charter city
A new city built with its own special rules/governance, proposed (notably by Paul Romer) as a way to import good institutions; Bertaud is skeptical given location scarcity.
As defined in Alain Bertaud
Where it comes up · 5
- Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/20109 claims
- Alain Bertaud2 claims
- Paul Romer on Urban Growth2 claims
- Stephen Jennings1 claim
- Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “charter city” →
- Setting up a charter city's foundational rules (e.g., guaranteed freedom of religion, protection of contracts, prevention of kidnapping) does not require central planning of city details like street layout or minimum shop square footage—these are second-order matters separable from the obvious sensible rules.Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/2010
- Hong Kong was effectively the first charter city — proof the model can work — but was done incorrectly because the deal was forced on China by Britain rather than agreed voluntarily, even though Chinese now say it turned out so well they would do it again.Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/2010
- Hong Kong was effectively the first charter city, though done incorrectly because the deal between China and Britain was forced on China rather than voluntary; the Chinese today might say it turned out so well they'd do it again.Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/2010
- Three conceptual roles—host (provides land), source (provides people), and guarantor (enforces and protects rules)—can be mixed and matched among nations to build a charter city, as illustrated by India running an internal contest among states or Brazil hosting and guaranteeing a zone for Haitian migrants.Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/2010
- Charter cities have rarely happened because seeding or taking sovereignty is an intractable problem; Tatu City instead operates as a private municipality with devolved authorities, giving it charter-city-like decision-making power and the incentive to optimize the long-term net present value of the city, thereby realizing many of the envisaged benefits—quality governance, infrastructure, security, environmental amenities—without the sovereignty obstacle.Stephen Jennings
- Rather than pressuring for more aid, celebrities could use their influence to pressure a particular poor country's government to reduce regulatory red tape and strengthen property rights, justice, and the ability to register a business, creating a natural experiment—though the obstacle is that such reforms are hard to make emotionally compelling or 'write a song about.'Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
- A charter city is unoccupied land with a charter specifying a system of rules that people, investors, and employers can voluntarily opt into, requiring governments to establish a legal governance structure that credibly enforces those rules into the future.Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/2010
- A guarantor nation can solve the long-term commitment problem for infrastructure investors who would not invest if their only guarantee came from a host country (like Madagascar) at risk of political unrest—as demonstrated when a coup ended the Madagascar charter city plan.Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/2010
- A charter city would be built on unoccupied land with a charter specifying a system of rules, and residents, investors, and employers would have the choice to opt in—requiring governments to credibly enforce those rules into the future.Paul Romer on Charter Cities 04/26/2010
- Cities need good locations and there are not 50 (or even many) excellent unused locations left in the world, so Paul Romer's vision of creating 50 charter cities is unrealistic; great cities like Singapore, Malacca, and Mumbai exist for good geographic reasons.Alain Bertaud