Jonathan Haidt
What this covers
This conversation with Tyler Cowen brings together Jonathan Haidt's work across moral psychology, higher education, and the nature of political difference. Haidt argues that beneath surface disagreements lies a deeper architecture: humans possess innate moral intuitions—described via the Moral Taste Buds Analogy—that cultures then build upon variably. Moral Foundations Theory holds that care, fairness, loyalty, authority, sanctity, and liberty are all evolved foundations that humans share, yet left and right emphasize them differently. This reconciles universal human nature with genuine cultural variation. The conversation ranges across how personality traits like openness to experience and conscientiousness correlate with political orientation, why Intuitions Come First, Reasoning Second—a principle that explains Motivated Reasoning and the phenomenon Morality Binds and Blinds—and what heritability research reveals about the genetic contribution to human traits.
The second half turns to universities and institutional decline. Haidt contends that elite universities have undergone a fateful shift: their Sacred Values moved from truth to social justice, a move that correlates with the academy's political imbalance and, paradoxically, with proliferation of microaggression complaints precisely in the most egalitarian institutions. He argues that university authorities' habit of intervening in minor conflicts creates moral dependence among students rather than resilience. The discussion also covers Antiparsimonialism—the view that single-principle explanations often mislead in the social sciences—and defends positions on affirmative action, family stability, psychedelic drugs, and why demographic diversity, though valuable in some contexts, can undermine institutional cohesion without offsetting unity of purpose.
Haidt argues that political and moral differences stem from innate, evolved psychological foundations (moral 'taste buds') that cultures build upon variably, and that elite universities have collapsed into a monoculture by replacing truth with social justice as their sacred value—a shift that paradoxically intensifies grievance as conditions improve.
- Moral foundations theory: humans share innate moral intuitions that cultures develop differently, with left and right emphasizing different foundations.
- Victimhood culture and microaggression complaints proliferate precisely in the most egalitarian, progressive campus communities.
- Universities have abandoned truth for social justice, producing ideological uniformity that destroys the marketplace of ideas.
Moral intuitions are evolved foundations that cultures build upon variably, making morality universal yet culturally distinct.
- Moral foundations function like taste buds: they are innate receptors present from birth (not modules firing at the moment of judgment), and each culture builds a distinctive 'cuisine'—a morality—that must ultimately please the same universal set of moral taste buds, with different cultures emphasizing different ones.
“Think about it as like taste buds. We have these innate taste buds... Each cuisine is a cultural creation that has to, ultimately, please the same universal taste buds.”
- Moral foundations theory holds there are roughly six innate moral 'foundations'—care/harm, fairness/reciprocity, loyalty/betrayal, authority/subversion, sanctity/degradation, and liberty/oppression—that are products of evolution but that cultures build upon variably, reconciling the universality of human nature with the deep variability of cultures.
“We all have the same, let’s call them six moral taste buds. The sixth one I didn’t mention before is liberty versus oppression.”
- Much of what humans do is weird and inexplicable until viewed through a Durkheimian lens: we are trying to form moral communities that give order, punish deviants, and allow us to work together—a framework Haidt would endorse if it underlies Girard's theory of sacrificial violence.
“We’re trying to form moral communities that will give order, punish deviants, allow us to work together.”
- The pursuit of parsimony—treating the simplest one-principle explanation as automatically better—is a bad, almost religious quest that is a disaster for the social sciences, because people are far more complicated than matter; Haidt advocates 'antiparsimony' and is normatively a value pluralist (drawing on Isaiah Berlin), holding that extremism in defense of any single virtue becomes a vice.
“The pursuit of parsimony is a bad idea. It becomes almost a religious quest... That’s a disaster for the social sciences... people are really complicated, much more so than matter.”
- The sanctity/degradation foundation—worry about purity and treating the body as a temple—tends to be moralized more on the political right (regarding sex and the body), though elements of the left also exhibit it (e.g., yoga culture, GMOs, ethical sourcing of clothing).
