fifth column
A group within a country that secretly supports its enemies; here the enslaved population of the South, who were pro-Union.
As defined in Bruce Bueno de Mesquita on the Spoils of War
Other definitions
A group within a country that secretly works for or sympathizes with an external power or enemy; here the feared role of diaspora communities mobilized by their home states.
Bruno Maçães
Where it comes up · 5
- Bruno Maçães2 claims
- 428 - Political Extremism2 claims
- Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history1 claim
- Bruce Bueno de Mesquita on the Spoils of War1 claim
- Bassem Youssef1 claim
Most important claims · 7 of 7Search all claims for “fifth column” →
- Applying Scott Bennett and Allan Stam's statistical model of war duration to the Union and Confederacy predicts the Civil War should have lasted approximately six months rather than four years, because the South was hugely outmatched—21 million Northerners versus ~4.5 million effective Southerners (half of the 9 million Southerners were slaves, a pro-Union fifth column), and the South grew cash crops, not food, and produced no munitions.Bruce Bueno de Mesquita on the Spoils of War
- Yahya Sinwar's open strategy was to use Palestinian civilians as sacrificial lambs to break Israel's will and invite global condemnation, and treating Hamas like a government rather than a prison gang with a death-cult patina (one that steals construction materials for bunkers and uses civilians as human shields) leaves Israel in the impossible position of being expected to care more about Palestinian lives than Hamas does; this strategy is starting to pay off as European countries demand Israel feed Gaza while asking little of Hamas, so despite the structural antisemitism Israel should end the war for now on prudential grounds.428 - Political Extremism
- When a US president says Jews would not be safe anywhere without Israel, it is dangerous because it is factually false (America has historically been safer for Jews, with no pogroms) and it feeds the antisemitic 'fifth column' trope by implying American Jews owe loyalty to a foreign country rather than belonging at home.Bassem Youssef
- Interrogators and executioners could continue victimizing people they knew were likely innocent because they believed to their bone marrow that real enemies—masking loyalty, hiding as a future fifth column—existed and were hard to identify, so they overcompensated to ensure they caught every last enemy, accepting that some innocents would be destroyed in the process.Stephen Kotkin — How Stalin became the most powerful dictator in history
- Antisemitism on the left is driven more by attitudes toward Israel under a colonial-oppressor framework and sympathy for Palestinians as victims, whereas antisemitism on the right is driven more by a conspiratorial mindset feeding on ready-made off-the-shelf anti-Jewish material (Candace Owens, Tucker Carlson), with its Israel criticism rooted in viewing Jews as a fifth column dragging America into foreign conflicts rather than in sympathy for Palestinians.428 - Political Extremism
- China will not give up on mobilizing its overseas citizens, and the strong Western reaction against this will feed into xenophobic tendencies, with people quickly assuming every Chinese person is working for the Chinese state — and similar, if less acute, dynamics will appear with India's diaspora.Bruno Maçães
- Borders are becoming diffuse and countries footloose like multinationals: a country like Russia or China no longer stops at its borders but holds stakes and participations elsewhere — China holds a 20% stake in Djibouti and an '80% stake' in the Chinese diaspora — so a country is becoming a diagram of stakes worldwide rather than an organized national community within borders, making the world ripe for conflict.Bruno Maçães