What this covers
Tyler Cowen and Jerusalem Demsas conduct a book-club conversation on three works of speculative and travel fiction: Ursula K. Le Guin's The Dispossessed, Jonathan Swift's Gulliver's Travels, and Richard Reeves's Of Boys and Men. Their discussion revolves around a shared premise—that you never escape your prisons—but splits sharply on what fills them. Both speakers read utopian and fantastical societies as revealing deep human constraints: Le Guin's anarchist collective turns oppressive once examined; Swift's various lands, despite their absurdity, recapitulate slavery, faction, and hierarchy. Yet they diverge fundamentally on origin. Cowen argues these patterns trace to durable features of human nature, particularly male nature. Demsas contends that institutions and incentives explain the bulk of variation, and that moral progress can reshape outcomes. The conversation also explores why fiction and travel matter as modes of understanding, even when they do not maximize happiness.
The speakers examine gender and male disadvantage in contemporary society with particular intensity. Cowen points to striking elasticity gaps: when Kalamazoo offered free college, women enrolled in far greater numbers than men, suggesting policy response itself differs by sex. Demsas counters with evidence that gaps disappear among gay men and vary across countries, implying institutions and cultural versus institutional barriers drive outcomes more than fixed traits. She also critiques Richard Reeves's framing, noting that men face no legal barriers to education—indeed face affirmative action in admissions—whereas women historically faced physical and legal exclusion. The pair also disputes how to read The Dispossessed: whether Shevek's assault on Urras reflects immutable male nature or emerges from exposure to different incentive structures. On Gulliver's Travels, Cowen argues for a Straussian reading in which Swift, skeptical of moral progress despite his humanitarianism, depicts war and faction as eternal to human affairs—a reading that finds even the Houyhnhnms oppressive and conformist. The discussion weaves across philosophy, policy, and literature without resolving whether the patterns these texts reveal are tragic constants or mutable artifacts of choice.
Across The Dispossessed, Gulliver's Travels, and Of Boys and Men, Cowen and Demsas argue that no society escapes its 'prisons'—human nature (especially male nature), faction, and conflict recur across utopias and travelogues alike—while disagreeing over whether these patterns are intractable instincts or products of institutions and incentives that moral progress can reshape.
- Both classic novels reveal communal/utopian societies as oppressive once seen through, suggesting you never escape your prisons
- Cowen leans toward durable human/male nature constraining outcomes; Demsas insists incentives and institutions explain much of the variation
- Travel and speculative fiction are valued as modes of knowledge even when they don't make people happier
Human behavior is contextual and malleable, determined by institutional incentives and social norms rather than fixed nature.
- Shevek's sexual assault on Urras is not evidence of a fixed human nature but of his entering a non-egalitarian society with different incentives and rules; behavior is extremely contextual, so where there are no mores against treating women as inferior, such behavior opens up—he would have been constrained on his home planet.
“the behaviors that people engage in are going to be extremely contextual. If there are no laws or if there are no rules or mores around treating women as inferior, then I think it’s going to open up a lot of things there.”
- On Anarres a character argues it is better to have conflict outside your head than within yourself; the anarchist society's pretense that there is no hierarchy or government to confront makes it harder to confront the real problems, which turn out to lie in the collective minds and social norms of its members.
“it’s better to have the conflict outside of your head than to have the conflict within yourself.”
- Because there is remarkable overlap between the genders on traits like aggressiveness, and because many wealthy, white men escape the 'masculinity trap,' institutional interventions could affect large portions of the population—so it would be premature and overly fatalistic to write men off when low-hanging policy fruit remains untried.
“The fact that there are a lot of men who are wealthy and white who are able to escape this “masculinity trap” just indicates that there are institutional things that you could do to affect large portions of the population.”
- Reeves abdicates any idea of cultural shifts for boys: just as women received transmittable workplace lessons (salary negotiation, assertiveness, not letting people interrupt them, à la Lean In), boys could be given lessons—e.g., the gap in early schooling stems largely from girls being more willing to sit still and do the work, and nothing stops boys from reading.
“there’s no question about, should men be given lessons as well?... the reason why you’re doing better in school at a younger age if you’re a girl is usually because you’re more willing to sit still... there’s a complete abdication of any kind of idea that there should be some kind of cultural shifts around what you should be telling young boys to do.”
- The claim that men simply cannot succeed in modern society is undercut by research showing the educational gaps disappear among gay men, who perform as well as women—evidence (alongside cross-country variation in male violence) that institutions and incentives, not fixed male nature, drive the outcomes.
“there is some research showing that these gaps disappear with gay men and that on educational fronts, they’re doing as well as women.”
Speculative fiction's value lies in clarifying what we aim toward and enabling productive political discourse without emotional paralysis.
- The value of utopian writing is not predicting that a society will arise from one's preferred policies, but clarifying what you are actually trying to get to—defining 'Eden' so you can approximate it as closely as possible.
“I see the value of utopia as trying to clarify what it is that you’re actually trying to get to... if you can define what Eden is, then you can approximate it as close as you can get.”
- Reading science fiction provides a way to have conversations about politics without being overcome by the emotion and anger that otherwise make productive discussion difficult, serving as a genuine entry point into reasoned debate.
