Michael Matheson Miller on Poverty, Inc
What this covers
Michael Matheson Miller and host Russ Roberts examine how post-World War II poverty alleviation has evolved into a self-perpetuating industry. Miller, director of the documentary Poverty, Inc., argues that the dominant model treats poor people as objects of charity rather than agents of their own development. The conversation centers on a counterintuitive claim: the poor lack not material goods but [institutions of justice](jargon:institutions of justice)—secure property rights, functioning courts, enforceable contracts, and the ability to register a business without prohibitive burden. Without these institutions, he contends, transfers of aid, food, or goods cannot generate durable wealth.
The episode traces how various well-intentioned mechanisms have backfired. NGOs and social entrepreneurship initiatives crowd out local businesses by flooding markets with free goods; Miller cites the Haitian solar panel company Enersa, which lost sales when NGOs distributed free streetlights after the earthquake. Foreign aid itself creates perverse incentives: governments need not build inclusive economies or tax bases when donors fund them directly, discouraging the very institutions the poor need. Agricultural subsidies and dumping from the West destroy developing-world farming. The conversation also addresses why elites in poor countries lack incentive to build these institutions—cheap labor from servants provides comfort without requiring systemic economic inclusion—and examines Hernando De Soto's finding that registering a business in Lima took 289 working days, revealing how legal systems structurally exclude the poor. Throughout, Miller argues the emergency-relief model, appropriate for crises, has been wrongly extended as a permanent development strategy for seventy years.
Miller argues that the dominant post-WWII model of poverty alleviation has become a self-perpetuating industry that treats the poor as objects of charity rather than as agents, and that real prosperity requires building 'institutions of justice' (property rights, access to courts, ability to register a business) rather than transferring aid, food, or goods.
- Aid, NGOs, and social entrepreneurship crowd out local businesses and create incentives that perpetuate poverty
- Poor people lack institutions of justice, not stuff, so transfers don't generate durable wealth
- Foreign aid lets governments avoid building inclusive institutions because they don't need a vibrant tax base
Aid systems create perverse incentives for governments to avoid building institutions of justice.
- The poverty industry creates incentives for developing-country governments precisely not to build institutions of justice, because aid means governments don't need a vibrant tax base or a dynamic economy to stay in power; thus 70 years of emergency-model and sentimental aid have produced exactly the incentives needed for governments to avoid building inclusive institutions.
“the poverty industry as it is now operating creates the incentive for governments in the developing world precisely not to build these institutions of justice. Because...the governments don't need a vibrant tax base and a dynamic economy to be able to stay in place.”
- Seventy years of arguing that more money will solve poverty (from the Marshall Plan to the ONE campaign and the Millennium/Sustainable Development Goals) has produced little evidence that increased foreign aid helps, because without the capacity to absorb aid it tends to create crony capitalism and exclude the poor.
“really there hasn't been that much evidence that increased foreign aid helps”
- Developing-country governments are pressured from above by the UN, World Bank, USAID, and IMF and from below by supposed 'grass roots NGOs,' but because the bottom-up organizations are themselves funded by the World Bank and IMF, they are more astroturf than genuine grassroots movements.
“the money is being funded from the World Bank and the IMF--to these so-called grass roots organizations it's a lot more astroturf than it is grass roots”
- Despite benevolent intentions, anti-poverty work has become an industry whose incentives reward the people who work in it more than the poor; like any industry it acts to stay in business, and thus ends up perpetuating poverty rather than creating the conditions for people to build their own prosperity.
“poverty, despite really good intentions of most of the people who have become involved, has become an industry, and the fact that all the incentives--many of the incentives--of humanitarian charity...the people who actually benefit the most from it are not the people we're trying to help, but actually the people who work in the industry”
- The emergency-relief model has been wrongly used as the model for long-term economic development for over 50 years, even though most of the postwar period in the developing world has not been a tragic emergency; aid is good in acute crises but harmful when continued as a permanent development strategy.
“we've used the emergency model as the model for economic development for 50-plus years. And the second part of the problem is that not every moment in those 50 to 70 years in the developing world has been this tragic emergency need”
Institutions of justice—clear land title, contract enforcement, accessible courts, business registration—are foundational to wealth creation and absent across the developing world.
- Access to justice in the courts is a key institution; a study cited indicates that in India it takes on average 20 years to get a court case heard and costs a great deal, so the poor are effectively excluded from legal recourse.
