factual

Religious Explanations Win on Non-Epistemic, Science on Epistemic

For existential questions, people rate scientific explanations higher on epistemic dimensions (evidence, logical argumentation) and religious explanations higher on non-epistemic dimensions (comfort, reducing negative emotions, promoting moral behavior, bringing people together)—and this pattern replicates at every level of how strongly the individual believes the explanation.

factualpending

Speaker

Tania Lombrozo

Evidence Quote

“suppose you have two people who both give a given religious explanation of four on this five-point scale... they're still going to say that the scientific one is better than the religious one, in terms of these epistemic dimensions, and the religious is better than the scientific in terms of the non-epistemic characteristics.”

Source

223 | Tania Lombrozo on What Explanations Are— Sean Carroll's Mindscape
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:17:23 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...