What this covers

Rebecca Goldstein, a philosopher and novelist, speaks with Sean Carroll about what it means to matter—both for something to hold importance and for a person to feel deserving of their own attention. The conversation centers on The Mattering Instinct, Goldstein's account of a biological drive embedded in humans as creatures born helpless and dependent: the need to justify ourselves to ourselves and to feel worthy of the attention we inevitably pay ourselves. She traces this instinct to Spinoza's concept of conatus, a striving to persist and flourish that makes self-regard involuntary and excessive. Against this backdrop, Goldstein argues that while there is no single objectively correct way to matter, there are better and worse ones—those aligned with the order-creating resistance to entropy that defines life itself.

The discussion ranges across how humans become justificatory creatures, making values and meaning in ways no other animal does, and how this shapes conflict. Goldstein introduces the Mattering Map, a taxonomy of four broad strategies people pursue: transcendent mattering through religious or cosmic purpose; social mattering, divided between intimate belonging and the pursuit of fame; heroic striving toward excellence; and competitive mattering, where one person's importance requires another's diminishment. The conversation examines why people universalize their own mattering project, seeing it as objective truth for all, which fuels political and religious division. She illustrates this through cases ranging from reformed extremists to the paradox of fame-seeking among the young, and argues that dignity and respect—rather than contempt—offer a path away from toxic forms of mattering. Throughout, she locates human flourishing not in cosmic purpose or social isolation, but in lives and projects that create order: knowledge, justice, beauty, and fairness.

Sharpest takeaway

Goldstein argues that humans are 'creatures of matter who long to matter' — that an instinct to feel deserving of our own attention is built into our biology, drives us to pursue 'mattering projects,' and that while there is no single right way to matter, there are objectively better and worse ways to satisfy this longing, with the best ones aligning with the counter-entropic, order-creating force of life itself.

  • Mattering means being 'deserving of attention,' a normative notion applied reflexively to ourselves
  • Living systems resist entropy, and good mattering projects create order (knowledge, justice, beauty)
  • People universalize their own mattering project, which drives political and religious conflict

The argument · threads4 threads · 29 claims
0.85

The mattering instinct defines humanity but creates suffering when people feel worthless or impose their values on others.

1 pointcentrality 5/5
  • The mattering instinct is what makes us specifically human, providing purpose and meaning, but it also hurts us — both when we feel we don't matter and when we demand that others' ideas of what matters line up with our own.

    “It's both what helps us in many ways. It provides purpose and meaning to our lives, and it hurts us in certain ways if we feel that we don't matter”

0.71

Many valid paths to mattering exist alongside objective standards distinguishing right ways from wrong ones.

1 pointcentrality 4/5
  • There is no single right way to matter — many ways are valid, such as creative novelty for one person or a quiet family life for another — yet there are simultaneously objectively wrong ways and many right ways to care about mattering.

    “there's no right way to matter. There's no single right way to matter. And yet there are right and wrong ways to care about mattering. Both of that is true at the same time.”

0.44

The universe operates by physical laws alone, without supernatural deities or spirits guiding human life.

1 pointcentrality 2/5
  • Naturalism is the view that the universe is just stuff obeying the laws of physics, with no supernatural deities, demigods, or spirits affecting our lives or giving us guidance, as opposed to theism.

    “Naturalism being the view that the universe is just stuff obeying the laws of Physics, that there's no extra supernatural deities or demigods or evil spirits or good spirits pushing us around”

0.30

Boltzmann grasped how life uses free energy to resist entropy before Schrödinger received credit for the insight.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • Although Schrödinger is often credited with the insight that life uses free energy from the world to resist entropy, Boltzmann fully understood this and mentioned it from the start, even though he did not write a book devoted to it.

    “it's absolutely true that Schrödinger highlighted this fact that we make use of free energy out there in the world. But Boltzmann totally understood it.”