epistemic
Relating to knowledge and its justification; epistemic features of an explanation include evidence and logical argumentation, as opposed to non-epistemic features like comfort or moral value.
As defined in 223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are
Other definitions
Related to knowledge, how we know things, and what we can claim to be true. In this context, used to describe the 'epistemology of the Republican party'—how Republicans collectively determine and maintain shared claims about reality.
Trump 2.0, DOGE, and America's Global Decline with Sam Harris and Jonah Goldberg
Where it comes up · 4
- The Merge: Ep. 03 | The past is not gone; it lives on in the future4 claims
- 223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are3 claims
- 354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality2 claims
- The Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)2 claims
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “epistemic” →
- For existential questions, people rate scientific explanations higher on epistemic dimensions (evidence, logical argumentation) and religious explanations higher on non-epistemic dimensions (comfort, reducing negative emotions, promoting moral behavior, bringing people together)—and this pattern replicates at every level of how strongly the individual believes the explanation.223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are
- The pattern of results is explained by people holding different thresholds for believing scientific versus religious explanations: to confidently believe a scientific explanation they demand a lot of evidence while being less demanding on non-epistemic characteristics, whereas for religious explanations they demand high non-epistemic characteristics while being less demanding on epistemic evidence.223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are
- Randomness is epistemic, not metaphysical—whether something appears random depends entirely on the observer's knowledge state. A pregnant woman's baby's sex is approximately 50/50 random to a stranger, 100% (or 95%) determined to her doctor, and the baby's outcome is never truly random but only appears so because the observer lacks information about the deterministic process.The Merge: Ep. 03 | The past is not gone; it lives on in the future
- A Black Swan's status is also epistemic: an event is a Black Swan relative to what an observer knows, not intrinsically. For a butcher, a turkey's fate is not a Black Swan; for the turkey, it is. For September 11 hijackers, the event was certain; for the rest of the world, it was an extreme surprise.The Merge: Ep. 03 | The past is not gone; it lives on in the future
- Non-epistemic goals pervade everyday explanation, not just religious explanation: when explaining something like forgetting a birthday, people simultaneously pursue epistemic goals (saying true things) and non-epistemic goals (not appearing to be a terrible person, regulating emotions, managing social and moral consequences), often non-consciously and via self-deception toward the most charitable interpretation.223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are
- Randomness is not an objective property of events but an epistemic property dependent on the observer's knowledge; what appears random to one person (a pregnant woman's baby gender being ~50/50 for a stranger) is nearly certain to another (95-100% for her doctor with medical information).The Merge: Ep. 03 | The past is not gone; it lives on in the future
- While most of the observable universe is composed of ordinary matter (stars, planets, etc.), that matter represents only about 4% of the universe—the other 96% is dark matter and dark energy that physicists haven't figured outThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Status functions often need status function indicators to mark that one has the status—uniforms indicate police status, driver's licenses indicate authorized driving, wedding rings indicate married status—and these indicators are primarily epistemic devicesThe Logical Structure of Human Civilization (John Searle)
- Philosophical discussions about whether randomness is truly random are functionally useless—a blind alley—and ultimately lead back to theological definitions of God as that For Whom nothing is random; the practical approach is to treat randomness as epistemic and focus on real-world consequences.The Merge: Ep. 03 | The past is not gone; it lives on in the future
- A system genuinely is an intentional agent (not merely interpretable as one) when viewing it as an agent is explanatorily indispensable — when one cannot adequately explain or predict its behavior in any other way — which goes beyond Dennett's instrumentalist intentional stance by treating indispensability as strong ontic evidence rather than mere interpretability.354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality