focal point
In coordination problems without communication, a solution that stands out as natural or salient (like a central bridge or a 50-50 split) that people gravitate toward independently.
As defined in 203 | N.J. Enfield on Why Language is Good for Lawyers and Not Scientists
Where it comes up · 8
- Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/20083 claims
- Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge3 claims
- Jeffrey Sachs2 claims
- Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 3--A Discussion of Part II 04/22/20092 claims
- Garett Jones — Immigration, national IQ, & less democracy1 claim
- Peter Boettke on Public Administration, Liberty, and the Proper Role of Government1 claim
- 203 | N.J. Enfield on Why Language is Good for Lawyers and Not Scientists1 claim
- Has Trump damaged the dollar?1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 14Search all claims for “focal point” →
- Because Super Bowl viewers know that millions of others are watching simultaneously, advertisers concentrate on 'social goods' (drinks, fashions, software) whose value depends on common knowledge; the shared viewing acts as a focal point making a brand acceptable or stylish to display at any party.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- A world without a clear focal point for reserve currency—multiple competing alternatives with no consensus—is more prone to runs and destabilizing currency shifts, creating a less secure and stable global financial system than the current dollar-centered systemHas Trump damaged the dollar?
- Coordination problems are solved by public conspicuous signals or, in their absence, by focal points—solutions salient enough that each party guesses the same solution will occur to the other, as in Schelling's example of separated people meeting at the clock in Grand Central Station not because it is convenient but because it is obvious.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- Moral judgment operates like common law or precedent: rather than possessing a rich full description of spectators' sensibilities, we accumulate 'markers' or focal points from prior accepted judgments and carry them forward as guides to evaluate new cases.Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 3--A Discussion of Part II 04/22/2009
- Buchanan viewed constitutions as contracts—like Ulysses tying himself to the mast—that bind one's natural proclivities from exploiting situations, whereas Russell Hardin argued constitutions are focal points reflecting the evolving culture and consensus of the current people.Peter Boettke on Public Administration, Liberty, and the Proper Role of Government
- Humans cannot hold an infinite recursion of 'I-know-that-she-knows' in a finite skull; instead, common knowledge is psychologically realized as a sense that something is public, salient, self-evident, or 'out there'—and when two people observe something while observing each other observing it, that mutual visibility is enough to guarantee common knowledge.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- Law is effective not merely because courts and police can detect every infraction—they cannot—but because commonly known law acts as a focal point that tells parties in a confrontation who should stand their ground and who should back down, letting people accept any decision rather than fight over everything, as illustrated by no-smoking signs designating that the smoker gives way.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
- Schelling's coordination experiments (e.g. two parachutists with the same map trying to meet, or two people splitting $100 in separate rooms) show that people are well practiced at thinking through how to converge with another person without communicating — reasoning recursively about what the other will do given what they think you will do — and converge on focal points like the bridge or a 50-50 split far more often than chance.203 | N.J. Enfield on Why Language is Good for Lawyers and Not Scientists
- The reviewer who reacted in horror to a stranger thanking fund manager Peter Lynch for the returns that let him build a home addition—insisting such gratitude belonged to labor unions and political parties—reveals the people's-romance hostility to private actors as rival focal points of shared experience.Dan Klein on Coordination and Cooperation 02/04/2008
- Smith's reality is 'a fog' with only a finite number of focal points—stars that flicker—and we must work comparatively with what is available; how things actually turn out (e.g., whether the pitcher won 20 games) is highly focal and provides a usable anchor for judgments of propriety, whereas the philosophically purer standard based on effort or intention 'sounds nice but there are no focal points to hang it on.'Dan Klein on The Theory of Moral Sentiments, Episode 3--A Discussion of Part II 04/22/2009