
Richard Epstein on the Rule of Law 06/1/2009
What this covers
This is a conversation between Russ Roberts and Richard Epstein that starts from the distinction between a minimal and a robust rule of law. Epstein argues that prospective, general rules enforced by proper tribunals can still be oppressive. A ban on contracts above a set income, or a law legalizing squatting, would meet every formal test, and he says minimum wage laws and collective bargaining statutes fail in the same way. He then works through the Notice Function, retroactive punishment, and the special assessment. His example of a special assessment is a road whose cost is charged to only one side of the street. He criticizes Justice Holmes for sustaining such an assessment against a railroad in 1905.
The middle of the conversation is legal history. Epstein covers the police power and its health-and-safety core, crediting sanitation investments with rising life expectancy. He defends the result in Lochner on the grounds that the bakers' statute was a labor-market measure and not a safety rule. He traces the erosion of property and due process protections from the New Deal onward, including the 1937 shift on the Court and the court-packing plan. He reads the plan as a breach of an unwritten norm, not of any written law. He also quotes Woodrow Wilson's hostility to the separation of powers. On land use, he argues that restrictions on use are servitudes, which makes compensation under the Takings Clause unproblematic.
The last stretch applies these principles to 2008–2009. Epstein treats the Lien Priority Principle as the foundation of credit markets. He argues that the Chrysler bankruptcy put unionized pension and health funds ahead of secured bondholders, which he calls a taking. He grants that the Bear Stearns rescue preserved priority order but calls it a disastrous precedent. His account of the mark-to-market spiral, in which forced sales in correlated markets drag down other institutions, is one of the more contested claims. So is his claim that Bear Stearns was not short of cash in March 2008.
Epstein argues the rule of law requires generality, procedural fairness, and secure property and contract rights, and that the 2008-2009 bailouts and government-as-creditor-and-regulator interventions (Chrysler, Bear Stearns, AIG, zoning) violated those principles.
- Formal generality is insufficient; a robust rule of law requires limits on the state's power to take, retroactively punish, or coerce, which implies classical liberalism
- Courts and legislatures since the New Deal eroded takings, due process, and property protections, and Epstein traces the erosion through specific cases
- The government's role as regulator, creditor, and shareholder in the bailouts coerced parties and overrode the lien priority system that underpins credit markets
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Mortgages are non-possessory property interests that give the lender the right to take absolute title to collateral on default, and Epstein argues that lien priority is the core of the financial system because each creditor's interest and loan terms are calculated on the expectation that earlier liens are paid first.
“a mortgage is a non possessory interest in land it is essentially a right to say that if in fact you who have borrowed money from me do not repay it”
The rule of law prohibits imposing special restrictions or assessments on one class of individuals that are not imposed on another; in the road example, charging only east-side residents half the cost of the road while the road benefits both sides shifts income between classes, which is inconsistent with the rule of law regardless of substantive policy goals.
“you cannot in effect impose special restrictions on one class of individuals that you don't impose on another”
The rule of law prohibits retroactive punishment: people must be able to regulate their conduct by known rules, so a state cannot make legal conduct illegal after the fact. The state also should not be able to announce a future law to deter conduct and then decline to enact it, because that creates gaming between the state and citizens.
“we never ever ever want to give the state the ability to threaten you by announcing it will pass the law have you cut back on your conduct and then decide not to go through with the law at all”
Lien priority is critical to credit markets: first mortgagees must be paid in full before second mortgagees, who must be paid before equity holders, and lenders price risk based on this sequence, so bankruptcy that disrespects the ordinary priority system destroys credit markets.
“the world will fall into chaos if the priority system that exists outside of bankruptcy is disrespected inside of bankruptcy”
In Lochner v. New York the Supreme Court struck down a 60-hour-week and 10-hour-day bakers' statute, but Epstein argues the statute was a labor regulation designed to advantage union bakers over competitors (union bakers worked two shifts that kept them under the 10-hour limit), not a genuine health and safety measure, so the court correctly distinguished safety from interference with competitive markets.
“this was clearly a case of a differential regulation which was designed to advantage one competitor at the expense of another”
Mark-to-market (fair value) accounting can trigger a cascade: when a distressed institution must sell assets at depressed prices in a correlated market, the market revalues others' holdings downward, potentially making solvent institutions insolvent, and buyers wait for further distress, so forced sales spiral downward.
