definition

Explanatory Indispensability Test for Agency

A system genuinely is an intentional agent (not merely interpretable as one) when viewing it as an agent is explanatorily indispensable — when one cannot adequately explain or predict its behavior in any other way — which goes beyond Dennett's instrumentalist intentional stance by treating indispensability as strong ontic evidence rather than mere interpretability.

definitionpending

Speaker

Christian List

Evidence Quote

“to be an agent is not yet the same as to be interpretable as an agent, 'cause one is a sort of epistemic criterion and the other one is sort of ontic. Rather, if a system is interpretable satisfactorily, adequately, only by viewing it as an agent... then the explanatory indispensability of viewing the system as an agent is a very good, strong indicator... that we are truly, really dealing with an agent.”

Source

354 | Christian List on Free Will and Levels of Reality— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:28:26 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...