deontology
The ethical approach, associated with Kant, that judges actions by duties and intentions (a pure will and universalizable maxims) rather than by their consequences.
As defined in ms_254
Where it comes up · 21
- Robert Frank on Coase5 claims
- Paul Bloom on Cruelty2 claims
- Robert Frank on Inequality 11/15/20102 claims
- 100 | Solo | Life and Its Meaning2 claims
- 176 | Joshua Greene on Morality, Psychology, and Trolley Problems2 claims
- 30 | Derek Leben on Ethics for Robots and Artificial Intelligences2 claims
- 53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality2 claims
- AMA | October 20212 claims
and 13 more
Most important claims · 10 of 32Search all claims for “deontology” →
- Utilitarianism (maximize aggregate utility) and deontology/Kantianism (follow hard-and-fast rules regardless of consequences) both claim to possess a formula that makes moral intuition unnecessary, yet each refutes the other only by appealing to moral intuition—the utilitarian invokes our gut sense that betraying Anne Frank is wrong, and the deontologist invokes our gut sense that harvesting one healthy visitor's organs to save five patients is wrong—proving moral intuition is inescapable.Moshe Koppel on Norms, Tradition, and Resilient Societies
- Deontological principles and virtues are only ever nominated as good because we believe they have good consequences on balance; no one would endorse a categorical imperative known to uniformly produce terrible consequences, and a virtue like courage in service of an awful end (e.g., a more courageous Hitler) ceases to be praiseworthy—so non-consequentialist theories covertly smuggle consequentialist assumptions everywhere.305 - Moral Knowledge
- Deontologists and virtue ethicists smuggle good consequences into their theories from the start—no one would defend the categorical imperative if it reliably made everyone miserable, and no sane person would call virtues like generosity good if they caused nothing but pain and chaos—so consequences, whether real or imagined, are ultimately always the point of any ethics.364 - Facts Values
- Criticism that utilitarianism or consequentialism is bad amounts to a claim that it has bad consequences, which can simply be folded into a fuller consequentialism; everyone is in fact some form of consequentialist, since if you listen to people long enough—even deontologists or virtue ethicists—they reveal the consequences they really care about.303 - The Fall Of Sam Bankman-fried
- Ethical approaches divide into deontology, where morals come from a set of rules to obey (e.g., Kant's categorical imperative), and consequentialism, where what matters is the consequences of actions (e.g., utilitarianism maximizing utility); both face serious problems when applied to real situations.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- Deontological reasoning is highly rational in a social sense because deontological reasoners are seen as more trustworthy social partners; close relationships are premised on prioritization, so people overwhelmingly prefer deontological reasoners over utilitarians as spouses and best friends—challenging the view that deontology is merely an irrational intuition.227 | Molly Crockett on the Psychology of Morality
- Deontology fails for the same reason bureaucracies fail: you cannot anticipate every future situation a rule will face, so cases inevitably arise where the obvious right action conflicts with the rule, as when an absolute prohibition on lying would require telling a murderer where their hidden victim is.53 | Solo -- On Morality and Rationality
- When systematizing moral preferences into a coherent theory, there is a danger of over-simplifying—as with naive utilitarianism that would endorse secretly killing one healthy person to harvest organs for twenty—and the right response is usually not to accept the repugnant conclusion but to recognize the systematization was too crude; moral systems should be logical but may legitimately remain fuzzy, balancing aggregate welfare against individual rights as the trolley problem illustrates.100 | Solo | Life and Its Meaning
- A revised consequentialism can capture everything we want to say about moral truth, because purported non-consequentialist objections (like the deontological organ-harvesting trolley case) actually rely on an incomplete tally of consequences—the doctor-vivisection example is rejected precisely because of the terror and paranoia of living in a society where such killings are normal, which is itself a consequence.299 - Steps In The Right Direction
- Moral philosophy is best understood as the codification of our inner subconscious preferences for how we want to treat others and be treated—taking the various biological, cultural, and cognitive intuitions we have and bringing them into the clear light of reason to form a coherent system—rather than the discovery of objective moral facts existing in nature.100 | Solo | Life and Its Meaning