“you get a cascade that runs downhill at a very rapid rate”
The Supreme Court's shift in 1937 was driven by anticipated retirements and the prospect that Roosevelt would appoint new justices, and by the overwhelming 1936 Roosevelt victory; Justices Hughes and Roberts changed their jurisprudence, which Epstein reads as a response to electoral mandate rather than abject capitulation.
“everybody saw the writing on the wall in 1937 they knew that they would be retirements either that year or the next year”
Restrictions on lawful land use are a form of servitude that dates back to Roman times, and the common law already treats easements (rights to cross land) and restrictive covenants (rights to stop building) as property interests, so compensating restrictive land-use regulation requires no new property theory.
“the notion that somebody is taking a servitude as it's called by restricting your lawful uses of land goes back to Roman times”
Bear Stearns in March 2008 was not cash-flow negative: it was taking in more cash than it paid out on a current basis, so the real question was whether the value of its asset pool covered accumulated liabilities, which made the case distinct from a simple liquidity failure.
“they were actually taking in more money than they paid out the real question was whether or not the value of their asset pool was sufficient to cover the accumulated liabilities”
The Bear Stearns rescue kept the priority order intact: shareholders were largely wiped out, falling from about $300 to $2 per share and eventually receiving about $10, which Epstein says is correct accounting; but he considered the rescue a disastrous precedent because it would teach people to expect bailouts whenever a firm got into trouble.
“my attitude about it was as as followed as a transaction I thought that it made some sense as a precedent I thought it would become disastrous”
Roosevelt's 1937 court-packing plan did not violate any written law: the Constitution does not fix the size of the Supreme Court (nine was a convention, not a requirement), but adding justices violated a sub-constitutional customary norm that gave too much power to one administration.
“it doesn't tell you the size of the court nine was by convention not by requirements”
The fair value rule's effect depends on correlation: in uncorrelated events the sale price is independent of the seller's distress, but by March 2008 the Bear Stearns distress was correlated with market conditions, so a forced sale set a price that would be applied to others' portfolios.
“if it turns out you're dealing with randomized events uncorrelated with one another in relatively stable markets when you sell into the market”
Voluntary exchange and partnerships are consistent with the rule of law as long as the parties' combined resources do not give them greater claims against third parties than they had acting separately; this is why collective bargaining statutes are inconsistent with the rule of law, since they let a group of workers impose a duty to bargain in good faith on an employer that never agreed to it.
“a system of voluntary exchange meets the rule of law so long as you can say that the buyer and the seller do not have any greater or lesser claims against third parties”
The traditional police power had four heads (health, safety, morals, general welfare); health and safety justified sanitation and sewage investments in the late nineteenth century, which Epstein argues were the main driver of rising life expectancy: in England and Europe life expectancy had hovered around 40 years before 1850 and rose to about 48 in the 1900s, and in the United States it rose from about 47-48 to around 54 in the following 20 years.
“the health and safety stuff was the kind of police power which allowed for sanitation and sewage in the last half of the nineteenth century which was by enlarged the main driver of increased life expectancies”
In the Chrysler bankruptcy, the government put unsecured creditors (the UAW pension and health funds) ahead of secured bondholders who held first priority; under the absolute priority rule, promoting an unsecured creditor over secured creditors is a taking to the extent the secured party lost value, so this outcome violated property rights.
“if the second mortgagee is promoted over the first mortgagee it's a taking to the extent that the guy who had the first position has lost value”
Woodrow Wilson, in his 1885 book Congressional Government, declared the separation of powers in the original Constitution a grievous mistake, and Epstein implies this reflects a progressive hostility to checks and balances that is in tension with the rule of law.
“Woodrow Wilson who was in many cases the theoretical architect of this writing in his book on congressional power in 1885”
Formal rule-of-law constraints (prospective, general, enforced by proper tribunals) are not sufficient to prevent oppressive legislation: one could pass a law banning contracts above $10,000 in income or legalizing squatting on any land, meeting every formal requirement while destroying freedom of contract and the right to exclude. Minimum wage laws share these characteristics, which is why the rule of law must be blended with a conception of contract and property.
“I could think of all sorts of oppressive legislation that meet every one of the requirements that we're talking about and yet would be rejected by anybody who thinks that law ought to be an instrument to social welfare”
In Armstrong v. United States (1960), the government took a ship out of Maine waters into international waters to avoid a materialman's lien, and the Supreme Court held that the government must pay the lien holder as a general creditor, establishing that liens are protected property; Epstein calls this the most famous pro-property aphorism in takings law.
