Doc Searls on the Intention Economy
What this covers
Doc Searls and Russ Roberts discuss how the internet is reshaping the relationship between buyers and sellers. Searls, author of The Intention Economy and director of Project VRM at Harvard's Berkman Center, argues that new tools enabling customers to broadcast their intentions will invert centuries of supply-driven marketing. Rather than companies capturing and shaping demand, buyers will signal what they want and let sellers respond competitively. This shift, Searls contends, depends on a broader principle: [open systems](concept:Open vs Closed Systems) outperform closed ones. He contrasts the vertical vs horizontal strategies of Apple and Google, examines how Linux and cities thrive as open commons while corporations ossify, and warns that telephone and cable ISPs threaten to enclose the internet within legacy business models.
The conversation ranges across how e-commerce remains stuck since the cookie era, how terms-of-service agreements function as marketplace friction, and why regulatory capture in telecommunications blocks innovation. Searls articulates the NEA) principle—that generative systems like the internet and open source software follow a pattern of Nobody owning, Everybody using, and Anyone improving. He sketches a future where customers maintain personal APIs and work with fourth parties to cast intentions as aggregated demand signals, and where genuine relationships replace the coerced loyalty of tracking and switching costs. Roberts counters with questions about whether government regulation or market competition better serves consumers, and both engage the tension between innovation and incumbent power through frameworks like creative destruction and Clay Christensen's Innovator's Dilemma.
Searls argues that the internet is shifting market power toward buyers by enabling them to broadcast intentions and assert their own terms, creating genuine rather than coerced relationships, and that open, horizontal systems (like Android, Linux, and the internet itself) outperform closed, verticalized ones controlled by phone and cable companies.
- Tools for customers to express intention ('intent casting') will let demand seek supply rather than supply capturing demand
- Open systems like cities, Linux, and Android grow and adapt while closed corporate systems stagnate and die
- Telephone and cable companies threaten the internet's commons by enclosing it within legacy, vertically-controlled business models
Markets will invert when customers control and broadcast their own intention data directly to sellers.
- When customers control and bring their own data (financial data, RFQ data) to the marketplace in coherent, manageable forms, they can establish relationships based on what they bring to the table rather than only what sellers allow them to bring.
“let's say that we're in charge of our own RFQ data, we're in charge of our own financial data... And we bring those to the marketplace and we can establish relationships based on what we're bringing to the table and not just what the other side allows us to bring to the table.”
- If customers could broadcast specific willingness-to-pay signals (e.g., paying extra for a particular window seat), aggregated intention data held by fourth parties could reveal latent demand that sellers like airlines never knew existed, prompting them to incrementally change systems built entirely around their own statistical convenience.
“What if I can send out the economic signal that I am willing to pay for these seats, guys?... it turns out there really are a lot more people that want window seats than we thought, and we can make adjustments based on that.”
- For roughly the last 1500 years, marketing efforts have been oriented around supply capturing and leading demand, but new tools that equip customers to express intention will invert this so demand can seek supply directly.
“businesses build around equipping demand to seek supply and not just for supply to capture and lead demand. Which is where most of the marketing efforts have gone for the last 1500 years.”
- Current tools like Siri, Google Maps, and Priceline draw their portfolio of knowledge entirely from the sell side of the marketplace—they are about sellers trying to find buyers; the missing capability is equipping buyers to find sellers by expressing rich, granular intent.
“it's all about sellers trying to find buyers. What about the buyers trying to find the sellers? Let's equip that.”
- In an NEA world, individuals will have their own personal APIs to expose their competencies (credit-worthiness, frequent-traveler status, medical history) to providers on their own terms, and these will be part of 'personal clouds'—zones of competence on the internet that individuals maintain and can program or have programmed for them.
“we will all have our own personal APIs, where I can expose my own competencies: Here's my credit. I'm not a credit risk... There's lots of things I can expose as an API.”
- In the intention economy, individuals will have relationships with 'fourth parties'—intermediaries that work for the customer (analogous to how a bank serves us with our money), doing the heavy lifting of casting out intentions like a personal Request for Proposal.
“she has relationships with what we're starting to call 'fourth parties'--which are third parties which are working for us, or in this case for her that serve the same role for her data that a bag serves with our money.”
Open commons and horizontal systems flourish while vertical closure and monopoly control stifle innovation and efficiency.
- Cities survive while companies die because companies tend to be closed systems while cities are open systems that admit new things, enable more connections between processes and cultures, and move faster—with bigger cities exhibiting faster human pace and more energy inputs.
“Why do cities live while companies die? And his case... is that... companies tend to be closed systems; cities are open systems.”
- Apple (vertical, closed, proprietary iOS) and Google (horizontal, open Android usable by any manufacturer) represent two orthogonal but complementary strategies—like two Etch A Sketch dials—that together create a larger, better-functioning market than either approach alone would.
“I actually see these as two Etch A Sketch dials: one is very proprietary and very vertical... while at the same time others, and even yourself in some ways, are going to open it up horizontally.”
- The internet is a commons that telephone and cable companies risk making tragic by enclosing it with contrived finitudes (like 'minutes' or 'channels') for their own parochial purposes, funneling internet access into legacy telephone and cable business models that the internet transcends and subsumes by design.
“This is the risk of subordinating the Internet to telephony and cable television, both of which the Internet transcends and subsumes by design--yet both of which funnel Internet access and contain use within legacy telephone and cable company facilities, provisioning, and business models.”
- The most generative things on the internet—like language, the internet itself, Linux, and open source—follow the NEA pattern: Nobody owns it, Everybody can use it, and Anyone can improve it, which makes them open commons that flourish.
