What this covers

This is a single-lecturer talk by Michael Sugrue on Edmund Burke, presented as a practical politician and not an academic. Burke grew up in Ireland, the child of a Protestant father and a Catholic mother. He rose in the House of Commons through ability rather than lineage, as one of the Rockingham Whigs. Sugrue follows his working-out of how theory should connect to practice in a representative legislature. He frames Burke's thought as anti-utopian, set against the tradition of Plato and Thomas More of imagining an ideal society and judging the world by it. Burke instead asks what demonstrably works. The lecture ties this to the skeptical empiricism of Hume) and Locke, arguing that it leads to conservatism because the empiricist must ask of every reformer what grounds there are to believe the reform will succeed.

The range is wider than the "conservative" label suggests. Sugrue stresses that Burke backed reform: he urged giving the American colonies representation in Parliament, investigated the East India Company, and sought relief from English oppression in Ireland. Burke's warning was that refusing liberalization would push colonies toward revolution. On the French Revolution, Sugrue presents Burke as holding that terror) was implicit in the revolution's abstract rationalism, with Rousseau) as a source of dangerous ideas. Revolutionary terror consumes its own leaders, Robespierre) among them, and Burke predicts a Caesar-like despot. The lecture also covers the English constitution as an unwritten entailed inheritance that changes gradually.

A third thread, and the most distinctive claim, is that Burke was the first to argue political parties are necessary, a conclusion drawn from his years enforcing party discipline. Sugrue connects this to social contract thinking and the modern idea of loyal opposition, in which opponents hold different opinions rather than being enemies of the state. He also concedes a cost: skeptical caution can block reforms, including Enlightenment moral advances such as the objection to slavery.

Sharpest takeaway

Edmund Burke demonstrates that practical political philosophy must be grounded in empirical observation of what works rather than abstract rationalist theory, and that conservative skepticism about untested reforms, while sometimes limiting necessary change, protects against the catastrophic failures that result from imposing radical ideological schemes without regard to historical experience and human nature.

  • Burke's empiricism makes him intrinsically skeptical of reforms lacking historical precedent, as in the French Revolution's abstract rationalism leading to terror
  • Gradual, piecemeal reform tested empirically reduces risk better than revolutionary wholesale change, as prohibition demonstrates
  • Political parties and loyal opposition are legitimate and necessary features of representative legislatures, discovered through practice rather than theory

The claims · ranked81 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.86

Burke, as a rational risk minimizer, argues that gradual, slow-moving, well-considered reforms implemented over a period of time are actually risk-reducing mechanisms because they prevent the necessity for revolutionary violence, which is the worst possible state of affairs.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“being a rational risk minimizer, Burke says that occasionally gradual, slow-moving, well-considered reforms implemented over a period of time are actually risk-reducing mechanisms because they prevent the necessity for revolutionary violence, which is the worst possible state of affairs.”

0.86

The idea of legitimate political parties, of a loyal opposition, of legitimate dissent, is a peculiarly modern idea, and Burke helps to legitimize this idea by recognizing that in representative legislatures it is necessary to organize both those who support government policy and those opposed to it so that we can effectively legislate or obstruct legislation within the legislature itself.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“The gist of it is something like this, that the idea of legitimate political parties, of a loyal opposition, of legitimate dissent, is a peculiarly modern idea and Burke helps us legitimize that idea...in addition to that, they are things that are still with us today one way or another. Ideas that have been introduced that are quite important. The first and most important idea that Burke comes up with is the idea that political parties are not only legitimate, but necessary...it means the rise of legitimate [36:49] dissent and loyal opposition. And also, it means the rise of legitimate political parties”

0.86

Burke, remarkably, is the first person to say that political parties are not only desirable but necessary because you can't run a legislature without them, a conclusion he reached from spending most of his career in the Rockingham Whigs maintaining party discipline.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke, remarkably enough, is the first man to say that political parties are not only desirable, but they are necessary because you can't run a legislature without them. And how did he find that out? He spent most of his career in a legislature as is of the Rockingham Whigs. And he maintained party discipline and he said, 'Not only is this not a bad thing, but I have no idea how you theorists would run a legislature without it.'”

0.80

Reform and stability are in some respects antithetical, with a certain degree of tension between the two, and Burke recognizes the need for reform but also recognizes the need for political order, with his primary emphasis on political order and his belief that the Hobbesian state of nature (the lapse back into lawless terror characteristic of the French Revolution) could have been predicted by a wise political science.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“reform and stability are in some respects antithetical. There's a certain degree of tension between the two. Burke recognizes the need for reform, but he also recognizes the need for political stability, for political order. Sometimes he goes for one, sometimes for the other, but my sense is that his primary emphasis is on the idea of political order. He thinks that the Hobbesian state of nature, the lapse back into lawless terror that was characteristic of the worst excesses of the French Revolution, could have been predicted.”

0.80

Burke's theory is going to be anti-utopian, moving away from the tradition of creating an ideal society (as in Plato or Thomas More) and judging the world on the basis of that, instead taking the other tack of looking at what works in the world around us and saying at least this works and has some connection to reality, with reform proposals judged within the context of what works.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Hume's theory is going to be anti-utopian. It's going to move away from the tradition of thought that we got with Plato or Thomas More of creating an ideal society and judging the world around us on the basis of that. He's going to take the other tack. He's going to look at the world around us and say at least this works. We can be sure that this has some connection to reality. It is reality.”

0.80

Burke argues that the terror is implicit in the French Revolution itself, and that demands for complete change are not only unrealistic but dangerous, products of abstract rationalization from the Continental tradition, with radical democratic figures like Rousseau promoting dangerous ideas about human liberation that cannot be achieved immediately or in the foreseeable future.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke says that the terror is implicit in the French Revolution itself. And that these demands for complete change now are not only unrealistic, but dangerous, and they're the product of this abstract rationalizing that we get in the Continental tradition. He thinks that people like Rousseau, with their radical democratic tendencies, their insistence Remember the the beginning of Rousseau's Social Contract, um 'Man is born free, but everywhere is he is in chains.' It's a beautiful poetic line. Does anyone clearly understand what it means? It means that the world's bad and that lots of political stuff is evil. And Burke says, 'Well, that may be true, but that's a very dangerous idea to introduce. We cannot make complete human liberation tomorrow, or or in fact, we cannot create complete human liberation within the foreseeable future. So, in practice, that's impossible.'”