“they literally took the book boat out of Maine waters and sent them into international waters”
Health and safety police-power regulation could legitimately require exit doors to open outward in theaters and factories; had the Triangle Waist factory been subject to such rules, the 1911 fire that killed many workers would have been prevented, and mass disasters such as boat capsizes, theater fires, and the Titanic were common in the early twentieth century.
“that would have stopped the triangle waste factory for example from going up in smoke and killing everybody in 1911”
In the 1905 Louisville and Nashville Railroad case, Justice Holmes sustained a front-foot special assessment that charged the railroad half the cost of a road that benefited homeowners on the other side, reasoning that valuation questions were extraordinarily difficult, an opinion Epstein considers one of Holmes's worst.
“the most famous case on this actually goes back to 1905 involving the Louisville and Nashville railroad and it's one of Justice Holmes worst efforts”
In the Chrysler bankruptcy, the Treasury put government money into the deal and pressured secured creditors to accept terms that let unsecured pension and health funds for the UAW share in the equity, so secured bondholders recovered an estimated 10 to 20 cents on the dollar while unsecured union funds received much more than their priority entitled them to.
“the secured creditors got ten cents on the dollar or 20 cents on the dollar nobody's quite sure and the pension fan funds for the UAW they got a lot more money”
Minimum wage laws have the same defect as a law banning contracts above a threshold: they are prospective and general but still violate freedom of contract, and the traditional argument that democratic majorities would never pass such laws because everyone is hurt is wrong, since minimum wage laws do exactly that.
“in effect minimum wage laws to have exactly those sorts of characteristics”
Modern zoning and special legislation destroy the simplicity of the property system: zoning one owner for a 10-story building and another for a 2-story building generates special-legislation difficulties, and after 50 years of such administration cities like New York face a genuine fiscal and real estate crisis.
“the moment you start changing this to the modern rule it says well we're gonna zone you e1 so that you can build a 10-story building”
The National Labor Relations Act's structure, under which the five-member labor board has three seats for the president's party and two for the opposition, creates partisan linkage that makes nominations contentious and makes a special labor tribunal a source of trouble; a district court judge without political affiliation would be less partisan.
“the labor board shall have five members three of whom are the president's party and two of whom are not”
Progressive New Deal thinking treats big government as too important to be slowed by procedural protections on the separation of powers; Woodrow Wilson's 1885 writing on congressional power called the separation of powers in the original Constitution a grievous mistake in judgment.
“Woodrow Wilson who was in many cases the theoretical architect of this writing in his book on congressional power in 1885”
Until the 1937 constitutional revolution, American courts had worked out a reasonably successful system for distinguishing legitimate property uses (ones that carry risk and deserve returns) from harmful ones such as trespass, nuisance, ultra-hazardous activities, and fishery destruction; in 1937 the Supreme Court abandoned this effort and held that whatever the state wants to do is fine.
“until the 1937 Revolution when the United States Supreme Court said hey it's not worth trying to keep these things in place anymore”
Justice Holmes's formulation in Pennsylvania Coal v. Mahon that regulation is a taking 'when it goes too far' is vapid, and combined with the Supreme Court's takings jurisprudence this produces a dreadful intellectual mess in which nobody knows when land regulations go too far, generating enormous value destruction through landmark preservation and Endangered Species Act habitat rules.
“nobody but nobody knows exactly when those regulations quote-unquote go too far”
Government foreclosure moratoria and relief programs destroy the value of mortgage pools: delayed foreclosures leave owners unable to repay and not maintaining properties, and when relief ends the resulting wave of pent-up foreclosures further depresses property values and the value of mortgage-backed portfolios independent of other evaluations.
“what that does is have a devastating value on the portfolio's of all these companies and forces them down”
Under modern American constitutional law, retroactive regulation receives essentially no due process protection beyond a clear statement rule: courts read statutes as prospective unless the legislature explicitly says otherwise, a principle that began with black lung benefit cases that required companies to fund insurance for workers injured by conduct legal at the time, and was upheld by the Supreme Court in Turner v. Elkhorn (1976, Justice Marshall).
