factual

Illogical Accusations Function as Cult Shibboleths

The illogicality and self-contradiction of anti-Jewish accusations is itself a characteristic of the Pattern, working like the credos or shibboleths of cults and religions: asserting something illogical serves as a badge of membership, and in some situations the more illogical the shibboleth, the stronger it functions as such a badge—illustrated by Germans claiming Jews caused WWI and made it stop while the British press claimed Jews caused it and prevented it from stopping.

factualpending

Speaker

David Deutsch

Evidence Quote

“Cults and religions often have credos--shibboleths--where to be a member, you have to assert something illogical. And it's a badge of membership. So, in some situations, the more illogical the shibboleth is, the stronger it becomes as a badge of membership.”

Source

David Deutsch on the Pattern— EconTalk
Created: 6/13/2026, 12:29:51 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...