0.80

Society is not held together by rationality; people normally do not sit down, do mathematical problems, and conclude that they love their family, country, or hometown, because people are essentially creatures of sentiment, which connects to the Humean tradition of moral theory and the skeptical empirical tradition from Locke.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Society is not held together by rationality. People normally do not sit down, do some mathematical problems, and conclude that they love their family, that they love their country, that they like their hometown. People are essentially creatures of sentiment. This connects it back up to the Humean tradition of moral theory. This connects it to the skeptical tradition of epistemology that comes out of Locke and empiricism and things like that.”

0.80

Burke views the English constitution as an entailed inheritance—inherited from our ancestors as a system of government and society that cannot be simply thrown out all at once, but must be changed gradually within the framework of what was inherited.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke thinks that the English constitution is an entailed inheritance as he puts it. We inherit a system of government and a society from our ancestors and it is an entailed inheritance. You can't just throw it all out. You can't get rid of it all at once.”

0.80

During the Enlightenment, people began to object to things like slavery, the oppression of women, and the genocidal treatment of non-Western peoples—these ideas are new, and many of the most important moral and political breakthroughs of the Enlightenment are dogmatic one way or another because a skeptic would have good reasons for objecting to them or having misgivings.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“In the enlightenment that we start to see people begin to object to things like slavery. They begin to object to things like the oppression of women. They begin to object to the thing to to the to ideas like uh the extermination and genocidal treatment of the Indians or non-Western peoples. These ideas are new...the most important breakthroughs in the political theory of the enlightenment are, like it or not, dogmatic one way or another. A skeptic would have good reasons for objecting to them or at least having some misgivings about them.”

0.80

When we move into the modern world and adopt social contractarianism—the idea that government legitimacy derives from the consent of the people who form the social contract—it becomes necessary to make possible the idea of legitimate dissent and loyal opposition because people with differing opinions about governmental policy are not children of the devil but simply have different opinions.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“When we move into the modern world, social contractarianism, an idea of political legitimacy which says that governments derive their legitimacy from the consent of the people who allegedly get together in the state of nature and form the social contract and all that jazz. Well, when that becomes possible, then that means that there's no divine sanction for the government and one way or another we are going to have to make possible the idea of legitimate dissent, of a loyal opposition because it means that people that think governmental policy is mistaken are not children of the devil. It just means they have a different opinion.”

0.80

One of the great advantages of the English constitution is that it is not written down but rather a general, nebulous collection of traditions and practices and sentiments, which has the advantage that it can change gradually and imperceptibly, giving a sense of continuity over time, which Burke considers very important.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“And one of the great advantages of the English constitution is that it's not written down. It's a general kind of nebulous collection of traditions and practices and sentiments. And the advantage of the fact of that is that it can change gradually and imperceptibly. It gives you the sense of continuity over time. Burke thinks that very important.”

0.80

Political terror is dangerous because no one knows who to trust or where to go; the revolutionary leaders like Antoine and Robespierre first persecute those suspected of royalist sympathies, then turn on their own political enemies within the revolutionary movement, and finally get turned on by their own enemies who kill them, demonstrating the self-consuming nature of revolutionary terror.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“First Antoine and Robespierre start to persecute those they suspect of having royalist sympathies, and then they get their own political enemies within the revolutionary movement, and finally their own political enemies get them and chop their heads off because political terror is a dangerous thing. No one knows who to trust, no one knows where to go.”

0.80

Burke's primary concern in investigating political life is to find out what works in practice, specifically under the circumstances of a roughly democratic or representative legislature, and to understand how legislatures function, how new democratic governments operate, and how political theory ought to connect to political practice.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke's primary concern in investigating political life is to find out what works in practice. And not just in practice across the world, his his concern is to find out what works in practice under the circumstances of a roughly democratic legislature or a representative legislature.”

0.80

The rise of representative legislatures and human-centered political theory necessitates both the rise of legitimate dissent and loyal opposition, and also the rise of legitimate political parties, which are not seen as threats to the state but as the natural condition of human beings who intrinsically have different perspectives on the world.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“And it is necessary for us to be able to organize people that support governmental policy and people who are opposed to it so that we can effectively legislate or at least obstruct legislation within the legislature itself. In other words, the rise of representative legislatures and the rise of human man-centered political theory means that we're also going to have the rise, first of all, of legitimate dissent and loyal opposition. And also, it means the rise of legitimate political parties, which are not seen as being a threat to the state but rather seen as being the natural condition of human beings who intrinsically have different perspectives on the world.”

0.79

Both Hume and Burke are rational risk minimizers who understand that empiricism—as a skeptical philosophy—leads intrinsically to conservatism because the empiricist must ask about every proposed reform: 'What grounds do I have to believe that your reform is going to work?'

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Hume would understand Burke. Both of them are rational risk minimizers. Think about what the implications are of empiricism for political theory. Let's take Hume's empiricism, but we could take any of them. What is an empiricist sure of? Well, nothing. Empiricism is basically a skeptical philosophy.”

0.79

It cannot be certain what will happen if we make fundamental changes immediately, and therefore empiricism is intrinsically skeptical and intrinsically conservative because the skeptic will say to every would-be reformer: 'What grounds do I have to believe that your reform is going to work?'

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Who knows what will happen what will happen if we make fundamental changes immediately. You can't be certain of that. So, what it means is I think that empiricism is intrinsically skeptical and in addition intrinsically conservative. Skepticism is intrinsically conservative because the skeptic is going to say to every would-be reformer, 'What grounds do I have to believe that your reform is going to work?'”

0.78

Prior to the American Revolution, Burke advocates liberalizing the relationship with the American colonies, saying 'Give them some representation in Parliament. You are actually denying them the rights of Englishmen, which had been established by the Glorious Revolution.'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“In other words, prior to the beginnings of the American Revolution, Burke advocates liberalizing the relationship with the American colonies. He says, 'Give them some representation in Parliament. You are actually denying them the rights of Englishmen, which had been established by the Glorious Revolution.'”

