What this covers

Louis Michael Seidman of Georgetown University and host Russ Roberts debate whether Americans should follow the Constitution at all. Seidman contends that policy should be decided on present merits rather than constitutional authority, calling appeals to the Constitution authoritarian and dishonest when they shut down reasoned debate about what is actually good. Roberts counters that constitutional constraints serve a vital function: they impose limits on centralized power and guard against faction and mob rule, reflecting skepticism about Limits of Reason rather than blind deference to the Founders. The two move through concrete cases where the Constitution was violated without catastrophe—the Constitution's own ratification (which violated the Articles of Confederation), the Louisiana Purchase, the Emancipation Proclamation, and Brown v. Board—to anchor their disagreement about whether legal constraints or reasoned policy debate should guide the country.

The argument spans history, philosophy, and constitutional law. Seidman argues that much of the Constitution is so ambiguous it cannot settle disputes, allowing people to read their preferred outcomes into the text and then accuse opponents of heresy. He points out that the Constitution is extraordinarily difficult to amend and that the Supreme Court's major decisions—segregation, abortion, affirmative action, gay rights—rest really on judges' views of political morality rather than constitutional text. Roberts, drawing on Hayek and Charles S. Peirce, argues that constraints exist because humans are prone to error and self-interest, and that written limits provide protection even though they can themselves produce mistakes. Roberts also defends institutional slowness as a virtue, preventing wild ideological swings. Throughout, Seidman pushes against what he calls Cognitive Dissonance in judicial reasoning, while Roberts insists that abandoning constitutional obligation is far riskier than the Limits of Reason it acknowledges.

Sharpest takeaway

Seidman argues Americans should decide policy on its present merits rather than on whether it is constitutional, and that invoking the Constitution as a trump card is authoritarian and dishonest; Roberts counters that constitutional constraints are a valuable, humility-driven check on majority rule and faction given the limits of reason.

  • Many foundational American acts (the Constitution's own ratification, the Louisiana Purchase, the Emancipation Proclamation, Brown v. Board) were themselves constitutional violations yet did not cause chaos
  • Much of the Constitution is so ambiguous that it does not actually settle disputes; people read their preferred outcomes into it
  • Constraints exist precisely because human reason and political processes are limited and prone to faction and mob rule (Roberts's counter)

The argument · threads5 threads · 24 claims
0.85

The Constitution is fundamentally flawed: it is nearly impossible to amend, written in ambiguous language that masks judicial politics, and produces bad outcomes no one would defend today.

6 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Much of the Constitution is written in broad, ambiguous language, which allows people on both the left and right to read their own preferred settlement into the text; rather than settling arguments, this leads each side to accuse the other of violating the foundational document and of being traitors or heretics, raising the temperature and degrading mature democratic debate.

    “Much of the Constitution is written in very broad language and very ambiguous language. And that fact has allowed people both on the left and on the right... to read their own preferred settlement into the language.”

  • Of all national constitutions, the United States Constitution is not only the oldest but also the hardest to amend; it has been amended very few times—only 17 times after the original Bill of Rights over 225 years, with the last meaningful one around 1971—making correction of bad provisions a practical impossibility.

    “Of all the national constitutions, it's not only the oldest but also the hardest to amend.”

  • Some unambiguous constitutional provisions produce bad outcomes almost no one would defend today: District of Columbia residents are ruled directly by Congress with no vote, and presidential electors are legally free to vote for anyone, even someone soundly defeated or not on the ballot—both arrangements are appalling and nutty 18th-century judgments we are effectively stuck with.

    “The Constitution is quite unambiguous that the residents of the District of Columbia are ruled directly by Congress and that they have no vote for the people who rule them.”

  • Supreme Court Justices vote their politics, ideology, and philosophy while dressing it up as constitutional interpretation, which produces a kind of cognitive dissonance in which bright, often good people must live daily with knowing that what they are doing is at some level dishonest.

    “It's a cognitive dissonance. I think it would be--being a Supreme Court Justice is quite a job. They have to live every day with at some level a knowledge that what they are doing is just dishonest.”

  • The Supreme Court's most important decisions—outlawing segregated schools, creating an abortion right, limiting affirmative action, protecting gay rights—have essentially no grounding in the Constitution and are really combinations of the Justices' views of political morality, tradition, and prior precedent; the Court should be honest that this is what it is doing.

    “It's a cognitive dissonance. I think it would be--being a Supreme Court Justice is quite a job. They have to live every day with at some level a knowledge that what they are doing is just dishonest.”

  • Exercising power through a mechanism designed to fool other people about what one is actually doing is uniquely objectionable; even if an elite body like the Supreme Court should have the last word on some matters, it ought to come clean about deciding on political morality rather than disguising those judgments as constitutional interpretation.

    “It's a cognitive dissonance. I think it would be--being a Supreme Court Justice is quite a job. They have to live every day with at some level a knowledge that what they are doing is just dishonest.”

0.75

Demanding obedience to the Constitution without present-day justification is authoritarian and degrading to democratic deliberation.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Telling people they must accept a policy simply because the Constitution says so, without giving present-day reasons, is deeply authoritarian; obligations should be justified by reasons that make sense now, not by the judgments of people who lived 250 years ago.

    “when you tell people this is the way it has to be whether you like it or not and I don't have to give any arguments in support of it, that's deeply authoritarian”

  • Because this is the country of the living, we should no more accept rule by a small group of long-dead framers who probably did not represent a majority even in their own time than we would accept rule by France or the United Nations.