“you have no due process protection against retroactive regulations this started with the black lung disease cases”
The New Deal abandoned the distinction between safety regulation and economic interference: the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 imposed minimum wage and related rules, which Epstein calls one of the worst statutes on record, and the National Labor Relations Act authorized collective bargaining that the Court had struck down about 30 years earlier.
“all of a sudden you get the Fair Labor Standards Act in 1938 which allows for all sorts of wages and our regulations”
US courts have accepted that property means the right to exclude but not the rights to use or dispose of property, so regulation that restricts use is not treated as occupation and provides no compensation; this has left owners subject to arbitrary restrictions on use and disposition.
“everyone knows that property means the right to exclude it doesn't mean the right to use it”
In administrative agencies, combining the prosecutorial and adjudicatory roles in one body violates the rule of law's concern about bias, but in a 1970s case Justice White held this was acceptable unless actual bias could be shown, since the administrative state needed to take shortcuts.
“in a case again from the 1970s justice white announced this was perfectly okay by him”
Property ownership includes the right to exclude and also the right to use and develop; the baseline duty owed by everyone else is non-interference (not throwing bombs or filth onto one's land), and because these rules are simple and scalable they work equally well in ancient Rome and modern New York, which is why property rules are identical across those settings.
“the rule is generalized very easily in that they will work as well in ancient Rome as they do in modern New York”
Just compensation requirements neutralize down-zoning threats: if a government must pay a landowner the value lost when a parcel is reduced from $100,000 to $10,000, the threat becomes idle because the government can force the reduction only by paying the full loss, so the takings clause protects against arbitrary power.
“the threat becomes completely idle because the only way that they can force you to take a reduction in the value of the land is to pay you”
When a government is both regulator and counterparty, no deal it enters can be treated as free of coercion, because it can threaten regulatory retaliation such as permit denial; for example, a deal that offers a company a choice between two of its properties while keeping the third is a form of coercion.
“you can never ever say that any deal that you enter into them is free of coercion”
Roman law treated restrictions on a landowner's lawful use as a servitude, and the common law does not distinguish an easement that lets someone walk across your land from a restrictive covenant that stops you from building, so the takings doctrine's failure to treat use restrictions as property interests is a deep gap in the property system.
“the notion that somebody is taking a servitude as it's called by restricting your lawful uses of land goes back to Roman times”
In the Lucas litigation, South Carolina changed its rules in the middle of the case, imposing impossible procedural restrictions on bringing takings claims and substantive requirements that made valuing the owner's entitlement impossible, thereby evading the full-compensation rule.
“in the middle of the case the South Carolina folks changed their rules”
AIG executive 'bonuses' are typically deferred compensation designed to handle tax and business constraints and to reward performance under risk; because deferral requires extra compensation for time and performance-contingent pay requires a premium for risk, these contracts were worked out in ordinary business terms, and the government's objection is political, not economic.
“the moment you defer it you have to compensate them for the time and the moment you deferred contingent upon good performance you have to give them more money”
Coercive down-zoning to extract land donations is improper and thuggish: a government can threaten to reduce a landowner's parcel from a buildable value to a much lower value unless the owner donates the land for a tax deduction worth less than the land, and under current American constitutional law there is generally no strong protection against down-zoning of undeveloped land.
“as far as I'm concerned that zoning threat is absolutely improper this is very thuggish”
The bankruptcy system is preferable to government bailouts because it involves no infusion of public cash, and the federal government's practice of promising a 'lockbox' while forcing bankruptcy effectively reopens all contracts for renegotiation, placing the sanctity of contract behind the relative priority of claims, so that unsecured labor unions and auto dealers bear the cost.
“the truth about the matter one of the great virtues of the bankruptcy system is that there is no infusion of public cash”
When the state becomes an owner of private firms, the owner's interest in capital allocation becomes politically mediated instead of economically disciplined; to prevent this, a government investment should go into an independent fund with its own board and discretion over investments, not reviewable by political branches, as the NFL's charter does by barring public entities from membership.
“no public entity could ever be a member of our league because they understood exactly what would happen”
Foreclosure moratoria and interim relief on mortgages destroy the value of mortgage portfolios because they stop lenders from collecting, and the only way to revive the mortgage market is to realize losses through foreclosure or sales in lieu of foreclosure so that properties move quickly to new owners.
