The Mattering Instinct (with Rebecca Newberger Goldstein)
What this covers
Rebecca Goldstein, a philosopher and author, joins Russ Roberts to discuss her argument that humans are fundamentally driven by a need to matter—to be worthy of the attention we necessarily pay ourselves. Goldstein traces this instinct from physics through biology to ethics, grounding it in thermodynamics and the brain's default mode network, which keeps us constantly focused on ourselves. She positions the Mattering Instinct as a defining feature of human nature, drawing on thinkers like Adam Smith, whose claim that humans naturally desire both to be loved and to be "lovely" (worthy of respect) anticipates her central thesis. The conversation explores how this hardwired need, when unmet, drives loneliness, extremism, and destructive behavior—particularly acute in materially wealthy societies where money alone cannot satisfy the longing to matter.
Goldstein distinguishes four ways people pursue mattering: transcendent mattering, social mattering, competitive mattering, and heroic striving. She argues that much modern suffering stems from conceiving mattering as zero-sum—the belief that others' significance diminishes one's own—a framing extremist movements exploit to recruit the vulnerable. Roberts and Goldstein examine why material success and comfort fail to resolve what she calls a "crisis of mattering," questioning how economists measure wellbeing when meaningful work differs profoundly from mere consumption. The discussion touches on clinical depression as an expression of feeling undeserving of one's own attention, family dynamics and jealousy among siblings, and the role of the Urge to Universalize—people's tendency to insist their mattering project is the only worthwhile path. Goldstein also acknowledges the theory's breadth, noting that explanations claiming to account for everything warrant suspicion, a caution she applies to her own framework.
Goldstein argues that humans are 'creatures of matter who long to matter'—a hardwired instinct, traceable from thermodynamics through biology to ethics, to prove we deserve the attention we cannot help paying ourselves; the unmet need to matter underlies loneliness, extremism, and polarization, especially in materially wealthy societies.
- Attention evolved to resist entropy, leaving us fixated on ourselves and uneasy about whether that self-fixation is deserved
- People pursue mattering through four strategies—transcendent, social, competitive, and heroic-striving—and zero-sum framings of mattering drive division
- Material wealth cannot satisfy the need to matter, so affluent societies experience a 'crisis of mattering' expressed as loneliness, resentment, and destructive behavior
The mattering instinct is a fundamental human drive distinct from loneliness, rooted in self-attention and deserving of that attention.
- The brain's default mode network—what consciousness does when not attending to the outside world—shows we constantly think about ourselves, our past, and our future, demonstrating how much we matter to ourselves.
“Something in neuroscience called the default mode network--you know, what's going on in our consciousness when we're not paying attention to things outside. And, we're thinking about ourselves.”
- Because self-reflection lets us step outside ourselves and see that the amount of attention we pay to ourselves implies we think we matter more than anything in the universe—which we know is false—this produces unease, and life becomes a quest to validate our inherent self-centeredness by proving we deserve that attention.
“What the mattering instinct is about is trying to prove to ourselves that we are deserving of all the attention that we can't help paying ourselves.”
- Severe clinical depression, even in talented people with loving relationships, is often expressed as the conviction 'I don't matter'—an unappeased need to feel deserving of one's own self-attention rather than loneliness, suggesting the mattering instinct is a distinct cornerstone of human wellbeing.
“some of them are the most talented, brilliant people I know, with good family lives, with loving friends--'I don't matter.' And, there is such self-loathing in this.”
- Because the Second Law of Thermodynamics dictates that closed systems decay toward disorder, living systems exist as a constant resistance to entropy requiring external energy input; attention evolved as a tool for this resistance, and in highly complex creatures like humans that attention becomes intensely fixated on the self.
“to be a living system is to be in resistance to entropy. We are not closed systems... we require a lot of input of energy--sunlight, food--that is put to work to resist.”
- Our species is best defined as creatures of matter who long to matter; this longing to matter—to be deserving of attention—characterizes and distinguishes humanity.
“I would define us, our species, as creatures of matter who long to matter.”
- To matter is defined as being deserving or worthy of attention; thus to long to matter is to long to be worthy of attention—and ultimately of the attention we already pay ourselves.
“I define, by the way, this word 'mattering' to mean deserving of attention. So that word, 'deserving,' 'worthy,' is built into the notion of mattering.”
Mattering operates through four general strategies: transcendent, social, competitive, and heroic-striving modes of seeking significance.
- Beneath the many domains of the 'Mattering Map' there appear to be four general strategies for appeasing the mattering instinct—transcendent mattering (to the universe/God), social mattering (to others), competitive mattering (more than others), and heroic-striving mattering (realizing standards of excellence)—a taxonomy Goldstein offers as open to empirical falsification.
“there are just generally four different strategies... transcendent mattering, and social mattering, competitive mattering, and heroic striving mattering”
- Competitive matterers think of mattering in zero-sum terms—needing to matter more than others and to be the person in the room who matters most—a pattern Goldstein observes in some prominent and powerful figures on the world stage.
“they really think of mattering in zero-sum terms; that to the extent that others matter, they're taking something away from me, that it's always a striving to matter more.”
- Heroic strivers seek to matter not to others or to a transcendent presence but by realizing standards of excellence—intellectual, artistic, athletic, or ethical—that they feel born to realize, often experiencing this as a self-defined mission.
“They are trying to realize certain standards of excellence that they feel they are born to realize. And, it could be intellectual, artistic, athletic, and ethical.”
- Social mattering—justifying oneself by mattering to others—increasingly takes the form of seeking fame, which has become ever easier to attain (e.g., lip-syncing on YouTube to a million followers), and probably describes how most people conceive of mattering, in both healthy and unhealthy ways.
