affirmative action
Government-mandated quotas in jobs and education reserved for historically disadvantaged caste and tribal groups.
As defined in Barkha Dutt
Other definitions
Policies that consider race or other protected characteristics in admissions or hiring to increase representation of historically disadvantaged groups.
Roland Fryer on Race, Diversity, and Affirmative Action
Where it comes up · 31
- 134 - Beyond The Politics Of Race6 claims
- Roland Fryer on Race, Diversity, and Affirmative Action4 claims
- 336 - The Roots Of Identity Politics4 claims
- From ChatGPT to Billions of Robots: Marc Andreessen’s Prediction4 claims
- 217 - The New Religion Of Anti-racism3 claims
- 165 - Journey Into Wokeness3 claims
- 257 - The State Of The World3 claims
- Saagar Enjeti #23 claims
and 23 more
Most important claims · 10 of 61Search all claims for “affirmative action” →
- We should not seek a replacement for religion (such as a religion of humanitarianism), because once you make something a religion—even helping the poor or oppressed—you become impervious to evidence and committed to rituals even when they make things worse; for example, affirmative action and diversity training show no evidence of helping and some evidence of harming, so we should instead arrange society so no big unifying religion exists and people find meaning in private lives and smaller associations.Jonathan Haidt
- Caste persists in India not because the state supports it (it actually offers affirmative action quotas) but because of an entrenched social structure that survives even where professional practices are no longer caste-linked; this will not change until there is full economic, professional, and social mobility, and the real test is love and marriage, where inter-caste marriage remains woefully low.Barkha Dutt
- Affirmative action, which in practice lowers standards rather than merely breaking ties, was a humane and necessary policy for roughly one generation but should have been treated like chemotherapy and phased out, because it permanently generates two harms: resentment among rejected non-beneficiaries and the burden on black beneficiaries of knowing they were admitted by different standards.217 - The New Religion Of Anti-racism
- The traditional, bipartisan Supreme Court framework on affirmative action holds that the 14th Amendment makes using racial categories generally toxic, that exceptions require a compelling state interest, that any such remedy must be narrowly tailored with no race-neutral alternative available, and must survive strict scrutiny—a framework Mounk endorses while arguing Harvard's standard-deviation downgrading of Asian applicants' 'personality' scores was shameful discrimination.336 - The Roots Of Identity Politics
- Elite colleges admit first-generation African American students who aspire to be doctors, knowing in admissions committee that these students—coming from under-resourced schools—will be outcompeted by tutored, lab-experienced peers and likely wash out of STEM into 'soft sciences,' a different income trajectory; the schools won't honestly tell students this or offer remedial bridges because it would seem racist, costing the nation generations of black physicians.165 - Journey Into Wokeness
- Reeves's framing wrongly equates the type of harm men face with that women faced: women's movement obstacles were legal and physical barriers to academia, jobs, voting, and safe movement, whereas there are no laws barring men from college—indeed there is affirmative action for men—so the male disadvantage is cultural, not institutional, and his prescriptions fail to engage that cultural dimension.Jerusalem Demsas
- Treating blackness as monolithic and interchangeable is demonstrably false because the experiences and outcomes of American descendants of slavery, Somali immigrants like Ayaan Hirsi Ali, and Nigerian immigrants (one of America's most successful ethnic groups) are radically different, and the specific disadvantage of race in America stems from slavery as a founding sin affecting a specific group.182 - Unlearning Race
- Universities should be intentional about hiring libertarians, people of strong religious faith related to their scholarship, and traditional conservatives—effectively an affirmative action program for conservatives—because lived experience and ideological diversity improve teaching and inquiry, even though this proposal angered both left and right.431 - What Is Happening On College Campuses
- Material reparations for African Americans already occurred under different names—affirmative action, the late-1960s expansion of welfare aimed especially at black women, and the Community Reinvestment Act of 1977—some of which worked and some did not, so the claim that nothing counts as reparations is mistaken.John McWhorter
- Affirmative action and DEI are adult fixations applying to those 18 and above, skipping the most malleable childhood years where interventions have the most effect; instead disparities should be shrunk through class-based interventions in education (like Roland Fryer's Houston study raising math scores by controlling principals, teachers, and curriculum) and crime reduction, which would disproportionately benefit black and Hispanic kids.353 - Race Reason