0.78

Burke also thought the French government had reform coming to it but argued that the revolutionaries are actually worse than the government they had replaced, and that while oppression under absolute monarchy existed, terror under revolution produces a worse state, with the likely outcome being something like Caesar—a despotic figure who creates order at the cost of all liberty that existed before the revolution.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“He thinks that the French government has it coming too because they're also unwilling to make reforms, but he says the revolutionaries are actually worse than the government they already had. While we may have had oppression under an absolute monarch, we have terror under under a revolution and what we can reasonably expect to come out of this revolution is something like a Caesar, some sort of despotic figure that will dominate this age of chaos and create order at the price of all the liberties that everyone had prior to the revolution.”

0.74

Burke's position as a Whig involves supporting the country party as opposed to the court party, wanting to ensure corruption doesn't dominate English government, preventing unforeseen revolutionary emergencies that would create desperate political situations like France's during the French Revolution, and examining the origins of legitimacy, structure of legislation, and how governments can be both reformed and made stable despite the tension between reform and stability.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke's position is that of a Whig. He's an outsider. He supports the country party as opposed to the court party. He wants to make sure that corruption doesn't dominate the English government. And he wants to make sure that no unforeseen revolutionary emergencies create the kind of desperate political situation in England that is characteristic of France during the time of the of the French Revolution.”

0.74

Burke is often seen as one of the most conservative thinkers of the Enlightenment and as a precursor to romantic reaction, but he is also a reform-minded Whig who supported the ideals of the American Revolution, investigated corrupt practices among the East India Company, and wanted to alleviate oppression in the English treatment of Ireland.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke is often seen as one of the most conservative thinkers of the Enlightenment as a kind of precursor to romantic reaction. There's a certain degree of truth in that. But he's also a rather reform-minded Whig as well. He, although he was against the French Revolution, he supported the ideals of the American Revolution. He investigated corrupt practices among the East India Company. He wanted to alleviate some of the oppression that was characteristic of the English treatment of Ireland”

0.74

Burke himself grew up in Ireland and was the product of a mixed marriage between a Protestant father and a Catholic mother, making him something of an outsider and parvenu in his political career—someone who showed up in Commons and got there by dint of his ability, not by his lineage or connections.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke himself grew up in Ireland. He's the product of a mixed marriage between a a Protestant father and a Catholic mother. All through his political career, he's something of an outsider. He's a parvenu, someone that shows up in Commons and got there by dint of his ability, not by his lineage, not necessarily by his connections.”

0.74

By empirically studying the data of history, Burke believes we can come to a rough empirical understanding of what human nature is in the case of individuals and what the nature of human societies and governments is as a matter of practical fact.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“that by empirically studying the data of history, Burke thinks that we can come to a rough empirical understanding of what human nature is in as in in the case of individuals, and what the nature of human societies and human governments is as a matter of practical fact, empirical fact.”

0.74

As a leader in the House of Commons, Burke is a noted orator, an indefatigable writer of pamphlets, and someone who knows how to manage men and legislatures and get things done, recognizing both the need for reform and the danger that reform poses because change always involves risk.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“as a leader in the House of Commons, he's a noted orator. He is an indefatigable writer of pamphlets, and he knows how to manage men. He knows how to manage legislatures. He knows how to get things done. He recognizes the need for reform and pushes for reform when he thinks it's unavoidable. Reform is dangerous because there's always a certain degree of risk involved in changing the status quo.”

0.74

Burke argues that if England does not liberalize its connections with the American colonies and other colonial possessions like India, it will lose them by driving them to the 'unavoidable expedient' of a massive revolution that will cost lives, money, and ultimately America itself.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“He says, 'If we don't liberalize our connection with them, and in addition, not just to the Americans, but he was also willing to liberalize his relations with India and other colonial possessions of England. He says, 'If we don't liberalize our connections with them, in fact, we will lose them. We will drive them to the unavoidable expedient of of an enormous revolution, which will cost us men, which will cost us money, and which will ultimately cost us America.'”

0.74

Burke is not a reactionary in the sense that he is entirely against reform, but rather a conservative who wants to make reforms piecemeal and slowly, distinguishing himself from those who oppose all change.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke is not a reactionary in the sense that he's entirely against reform. What he is is a conservative, one who wants to make reforms piecemeal, slowly.”

0.74

The idea that faction and party are intrinsically evil—a sign of disease within a society potentially resulting in civil war and the state of nature—comes from ancient theory and persists at least as far as Hume, who is the first political thinker in his political essays to want to allow for the idea of legitimate opposition while trying to avoid the dangerous element of faction and party that could lead to civil war.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Now, that idea that faction and party are intrinsically evil, a sign of disease within a society, and potentially the result the result which will present potentially result in a civil war, which means back to the state of nature, the war of all against all, this idea is taken up factions and parties are bad and it comes right into political theory and it goes at least as far as Hume. Hume is the first political thinker in his political essays, I think this is the essay on the ideal commonwealth where he brings this up. He kind of wants to allow for the idea of legitimate opposition”

0.74

Legitimate dissent and loyal opposition cannot happen until the secularization of politics, which cannot happen until the Enlightenment, meaning the idea of loyal opposition is an immensely sophisticated and peculiarly modern thought requiring certain adjustments in political theory.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“That can't happen until the secularization of politics and that can't happen until the enlightenment. What that means then is that first of all the idea of a loyal opposition, of legitimate dissent is an immensely sophisticated thought. It is a peculiarly modern thought. And it needs certain adjustments in our political theory”

0.74

Once politics is sanctioned only by the will of the people, legitimate dissent must be made room for as a simple empirical fact, and therefore the older tradition saying that all parties and factions are evil must be gotten rid of.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“So, once politics is sanctioned only by the will of the people, then legitimate dissent has to be made room for cuz it's a simple empirical fact. And if it's a simple empirical fact, then the older tradition, which says that all parties and all factions are evil, has to be gotten rid of.”

0.74

Hume attempts to create the idea of a legitimate opposition through his 'court of competitors' in his essay on the ideal commonwealth, trying to give potentially powerful opponents of government a limited kind of negative supervisory role, which is a brilliant thought but still reflects the older desire to avoid faction and party that could create civil war.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Now, Hume starts to do that when he creates what's called the court of competitors in that essay on the ideal commonwealth. He wants to take potentially factious members, potential potentially powerful opponents of the government, and give them a limited kind of negative supervisory role in the government. What's he doing there? He's trying to create the idea of a legitimate opposition. It's a brilliant thought. But also, all when you if you look at Hume's political essays, he constantly says that we have to avoid faction. We have to avoid party.”

