fallibilism
The epistemological stance that any belief or claim may be wrong and is held only provisionally, requiring openness to revision.
As defined in Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
Other definitions
The philosophical position that any of our beliefs could turn out to be wrong, so claims are held tentatively rather than with certainty.
Kwame Anthony Appiah
Where it comes up · 6
- Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity2 claims
- 52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 67 Introduction to Existentialism1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism1 claim
- AMA | November 20211 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 17 Greek and Roman Skepticism1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “fallibilism” →
- Human rights and consent are not fundamental but derive from epistemology: any institution that lets one person enforce an idea on another who disagrees closes off the means of correcting errors; since all our moral theories are fallible, it is a fundamental objective truth of morality that it's immoral to close off the paths to correcting a theory that may turn out to be false.52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos
- Scientific thinking is fallibilistic and ultimately empirical, but theoretical insight alone—without any new experiment—can dramatically boost or squelch credence in a theory, as demonstrated when 't Hooft proved spontaneously broken gauge theories are renormalizable in the early 1970s, causing interest in Weinberg's previously ignored 1967 electroweak model to surge from near-zero to becoming the most-cited particle physics paper.AMA | November 2021
- All claims that knowledge must start somewhere on faith are fallacies; one does not have to accept anything as an uncriticizable foundation—even the claim that the worst possible misery for everyone is bad is not a foundation in the sense of being uncriticizable, since we can always ask why that criterion and not another, why assume we exist, why assume there is truth.52 - Finding Our Way In The Cosmos
- In addition to coherence, Quine offers a pragmatic justification for the web of beliefs: we accept a pattern of scientific hypotheses as probably correct because it is fertile and fruitful, enabling further hypothesis-proposals, research programs, and future inquiry rather than being blocked or sterile.A History of Philosophy | 76 Logical Positivism
- Hayek's most reasonable readers take him as a warning against overconfidence and naive trust in expertise and a reminder of fallibilism and local knowledge, but extreme libertarians and traditionalists misuse him as a justification for rejecting all forms of expert knowledge—a use Hayek himself may not have approved of.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Science is best understood not narrowly as hard data and statistics but as a process of knowledge acquisition—putting forth ideas, inviting anyone to criticize them, assuming you might be wrong, and seeking results reproducible regardless of the inquirer's identity—so that over time inquiry converges closer to truth.Helen Pluckrose and James Lindsay on the Enemies of Modernity
- Richard Bernstein identifies five key contributions of pragmatism: rejection of foundationalism, fallibilism (all human judgments are fallible), the social character of the self (rejecting atomistic individualism), contingency in human life and nature, and acceptance of philosophical pluralism across viewpoints.A History of Philosophy | 67 Introduction to Existentialism
- Oliver Cromwell's maxim 'I beseech you, sir, by the bowels of Christ, consider that you may be wrong' exemplifies the fallibilist recognition that human judgment is inherently fallible and that this fallibility should inform intellectual humility.A History of Philosophy | 17 Greek and Roman Skepticism