“In general, the right. If you look at who moralizes sex, the body... It tends to pop up more on the right, but elements of the left have it, again, if you look at yoga.”
- Cultures under threat (warrior cultures, fraternities) build heavily on loyalty, authority, and sanctity to create tribal consciousness, whereas diverse commercial port cities (Amsterdam, New York) thin down the moral domain to a minimal 'don't hurt me, honor your contracts' morality that is more appropriate for diversity and commerce.
“those tend to thin down the moral domain. They don’t tend to do a lot with group loyalty and hierarchy... This is a more appropriate morality for diversity and for commerce.”
- All kinds of morality appear compromised in psychopathy because psychopaths have no moral emotions—no sense of care, compassion, or sympathy, and no concern for fairness—and Haidt predicts that group loyalty, tribalism, and hierarchy foundations are also compromised, though these have been understudied because research has focused narrowly on care and fairness.
“The answer is generally yes, because they have no moral emotions... Psychopaths have no sense of care, or compassion, or sympathy... My prediction is that all forms are compromised.”
Tribal psychology causes humans to moralize group conflict rather than evaluate policy on merit, making reasoning defensive.
- Moral psychology can be reduced to three principles: (1) intuitions come first, strategic reasoning second—we start with gut feelings or partisan loyalty and then become lawyers defending them rather than truly listening; (2) there's more to morality than harm and fairness (the multiple moral foundations); and (3) morality binds and blinds—humans form groups so effectively that once an issue becomes us-versus-them, arguments stop being heard.
“The first principle is intuitions come first, strategic reasoning second... The second principle is there’s more to morality than harm and fairness... The third principle is morality binds and blinds.”
- Because humans are intensely tribal, almost anything that gets tagged as predictive of group membership can be moralized; the individual mandate, originally a right-leaning Heritage Foundation idea, became tagged as bad once Obama promoted it in a hostile, tribal climate, showing that group conflict, not the policy's content, drives moralization.
“Almost anything that can be associated with an ongoing hot conflict can be moralized.”
- Once people take a position on something—especially when it relates to sacred values that have become sacred to them—they become essentially impervious to arguments; also, the harm foundation is activated by visceral perception of suffering, not by abstract claims that a policy works against one's interests.
“once people have taken a position on something, especially if it relates to sacred values... they’re pretty much impervious to arguments at that point.”
- Paradoxically, the better and more egalitarian a community becomes, the worse the protests get: microaggression and victimhood culture proliferate precisely in the most egalitarian, progressive institutions (Yale, Amherst, Brown) because when a group is highly egalitarian and bureaucrats will punish any conflict, everyone becomes incentivized to plead victimhood or champion victims, per Manning and Campbell's analysis.
“microaggression culture, and a lot of the current campus protests, only emerges when you actually get really close to an incredibly egalitarian, open society.”
- We should not seek a replacement for religion (such as a religion of humanitarianism), because once you make something a religion—even helping the poor or oppressed—you become impervious to evidence and committed to rituals even when they make things worse; for example, affirmative action and diversity training show no evidence of helping and some evidence of harming, so we should instead arrange society so no big unifying religion exists and people find meaning in private lives and smaller associations.
“once you make it a religion, that means you are impervious to evidence. You are committed to certain religious rituals even if those rituals make things worse.”
Universities shifted from pursuing truth to pursuing social justice, creating ideological monopolies that destroy intellectual marketplace diversity.
- The sacred value of universities from the 19th century through the 1980s was truth (Veritas, Lux et Veritas), but a demographic flip occurred in the 1990s—the academy's left-right ratio went from 2:1 in 1990 to 5:1 by 2005, and 10:1 or 20:1 in the humanities and non-economics social sciences—producing a bifurcation in which the sciences still pursue truth while the humanities and social sciences now pursue social justice and protection of victims.