0.74

Burke is an engineer rather than a scientist in politics—he wants to know 'How does it work in practice?' and is not otherwise interested in theory, embodying the most philosophical of the practical politicians of the 18th century and a worthy heir to the English skeptical, empirical, practical tradition of politics and philosophy.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“He's an engineer, not a scientist. He wants to know, 'How does it work in practice? I'm not otherwise interested in your theory.' Burke in that respect is the most philosophical of the practical politicians of the 18th century, and a worthy heir to the English skeptical, empirical, practical tradition of politics and philosophy.”

0.74

Edmund Burke was not a professional scholar or academic, but rather a practical politician who was very influential in late 18th century England, a member of the House of Commons, and one of the Rockingham Whigs who spent a long career working out the connection between political theory and political practice.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Edmund Burke is an unusual figure in a course on the history of philosophy because he wasn't a professor professional scholar, wasn't a professional academic, wasn't a a man who lived the contemplative life...Edmund Burke was a practical politician who was very influential in late 18th century England. He was a member of the House of Commons. He was one of the Rockingham Whigs.”

0.74

Burke makes two more important contributions to political science that are departures from earlier political conceptions of both English and French Enlightenment and that persist today: first, that political parties are not only legitimate but necessary.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Now, in addition, there are two more contributions that Burke makes to political science, which are departures from the earlier political conceptions characteristic of both the English and the French Enlightenment. And in addition to that, they are things that are still with us today one way or another. Ideas that have been introduced that are quite important. The first and most important idea that Burke comes up with is the idea that political parties are not only legitimate, but necessary.”

0.74

The true and appropriate label for Burke is 'conservative' rather than 'reactionary,' because he does not oppose all reforms and does not want to go back to feudalism, but rather wants to ensure that reforms are slow and gradual, which puts him out of step with the continental Enlightenment but more or less consistent with the English Enlightenment.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“It's not fair to call him a reactionary. The true label, the appropriate label would be conservative. He doesn't oppose all reforms. He doesn't want to go back to feudalism, but he wants to make sure that these reforms are slow and gradual. In some respects, that makes him out of step up with the Enlightenment. It certainly makes him out of step with the Enlightenment as it's existing on the continent. The French and German traditions are very rigorous and absolute and abstract. He's more or less consistent with the Enlightenment as it happens in England.”

0.74

Burke's second major contribution is his theory of representation; he distinguishes between virtual representation (where representatives take instruction from the people and do exactly what they want) and actual representation (which Burke supports, where the representative thinks about what is good for the nation as a whole from a large perspective).

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“One more thing and then I'll close on Burke. Burke is also known for his theory of representation. He offers the idea, and this is again one of the throwbacks, I would say, to the older idea that there's a unified public spirited thought uh approach to politics. He says that there are two two ideas of representation, what he will call virtual representation and actual representation. And he supports the idea of virtual as opposed to actual representation. Here's the thought. A virtual representative is one who takes instruction from the people who elected him, and he does exactly what they want.”

0.73

An empiricist can reasonably believe that if we continue in the way we're going, the future will be roughly like the past because we notice regularities in the world; if monarchy has existed in England for centuries, we can expect continuity between earlier and later forms as long as we don't rock the boat too much, providing reasonable certainty compared to the uncertainty of fundamental changes.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Well, what sort of things can you be comfortable with? Can you have a reasonable belief in? Well, you can believe in what you see, and what you have experience with. And what do we have experience with? The brute facts of human history. In other words, the empiricist is always going to say, 'Well, we can at least be reasonably certain that if we continue on the way we're going, that the future will be roughly speaking like the past because we notice certain regularities in the world around us. So, if monarchy has been in England for the past 200 or 300 or 400 or 500 years, as long as we don't rock the boat too much, the empiricist says we can reasonably expect it will have a continuity between the earlier forms and the later forms.'”

0.73

Burke acknowledges that France has legitimate grievances against absolute monarchy, divine right despotism, the domination of the church in political affairs, and the hereditary nobility's legal and institutional advantages, but argues these could be redressed only one at a time and only gradually, and the idea of killing the king, then all the nobles, then all people who dispute within the radical party, then killing each other is what you would expect from people with no connection to their earlier traditions.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“He says, 'Look, the French have a legitimate set of objections to the kind of government they have. An absolute monarchy is an evil thing. Divine right despotism, divine right monarchies are a mistake. They're a relic of the feudal past. These ought to be gotten rid of. The domination of the church in French political affairs is, Burke thinks, an evil. The hereditary nobility and the particular legal and institutional advantages that they have, at least some of those for Burke are evil. But he says, 'Look, all of these grievances could be redressed, but they can be redressed only one at a time and only gradually. The idea of killing the king and then killing all the nobles and then killing all the people who dispute within the radical democratic party and then starting to kill each other is what you would expect from people that have no connection to their earlier traditions”

0.73

The bigger a proposed reform is, the more risk is involved and the more dangerous it is, so the more salutary skepticism might be, and the people who advocate radical, complete, ultimate reform in Enlightenment political theory are all rationalists, not empiricists, which is not an accident.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“You don't know what's going to happen if you haven't tried it yet. So, if you're going to propose a reform, well, then the bigger the reform is, the more risk involved, the more dangerous it is, the more salutary skepticism might be. The people who advocate radical, complete, ultimate reform in the political theory of the Enlightenment are all rationalists. None of them are empiricists. And that's not an accident.”

0.73

Dogmatism is connected to rationalism, and rationality involves the willingness to ruthlessly pursue the implications of one idea, exemplified by Kierkegaard's statement 'Purity of the heart is the will to one thing,' which is characteristic of continental rationalism—the willingness to take one idea ruthlessly to its logical consequences.

definitionhigh valueestablishednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Dogmatism is connected to rationalism. Remember when I talked about Kant last time? Rationality, the willingness to ruthlessly pursue the implications of one idea. As Kierkegaard said, 'Purity of the heart is the will to one thing. The willingness to take one idea ruthlessly to its logical consequences, that's characteristic of continental rationalism.”

