Shibboleth
A belief, phrase, or custom that functions as a badge of group membership; here, an illogical assertion one must affirm to belong to a cult or religion.
As defined in David Deutsch on the Pattern
Other definitions
A word, custom, or piece of knowledge whose pronunciation or familiarity distinguishes members of one group from another; originally a Hebrew word used as a fatal password test in the Book of Judges.
Michael Munger on Cultural Norms 8/31/2009
Where it comes up · 3
- Michael Munger on Cultural Norms 8/31/20092 claims
- David Deutsch on the Pattern2 claims
- Jason Zweig on Finance and the Devil's Financial Dictionary1 claim
Most important claims · 5 of 5Search all claims for “Shibboleth” →
- Cultural norms are inherited from the people who raise you rather than genetically determined, yet they become so deeply embedded as to be near-hardwired—illustrated by the Shibboleth test, where identical Ephraimite twins raised in different tribes would acquire different pronunciation before age six or seven.Michael Munger on Cultural Norms 8/31/2009
- The term 'irrational' should be banished from behavioral economics because it functions as a tribal shibboleth dividing 'smart money' from everyone else (while the labelers commit the same errors), and because it has little real meaning: investors are not rational or irrational, they are simply human, and reconsidering a decision when something you paid $180 for becomes worth $1000 is a normal human response, not irrationality.Jason Zweig on Finance and the Devil's Financial Dictionary
- Baseball functioned as an American Shibboleth during the Battle of the Bulge, when US soldiers identified German infiltrators in American uniforms (whose English was perfect) by asking baseball trivia such as who led the American League in home runs in 1941.Michael Munger on Cultural Norms 8/31/2009
- The illogicality and self-contradiction of anti-Jewish accusations is itself a characteristic of the Pattern, working like the credos or shibboleths of cults and religions: asserting something illogical serves as a badge of membership, and in some situations the more illogical the shibboleth, the stronger it functions as such a badge—illustrated by Germans claiming Jews caused WWI and made it stop while the British press claimed Jews caused it and prevented it from stopping.David Deutsch on the Pattern
- The Gospel scene in which a crowd of Jews tells Pilate to crucify Jesus and accepts his blood 'on us and our children' did not happen and was constructed as an illogical allegation serving as a badge of Christian membership—because crowds don't speak in unison, and no crowd in history has ever volunteered that they and their descendants should be punished to the nth generation.David Deutsch on the Pattern