“in India, did a study and they said on average it takes 20 years to get your court case heard. And it costs a lot of money. So, if you are poor, you are completely excluded.”
- Hernando de Soto's experiment, in which student lawyers followed all rules to register a small sewing shop outside Lima using only public transport, took 289 days of 8-hour days, demonstrating that the legal and regulatory system is structurally unfriendly to poor people who cannot afford to circumvent it.
“it took them 289 days, 8 hours a day. Two hundred and eighty nine days to get their business registered. That's 289 days of not being able to work”
- Prosperity depends on 'institutions of justice'—clear title to land, access to justice in the courts, enforcement of contracts, the ability to freely exchange, and the ability to register a business without undue burden—that are taken for granted in the West but are weak or absent across much of the developing world; without them, free or erratic aid cannot be absorbed and people cannot build wealth.
“we take for granted a certain, what we call 'institutions of justice' in the film...like clear title for land, ability to register your business without undue burden, ability to engage in economic activity and free exchange, enforcement of contracts...these things actually don't really exist so much in lots of places in the developing world”
- In many places 50-60% of land has no clear title, and where ownership is unknown there is no incentive to start a business because it can be taken away, with widows and orphans especially vulnerable—so the poorest are in the most dangerous position.
“Clear title to your land. In some places, 50, 60% of the land has no title. If you don't know who owns the land, then you have no incentive to start a business, because it can be taken away from you.”
Free goods and giveaways destroy local producers and markets without generating economic growth or employment.
- TOMS Shoes' goal of becoming a sustainable for-profit so it can provide children shoes 'for the rest of their lives' implicitly desires those children to remain dependent so the company can keep providing; the deeper harm is anthropological, not merely economic, because no one wants to be a beggar for life and permanent giving perpetuates joblessness and the inability to build markets.
“Saying that you want to provide children for shoes for the rest of their lives is implying that you don't want them to have shoes so that you can provide them...No one wants to be a beggar for life.”
- Unlike in developed economies where information about market changes is widely available, free-good influxes in the developing world are erratic and unpredictable, so local producers like cobblers cannot anticipate or plan around them, and combined with weak market dynamism this is where the damage from giveaways like TOMS Shoes actually comes from.
“for the cobbler, he can't simply predict, 'Hey, guess what? I hear some shoes are coming in. Let's make sandals.'...It's just kind of coming in blind. And so that's the one problem that's erratic.”
- NGOs frequently crowd out local businesses by giving away goods for free; after the Haiti earthquake the local solar panel company Enersa, which had been selling about 50 streetlights a month, sold only about 5 in 6 months despite rising demand, because NGOs flooded the market with free goods, disemploying poor workers who had few other opportunities.
“before the earthquake, they were selling about 50 streetlights a month...And after the earthquake, they sold I think 5 streetlights in 6 months. And even though the demand went up”
- Western countries subsidize their own agriculture, erect tariffs to protect their markets, then dump subsidized or free food into developing-country markets as aid, which undermines and destroys local agriculture and drives farmers out of business; meanwhile the aid itself flows to a few large companies, as when The Guardian reported about 70% of $1 billion in American food aid went to just 3 companies.
“we sell subsidized agriculture at low tariffs, and we dump it into the markets. And in doing that, we can actually undermine and destroy the local markets”
- One should not care about protecting particular businesses but about a free and competitive market economy that gives people opportunity; if a firm goes out of business because it stopped serving people better, that is good, though this concern for the market is compatible with concern for the workers who lose jobs during transitions.
“I don't really care about business. I care about a free and competitive market economy. That gives people opportunity. If you go out of business, good--that means that you are not serving other people. I'm glad you went out of business.”
The right development approach partners with the poor to build their own prosperity through jobs and enterprise, not through charity.
- The dominant development model treats poor people as objects of charity, pity, and compassion rather than as the subjects and protagonists of their own story of development, which leads to using the developing world as an experiment for new policies instead of asking what the poor need to create their own prosperity.
“we have tended to treat poor people like objects--objects of our charity, objects of our pity, objects of our compassion--instead of as the subjects and protagonists of their own story of development”
- The right question for development is not 'What can I do to help?' but 'What do people in poverty need to create prosperity for their own families and communities, and how can I partner alongside them to do that?'
“the deeper question...is not 'What can I do to help?'...the better question is: What do people in poverty need to create prosperity for their own families and for their own communities? And then: How can I go alongside them to partner with them to help do that?”
