factual

Pilate Crowd Scene Was Fabricated

The Gospel scene in which a crowd of Jews tells Pilate to crucify Jesus and accepts his blood 'on us and our children' did not happen and was constructed as an illogical allegation serving as a badge of Christian membership—because crowds don't speak in unison, and no crowd in history has ever volunteered that they and their descendants should be punished to the nth generation.

factualpending

Speaker

David Deutsch

Evidence Quote

“That scene didn't happen. It was made up for the purpose of being an illogical allegation that it was a badge of membership--in this case of Christianity--to endorse.”

Source

David Deutsch on the Pattern— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:51 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...