“if you're giving foreclosure released every Tom Dick and Harry you can't pay his money”
A robust rule of law requires property rights that are definite rather than indefinite, because indefinite property opens the door to political intrigue; when the president and Congress aggressively intervene in commercial affairs, property becomes less definite, and in the long term everybody loses even if some gain in the short term.
“in the long term everybody will lose even if in the short term one or another people will say gee pinned I really win big today”
The first-best policy is not to mess up the market at all, and if the government has messed things up, it has some obligation to keep the affected firms alive; allowing private contracts to specify whether to use mark-to-market accounting is preferable to government regulation, though some private contracts were underpowered and prevented timely renegotiation, which harmed both sides.
“the wrecks first best solution is don't mess anything up and one way to do that is to allow private contracts to specify”
In Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Council, Justice Scalia held that a land-use restriction that wipes out the entire economic value of land is a taking requiring compensation, but refused to specify how much value must be lost before a regulation counts as a wipeout; Epstein proposes that compensation plus residual use value should always sum to the land's full prior value (for example, a house permitted only at 10x10 feet should be compensated for the value lost above the residual value).
“the right answer is if you give somebody the right to build on a house something ten feet square”
The Treasury Department in the Chrysler case coerced secured creditors by threatening unspecified retaliation, including against TARP recipients, so that some secured creditors relented; Epstein argues that a voluntary-looking waiver obtained under such threat is not a real waiver of priority, since no rational creditor would give up priority unless threatened with greater calamity.
“nobody gives up rights like this unless somebody's beating them over the head and the government in effect surely did this”
Government ownership or a government-imposed stake in a firm, as with a quid pro quo for bailout money, undermines capital allocation because the owner's interest becomes mediated through politics rather than economic returns, and Epstein argues that the government should not act as an owner-regulator.
“the interest so-called interest of the owner is is mitigated through politics in a way that's not useful for capital allocation”
When the adversary is the state, procedural fairness is harder to achieve, because the state runs the administrative apparatus and the prosecutor's office; the rule of law therefore requires separation between the prosecutorial function and the judicial function so political forces cannot encroach on judicial capacity.
“the state runs the administrative apparatus it runs the prosecutor's office and so the rule of law requires that there be some degree of separation between the two of them”
In the AIG case, the Treasury effectively nullified contracts by presenting waivers on a Friday afternoon to be signed by Monday without time to see a lawyer; Epstein argues this coerced counterparties who had contractual claims, and that the government should not overturn compensation agreements that AIG executives had negotiated.
“you know we've been given this ultimatum now we have to sign these waivers by tomorrow or else”
Separation of powers and checks and balances are failing today because there is a surprising concordance across the executive, Congress, and the courts about policies that Epstein regards as unwise and indefensible, so the usual check of one branch against another cannot operate.
“there is a surprising concordance of opinion amongst all three branches of governments about the desirability of policies”
The notice function of the rule of law requires that a person be told the nature of the charges, which in turn requires a statute of reasonable clarity and a link between the statute and the specific conduct at issue; without this, a person is left in the dark about why their conduct is wrong.
“you have to be told the nature of the charges against you that requires that there be a statute of relative clarity”
Zoning in Palo Alto is arbitrary because permits are granted case by case, the conditions a zoning board can impose on construction (height, setbacks, whether one can rent a room) are as varied as the legal imagination allows, and the same project can be approved or rejected depending on the stated rationale, so the rule of law is dented there.
“the kinds of conditions that can be imposed by a zoning board with respect to new construction are essentially as varied as the legal imagination can possibly get”
Procedural protections before the state can deprive a person of money, property, liberty, or subject them to criminal sanctions require an impartially constituted tribunal, so that litigants are not 'playing with loaded dice'; this means judges need independence through term limits or permanent appointments and no family or financial ties to the parties.
“you're not having to play with a set of loaded dice which means that your chances of winning are going to be lower”
The minimal definition of the rule of law (equal treatment, no ad hoc rules) is insufficient, because the real problem is how to limit a sovereign that would otherwise be plenary in power so that citizens can prosper.
“this definition is one that nobody wants to deny but nobody who's serious about the subject thinks that it's going to be sufficient to deal with the basic problem”
Mortgages are non-possessory property interests because a lender can obtain title to secured property if the borrower defaults and use it to repay the debt; the Armstrong v. United States (1960) case, about a materialman's lien on a ship, shows that property protection extends to liens and their priority.
