charter cities
New cities granted authority to run their own legal and governance systems, often within a host country.
As defined in Brian Armstrong
Where it comes up · 12
- Paul Romer on Growth, Cities, and the State of Economics3 claims
- Paul Romer2 claims
- Abhijit Banerjee1 claim
- Brian Armstrong1 claim
- Chris Blattman1 claim
- David Brooks1 claim
- Edward Glaeser and David Cutler1 claim
- Jeffrey Sachs1 claim
and 4 more
Most important claims · 10 of 15Search all claims for “charter cities” →
- A charter city cannot succeed by importing good laws without the matching culture: Maryland legally guaranteed religious freedom but it failed because its founding population (a Catholic elite over Protestant servants) wasn't committed to it, whereas Pennsylvania's freedom of religion endured because William Penn recruited people who actually believed in it — proving the document didn't matter, the founding population's beliefs did.Paul Romer
- Like baking a pie, an economy has recipes (rules), people, and resources; the raw ingredients and the people are largely given, so the one variable a policy analyst can actually adjust is the rules under which people interact with each other and with resources—which is why Paul Romer's charter cities focus on rules.Peter Boettke on Katrina, Ten Years After
- Charter cities like Próspera in Honduras are very hard to sustain because it is hard for governments to keep their hands off the golden egg; populist political dynamics tend to unravel a separate, more-successful jurisdiction, whereas Hong Kong worked because the British Navy protected it so neither China nor anyone else could grab it.Edward Glaeser and David Cutler
- Charter cities carry a large risk of becoming the Cabrini-Green housing projects of the 21st century, going awry when high-risk development strategies are imposed on someone else's life; an attractive feature of good development strategies is low downside risk, and a depopulated coastal site near trade networks could be a fair experiment but the actual proposals targeted established settlements rather than building a Singapore in a swamp.Chris Blattman
- A charter city is a new city built on a blank sheet of paper—empty land—where a breakaway group with desired norms forms the majority, so that subsequent immigrants assimilate to those norms; Romer designed it as the smallest viable new social unit (a city of up to 10 million) to give people unhappy with their society's norms a way to change or choose them.Paul Romer on Growth, Cities, and the State of Economics
- The biggest obstacle to charter cities is that all land is claimed by a sovereign, making it hard to get one truly independent of the surrounding legal system; the more tractable path is to first gather critical mass in the cloud (VR or video calls), then collectively bargain with a sovereign for a piece of land, as Próspera in Honduras has done with a legal-system exception.Brian Armstrong
- Developed countries like Britain, Germany, or Canada could voluntarily acquire land and set up a new jurisdiction that people could move into—replicating the Hong Kong experience without the historical coercion—as a humanitarian way to change norms and accommodate the hundreds of millions of people who say they want to leave their current society.Paul Romer on Growth, Cities, and the State of Economics
- When a population's norms are inefficient and holding it back, an effective mechanism for changing the whole distribution of norms is to let a nonrepresentative subgroup found a new place; as people then migrate in at a moderate rate from the old population, they get socialized into the new place's predominant culture — changing norms more feasibly than trying to change them in place.Paul Romer
- The internal-reform (Shenzhen/Deng Xiaoping) model of charter cities is unworkable for most of the developing world because low-development, low-government-capacity countries struggle to run a differently-governed zone, and domestic actors pushing the project oppose the outside influence needed to make it work, as Romer experienced in Honduras and Madagascar.Paul Romer on Growth, Cities, and the State of Economics
- Charter cities are fragile because handing over law enforcement to a foreign enforcer is an easily exploited political target; the very reason a country cannot enforce its own laws is usually political rather than mere incompetence, so outsiders enforcing them is internally contradictory and unstable.Abhijit Banerjee