A hard rule is one like a grammatical rule (every English sentence must have a verb—no exceptions); a soft or slippery rule is like the rule that a good essay should be broken into paragraphs—real and important but not precisely defined; we should not say that if a rule isn't well-defined it isn't really a rule, which would be the positivist mistake, nor should we say soft rules aren't knowledge, which would be the historicist mistake.
factualpending
Evidence Quote
“hermeneutics this hermeneutics that's guided by language is a science of soft rules which says don't throw the baby out with the bath water all rules aren't hard that's the big mistake of positivism don't think that soft rules aren't really a kind of knowledge that's the mistake of historicism”
Created: 8/11/2026, 12:37:25 AM
Your notes
Loading notes...