“a mortgage is a non possessory interest in land it is essentially a right to say that if in fact you who have borrowed money from me do not repay it”
The Constitution's judicial article does not fix the size of the Supreme Court, and adding justices to a court of nineteen would make it impractical for all justices to sit together, which is one reason the nine-member convention is useful.
“the last thing you want is nineteen justices on a court and then have to decide whether they all have to sit on bunk every time”
Progressive critics of the era did not understand how competitive markets worked and naively favored cartels on the assumption that whatever is good for cartel members must be good for society, a mistake Epstein says is one of the few lessons learned from the Great Depression.
“their progressive critics who basically didn't even understand the way in which competitive markets operated and we're completely keen on setting up cartels”
The core of the rule of law is that there are no extraordinary processes: everyone is subject to the same legal system, sanctions, and courts, so the state cannot treat one person differently from anyone else, and rules cannot be ad hoc toward particular individuals.
“the basic notion of the rule of law at its core is the notion that there are no extraordinary processes and that everybody is going to be subject to the same kinds of legal system sanctions and courts”
The right to be heard, historically meaning an oral hearing before the judge to present one's case in one's own words, includes calling witnesses, cross-examining opposing witnesses, and building a full and complete record before the decision-maker rules against a party.
“the right to be heard actually is kind of a funny word originally in some sense it meant that you only have the right to a kind of an oral hearing”
The 2008 financial crisis resulted from a combination of loose monetary policy, aggressive subsidies through Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, and international capital flows into the United States (including from China), which made it very difficult to control prices in the US by controlling domestic money supply alone.
“coupled with a very aggressive subsidy policy through Fannie and Freddie Mac coupled with this entire complications with the international capital markets”
If the Constitution says one thing and democratic majorities want another, the correct path is to amend the Constitution rather than have courts abandon its meaning; the courts' 1937 deference was wrong on the law.
“it is a Constitution you enforce it and the democratic processes don't like it then let them go through the amendments”
Russ Roberts describes the Economic Machine-style view that the Bear Stearns bailout was justified on systemic-risk grounds because its counterparties had thousands or millions of contracts, though Roberts himself is skeptical that this was the real cause of the Lehman problems and cites John Taylor's work questioning the standard view.
“John Taylor's written some interesting things showing that Oregon may not be that the standard view is could be wrong”
The government's $200 million investment in AIG was about one part in ten thousand of the company's roughly $200 billion scale, so no responsible owner would cheat on compensation for such a small share; Epstein argues the government should have announced it would protect its investment rather than publicly pursuing executives' scalps.
“two hundred million dollars relative to two hundred billion dollars is a you know one part in ten thousand”
In May 2009 Epstein said that the zoning situation in Palo Alto was in a steady state, neither appreciably worse nor better, but that the arbitrariness of zoning permits (height, setbacks, rentals of rooms) lets local boards impose conditions as varied as the legal imagination can devise.
“the kinds of conditions that can be imposed by a zoning board with respect to new construction are essentially as varied as the legal imagination can possibly get”
A robust version of the rule of law, with generality, procedural fairness, and secure property and contract, ends up being a relatively powerful system of classical liberalism.
“the roast robust system of the rule of law comes up to be a relatively powerful system of classical liberalism”
Epstein argues that the Obama administration's handling of the auto bankruptcies showed a muscular form of government aggression, and that the administration and Treasury (including Lawrence Summers) did not understand the implicit threat to property rights and credit systems that such coercion creates.
“what you see here is a really muscular version of government aggression which is not becoming”
Forty Republican votes in the Senate, possibly joined by some Blue Dog Democrats, could slow the 2009 economic policies, but Epstein's main hope is that people think hard about the implications of the policies so as to expose policies he regards as disastrous, despite an administration with strong public relations skills.
“one of them is 40 real Republican votes in the Senate which may include some Blue Dog Democrats to slow some of this stuff down”
The TARP funds were appropriated and then subject to shifting congressional commands, and banks were not allowed to return TARP money because doing so would remove a layer of government control over them, making the program a fiasco likely to get worse.
“there's some talk that the banks aren't allowed to return the tarp money because that removes one layer of government control over them”
The current administration's economic policies are disastrous but are defended with strong public relations skills, and Epstein says the previous administration pursued similar policies with poor public relations, so public understanding of policy consequences is the main way to change outcomes.
“the disastrous policies on economic issues of an administration which has absolutely wonderful public relations skills”