0.70

Since innovation entails risk, and risk is dangerous and potentially undermines human felicity, the rational thing to do is to oppose or at least regulate and make gradual any political reforms, because this moderates the risk, and the rational minimization of risk is what empiricism is fundamentally about.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“And since innovation entails risk and risk is dangerous and undermines, at least potentially, human felicity, the rational thing to do is to oppose or at least to regulate and make gradual in political reforms because that regulates and moderates the risk. And the rational minimization of risk is in a way what empiricism is all about.”

0.69

Burke appeals to the example of Athenian democracy as described in Thucydides' Peloponnesian Wars to argue that democracy is downright dangerous because the Athenian inability to make intelligent decisions caused them to lose the Peloponnesian War—Alcibiades proposed invading Syracuse, the aroused people approved, and the resulting disaster destroyed Athenian culture.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“He says, 'Do we have any experience with that?' Well, yes, we do. We have stories in our histories about democracy. If you I mean, if you are familiar with Thucydides' Peloponnesian Wars? Well, in that, when we look at the results of Athenian democracy, it was disastrous, and it was the actual inability of Athenian democracy to make intelligent decisions that causes them to lose the Peloponnesian War. It's Alcibiades who says, 'Let's go invade Syracuse.' And the people really like it. And democracy says that yes, we'll go do this because the people are very aroused by it. It's disastrous. They lose the war, and their culture is destroyed.”

0.68

Burke's position supporting Whig policies involves advocating the principles of the Glorious Revolution of 1689, which he views as establishing rights of Englishmen that should apply to all English subjects, including American colonists and people in India and other colonial possessions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“There's a little bit of a disingenuous element here. He is, after all, a practical politician supporting Whig policies. What's more Whig than to advocate the principles of the Glorious Revolution of '89? His reason for supporting the protests of the American colonists was that their demands were within the province of the rights that had been established for Englishmen in the Glorious Revolution of 1689.”

0.68

In the ancient political tradition, parties are understood as the extreme, superlative form of faction, and faction is understood as intrinsically evil; all ancient political theory, whether Platonic, Aristotelian, Roman, or Greek, is organized around the problem of preventing society from breaking up into antagonistic factions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“In the ancient political tradition, parties are the extreme, the superlative form of faction, and faction is understood to be intrinsically evil. All of political theory in the ancient world, it doesn't matter whether it's Platonic or Aristotelian or Roman or Greek, or is all organized around the problem of preventing society from breaking up into antagonistic factions.”

0.68

In the ancient political tradition and medieval age, the idea of legitimate dissent never comes up because the government is backed by God; dissent is by definition evil, so the idea of loyal opposition cannot exist.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“What that means is that in the ancient political tradition, in the it moves all the way up to the medieval age, the idea of legitimate dissent never comes up. Dissent is by definition evil since the government is backed by God.”

0.68

Burke thinks actual representation (following what the constituency wants) is a mistake because he has a partiality to hierarchical political theory and believes not everybody is equally smart, virtuous, or wise; there is a strong element of disdain for the average common man, which he refers to in the Reflections on the Revolution in France as 'the swinish multitude.'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke thinks it's a mistake because he has a partiality to hierarchical political theory. He doesn't think everybody's equally smart or equally virtuous or equally wise. And there's a There's a a strong element of a kind of disdain for the average common man. He refers in the Reflections on the Revolution in France to the swinish multitude.”

0.68

Burke's most important work is 'Reflections on the Revolution in France,' ostensibly a letter to a young French nobleman explaining the English conservative interpretation of the French Revolution and the terror—a breakdown of legal order which amounts to the law of war of all against all, a horrifying situation where no one has security for property or life and terror reigns with unpredictable governmental policy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“His most important work is called Reflections on the Revolution in France. It is ostensibly a letter written to a friend a young French nobleman explaining the English conservative interpretation of the French Revolution and in particular the interpretation of the terror. Burke thinks that the terror, essentially a breakdown of legal order which amounts to the law of of the war of all against all, to a horrifying situation which is the worst of political circumstances where no one has any security for property or for life, where terror reigns, where there's no predictability with regard to governmental policy”

0.68

Burke advocates certain kinds of reform including reforms of English foreign policy, reform in the treatment of Ireland, reform in the organization of government, and reform of political theory itself—how people think about politics—because he believes that based on his experience as a practical politician, he has something worthwhile to say about political theory.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“And he advocates certain kinds of reform, reforms of English foreign policy, reform in the treatment of Ireland, reform in the organization of the government, and Burke also wants to reform political theory, the idea of politics, the way in which people think about politics. Burke believes the on the basis of his experience as a practical politician that he has something worthwhile to say about that”

0.68

Virtuous individuals in ancient political theory have no separation of their interests from the interests of society as a whole, which is why Plato's guardian class is not allowed to have their own family or private property, as these would give them special particular interests independent of the society's interests.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“A virtuous individual will be public-spirited, will have no separation of their interest from the interest of society as a whole. That's why the Platonic guardian class is not allowed to have their own family and is not allowed to have their own private property because that would give them a special particular interest independent of the interest of the society as a whole.”

0.68

The difficulty with virtual representation is that it is essentially undemocratic because the virtual representative believes himself to be nature's aristocrat, smarter than the people who voted for him, and says 'I really don't want your advice. I know what's best, or at least I'm figuring out what we ought to do, and I'm going to vote my conscience based on information and understanding you don't have.'

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“The difficulty with it is is that it is essentially undemocratic. What it means is is that the virtual representative believes himself to be essentially nature's aristocrat, believes that he's smarter than the people that voted for him, and says, 'Look, I really don't want your advice. I know what's best, or at least I'm doing my best to figure out what we ought to do, and I'm going to vote that way. I'm going to vote my conscience. And frankly, I have access to more information. I know what the inside dirt is on everybody that's in proposing these things, and I know what the actual practical capacities of the legislature are. So, folks, trust me. I'm I'm going to vote the way I think rather than the way you think cuz I'm a lot smarter than you are.'”

0.68

In the ancient and medieval worlds, governments legitimized themselves by reference to the will of God or ultimate rationality (in Plato's ideal city) or myths that legitimize the king; divine right monarchy is the best example, where you obey the king because he has a special connection to God that differs from you, and disobeying the king is essentially opposing God.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“In the ancient world and the medieval world. In the ancient and medieval world, a government legitimized itself by reference to the will of God or there of ultimate rationality in the case of the Platonic ideal city or with reference to some set of myths that legitimize the king. Divine right monarchy is the best example of this. Why do you have to obey the king when he tells you to do something? Because he's God's friend or he's God's chosen, he's God's electors. He has some special connection to God that differs from you.”

