faction
The Founders' term for a group organized around a common self-interest; not inherently bad, but dangerous when it enlists government power to win against rival factions.
As defined in Jonah Goldberg on The Suicide of the West
Where it comes up · 11
- Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism5 claims
- Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Swift, Gulliver's Travels3 claims
- Louis Michael Seidman on the Constitution2 claims
- George Will on the Conservative Sensibility2 claims
- Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/20062 claims
- Paul Gregory on Politics, Murder, and Love in Stalin's Kremlin 07/12/20101 claim
- Jonah Goldberg on The Suicide of the West1 claim
- Why Christianity Needs to Help Save Democracy (with Jonathan Rauch)1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 20Search all claims for “faction” →
- Madison revolutionized democratic theory by rejecting the idea that democracy requires a small homogeneous society; since the worst outcome is tyranny of the majority, the solution is to prevent stable tyrannical majorities by fostering ephemeral, constantly shifting coalitions of minorities in an extensive republic, protecting the unequal capacities of acquiring property to produce a saving multiplicity of factions.George Will on the Conservative Sensibility
- Madison's Federalist No. 10 argument—that increasing a republic's size increases the number of factions, which interact and cancel each other out, enhancing stability rather than diminishing it (analogous to Adam Smith's marketplace of competing interests increasing productivity)—was so original that few contemporaries grasped it, and the Constitution was actually ratified for interest-driven local reasons rather than because Madison's idea persuaded people.Joseph Ellis on American Creation and the Founding 09/08/2008
- It is easier for a special interest (faction) to manipulate the levers of power at the local level than at the national level, so courts must be especially careful to protect constitutional liberties locally, since individuals are often powerless in the political process and only meet powerful interests on a level playing field in court.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- In 18th-century political theory, faction and party were viewed as intrinsically bad and signs of depravity and corruption, unlike the modern concept of legitimate opposition that Edmund Burke would develop about 100-50 years later.Great Authors - Neoclassical and Romantic Literature - Swift, Gulliver's Travels
- Romanticizing majority rule is a road to tyranny; the framers, especially Madison, were cynical about government power and recognized that special interests (factions) can manipulate levers of power more easily at the local level than the national level, making local government a special danger to liberty.Clint Bolick Defends Judicial Activism 10/31/2006
- Humans are 'hive creatures' like bees; we need webs of shared meaning to cooperate effectively; we cannot function as a single global hive because cooperation requires competition (groups competing creates social cohesion), and humans are prone to tribal division as described by James Madison (even trivial distinctions kindle mutual animosities and violent conflict).Democracy in the Next Cycle of History | Jonathan Haidt
- The idea that faction and party are intrinsically evil—a sign of disease within a society potentially resulting in civil war and the state of nature—comes from ancient theory and persists at least as far as Hume, who is the first political thinker in his political essays to want to allow for the idea of legitimate opposition while trying to avoid the dangerous element of faction and party that could lead to civil war.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- Hume attempts to create the idea of a legitimate opposition through his 'court of competitors' in his essay on the ideal commonwealth, trying to give potentially powerful opponents of government a limited kind of negative supervisory role, which is a brilliant thought but still reflects the older desire to avoid faction and party that could create civil war.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- Once politics is sanctioned only by the will of the people, legitimate dissent must be made room for as a simple empirical fact, and therefore the older tradition saying that all parties and factions are evil must be gotten rid of.Burke and the Birth of Enlightened Conservatism
- Under the tutorship of Public Choice Theory (Buchanan and Tullock), Will shed his romantic view of government and concluded that just as private-sector actors maximize wealth, public-sector actors maximize power, so the national pastime is no longer baseball but rent-seeking—bending public power for private advantage to confer benefits on a faction or disadvantage its competitors.George Will on the Conservative Sensibility