“reading science fiction — it’s like a way of having conversations about politics without having to necessarily feel that. It actually felt like a real entry point into how to start having discussions”
- Whether speculative fiction and travel or succinct, concrete policy arguments do more good depends on your theory of change—illuminating broad truths entertainingly versus solving a clearly defined policy problem—and it is an unsettled question which approach gets you further, though a society needs both.
“it depends what your theory of change is. Is your theory of change that whatever you can do to illuminate these broader ideas or truths... is how you actually effect long-term change? Or is it a very succinct argument about how we can actually change a very clear policy problem... it’s a very unsettled question about which one of those things gets you further.”
Moral progress is real because egalitarian, less exploitative societies outcompete unsustainable hierarchical ones over time.
- Le Guin clearly prefers the anarchist world and judges that the capitalist society's gains are not worth the hidden pain and suffering, even as she refuses to depict any society—including her preferred one—as fully satisfactory.
“it’s pretty clear to me that she doesn’t think it’s worth it. She doesn’t think it’s worth it, the pain, the suffering, everything that’s hidden there.”
- There is a striking amount of thematic overlap across these books written over centuries: we keep having the same conversations about human nature, institutions, and freedom in different formats, which can feel unifying but may also be a knock against moral progress—as if humanity is forced through one circular condition.
“we’re having the same conversations in so many different contexts over decades, over centuries... Maybe it’s a knock against moral progress that the same questions are being debated over centuries.”
- Moral progress is real and linked to economic progress: true and persuasive ideas tend to win over time because societies organized on non-egalitarian, exploitative lines are unsustainable and get beaten by more egalitarian societies that don't squander human potential—so classical-liberal equality wins out repeatedly.
“those ideas end up winning out time and again because they’re just unsustainable when you set up societies that don’t work that way. They’ll be beaten by other societies that are more egalitarian... I think moral progress goes along with the economic progress. Those are inextricably linked”
Gender equality faces biological constraints from reproduction costs that policy alone cannot solve without technological change.
- Le Guin critiques how women are commodified under capitalism through the wealthy, well-connected woman who believes her power lies in secretly steering men, only to be unable to stop a stranger from assaulting her—showing that even those who recognize the commodification are harmed by it.
“she’s making a critique of how feminism or women are treated under capitalism, how they’re commodified, and even the people who realize that commodification ends up hurting them.”
- Reeves's framing wrongly equates the type of harm men face with that women faced: women's movement obstacles were legal and physical barriers to academia, jobs, voting, and safe movement, whereas there are no laws barring men from college—indeed there is affirmative action for men—so the male disadvantage is cultural, not institutional, and his prescriptions fail to engage that cultural dimension.
“The things that he’s identifying that are barring men are not... There are no laws saying men can’t go to college... Actually, there’s affirmative action for men... if we’ve identified that these two things are actually quite different in kind, then the question is, these responses have to actually engage with the cultural pushes, not just the institutional pushes.”
- Reeves's signature prescription of redshirting boys—starting them in kindergarten a year later than girls—is not well thought through, as he devotes no attention to the classroom dynamics of mixing 14-year-old boys with 13-year-old girls or to how it would affect girls' educational outcomes.
“I found redshirting the boys to be not very well thought through in many perspectives. I don’t think he devotes any time to what it would look like to have a class full of 14-year-old boys and 13-year-old girls, or what kind of dynamics that would create, or how that would affect women’s educational outcomes.”
- Biological sexism imposes limits on gender equality because the costs of the wage gap are largely explained by the cost of having children and what happens after; while fertility is falling, equality may require technological change such as artificial wombs, since being pulled out of the workforce and bearing long-term health costs remain near-permanent facts of being a woman who has children.
“The costs of the wage gap are largely explained by the cost of having children and what happens after you have kids... being pulled out of the workforce and, in many ways, potentially having your healthcare disabled long-term seem like things that are such permanent facts about being a woman right now.”
Travel and geographic displacement are not necessary conditions for acquiring knowledge of institutional problems.
- Travel may not be necessary to acquire deep knowledge: in The Dispossessed, Shevek's friend reaches the same realization about their society's flaws without ever traveling, just by observing his inability to do his research and a friend's institutionalization—suggesting the knowledge was available without leaving.
“I question whether they needed to travel to get the knowledge, because Shevek is really pushed out of his framework of viewing his own society as utopian by a friend who has this realization, never travels, is within that community the entire time.”
- Many people do not travel well for what they actually want—they get sucked into activities that don't make them happy while missing things at the destination that would have, and they often stay within familiar social groups or only among fellow Americans, with little meaningful interaction with locals.
“I think many people, when they travel, end up staying within very similar social groups or even only with Americans or the people they’re traveling with, and have very little interaction with people and learning about their lives in any meaningful way.”
- Shevek and Gulliver are men who would not be happy in any society or context—Shevek is frustrated by the communitarians yet defends them when criticized, and Gulliver finds something to critique everywhere—suggesting their restlessness is internal rather than a response to defective societies.
“in both of these novels, these men would not be happy anywhere in any context. Maybe that’s part of what’s going on here, is that there’s not a society that would make Shevek happy.”