“At the start of the 1990s, the overall left‑right ratio of the academy... was two to one... But by 2005, it had gone to five to one... in the social sciences and humanities... it’s closer to 10 to 1 or 20 to 1.”
- Universities were designed to be marketplaces where people encounter and are challenged by diverse ideas, but just as a monopoly destroys the value of an economic market, an ideological monopoly destroys the intellectual marketplace—and campuses have become such monopolies over the last few years.
“if you have a monopoly on ideas in the intellectual marketplace, you kill the marketplace... Campuses are supposed to be places where nobody has a monopoly on ideas, but they’ve become that in the last few years.”
- Despite being discussed everywhere, the Lukianoff-Haidt Atlantic article on campus culture drew almost no coherent published criticism—the main responses were ad hominem ('you guys are white males defending your privilege') or marginal concessions about trigger warnings being sometimes useful—which Haidt finds amazing and notes many people privately loved it but feared saying so publicly.
“Almost nothing was written against it, it’s the weirdest thing... the only things that were written said, “You guys are white males. You’re just defending your privilege.””
- Social science research shows diversity is divisive—the more you make something diverse, the less trust there is and the harder it is for people to work together; this is why institutions needing cohesion (the military) bury demographic diversity in a sea of uniformity and common mission, whereas universities should pursue diversity of thought rather than demographic uniformity.
“Diversity is divisive. There’s a lot of social science research on this, the more you make something diverse, the less trust there will be, the harder it is for people to work together.”
- Libertarians—who have the highest IQ and are best at systemic thinking—are wasting their time in internet flame wars when they should be overrepresented in the academy, where they would be the easiest source of political diversity to spread, since social conservatives are very hard to find in academia; libertarian-leaning academics tend to concentrate in economics.
“you should be very upset that your fellow libertarians are wasting their time in flame wars... in the academy, where even though libertarians actually have the highest IQ, they’re the best at systemic thinking, they should be overrepresented.”
Political orientation flows from heritable temperamental traits that pull people toward left or right regardless of upbringing.
- Political orientation is rooted in personality traits: people on the left score higher on openness to experience, while people on the right score lower on openness but higher on conscientiousness (more orderly, deadline-meeting), and these temperaments manifest physically—Gosling's dorm-room research showed conservatives' rooms were neater with more calendars and stamps while liberals' had more stylistic, high-design elements and varied books.
“People on the left are higher on a variable called openness to experience. People on the right are lower on it, but they’re also higher on conscientiousness”
- Twins separated at birth and raised in different families will, once independent, converge on their brain's natural level of religiosity; similarly, while political left/right is not genetically determined, temperamental predispositions (e.g., finding diversity and challenging authority exciting) will pull a person toward left-wing politics regardless of upbringing.
“once we’re out on our own, we’re going to both converge on our brain’s natural level of religiosity. Same with politics”
- Even with reliable underlying personality regularities, predicting an individual's political orientation from a chance meeting is only modestly better than chance (around 0.57-0.58 probability), because people are highly variable and social science seeks underlying regularities rather than perfect individual prediction.
“Probably 0.58, 0.57. People are incredibly variable... Our goal is not to predict with perfect accuracy. We’re just trying to extract what are the regularities under the surface”
- The most important finding in psychology in the last 50-100 years is that everything you can measure is heritable, with heritability coefficients between 0.3 and 0.6 (30-60% of variance explainable by genes under certain assumptions), making genetics the largest single explainable piece of variance in human traits.
“The most important finding in psychology in the last 50 to 100 years, I would say, is the finding that everything you can measure is heritable. The heritability coefficients vary between 0.3 and 0.6”
- Occupational political clustering (dentists Republican, doctors Democratic; motel owners conservative, innkeepers liberal) emerges only in post-materialist societies where economic security lets people choose careers to express values rather than out of necessity; in caste systems or economically constrained generations, these patterns largely vanish.
“to the extent that the modern economy has opened up more and more choice for people to make career choices to express their values rather than acting on economic necessity, you’re going to see it. This is what we have in what’s called post‑materialist societies.”
