Zero-sum
A situation in which one party's gain necessarily equals another's loss; applied here to the mistaken belief that another's mattering subtracts from one's own.
As defined in The Mattering Instinct (with Rebecca Newberger Goldstein)
Other definitions
Strategic or economic interaction where one party's gain is another's loss—characteristic of territorial conquest where conquered territory changes hands but overall wealth is destroyed
The Geopolitics and History of Continental and Maritime Power - S.C.M. Paine
Where it comes up · 25
- Pete Buttigieg on 2024 and the ‘Crank Realignment’4 claims
- Exploring the Frontier4 claims
- Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement3 claims
- Peter Thiel on 'Anti-Anti-Anti-Anti Classical Liberalism' | Oxford Union3 claims
- The Dollar System Is Ending. Here's What Comes Next.3 claims
- Spilling the Secrets of Our Launch2 claims
- The Mattering Instinct (with Rebecca Newberger Goldstein)2 claims
- Wall Street’s Art Critic1 claim
and 17 more
Most important claims · 10 of 39Search all claims for “Zero-sum” →
- In the Minimal Group Paradigm experiments, people assigned to meaningless groups allocated resources so their group would win even at the cost of total payoff—choosing a condition where everyone gets less but the out-group gets even less rather than maximizing the common good—revealing a natural inclination to prefer relative victory over absolute benefit.Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement
- Structured finance deals that look like adversarial fraud from outside, such as call spread overlays, are often legal arrangements where client and bank split economically unjustified but legal tax benefits, so assuming zero-sum adversarial fraud misses the actual complexity.Wall Street’s Art Critic
- Classical liberalism's age is obsessed with inequality and disturbingly conflates it with poverty, as if the world were zero-sum and the rich impoverish the poor; but while rent-seeking sometimes does cause that, most poor people are poor because they lack the skills to contribute to the modern economy, and the small-government side has failed badly by ignoring their human flourishing.Russ Roberts
- Even if everyone is materially better off, inequality is intrinsically harmful because important goods are zero-sum—relative status, political power, cultural representation—so when income inequality correlates with these, some people are made genuinely worse off (very low status), which is bad for a healthy democratic society and itself justifies reducing inequality.84 | Suresh Naidu on Capitalism, Monopsony, and Inequality
- When competition between the parties is zero-sum, there is no place in the middle for compromise, and since compromise is the only way legislation gets done, democracy cannot function without it—reducing the correlation between citizens' policy preferences and actual political outcomes.Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement
- Good matchmaking is one of the hardest design/engineering problems because players claim they want fair, even matches but actually want to feel slightly better than the opponent and win; since it's zero-sum there must be winners and losers, and human psychology fixates on losing streaks while ignoring prior winning streaks.Lex Fridman Podcast #493 - Jeff Kaplan
- Through much of history life was negative-sum rather than zero-sum: although theft of grain appears zero-sum on the surface (the thief gains what the victim loses), it is actually negative-sum because the threat of theft induces victims to spend real resources on protection (private armies, locks, hiding) and to avoid producing valuable things they cannot protect, reducing overall production.Omer Moav on the Emergence of the State
- In classical mercantilism, silver (not gold, which was too rare) was seen as actual wealth, and countries realized they had to run positive trade balances because in a zero-sum world of warring states, positive trade surpluses provided the metal and money needed to buy weaponry and pay mercenaries for defense.The Dollar System Is Ending. Here's What Comes Next.
- The media tends to portray legislation as Democrats or Republicans winning, covering policy like a horse race, so that when every government action becomes a win or loss for one side, there is no reason to compromise even on a good policy because a loss is felt as a defeat for the whole party—effectively gamifying the work of government.Lilliana Mason on Uncivil Agreement
- Adam Smith held that human beings have a basic desire to be believed and to persuade others, treating the primary function of language as satisfying a desire to be a thought-leader of others, which creates a deep asymmetry structuring communication and underlies status tensions and the zero-sum aspect of human experience—standing in tension with the positive-sum picture of trade in the Wealth of Nations.Agnes Callard on Philosophy, Progress, and Wisdom