0.66

Burke is skeptical of all utopian thoughts and all utopian rationalistic programs for the creation of ultimate human felicity, saying 'We'll do the best we can right here and now within the parameters of what can practically be done.'

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke is skeptical at all of all utopian thoughts, of all utopian rationalistic programs for the for all the creation of ultimate human felicity. He says, 'We'll do the best we can right here and now within the parameters of what can practically be done.'”

0.66

Burke asserts that all utopian schemes for the immediate creation of perfection are chimerical and wrong, an illusion, and that practice should come over theory—what works comes over what we would like.

normativehigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“All utopian schemes for the immediate creation of perfection are chimerical and wrong. They're an illusion. Burke says, 'Practice over theory. What works comes over what we would like.'”

0.66

Burke is well within the central trend of skeptical, empirical, gradual, sentimental English thought, consistent with the English tradition more than with the French and German rationalist traditions, and the advantages of the English constitution lie in its being a gradual accumulation of practices and traditions which minimized the need for revolution and could be gradually reformed from within.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke, while he's not a professional philosopher, is well within the central trend, the skeptical, empirical, gradual, sentimental trend of English thought. Now, he thinks that the advantage that the advantages of the English constitution is that it's a gradual accumulation of practices and traditions which minimized the need for revolution and which could be gradually reformed from within.”

0.66

The real problem with the French Revolution, for Burke, is that it was not a gradual series of reforms based empirically on the traditions of French ways of life and government, but rather came from abstract theorizing which is downright dangerous.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“So Burke says the real problem with the French Revolution is that it wasn't a gradual series of reforms. It wasn't based empirically on the traditions of the French ways of life and French government. The problem with it is that it comes from abstract theorizing which is downright dangerous.”

0.60

Many of the most praiseworthy and important political reforms of the Enlightenment had never happened in the past, creating a problem for an empiricist who must have misgivings about even the most attractive reforms because we lack good grounds to expect they will work, having no practical experience with them.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“But many of the political reforms and the most praiseworthy and important political reforms of the Enlightenment were things that had never happened in the past. And here's the problem. An empiricist, which is a skeptical kind of philosopher, is always going to be have some misgivings about even the most attractive reforms because we lack good grounds to expect that they're going to work because we have no practice, we have no experience with them.”

0.60

Burke supported the American Revolution because he felt that the American colonists had been forced, in defense of their Whig liberties, to reluctantly undertake a revolution, and he said 'I told you so' because the English government had it coming by refusing to make reforms.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Now, Burke supported the American Revolution because he felt that the American colonists had been forced in defense of their Whig liberties to have grudgingly a revolution. And he said, 'I told you so in a way the English government had it coming.'”

0.60

Burke eventually wins a seat from Bristol on his own merits in a real free election, but then gets bounced out of his seat when he writes a letter to his Bristol electors explaining that he is a virtual representative not interested in what they think, and that he represents the whole interest of society from a large perspective, not particular local interests.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Eventually, he manages to win a seat from Bristol on his own merits. He actually has a a real free election. And he eventually gets bounced out of his seat at Bristol, kicked out of a a popularly elected position in Commons because he writes a letter to his electors in Bristol and says, 'Look, you folks are under the misapprehension that I'm interested in what you think. No. I'm not an actual representative. I'm a virtual representative. A virtual representative is one who thinks about what is good for the nation as a whole. He doesn't represent London or Manchester or Bristol or any particular locality or any particular group of people. He represents the whole interest of society judged from the large perspective.'”

0.60

Burke notes that he himself was elected to the House of Commons in a rotten borough through the Marquess of Rockingham's patronage (one vote), demonstrating that he didn't need to be responsive to a popular electorate, which may explain his comfort with virtual representation theory.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Now, we don't hear any of our politicians talk that way and it's not an accident. All right, they don't talk about the swinish multitude. Burke does. And he says, 'Look, I'm not taking orders from the swinish multitude. I mean, hell, I got elected to the House of Commons in a rotten borough. The Marquess of Rockingham talked to one of his pals who was a peer and voted me in on the basis of one vote. Here I come. I'm in Parliament now.'”

0.60

The voters of Bristol figured out Burke's position and bounced him in the election after he revealed that he was a virtual representative; this didn't hurt him in terms of party affiliation or membership in the House of Commons because he found himself a rotten borough and got voted back in by the Rockingham Whigs, demonstrating that he understood how politics works.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Now, he doesn't quite add in the last, but it's implicit in the voters of Bristol managed to figure it out, and he got bounced in the election after he gave them that information about the fact that he was a virtual representative. That didn't hurt him in terms of political party affiliation, or in terms of membership in the House of Commons. He finds himself a rotten borough and gets voted back in by the Rockingham Whigs. I mean, he understands how politics works. He's something of a of an opportunist, but that's the downside of what I think is a desirable pragmatism in his political philosophy.”

0.60

There is a hierarchical system where God is above, then angels, then the king, then nobles, and then common people, and the reason you must obey those higher in the hierarchy is that God made the hierarchy that way; if you tell the king you don't like his laws or oppose his policies, you are essentially opposed to God, which makes you a friend of Satan who should be killed.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“If you remember Aquinas, we've got the God up here and the and the angels and then the king here and down below him are the nobles and below them are people like you. The reason why you have to obey people that are higher in the hierarchy is God made the hierarchy that way. If you tell the king you don't like his laws, if you tell the king you're opposed to his policies, you're essentially opposed to the king. And if you're opposed to the king, you're opposed to God. And if you're opposed to God, you're opposed to morality and virtue and goodness. And that means you're a friend of Satan and should be killed.”

0.56

If Kant is to be thought of as an intellectual scientist or political scientist in the strict sense, then Hume (and Burke following him) can be thought of as a political engineer who wants to take the insights of political philosophy and apply them, with pragmatism as the standard—does it work in practice?

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“If we think of someone like Kant as being a an intellectual scientist or a political scientist in the strict sense of the term, Hume can be thought of as a political engineer. He wants to take the insights of political philosophy and apply them. And his standard will be pragmatic. Does it work in practice? If it doesn't work in practice, he thinks that a theory is by definition a bad theory.”