Campus culture incentivizes victimhood claims and empowers illiberal activists who silence speakers and terrorize dissenters through social enforcement.
- If running Yale admissions, Haidt would admit for signs that an applicant can contribute to an intellectually diverse environment and would stop admitting for social justice credentials, because elite schools have empowered angry social justice warriors who dominate discourse so that the small illiberal left has terrorized the larger liberal left, leaving students afraid to speak in class or on social media.
“I would start admitting for signs that you can contribute to an intellectually diverse environment... I would stop admitting for social justice cred”
- Haidt finds illiberalism disgusting—specifically when a person or group takes it upon themselves to shout down or shut down a speaker so that those who came to listen cannot hear, which he distinguishes from legitimate protest like holding signs outside.
“These days I find illiberalism disgusting. The idea that one person takes it upon himself to shout down or shut down someone else”
- Universities should be extremely limited in letting authorities step in to resolve offenses, because doing so encourages microaggression culture and orients students toward appealing to authorities; the result is that young people become moral dependents who cannot resolve insults themselves and instead embroil everyone in eternal battles, turning college from fun into constant conflict.
“We should be extremely limited when we say that authorities can step in and change things. The very fact of doing that encourages microaggression culture... young people these days have become moral dependents.”
- Much bigger racial preferences in admissions will cause larger achievement gaps between Asians at the top and African-Americans at the bottom, which will inflame prejudice rather than reduce it—so the activists' demands for more affirmative action are likely to make campus race relations worse.
“Much bigger racial preferences, which will cause much bigger gaps between Asians at the top and African-Americans at the bottom. Which is going to inflame prejudice, not reduce it.”
Universities need free speech protections and deliberate governance processes distinct from corporate speech rules and reactive decision-making.
- Decisions to rename buildings or colleges should follow a deliberate process (e.g., three-quarters majority votes taken two years apart) rather than yielding to the loudest group in a single year, and a clear line should separate identity-bearing names like one's residential college (changeable by the affected community) from campus statues and paintings—because subjecting everything to a vote leads to taking down everything, since every group is offended by something.
“There should be a process that says if three-quarters of the people vote to do it, and you take that vote two years apart, then it should be done.”
- Companies, like the military, are organized to be effective in the world and so legitimately restrict speech to get people to work together, but universities are fundamentally different—they need not uniformity but basic civility plus the ability to critique each other's ideas without filing charges, and there is and should be far more free speech on campus than in companies.
“a company is organized to be effective in the world... your goal isn’t to encourage everyone to express their values and criticize each other, your goal is to get them to work together.”
- When deciding whether names like the Washington Redskins are offensive, one should run a thought experiment reversing the group; there is something genuinely legitimate about objecting to having your group mocked, which distinguishes legitimate grievances from the illegitimate concept of cultural appropriation, since cultural evolution requires the free exchange of ideas and artifacts.
“there is really something legitimate here to having your group be mocked. That I think might be the principle.”
Social science should embrace complexity and reject parsimony, studying multiple levels and recognizing humans' richer motivations than economics assumes.
- Behavioral economics is properly rated now but risks being overrated unless it becomes more social, because, per Zajonc's dictum that cognitive psychology is social psychology with all the interesting variables set to zero, current behavioral economics studies lone consumers optimizing choices while the genuinely interesting variables are social—what a choice says about me and whether I'll be ostracized.
“cognitive psychology is social psychology with all the interesting variables set to zero.”
- Early economists like Adam Smith were great social theorists who thought broadly as world philosophers and historians, but a weird turn toward mathematics in the mid-20th century caused economists to set all the interesting (social) variables to zero.
“the early economists were great social theorists. My God, you read Adam Smith... it seems there was a weird turn in the mid‑20th century towards mathematics. I think it made economists set all the interesting variables to zero.”