- Americans are natural entrepreneurs and problem solvers at home, but once they enter the developing world they fall into a 'boring box of humanitarianism' and apply their creativity to inventing schemes to raise money for projects rather than to creating jobs and building the institutions of justice—which is not wrong but is deeply unfortunate.
“Once we walk into the developing world we enter into this kind of boring box of humanitarianism. And we don't really apply all of our entrepreneurial skills to helping create jobs...Instead, we apply our creativity to figure out how we can raise money to create another project.”
- Instead of building orphanages, the Clays started a jobs-creating business making necklaces; they now employ about 220 people and Shelly Clay estimates they care for about 720 children using only the sale of goods and services rather than donations, because the real problem is not that there are orphans but that parents lack the means to care for them—as one father said, 'I don't need that. I just need a job.'
“instead of building an orphanage and raising money, they started a business doing like necklaces...They now hire, have about 220 people who work for them. Shelly Clay estimates they are caring for about 720 children...but actually with only selling goods and services.”
Poverty stems from institutional weakness, not lack of money or material goods.
- Political and economic institutions are not disconnected from culture but emerge out of it; a weakness of Why Nations Fail is its limited view of culture, because the institutions of justice rest on an ancient, non-linearly developed cultural and moral framework, and modern economics errs in splitting moral philosophy from economics as Adam Smith did not.
“they have this limited view of culture, as if somehow these political and economic institutions are disconnected: they don't emerge out of culture. But they do emerge out of culture.”
- Poor people are not poor because they lack stuff; even raising $84 billion from generous donors would not eradicate extreme poverty because poverty stems from the absence of institutions of justice; likewise infrastructure, education, and health care are results of wealth before they become its cause, since life expectancy does not rise dramatically until a certain level of development is reached.
“poor people are not poor because they lack stuff. Poor people are poor because they lack these institutions of justice we talk about”
- Poverty is very complex; there is no single solution and no silver bullet.
“Poverty is very complex. There's no single solution. There's no silver bullet.”
Work has intrinsic dignity beyond material provision and shapes human flourishing.
- Work has a transitive dimension (producing something of value or serving others) and an intransitive dimension (shaping and forming the worker as a person); a hollowed-out humanitarianism that focuses only on giving people stuff misses this dignity of work and treats comfort and basic needs as the highest value rather than as a foundation for fuller human flourishing.
“work also has an intransitive dimension--that it's actually shaping you. And this is, I think this underlying--part of the underlying problem with the humanitarian model”
- Roughly 80% of orphans in Haiti have at least one living parent, and in the Clays' orphanage about 22 of 26 children had a living parent; many of these children are given up not because they lack parents but because the existence of orphanage care creates economic incentives for impoverished parents to relinquish children they love but cannot afford.
“80% of orphans in Haiti have at least one living parent”
Aid's social impact should be measured by whether it builds local capacity, not just by outputs delivered.
- Social entrepreneurship and aid typically measure outputs (blankets delivered, shoes given, cost, return on investment) but fail to measure the actual social impact, such as whether the giveaway put local producers out of business; in a competitive market putting a rival out of business by serving customers better is fine, but giving free goods with benevolent intent destroys companies without growing the economy.
“We only tell us like well, how many blankets I delivered, how many shoes delivered...what was my return on investment...But we don't really look at the social impact. Like, did we actually put other people out of business?”
- Microfinance can be positive or negative depending on how it is done: it tends to be positive when money is lent for economically productive activity, but negative when lent simply for consumption because that creates consumer debt.
“microfinance can be very positive, or negative. And one of the ways it's positive is when the money is lent for economically productive activity, versus when the money is lent simply for consumption, because that creates consumer debt.”
- Even setting aside oligarchs, who have no economic incentive to build institutions of justice they don't need, the upper middle class in poor countries also lacks incentive: cheap servants like a driver and maid (which Schumpeter said is worth a household of appliances) make their lives comfortable, so they have a disincentive to create an inclusive economy that would raise wages and remove that benefit.
“if you are one of the oligarchs, in Latin America, Africa...there's no economic incentive whatsoever for you to help create the institutions of justice. You don't need them.”
- Poverty, Inc. won Best Film at a libertarian film festival and about ten days later won Best Documentary at a very progressive film festival, played in over 40 film festivals and numerous universities including Harvard, and was accepted to IDFA Amsterdam—indicating the argument resonates across the political spectrum.
“We won, actually, 3 awards, including Best Film...about 10 days later we won Best Documentary at a very progressive film festival.”