    “We would not accept rule by France or rule by the United Nations. And for the same reasons, we shouldn't accept rule by a relatively small group of people who probably did not represent a majority even at the time that they lived; but in any event have been dead for several hundred years.”

  • What we think of as constitutional rights will not survive unless people can explain to their fellow Americans why those principles ought to be accepted; rights imposed in an authoritarian way without justification are fragile, while those grounded in present reasons that persuade citizens are durable.

    “in the end what we think of as constitutional rights aren't going to survive unless folks can explain to their fellow Americans why these are principles that ought to be accepted”

  • A good law class, taught Socratically, is one where both professor and students have to think hard; the teacher's job is to ask critical questions of every argument regardless of side, with the ambition not to convince or indoctrinate but to leave students holding their own views in the most sophisticated form possible.

    “What I want them to come away the classes is holding the view they hold in the most sophisticated form that it can be held. And that's my ambition as a teacher.”

0.61

Constitutional obedience has not actually prevented special-interest favoritism or bad outcomes; the Constitution is ultimately only as binding as citizens' willingness to follow it.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Special-interest favoritism such as financial sector bailouts, farm aid, and sugar import quotas benefiting a handful of families are arguably unconstitutional yet occur anyway under a regime of constitutional obedience, showing the Constitution fails to provide the restraint on faction that its defenders value.

    “All of the things that you just mentioned are things that happened with Constitutional Obedience in place.”

  • The Constitution is ultimately just a piece of paper in the National Archives with no troops and no power to order anyone to do anything; what actually holds the country together is the willingness of living Americans to do what is in the best interest of the country, not deference to a document or to decisions made 250 years ago.

    “what the Constitution is, is a piece of paper that's in the National Archives. The Constitution doesn't have any troops, it doesn't order anybody to do anything”

  • For provisions of the Constitution worthy of respect, we should follow them because they are worthy of respect on the merits, not because people thought they were worthy several hundred years ago; constitutional disobedience means abandoning obedience-as-such, not abandoning every provision.

    “For those provisions that are worthy of our respect, we ought to follow them because they are worthy of our respect and not because it so happens that people thought they were worthy of our respect several hundred years ago”

  • The fact that the vast majority of people and law professors disagree with the constitutional-disobedience position gives the speaker genuine pause and makes him wonder whether he is simply wrong.

    “the vast majority of people and indeed, the vast majority of law professors agree with you. So there must be something to what you are saying. And it does give me pause that so few people see the point that I'm making.”

0.51

The Framers were not infallible; the Constitution was created unconstitutionally and involved petty factional deals, not wisdom for centuries.

2 pointscentrality 4/5
  • If reason is limited, we should be especially suspicious of people who believed they could think things through not just for their own generation but for generations centuries later; the Framers were not saints or all-knowing, and the Constitution's drafting and ratification involved petty interest-group deals and factional struggle—including a bargain with John Hancock to secure Massachusetts's decisive ratification.

    “If you think that reason is limited, then it seems to me we ought to be especially suspicious of people who think that they can think things through not just for their generation but for generations hundreds of years later. That's really quite arrogant.”

  • The Constitution itself was created in violation of existing law: the Framers were directed only to propose amendments to the Articles of Confederation, which required ratification by all 13 state legislatures, but they instead wrote a new document, provided for ratification by popularly elected conventions, and declared 9 states sufficient—so the founding document was itself unconstitutional.

    “the Congressional directive to them, was not to write a new constitution, but to propose amendments to the Articles of Confederation”

0.47

Sensible countries govern without written constitutions, and historical American violations of the Constitution produced beneficial results like abolishing slavery and school desegregation.

4 pointscentrality 3/5
  • It was common ground including Lincoln that the Constitution prohibited interfering with slavery in states where it already existed, so the Emancipation Proclamation—though justified as a temporary war power—violated that understanding; slavery's abolition was accomplished by force of arms in violation of the Constitution, and the subsequent 13th Amendment was adopted through constitutionally questionable mechanisms.

    “It was common ground, a view shared by everybody, including Abraham Lincoln and including most abolitionists, that the Constitution prohibited interfering with slavery in the states where it already existed. Lincoln violated that understanding... when he issued the Emancipation Proclamation.”

  • The practice of admitting new states with one senator serving a short initial term to stagger elections violates Article I, which provides all senators serve six years (with only the original group divided by lot); this glitch has been ignored since Vermont in 1791 with no harm, illustrating that sensibly ignoring a bad constitutional provision causes no chaos.

    “The way in which we have appointed elected Senators since 1791 pretty clearly violates Article I.”

  • The framers of the 14th Amendment would not have read their words as prohibiting segregated schools—the galleries watching Congress pass it were segregated by congressional order and Congress had segregated D.C. schools—so Brown v. Board of Education was a beneficial result reached in violation of the Constitution, as Justice Robert Jackson himself acknowledged when voting for it on grounds of political morality.

    “the vast majority of people who have studied it think that the framers of the 14th Amendment would certainly not have read their words as prohibiting segregated schools”

  • Several countries function well without a written constitution—the United Kingdom, New Zealand, and Israel—working out disputes through their mechanisms without descending into chaos, demonstrating that abandoning constitutional obligation is not a crazy idea.

    “There are other countries in the world that don't have Constitutions. The United Kingdom most prominently; but also New Zealand, Israel. Those countries, the last time I looked, haven't evolved into chaos.”