle is not a vicious circle it is simply the human condition when we interrogate our culture we get a set of answers when we get a new or novel or surprising answer we have to reformulate our questions reformulate our background knowledge and then go back to work again all right so the hermeneutic circle is not a vicious circle it is simply the human condition when we interrogate the realm of human symbols as opposed to knowledge when that becomes our pr or the realm of human symbols as opposed to nature when that becomes our primary concern in thinking”

0.73

Hans-Georg Gadamer's hermeneutic project attempts to find a set of unifying principles that connect the soft sciences and escape the paradigms of historicism and positivism which he believed threatened Western philosophical tradition.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“the hermeneutic project of hansger gottamer has been one of the most important and influential intellectual trends in post-world war ii high culture what he's attempted to do is find a sort of set of unifying principles which connects the soft sciences and which allows us to get outside the reigning paradigms of historicism and positivism which he thought threatened the tradition of western philosophy”

0.73

Aristotle holds that there are objective rules for constructing tragedies (as in the Poetics), and while aesthetic appreciation is subjective, it is not entirely subjective because there are actual objective rules for constructing tragedies; Gadamer thinks there are something like those objective rules for interpretation not just of tragedy but for whole domains of intellectual discourse.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“aristotle holds for example that there are rules for constructing tragedies if you've read the poetics and he agrees that while aesthetic appreciation is in some sense subjective it is not entirely subjective because there are actually objective rules for things like the construction of tragedies well what gotomer thinks is that there are something like those objective rules for the interpretation not just of tragedy but for whole domains of intellectual discourse”

0.69

Positivism and historicism both threaten the development of phronesis (judgment and practical wisdom) because positivism restricts knowledge to univocal, precisely defined rules while historicism, by emphasizing complete historical relativism, denies the possibility of any stable interpretive principles.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Speaker

“because positivism and historicism tend to undermine this sense of phrenesis this sense of judgment or wisdom what god ever wants to do is go back and reevaluate the theory of knowledge see where positivism and historicism went wrong and try and put western philosophy back on the right track”

0.66

Gadamer's sources include encyclopedic reach, emphasis on intellectual flexibility when evaluating different sorts of discourse, and Aristotle's idea of phronesis—all found in Aristotle and central to Gadamer's philosophy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“the source of gotom is very clearly aristotle if you think of what aristotle's approach to philosophy was the encyclopedic reach the tendency to emphasize intellectual flexibility when evaluating different sorts of discourse and most importantly the idea of phrenesis itself”

0.66

Aristotle's mark of an educated person—not demanding more precision from a subject than it can possibly give—is the foundation of Gadamer's approach: different domains of knowledge require different standards of precision, and it is a category error to apply geometric standards to aesthetics or ethics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Speaker

“aristotle was the one who said it is the mark of an educated man not to demand more precision from a subject than it can possibly give we do not allow for approximate geometry and we do not usually allow for deductive certainty in aesthetics rather we move and from one domain to another using different sort of hermeneutic principles different sorts of grounds for our evaluation”

0.66

Truth and Method is Gadamer's greatest work, published in 1960, as a reaction to dominant schools of thought particularly positivism and historicism; by the end of the book, having undermined both, he establishes the new discipline of hermeneutics.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“let's examine and given all these strictures let's examine truth and method which is gottamer's greatest work it's published in 1960 and it was a reaction to the dominant schools of thought particularly positivism and historicism and at the end of the book what he tries to do is having undermined both establish this new discipline of hermeneutics”

0.66

Art and aesthetics disclose human truth which is undeniable; even positivists in good faith cannot claim that art doesn't disclose information about the human world, but art discloses information not on the basis of a formula and is not necessarily univocal, which contradicts positivism.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Speaker

“the first is devoted to art and what he's the key thing for art and aesthetics as far as gotomer is concerned is that this discloses a human truth which is undeniable he says in good faith even a positives can't tell you don't learn things from shakespeare even the positives can't have the nerve to tell you that uh art doesn't disclose any information about the human world to you the problem is is that it doesn't disclose information it doesn't let you know things on the basis of some formula”

