Pascal's Wager
The argument that one should believe in God because the potential infinite gain outweighs the finite cost if one is wrong.
As defined in Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge
Other definitions
The argument that one should believe in God because the potential infinite reward outweighs the cost, regardless of God's actual existence
AMA | July 2022
Where it comes up · 6
- Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Pascal, Pensses3 claims
- Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler1 claim
- Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge1 claim
- Nassim Taleb on the Financial Crisis 03/23/20091 claim
- AMA | July 20221 claim
- Ep19. State of Venture, AI Scaling, Elections | BG2 w/ Bill Gurley, Brad Gerstner, & Jamin Ball1 claim
Most important claims · 8 of 8Search all claims for “Pascal's Wager” →
- Pascal's wager is bad reasoning because it only makes sense if the sole choices are atheism or the traditional Christian God, when in fact there are many more possibilities—including a God who rewards intellectually honest atheism and punishes hypocritical belief, or non-heaven-hell deities—so without a probability distribution over all these possibilities the wager cannot be accurately made.AMA | July 2022
- Pascal's Wager can be understood as 'theology for accountants'—it is for calculating, self-interested minds that are willing to worship God not because of spiritual illumination but because it looks like a good bet, showing that the smart money is on God.Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Pascal, Pensses
- Pascal's Wager operates on a mathematical structure: Either God exists or he doesn't (law of excluded middle); you have to bet; if you're an atheist and you're right, your life is meaningless and wretched so you get nothing to lose; if you're an atheist and God exists, you get damned for all time and deserve it.Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Pascal, Pensses
- A self-criticism of the book is that it may be a new version of Pascal's Wager: if sustained growth has value approaching infinity but the chance of ever reaching that glorious future is small (say 1% rather than 10%), then preaching belief in that future to make it self-fulfilling replicates the problematic structure of betting on a small chance of an enormous payoff that we reject in other contexts like belief in a deity.Rob Wiblin interviews Tyler
- A second problem with Pascal's Wager is that it assumes God does not like intellectual integrity; suppose God likes people who are caught up with a naturalistic conception of the world, people who don't lie to themselves, and prefers those who are intellectually honest and make the best rational sense of the world around them—Pascal's Wager doesn't allow for this possibility.Great Authors - Literature of the Renaissance - Pascal, Pensses
- Even if meta-cap companies are concerned about capex guidance and spending levels, the competitive environment creates a Pascal's Wager dynamic: if AI upside is potentially infinite and all competitors are investing heavily, no company can afford to pull back capital investment, even if returns are uncertain, because falling behind in AI capability would be catastrophic to their competitive position.Ep19. State of Venture, AI Scaling, Elections | BG2 w/ Bill Gurley, Brad Gerstner, & Jamin Ball
- Pascal's wager is a naive argument, but its core idea of an option with free payoffs applies broadly to decision-making: religious belief costs little and has much higher payoffs than the costs if God does not exist, though it assumes God would not see through the gaming.Nassim Taleb on the Financial Crisis 03/23/2009
- Because there is no guarantee that heaven or hell exists, people could take Pascal's Wager, but this is still weaker as an enforcement mechanism than a Big Brother regime with telescreens and secret police.Steven Pinker on Common Knowledge