closed system
A system with no access to external free energy; entropy can only increase within it, and no living thing is one.
As defined in 340 | Rebecca Newberger Goldstein on What Matters and Why It Matters
Other definitions
A self-reinforcing feedback loop in which generational cohorts are shaped by history, then shape history, which shapes the next generation, creating cycles
Keeping it Simple | Ep.38: Are We Fourth Turning Japanese? Or Is It Different this Time?
Where it comes up · 9
- Henry Ellenbogen - Man Versus Machine - [Invest Like the Best, EP.452]3 claims
- AI and algorithmic decision making3 claims
- Richard Davies on Extreme Economies2 claims
- AMA | November 20222 claims
- The Mattering Instinct (with Rebecca Newberger Goldstein)1 claim
- 158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time1 claim
- 340 | Rebecca Newberger Goldstein on What Matters and Why It Matters1 claim
- 67 | Kate Jeffery on Entropy, Complexity, and Evolution1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “closed system” →
- Prisoners created the 'dot economy' by exploiting open-system prepaid debit cards: an outsider buys a MoneyPak, scrapes off its 14-digit code (the 'dots'), and transmits those numbers—which themselves carry up to $500 of value—into the prison, where they are exchanged between prisoners and reloaded onto another card outside, creating a totally liquid, untraceable form of buying power because the payer and spender never meet, link accounts, or know each other.Richard Davies on Extreme Economies
- The old closed media system scheduled programming to maximize advertising and monetization rather than when viewers wanted to watch, so the best shows aired on Thursday and the worst on Sunday night, and that closed structure was vulnerable to internet distribution.Henry Ellenbogen - Man Versus Machine - [Invest Like the Best, EP.452]
- Because entropy increases in every closed system, and no living system is a closed system, life is fundamentally defined as being in resistance to entropy by drawing on external low-entropy sources of free energy such as food and sunlight, making each life a counter-entropic process.340 | Rebecca Newberger Goldstein on What Matters and Why It Matters
- In closed systems where humans identify targets and create rules, machines will eventually outperform humans because machines make fewer mistakes, even though the complexity of business and investment is vastly greater than chess.AI and algorithmic decision making
- In the early media era, cable networks were the best businesses because they grew about 20% for 20 years with roughly 20% returns on equity, while the rest of media earned average returns; John Malone backed most of the cable entrepreneurs.Henry Ellenbogen - Man Versus Machine - [Invest Like the Best, EP.452]
- The closed media system optimized for advertiser value rather than viewer timing, and the telecom bubble's broadband build-out eventually enabled YouTube and Netflix, which broke the oligopoly, so owning the durable asset was riskier than buying the next standard.Henry Ellenbogen - Man Versus Machine - [Invest Like the Best, EP.452]
- Human progress is not doomed to merely shift disorder around, because entropy only increases in closed systems and human systems are dramatically not closed—the biosphere receives low-entropy radiation from the Sun and returns high-entropy radiation—so while universal entropy rises, local entropy stays low, and the relaxation timescales of large-scale systems vastly exceed a human lifetime, making the detailed dynamics matter far more than the bare statement that entropy increases.AMA | November 2022
- Machine learning algorithms can be trusted when there is sufficient sample size in a closed system where the future resembles the past, but in situations where the future could differ from the past and deep understanding is absent, trusting machine learning becomes very dangerous.AI and algorithmic decision making
- Generations are shaped young by history—particularly by what they experience as children and during coming of age regarding what they fear, what they value, whether they are protected or unprotected—and then 40 years later that generation shapes history which shapes the next group, creating a closed system that produces four distinct generations with four distinct moods.Keeping it Simple | Ep.38: Are We Fourth Turning Japanese? Or Is It Different this Time?
- There is no contradiction between universal entropy increase and a person not being at equilibrium, because a human is not a closed system and maintains its own low entropy by dumping entropy into the surrounding world, just as a fridge stays cold by warming the room; similarly we can keep accumulating information about things of interest by randomizing the rest of the world.158 | David Wallace on the Arrow of Time