0.65

The fact that you learn something from reading Shakespeare establishes that there is knowledge not subject to formulaic method; if Shakespeare teaches anything, then we must ask what we learn and how we learn it without using precise scientific method; positivists cannot coherently deny that Shakespeare teaches us something while claiming knowledge can only come from scientific method.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“there is a that art contradicts any positivistic claim that i see the first time you read something like the complete works of shakespeare you learn something from it unless you're a complete dunder head if you do learn something from it then you have a good question to ask someone like karnap how is it possible that there can be knowledge that i get from shakespeare but there's no method for it how is it that i'm not following say popper's idea of the hypothetical deductive method how is it possible for me to get knowledge it seems that they are forced to tell you that shakespeare can't teach you anything and that's just a lie if they're going to concede that you learn things from shakespeare or from teishan or from any great artist if they're going to concede the point that you learn something from art then we must ask some very serious and pointed questions what do you learn and how do you learn it you sure don't learn it through any sort of precise scientific method”

0.56

Our interpretation of Oedipus now may differ from interpretations 2500 years ago because we are influenced by texts like Freud and may emphasize the Oedipal drama, sexual desire for the mother, and hatred of the father, but nonetheless there are certain facts about the Oedipus drama that must come through any successful interpretation; successful interpretation of Oedipus today must include these Freudian elements and other cultural additions while maintaining necessary continuity with successful interpretations of Oedipus 2500 years ago.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“think about the interpretation of oedipus back in the time of the ancient greeks and think of the interpretation of oedipus now although there are many changes between us and then and doubtless our interpretation of oedipus may have a great deal may have may have to deal with a great many other texts that have come to influence us since for example our staging of oedipus may have to have some sort of connection with fraud we may have to emphasize the edible literally the the sexual feelings for the mother in our interpretation of freud that made or our interpretation of oedipus that may not have been entirely necessary 2500 years ago but nonetheless there still are certain facts about the oedipus drama that must come through any interpretation if it is to be a successful or satisfactory or transparent interpretation so in other words our interpretation nowadays of oedipus in order to be successful and transparent and satisfactory we'll have to emphasize the edible drama and the sexual desire for the mother and the hatred of the father and it will have to include a great many other things that have been added to our culture that inform and deepen and enrichen the oedipus drama but there will be some sort of necessary continuity between a successful interpretation of oedipus today and a successful interpretation of 2500 years ago because it is alleged to be disclosing some ultimate fact about human life you cannot ignore that fact”

0.56

Gadamer brings in Kant and Schopenhauer on the objectivity of aesthetics and emphasizes that play and recreation are connected with representation; all aesthetic ideas are subsumed under the idea of a language game, and art as a whole is ludic (referring to games and play); Gadamer collapses the distinction between play, representation, and presentation to get a system of overlapping local language games with certain similarities but no unifying ultimate similarity allowing us to choose between them.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“here's where he brings in kant and schopenhauer on the on the objectivity of aesthetics and he also emphasizes the idea that play and recreation is connected with the idea of re-representation and all of these ideas are subsumed under the idea of a language game in other words for um for gottemer the idea of art as a whole is ludic in the sense that it is it refers to games and play and for gotham as a whole what he's going to end up doing is collapsing the distinction between play representation and presentation so that he gets a system of overlapping local language games which have certain similarities but no unifying ultimate similarity which allows us to choose between them”

0.56

In the last part of Truth and Method, Gadamer not only shows that we have reason to be suspicious of our cultural traditions and linguistic inheritances, but he also gives a history of the concept of language itself, going back to Plato and Aristotle, working through Thomas Aquinas and scholasticism, and bringing it up to Hans-Georg Gadamer, showing where the concept of logos and language has gone—an incredible intellectual tour de force.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“what in the last part of truth and method what heidegger what uh gotomer does which is a very impressive idea is not only does he show us that we have reason to be a little bit suspicious of our own cultural traditions a little bit suspicious of our own linguistic inheritances then the thing that he does is he gives us a history of the concept of language itself he says fine i'm going to appropriate the western cultural tradition he goes back to plato goes back to aristotle works on their concept of the logos and then writes us a small history of the concept of the logos of language that starts with the greeks moves through thomas aquinas and scholastic comes right up to hans georg gottemer and says this is where it goes to what an incredible intellectual tour de force”

0.53

If you read Plato at age 20 and Aristotle at age 25, but want to reclaim Aristotle and Plato later, you must read them again and reabsorb them based on changes in your knowledge, changes in society, and new thinking about Aristotle and Plato; this is not accidental but necessary due to temporality.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“i read plato when i was 20 i read aristotle when i was 25 but if i want to go back and reclaim aristotle and plato i must read it again and reabsorb aristotle and plato based upon the changes in my knowledge based upon the changes in society as a whole based upon our new thinking about aristotle and plato”

