freedom of contract
The legal principle that parties may agree to binding terms, raising the question of whether contracts can override fundamental notions of what property ownership entails.
As defined in Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!
Other definitions
The legal principle that private parties may freely make and enforce agreements, limited only by fraud, coercion, or harm to third parties.
Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
Where it comes up · 7
- Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good3 claims
- Doc Searls on the Intention Economy2 claims
- Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!2 claims
- Richard Epstein on the Constitution1 claim
- Cass Sunstein on #Republic1 claim
- Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/20061 claim
- Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/20091 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “freedom of contract” →
- Framing housing allocation as a 'rationing problem' that 'we as a society' must solve is itself an enormous concession, because there is no collective 'we'—houses are owned by individuals—so accepting that society rations privately owned property concedes the very moral point at the heart of the matter.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- The condominium form of ownership, invented around 1960 and imported from Germany via Puerto Rico to New York, was an ownership technology that made dense urban and suburban living possible, growing from essentially zero to nearly 80 million Americans, and its viability depended on the Nahrstedt cat case holding that associations—not individual residents—get the final say.Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!
- Although there are about 250,000 condominium associations in the US and in cities like Phoenix it is nearly impossible to buy a home outside one, they nearly all use the same pattern documents, so there is extremely little variation—meaning someone with an idiosyncratic preference (like keeping cats) may not actually find a community that suits them, undermining the assumed competitive diversity of associations.Michael Heller and James Salzman on Mine!
- Before the New Deal, courts invoking the 14th Amendment aggressively struck down laws interfering with freedom of contract or creating arbitrary impediments to economic liberty; after the New Deal the court abandoned that searching review and adopted an 'anything-goes' approach.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- If people actually read all the terms-of-service agreements they click through, it would consume roughly half the time they currently spend on the web, because the volume of prose is so high; these one-sided non-agreements are friction in the marketplace.Doc Searls on the Intention Economy
- Minimum wage laws have the same defect as a law banning contracts above a threshold: they are prospective and general but still violate freedom of contract, and the traditional argument that democratic majorities would never pass such laws because everyone is hurt is wrong, since minimum wage laws do exactly that.Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
- The destinationist (objectivist) argument against the minimum wage is that it wrongly interferes with the freedom of contract—an individual who wants to take a low-wage job to serve an apprenticeship and learn should be free to do so, and the state should simply not be permitted to forbid it.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- Offering someone a voluntary exchange cannot harm them, because they can always say no; if there are no other options available, then the price offered was justified in the first place—so an additional choice can never leave a person worse off.Michael Munger on the Perfect vs. the Good
- The marketplace would be more efficient if agreements were two-sided, achieved by having machine-readable code on both buyer and seller sides expressing good will and simple intentions—such as the customer requesting their own data back in a readable form or forbidding tracking by cookies and beacons.Doc Searls on the Intention Economy
- Government regulation is central, as Hayek rightly said, to the operation of a free market system because protecting property rights and freedom of contract requires government; therefore to oppose government regulation outright is inconsistent with the creed of those who believe in free markets, and the coherent position is to oppose only regulation beyond a specified catalog.Cass Sunstein on #Republic