“NEA--Nobody owns it, that's the 'N'; Everybody can use it; and the 'A' is Anyone can improve it.”
- In most places consumers can only choose from one cable company, with the new ISPs (phone and cable companies) acting as monopolists who want to verticalize and control the marketplace for their own purposes, throttling innovation with no competition.
“those new ISPs that are very controlling and really very much want to verticalize the marketplace and control it for their own purposes are, you know, acting as monopolists... Most people can only choose from one cable company.”
- The internet is the best thing that ever happened to the free marketplace—probably the biggest thing since moveable type, money, and credit—because it places countless connections, efficiencies, and signal exchanges in the middle of the marketplace.
“I believe the Internet is like the best thing that ever happened to the free marketplace. I think it is probably the biggest thing since moveable type.”
Machine-readable, two-sided agreements and APIs will replace today's opaque, unilateral terms and friction.
- The internet is causing companies to turn inside out by exposing their competencies externally as APIs (Application Programming Interfaces), which will become more abundant over time, making companies inevitably less secretive and less closed—potentially insulating them from the failings Christensen describes.
“companies are turning inside out... as companies turn inside out and expose their competencies on the outside in the form of these APIs, it makes a lot more things possible... companies are inevitably going to be less secretive and less closed”
- The marketplace would be more efficient if agreements were two-sided, achieved by having machine-readable code on both buyer and seller sides expressing good will and simple intentions—such as the customer requesting their own data back in a readable form or forbidding tracking by cookies and beacons.
“All we have to do is have machine-readable code on both sides that express good will and some simple intentions, one of which would be... I would like to have my own data back when we are done with this transaction.”
- E-commerce has been technologically and conceptually stuck since the invention of the cookie in 1995, with the customer's only real choice being to opt out entirely (not use the site), rather than negotiate terms.
“He says: 1995, Invention of the cookie; The End. We sort of stopped there. And the thing is that right now, as you said, our only choice is to opt out.”
- If people actually read all the terms-of-service agreements they click through, it would consume roughly half the time they currently spend on the web, because the volume of prose is so high; these one-sided non-agreements are friction in the marketplace.
“we would spend half the time that we spend on the web today would be taken up by reading these things, if we actually bothered to read them, because the volume of prose in them is so high. This is friction in the marketplace”
- Cookies are small text files invented by Montulli at Netscape in the mid-1990s to let a site keep track of 'state'—where the user was last time—such as remembering a shopping cart.
“They are actually little files. They are text files, generally... as a way for a site to keep track of what's called 'state,' which is: This is where we were the last time you visited.”
Current telecommunications monopolies and regulatory capture prevent technological capabilities from reaching customers.
- Verizon engineers are technically able to deliver much higher bandwidth (e.g., 100 Mbps) immediately but are prevented from doing so by Marketing and Legal, illustrating how one-sided terms create buildings full of lawyers saying No, a friction the internet could overcome via real-time API-based interaction.
“We can give you 100 Mmps (megabits per second) tomorrow, blow everybody else out of the water. But we're not doing that because Marketing won't let us. Now here's an engineer talking to a customer, and Marketing won't let them.”
- Verizon stopped expanding its FIOS fiber footprint, a decision that coincided with a deal it made with Comcast or another cable company for more wireless spectrum, reflecting a strategy of verticalizing the marketplace (e.g., buying NBC Universal) and treating the internet like television.
“they stopped expanding FIOS. They stopped enlarging the FIOS footprint... that decision that they made, as I understand it, was coincidental with their doing a deal with Comcast or one of the other cable companies for more wireless spectrum”
- There is a very high degree of regulatory capture in telecommunications, with most federal FCC chairmen going on to work for phone and cable companies through a revolving door, which locks out many possible innovations.
“there is a very high degree of regulatory capture in telecommunications. Most of the federal FCC chairmen now work for phone and cable companies. It's a--the revolving door is there”
Large incumbent companies fail to innovate because closed systems prevent them from absorbing new inputs.
- As companies get bigger they become unable to take in new inputs well because they are too encumbered by their own size and corrupted by 'smoking their own exhaust'—being closed systems—which is a corollary to Clayton Christensen's innovator's dilemma about how incumbents fail.
“they literally can't take in this new input very well because they are too encumbered by their own size and corrupted by smoking their own exhaust for so long. Because they are closed systems.”
- Loyalty cards are mostly about stores trying to track customers and create switching costs and inconveniences, rather than genuine loyalty; the intention economy would replace these coerced relationships with genuine ones where customers declare loyalty because they actually feel it.
“the loyalty cards are mostly about the stores trying to trap [track?] you and ways you are switching costs, they call it, and other inconveniences like that... But what this forms is genuine relationships, rather than coerced ones.”
Language and code flourish through openness and meritocracy rather than centralized control.
- English has proliferated partly because it is unusually accepting of new words, neologisms, and new usage conventions, whereas more formalized languages like French are more verticalized—consciously controlled by culture and institutions about what words are admitted.
“English, one reason English has proliferated, is that it is unusually accepting of new words and of, not just neologisms but new forms of usage and conventions.”
- Despite being perceived as a leftist back-to-nature project, Linux is about as brutal a meritocracy as imaginable—your code does not get into the code base, regardless of who you know, unless it makes the code base better.
“in fact it was about as brutal a meritocracy as you could possibly imagine... your code's not going to get into the code base unless it makes the code base better.”
- Inverting William F. Buckley's mission to stand athwart history yelling 'Stop,' Searls sees his role as standing athwart history yelling 'Hurry up'—being optimistic and trying to speed the inevitable arrival of customer-empowering tools.
“William F. Buckley once said... his purpose was... to stand on the side of history yelling, Stop. And I see my role as to athwart history yelling, Hurry up.”