0.52

Language turns out to be the horizon of hermeneutic ontology; Dasein is disclosed to us when we absorb human culture; these fuzzy rules governing the soft sciences must be appreciated as an important contribution to the theory of knowledge.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“very very deep interpretation of what knowledge is and how knowledge works now language turns out to be the horizon of this hermeneutic ontology and it turns out the design is disclosed to us the kind of being characteristic of human beings comes to us when we absorb human culture right when we perform this hermeneutic activity and what's very important for us here is that these slippery rules have to be appreciated as an important contribution to the theory of knowledge”

0.51

Gadamer's theory of interpretation shows commonalities about interpretation across domains: literary critics interpreting literature, psychoanalysts interpreting patients' statements, actors interpreting characters like Hamlet or King Lear, and writers like Joyce interpreting and accommodating Western tradition—revealing a skeleton key to what makes all interpretations successful or unsuccessful.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“a theory of interpretation a way of thinking about interpretation itself that will move from one domain to another in other words he wishes to point out certain commonalities about interpretation that apply for example to the interpretation of literature by a literary critic to the interpretation of a patient's statements in the case of a psychoanalyst to the case of an actor interpreting someone like hamlet or king lear to the case of of a litter of say a literary writer like joyce interpreting the western tradition and then accommodating it and bringing it into his own work the idea then is that there's something about interpretation that holds it together and what gotom has searched for and perhaps found is the skeleton key to interpretation what is it that makes all interpretations either successful or unsuccessful desirable or undesirable”

0.51

Gadamer's view might be understood as a 'soft form of Hegelianism' or 'weak form of Hegelian progress'—we progress not toward an eschaton (final stage where the world ends and we reconcile with God) but away from permanent alienation from culture; the human condition requires living in temporality, which necessarily excludes and alienates us from culture, so we progress when we complete the hermeneutic circle and undo that alienation, making it a much smaller and more local claim than Hegel's.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“i think the argument would be something like this that what gottamer forces us to or directs us towards something what i would call a soft form of hegelianism that leaves off the more extreme claims made by hegel i would be inclined inclined to say that uh gautama's view is a sort of weak form of the hegelian progress of the geist the culture progresses not away not towards some eschaton some final stage of history where the world ends and we finally reconcile with god rather i think that gautama has us progressing not toward some eschaton but away from our condition of permanent alienation from the culture in other words the human condition is such that does that human the design requires we live in temporality temporality necessarily continually excludes us and divorces us and alienates us from culture we progress when we manage to complete the hermeneutic circle and go back to our cultural orientation and undo that alienation so instead of progress towards something in gautama i think we get progress away from something and that's actually a much smaller more local claim it's a lot easier to make that argument”

0.51

At the time Gadamer was writing Truth and Method, methodological concerns, particularly the methodology of science, were central to philosophers, and the hope of positivists was that once the method of natural science was established beyond question, results of natural science would not be in doubt and we could move toward a unified science; Gadamer's response is that there may be a choice between truth or method.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“it was a reaction to the dominant schools of thought particularly positivism and historicism and at the end of the book what he tries to do is having undermined both establish this new discipline of hermeneutics and you could almost call his book truth or method because at the time that he was writing methodological concerns particularly the methodology of science was a central issue for philosophers and the hope of the positivist at least was that once we had established beyond question the method of the natural sciences then the results of the natural sciences would not be in doubt and we could move on towards the idea of a unified science you know the great uh kind of a shimmer of the po of positivism and what gautama is saying is that it may be a choice between truth or method”

0.51

We have encountered both good and bad interpretations; we know when interpretation is good and successful insofar as we no longer see or hear the interpreter—in other words, the interpreter becomes transparent, allowing us to see the thing being interpreted rather than the interpreter.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“we have encountered good interpretations and bad interpretations how do we know which are which and how do we move from one genre of interpretation of another in others is there anything which makes similar the interpretation of hamlet that we get from an actor and the interpretation of hamlet that we might get from a director both are interpreting well what gottammer says is yes there is something that holds these together and this is the idea of transparency of apprehension in other words you finally have a good interpretation or an interpretation is good and successful or adequate insofar as you no longer see or hear the interpreter in other words what makes i don't know if and if you know classical music but uh what makes vladimir horowitz a wonderful romantic pianist who covers uh schubert and schuman and all those those romantic musicians beautifully because when he plays his playing is transparent”