- The best criticism of moral foundations theory is simply that it has left some things out, which is surely true; the theory was always presented as a first pass from extensive reading rather than a closed list of exactly five (later six) foundations, and the only critic claiming morality is just one thing (harm), Kurt Gray, offers no real argument beyond the appeal of parsimony for cramming everything into one principle.
“The best criticism is just that we have left some things out, which is surely true.”
- Freud's value in academic psychology is essentially zero and his developmental ideas were completely worthless, but he was a provocative writer who is overrated in the humanities (still treated as a psychologist there) yet underrated in social psychology and arguably ought to be read a bit more.
“In academic psychology his value is essentially zero... Freud’s ideas about development were completely worthless... overrated in humanities... in social psychology, underrated.”
The replication crisis stems from researchers' tribal emotions and desired outcomes rather than rational methods, requiring transparency and reform.
- Politics must be analyzed at multiple emergent levels simultaneously (individual psychology, neural, sociological), and the Republican Party's higher-level social constructs have progressively drifted out of tune with the moral intuitions and psychology of its voters, explaining the unexpected failure of establishment candidates.
“But what if the emerging social constructs of the Republican Party have been getting progressively out of tune with the moral intuitions and the psychology of the voters? I think that’s what we have seen happening.”
- The replication crisis is very real and should be a top priority for science: sloppy methods made significant (and thus publishable) results too likely, the same problem appears across cancer and biomedical research, and the root cause is that researchers are not the idealized rational agents null-hypothesis testing assumes but emotional, tribal creatures who want certain outcomes; making data openly available will substantially raise research quality.
“I think that the replication crisis is very real. It should be a top priority for science.”
- National politics functions much more like a religion than local politics—the president is the high priest of an American civil religion—whereas local politics is practical and non-ideological (concerned with property values, dogcatchers, treasurers), which explains why a party can dominate locally while struggling nationally.
“National politics is much more like a religion. The president is the high priest of the American civil religion”
Family stability and conservative social insights matter and deserve academic respect despite left-liberal dominance in universities.
- Family stability, which Haidt once dismissed as unimportant, turns out to have powerful second- and third-order effects: children raised with incredible family stability come out much better and are far more likely to rise economically than those raised with any family instability—a point social conservatives make that Haidt now grants as a social scientist.
“The overriding importance of family stability, if you’re raising kids with incredible family stability, they just come out better. In fact they’re much more likely to rise economically than if they’re raised with any sort of family instability.”
Psychedelic drugs were unfairly demonized and show therapeutic promise; moral elevation produces calm receptiveness rather than action.
- Psychedelic drugs (the class including LSD, psilocybin, and yagé) have an incredibly positive track record of enriching rather than damaging lives, are the rare class of drugs that religions form around, and—based on 1960s research and emerging studies on cancer patients and prisoners in controlled settings—produce quite positive therapeutic effects; the moral panic of the 1960s-80s went too far, leaving them underrated.
“Psychedelics have an incredibly positive track record in terms of enriching people’s lives versus damaging them... when you give people psychedelic drugs in controlled settings, be they cancer patients, or criminals in jail, the therapeutic effects tend to be quite positive.”
- Disgust has a specific behavioral gating: Haidt's gag reflex prevented him from putting an insect (honey-covered grasshopper) into his mouth, but once an item passes beyond the lips the disgust response is largely too late and one can swallow it—illustrating disgust as a food-rejection mechanism centered on the mouth.
“once it’s beyond the lips then disgust, it’s sort of too late, and then I was able to eat it.”
- Moral elevation—the response to witnessing powerful displays of virtue like caring, compassion, loyalty, or courage—does not reliably make people go out and help others afterward (a small effect at best); instead it is calming, producing parasympathetic activation that leaves you not ready for vigorous action but more receptive to taking in information and changing your values.
“when you’re touched, moved, inspired, it doesn’t make you go out and take action. It’s calming you. I think you have parasympathetic activation... but I think you learn more. You take in more, and it can change your values.”