0.56

Burke continuously invokes the Glorious Revolution as his ideal of a fine revolution—quick, easy, and bloodless—and avoids discussing the English Civil War period (1640-1660) because it would give the impression that revolutions cannot always be avoided and that even governments he held in high regard were based on earlier revolutions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke continuously harks back to the Glorious Revolution as his idea of a of a fine revolution. Not much happens. The change is quick, easy, bloodless. He does his best not to talk about the period of English history between 1640 and 1660 because it would give people the unpleasant impression that once in a while revolutions can't be avoided, and perhaps even the government he thinks so highly of was based upon an earlier revolution.”

0.56

Burke wants something prudent, something you can count on, something that would be conservative without being reactionary, and is willing to make changes in political practice and theory so long as they are gradual, balance out empirical interests represented in the society, and are possibly reversible if they turn out to be deleterious in practice.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Well, Burke doesn't want anything uncommon or magnificent. He wants something prudent, something you can count on, something that would be conservative without being reactionary. And so he's willing to make changes in political practice and in political theory so long as they're gradual, so long as they they balance out the empirical interests that are represented in the society at the moment that a particular reform is suggested, and so that we can possibly reverse any given reform so that if it turns out to be deleterious in practice, we can say, 'Okay, we made a mistake. We're going to revoke that attempted reform.'”

0.56

Burke believes that the entire tradition of the French Enlightenment—the tradition of continental rationalism and abstract theorizing independent of contingent and immediate circumstances—leads to political fallacies like emphasizing the imprescriptible rights of man and other abstractions which have no immediate connection to the historical experience of French government.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke says this could have been predicted. The entire tradition of the French Enlightenment, the tradition of continental rationalism, of abstract theorizing independent of contingent and immediate circumstances, it would lead is what leads to political fallacies like emphasizing the imprescriptible rights of man and other abstractions which have no immediate connection to the historical experience of French government.”

0.56

An empiricist who hears that someone wants to abolish slavery globally and make everyone free will object as Burke would about prohibition, saying there are many potential dangers in such a project, and Burke particularly opposed the democratization of politics, not wanting to extend the franchise on the basis of one man, one vote.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“If you're an empiricist and somebody says that what I'd like to do is abolish slavery on a global basis and make everyone free. Well, Burke is going to say about that the same thing he said about prohibition only in spades and much more emphatically because this project of abolishing slavery, of creating universal human freedom is obviously some is obviously kind of thing some German thought up. Englishmen don't think up stuff like that unless of course they're moved by religious piety as opposed to skeptical empirical philosophy...Burke was very strongly against the democratization of politics. He certainly did not want to extend the franchise on the basis of one man, one vote.”

0.56

What Burke likes is whatever we happen to have, and this is true of every conservative: if you are a Burkean conservative and got born in feudal Japan, you would think feudal Japan is a terrific set of institutions, demonstrating a certain kind of piety about what you were raised with in Burke's ideas.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“So, what Burke likes is whatever we happen to have. And this is going to be true of every conservative. If you If you're a Burkean conservative by kind of outlook or inclination, if you get born in Japan in feudal ages, you're going to think that feudal Japan is a terrific set of institutions as well. There's a certain sort of piety about what you were raised with in Burke's ideas, which he gives a kind of philosophical formulation to.”

0.56

The upside of Burkean conservatism is that it restricts us from doing implausible, impractical kinds of reform; the downside is that it prevents us from making salutary reforms, and there is a sort of timidity to it which passes for wisdom but is often just timidity, a fear of taking a chance.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“So, the upside of Burkean conservatism is that it restricts us from doing implausible, impractical kinds of reform. The downside of it is that it prevents us from making salutary reforms, and that to be honest, there's a a sort of to marry There's a sort of timidity to it, which I think I don't know, passes for wisdom, but is often just timidity, which is often just a fear of taking a chance.”

0.56

Burke argues that if legislatures are to work scientifically, then parties are necessary, and since England has not had a civil war and sedition is not attached to political parties, they should not only be acknowledged but declared legitimate, and one shouldn't be afraid to say 'I'm a Whig' or 'I'm a Tory'—this is a triumph of practice over theory.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“And he says, 'Look, if we're going to be scientific, this is the way legislatures work. You can't make them work without political parties. And since we haven't had a civil war in England, and since there is no sedition attached to this political party, not only should we acknowledge them, we should say that they're legitimate and we shouldn't be afraid to say that I'm a I'm a Whig or I'm a Tory.' And that's a great breakthrough. It's the triumph of theory of practice over theory, and that's a typically English idea.”

0.56

Burke says that abstract theorizing done by professors in their studies is not only wrong but positively dangerous; when carried into practice, the result is not improvement but chaos, because trying to institute what amounts to a secular millennium by ending the messy, ugly, evil portion of human existence and creating a new, fundamentally changed social structure with perfect equality, perfect liberty, and perfect justice produces the opposite of these goods.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke says all this abstract theorizing done by the professors in their studies are not only wrong but positively dangerous. When carried into practice, the result is not improvement, it's chaos. By trying to institute what amounts to a secular millennium, by trying to end the earlier messy, ugly, evil portion of human existence and create a new, fundamentally changed social structure which in which creates perfect equality and perfect liberty and perfect justice, what you get is perfectly the opposite.”

0.56

Burke argues that since none of the theorists have left the library, they have no idea how legislatures actually work in practice, and he tells them: 'This is the way they work in practice. You create a theory which accounts for that. That's called a scientific approach to politics, as opposed to what he views as essentially a theological approach to politics.'

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“And as a matter of fact, since you theorists have no clue as to how to run a legislature, cuz none of you have left the library, let me tell you how legislatures are really run in practice. And then what I want you folks to do is create a theory which allows for this, because practice comes first. That practical English empirical approach to the world around us. He says, 'Look, I know a lot about legislatures. I spent 30 years years there. So, rather than me reading your French text about how all legislatures should work if you were to make yourself consistent with absolute reason or something along those lines, he says, 'This is the way they work in practice. You create a theory which accounts for that. That's called a scientific approach to politics, as opposed to what he views as essentially a theological approach to politics.'”

