active investing
An investment strategy where investors actively select individual securities trying to outperform a benchmark index, rather than passively holding the index
As defined in 6WroiiaVhGo
Other definitions
Investment strategy where an investor or manager attempts to outperform the market by selecting individual stocks, timing entries and exits, or using other active management techniques; contrasts with passive index investing
Morgan Housel: What You Need to Master (And Avoid) to Get Rich, Stay Rich, and Build Wealth
Where it comes up · 4
- The Value Investing Delusion | Aswath Damodaran on Why Value Investors Missed the Mag Seven12 claims
- Passive Investing Has Had a Major Impact on the Market: Here is What It Means for Your Portfolio9 claims
- Aswath Damodaran: I Am More Cautious Than Ever2 claims
- Howard Marks Warning: Why I'm Getting Out Now1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 24Search all claims for “active investing” →
- Active investing is inherently unprofitable for practitioners as a collective, like a 'plumbing business called Floods R Us' where you cause the problem you claim to solve; AI will make active investing harder, not easier, because all investors will have access to the same tools, eroding any information advantage.Aswath Damodaran: I Am More Cautious Than Ever
- The real test of active investing is not whether you beat the S&P 500, but whether you can beat an index fund built entirely around what you claim your philosophy is (e.g., value index funds); SPIVA data shows that 85-90% of active investors underperform their respective indices, which is the true measure of market efficiencyThe Value Investing Delusion | Aswath Damodaran on Why Value Investors Missed the Mag Seven
- Active investing is fundamentally flawed as a business model, analogous to a plumbing company that is called to fix a leak and instead causes a flood while still sending a bill—active managers reliably destroy value while charging for it.Passive Investing Has Had a Major Impact on the Market: Here is What It Means for Your Portfolio
- The rise of passive investing is not a market phenomenon but a response to the reality that active investing has been bad; better information (real-time fund performance vs S&P 500) and lower switching costs (trading online vs physically visiting a broker) enabled investors to discover and act on the fact that they were paying for underperformanceThe Value Investing Delusion | Aswath Damodaran on Why Value Investors Missed the Mag Seven
- Charlie Ellis wrote an influential 1974 article 'Winning the Loser's Game' arguing that because the future cannot be predicted, active investing doesn't work and instead of trying to hit winners (like tennis), investors should focus on avoiding losers and keeping the ball in play.Howard Marks Warning: Why I'm Getting Out Now
- Information technology and ease of trading removed friction that historically locked investors into underperforming active funds, allowing real-time performance comparison and quick capital reallocation to passive alternatives.Passive Investing Has Had a Major Impact on the Market: Here is What It Means for Your Portfolio
- Passive investing will eventually hit a cap where it becomes counterproductive, because if too few active investors are searching for bargains, the magnitude of mispricings will grow large enough to attract active capital back and make active management profitable again.Passive Investing Has Had a Major Impact on the Market: Here is What It Means for Your Portfolio
- Passive investing will eventually hit a natural cap where so few people are looking for mispricings that the magnitude of exploitable mistakes grows large enough to make active investing profitable again, creating a cyclical equilibrium.Passive Investing Has Had a Major Impact on the Market: Here is What It Means for Your Portfolio
- The rise of passive investing can be understood as a natural response to information availability and transaction cost reduction: when investors could suddenly see that their active managers were underperforming benchmarks (via continuous performance reporting) and could easily move their money (via electronic trading), they rationally switched to passive vehicles.Passive Investing Has Had a Major Impact on the Market: Here is What It Means for Your Portfolio
- Active investing has systematically underperformed passive indexing over the past 20 years, with approximately 95% of active managers underperforming their stated benchmarks on a 20-year basis according to S&P Dow Jones Index data.Passive Investing Has Had a Major Impact on the Market: Here is What It Means for Your Portfolio