“fame, to matter to many strangers--is such an important motive in our time because it's become ever easier to become famous. You can bob your head and lip sync on YouTube and have a million followers.”
- Transcendent mattering—the religious or spiritual belief that the universe or a God-like creator purposefully made each person for a reason—delivers the highest form of mattering by giving one a role in the narrative of eternity, and its loss leaves the universe and the self feeling diminished.
“This delivers the highest form of a sense of mattering: that you have a role to play in the narrative of eternity; that that which created the universe has a purpose for you.”
The human tendency to universalize one's mattering project as the only worthy path, evident in philosophy and extremism, reflects both estimable and dangerous aspects of human nature.
- Across all regions of the mattering map people feel an urge to universalize or proselytize their own mattering project—insisting 'do it my way or you're wasting your life'—because grounding one's life in something objective implies everyone ought to recognize it, even though projects actually depend on contingent talents, passions, and culture.
“it is the urge to try to found our life or mattering on something objective--that this really does matter... if it's objective, then everybody ought to recognize it.”
- Socrates' claim that 'the unexamined life is not worth living' is an example of the universalizing urge, and was so offensive—implying his jurors lived worthless lives—that more Athenians voted for his death than had voted for his guilt.
“he so offended people by saying that--basically implying that they were living lives not worth living... that more people voted for his death than had voted for his guilt.”
- A theory that seems to explain everything should be regarded with suspicion; the analytic philosophical training of taking small problems and analyzing them militates against grand metaphysical theories, which is itself a reason for caution toward the mattering theory.
“I'm very suspicious of big theories that seem to explain everything... My training in philosophy is as an analytic philosopher. We take little small problems and try to analyze them”
- Both the noun 'matter' and the verb 'to matter' derive in English from the Latin word mater, meaning mother.
“both of which come from the Latin word mater--mother. Which is interesting, actually.”
- Spinoza's magnum opus The Ethics begins from an abstract, unconventional notion of God identified with nature (Deus sive Natura) and works toward ethics—a structural model Goldstein adapts by beginning instead with physics and likewise ending with ethics.
“His magnum opus is called The Ethics... It starts with what he thinks of as the groundwork, which is his very abstract notion of God.”
- Physicists from Einstein onward have promised that, unlike all other physical laws which are subject to revision, the Second Law of Thermodynamics—that entropy increases in a closed system—will never be overthrown.
“the one law of physics that physicists have promised us--starting with Einstein and going forth... will never be overthrown. All physical laws are subject to revision... But not the law, the Second Law of Thermodynamics”
- The notion of the Mattering Map originated in Goldstein's first book, the 1983 philosophical novel The Mind-Body Problem, where her main character devised it—indicating the idea has been developing for over four decades.
“The first book I ever wrote, which happened to have been a novel... I had my main character come up with this notion of the Mattering Map... that book was published in 1983.”
Ethical pursuit of mattering requires grounding it in projects rather than objective claims and avoiding destruction of others.
- Following Spinoza's move from physics/metaphysics to ethics, Goldstein holds that not all ways of pursuing mattering are acceptable—there are bad places on the mattering map—even though a wide range of projects are legitimate; the ethical constraint is pursuing one's strategy without causing destruction or misery to others.
“Not all ways of pursuing our mattering are okay, I think. But, a whole bunch of them are, right?”
- We must ground the conviction that we each matter in mattering projects rather than in objective talent-claims, and the very fact that we long to justify our self-obsession is itself an indication that something matters—an estimable feature of our species, even though it can lead to dark and destructive places.
“our longing to matter is itself indication of something that matters. It's something estimable in us. I admire our species for taking on this burden of justifying, each of us justifying ourselves, ourselves.”
- Amending Freud's 'love and work,' Goldstein argues the two cornerstones of humanness are connectedness—having people who pay us attention whether we deserve it or not, without which we suffer anti-flourishing loneliness—and the mattering instinct, whose absence produces not loneliness but a feeling of waste, self-loathing, or outward resentment.
“Freud had said that the two cornerstones of humanness are love and work. And, I would amend that slightly... for love I would substitute connectedness--the feeling that there are people in our lives who will pay us attention whether we deserve it or not.”
Unappeased mattering and zero-sum thinking drive conflict, extremism, and large-scale destructive historical events.
- Many people conceive of mattering as zero-sum—believing that to the extent others matter, they matter less—and extremist movements exploit this by telling vulnerable, unappeased individuals that named groups are 'taking your mattering away,' offering identity-based significance as a lifeline.
“'You are a white male heterosexual American. And, these people are taking your mattering away from you.' This notion of mattering as being zero-sum that many people have: To the extent that others matter, I matter less.”
- Large-scale unappeased longing—above all the longing to matter—is what makes history, frequently producing the destructive events and constraints on freedom that fill history books.
“Longing, on a large scale--unappeased longing on a large scale--is what makes history... They are events that can lead to great destruction--towards all sorts of terrible constraints on freedom”
Each person's position on the mattering map is shaped by temperament, culture, and experience rather than chosen freely.
- Where a person ends up on the mattering map is shaped by temperament, culture, and personal experience rather than chosen; Goldstein, raised to be a transcender like her siblings, instead became a heroic striver for reasons she cannot fully explain.
“It's temperament, it's culture, it's personal experience. It's--where we end up on the mattering map, what continent we end up on”
- In raising more than one child it is critically important that each child feels there is enough mattering to go around, because the family provides the first model of where one stands vis-à-vis one's own mattering—a model that matters throughout life—and shortfalls produce fierce jealousy.
“it is terribly important that each child feels there is enough mattering to go around... that first modeling comes from the family.”