0.55

For Burke, as for Hume and the entire English tradition of political and moral thought, prudence is the great virtue, distinguishing English-speaking empirical philosophers from continental rationalists whose alternative great virtue is ruthlessness—the willingness to take an idea as far as it can possibly go regardless of common sense.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“For him, as for Hume, and this is one of the connections between Burke and the entire tradition of English political and moral thought, prudence is the great virtue. If we were to distinguish between the empiricists and the idealists, or distinguish between the the English-speaking philosophers and the continental rationalists, I would say that the great virtue of the English empirical philosophers is prudence. They are prudent men. They don't get carried away by either emotion or reason. They do things more or less within the bounds of common sense. The alternative virtue, which we find among the rationalistic philosophers, primarily among the German-speaking philosophers, also, I would say, among Plato, all metaphysicians, their great alternative virtue is ruthlessness.”

0.55

Burke believes that the abstract tradition of rational inquiry starting with Descartes and continuing through the French Enlightenment is dangerous because it neglects practicality in favor of abstract theories with no immediate connection to historical experience, and the guillotine is the logical outcome of rationalism—the logical outcome of insisting that both political and moral duty comes from pure reason rather than from the collected connection of our traditions, feelings, sentiments, and reasonings about those traditions and feelings.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“He thinks that the abstract tradition of rational inquiry that starts in French culture, I guess, with Descartes and moves on through the tradition of the French Enlightenment is dangerous because it neglects practicality in favor of abstract theories that have no immediate connection to historical experience. In some respects, the guillotine is the logical outcome of rationalism. It's the logical outcome of insisting that both political and moral duty comes from pure reason, rather than the collected connection of our traditions, our feelings, our sentiments, our reasonings about our traditions and feelings and sentiments.”

0.53

Rational risk minimization is a good thing and prudence is a virtue, but prudence is not the only virtue, and taken to an extreme, prudence may be sometimes a vice, whereas prudence has no understanding of the heroic virtues that attach to ruthlessness.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Rational mis- risk minimization is a good thing, and I must confess prudence is a virtue. My point in in suggesting that there are limitations to this is that prudence is not the only virtue, and that taken to an extreme, it may be that prudence is sometimes a vice. Prudence has no understanding and no appreciation of the heroic virtues that attach to ruthlessness.”

0.52

For the empiricist and skeptic and conservative, there is a moral in Athenian democracy's failure: the democratization of politics is downright dangerous, and potentially more dangerous than abolition of slavery because it has been tried before and was a disaster, whereas slavery abolition is entirely unprecedented.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“Now, for the empiricist, for the skeptic, for the conservative, there's a moral there. Democracy, the democratization of politics, regardless of whether the categorical imperative says you have to, regardless of whether Rousseau likes it or not, regardless of whether continental thinkers are going to approve of you, makes no difference. The democratization of politics is downright dangerous, and in some respects it's more dangerous than the abolition of slavery because that hasn't been tried before. We've tried democracy before. It's a blasted disaster.”

0.52

Burke advocates politics as the art of the possible, viewing proposals for reform that will have to be judged within the context of what works in practice.

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Someone wants to find politics as the art of the possible, and that's very much Burke's perspective. Does it work in practice?”

0.52

The idea that we can institute a whole new world today is implicit in rationalism, and someone noted that the guillotine is a very Cartesian instrument because it separates the mind and the body so completely, which Burke would sympathize with as an example of what happens when you treat reason as independent from the embodied, traditional, sentimental aspects of human life.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“In other words, the idea that we can institute a whole new world today. I think someone once said that a the guillotine is a very Cartesian sort of an instrument because it separates the mind and the body so completely. Well, I think Burke would would sympathize with that kind of a view.”

0.52

Hume is something between the ancient political tradition and modern enlightened political theory which says there will be a diversity and plurality of ideas and voices, halfway between the two in his attempt to create legitimate opposition while still fearing the dangers of party and faction.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“So, Hume is something between the political the ancient tradition of political theory and the modern enlightened political theory, which says that there'll be a diversity of plurality of ideas and voices. Hume is halfway between the two.”

0.51

Burke limits what might be called the standard deviation of virtue and vice; you don't get too bad and don't get too good, having more or less what you had before and able to make things a little better, but Burke counsels against getting out of hand or getting enthusiastic, and prudence can sometimes be a vice as well as being a virtue.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke limits what we might call the standard deviation of virtue and vice. We don't get too bad, we don't get too good. We have more or less kind of what we had before. Maybe we can make things a little bit better, but don't get out of out of hand about this. That's really dangerous. Don't get enthusiastic. Be prudent. Burke counsels us to prudence, and I think that prudence is sometimes a vice as well as being a virtue.”

0.48

Burke is a very pragmatic thinker and practical man who is something of an opportunist, and his occasional lapses in thinking and writing should be forgiven because the heat of political polemic causes people to over-formulate arguments and go too far, and there is confusion in his work as he concerns himself with different political issues at different times.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“Burke is a very pragmatic thinker, a very practical man, and something of an opportunist as well. We ought to forgive him the occasional lapses in his thinking and in his writing. The heat of political polemic often get causes people to go out on a limb, to over-formulate an argument, to take it a little bit too far.”

0.47

Burke's practical political ability to see what likely outcomes of chaos will be demonstrates his strength as a practical politician; his criticism of the French Revolution is what he is mostly remembered for, earning him the name of great reactionary, though this label is not fair.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Lecture Instructor

“In other words, he anticipates something like like Not a bad anticipation. Again, the practical politician can see what the likely outcome of chaos in real life is going to be. So, his criticism of the French Revolution is what he's mostly remembered for, and that's where he gets the name of being a great reactionary.”

0.44

Burke has been largely neglected by professional philosophers because there are a great many inconsistencies in his work; he is not the deep, rigorous thinker found in Hume or Kant or professional scholars, but nevertheless advocates and makes a couple of important arguments.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“And there's a certain degree of truth in that. Burke has been largely neglected by professional politicians because there are a great many inconsistencies in his work. He's not the deep rigorous thinker that we're going to find in Hume or Kant or any of the professional scholars. Burke does advocate and does make a couple of arguments that are not novel and important.”

0.20

Although Burke's outlook shows rough consistency, he varies and vacillates the way most politicians do, because that is about the best we can expect from a man who has to live with the rough and tumble of politics every day.

factualspeaker onlynovelty 0/4durability 3/4· Lecture Instructor

“although there's a rough consistency to his outlook, he varies and vacillates the way most politicians do. It's about the best we can expect from a man that has to live with the rough and tumble of politics every day.”