0.51

Vladimir Horowitz's Romantic piano playing is transparent: when he plays Beethoven or Schubert, you don't hear Horowitz but rather the composer's music; by contrast, a beginning piano student generates sour notes and mistakes that make you hear the student rather than the music, making the interpretation opaque and weak.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“what makes vladimir horowitz a wonderful romantic pianist who covers uh schubert and schuman and all those those romantic musicians beautifully because when he plays his playing is transparent when he sits down to the keyboard you don't hear vladimir horowitz you hear beethoven or schubert when you now compare a very fine penis to a beginning piano student that's making all kinds of mistakes and generating all sorts of sour notes when you listen to that the reason why it gets on your nerves is because you're not hearing beethoven it's a bad interpretation you're not hearing schubert it's a bad interpretation what you're hearing is the poor student of the piano that's what makes their interpretation a weak one because you're hearing them rather than the music”

0.51

The transparency criterion extends beyond music to dramatic interpretation: Lawrence Olivier in Hamlet is successful because we see Hamlet rather than Olivier; a director interpreting Hamlet must decide on blocking, lighting, timing, and line delivery such that we see the play rather than the director's choices.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“think about the interpretation that would be offered to hamlet by a director i mean they have to decide things like blocking and lighting and timing and the way in which lines are delivered and the way in which the space of the theater is organized well gottemer would argue and i think this is a very deep thought that what would make for a successful or good or desirable interpretation of hamlet was and a director interpreting that in such a way so that we saw hamlet rather than joseph papp makes a certain amount of sense insofar as you see the artist or the interpreter then the interpretation is not a good one right it's too it's it's opaque rather than transparent insofar as you see the thing being represented rather than the representer then you have a transparent interpretation”

0.51

Gadamer has found something like the bones or vertebrae, the skeleton to interpretation that had been previously thought invertebrate; this allows him to find fuzzy or slippery rules that govern discourse without making knowledge less rule-oriented or legitimate.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“in other words he has found a sort of bones or a sort of vertebrae a sort of skeleton to interpretation which had been previously thought invertebrate do you see the advantages to this so what he's doing is finding something between the absolute univocal certainty of of say arithmetic and the infinite variety of mere questions of taste showing that there are certain what i would call slippery or fuzzy rules which govern this sort of of a discourse which govern all the soft sciences and that doesn't make them less rule oriented and doesn't make them less legitimate knowledge for that purpose”

0.51

As a result of Gadamer's hermeneutic stance, we become a little suspicious and thoughtful about our own language and concepts, acknowledging that everyone is influenced by their cultural traditions and we must be too; while we cannot avoid absorbing cultural traditions, we must be thoughtful and suspicious about the way we do so.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“one of the results of vietnam of gotomer's particular hermeneutic stance towards the world is that it makes you a little bit dicey a little bit suspicious about your own language and about your own concepts it tells you look everybody else has been biased influenced by their cultural traditions you must be too so although you can't avoid the burden or the charge of absorbing your cultural traditions you must be a little suspicious a little thoughtful about the way in which you do that”

0.51

Gadamer's approach is not the snake eating its own tail but the snake vomiting itself up—creation of something not quite out of nothing but out of historical decay and Dasein, exemplifying the hermeneutic activity of appropriating tradition.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“and it is it's the opposite of the snake eating its own tail it's the snake kind of vomiting itself up right it's it's the creation of something not quite out of nothing but out of historical deray out of design”

0.47

The claim that positivism restricts knowledge to the domain of human understanding of the physical world is false because our first and immediate apprehensions are of the human world—the world of signs, symbols, and communication—not the physical world, which is a secondary property proposition.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlydurability 4/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“this gives the lie to positivism this gives the lie to naturalism this gives the lie to all the claims which want to restrict knowledge to the domain of human interpre of human understanding of the physical world in fact we do understand the physical world as a sort of secondary property uh proposition but our first and immediate apprehensions are of the human world the world of signs the world of symbols and the world of communication”

0.47

Contemporary thinkers, in contrast to Gadamer, tend to take one idea as far to an extreme as possible (e.g., Foucault with postmodernism, Lévi-Strauss with structuralism) before breaking down under contradictions, whereas Gadamer seeks reconciliation between competing domains of knowledge to absorb the entire cultural tradition and offer a new encyclopedia.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unidentified Speaker — Gadamer: Hermeneutics and the Human Sciences [07DrmAkIoE4]

“one of the facts about contemporary thinkers is that they for the most part tend to take one idea as far in an extreme as they can uh if you see foucault taking post-modernism or levy strauss taking structuralism they take one idea and see how far you can extend that idea before it breaks down and before you engender certain contradictions gautama is very opposite to that tendency he is looking to make a reconciliation between all the competing domains of knowledge so that he can completely absorb the entire cultural tradition of the west and offer us a new sort of encyclopedia”