Panopticon
Bentham's prison design enabling a single watchman to observe all inmates without their knowing, a metaphor for total surveillance.
As defined in Michael Nielsen
Other definitions
A prison design (and Foucault's metaphor for modern power) in which inmates can be watched at any time without knowing when, inducing self-discipline through the possibility of constant observation.
133 | Ziya Tong on Realities We Don't See
Where it comes up · 11
- Michael Nielsen1 claim
- Why China's manufacturing economy is dominating — Arthur Kroeber1 claim
- Let Me Be Forgotten (with Lowry Pressly)1 claim
- David Skarbek on Prison Gangs and the Social Order of the Underworld1 claim
- Michael Munger on Antitrust1 claim
- 207 - Can We Pull Back From The Brink1 claim
- 151 - Will We Destroy The Future1 claim
- Foucault: Power, Knowledge and Post-structuralism1 claim
and 3 more
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “Panopticon” →
- Awareness that a record is being made of what you say or do makes you self-conscious and second-guess yourself—the disciplining force of surveillance—because you become aware everything will appear in a future context; effective surveillance states like East Germany worked not through technological expertise but by instilling pervasive doubt about whether any unaccountable space exists.Let Me Be Forgotten (with Lowry Pressly)
- The reassurance 'if I'm not doing anything wrong, why should surveillance matter' misses the point: surveillance is not about what you are doing but about who you are, because if you fall into a disfavored category—Muslim, gay, or holding a certain political alignment—the accumulated data on you can be flipped and used against you when power changes hands.133 | Ziya Tong on Realities We Don't See
- Facebook and Google constitute a private 'panopticon'—Foucault's adaptation of Bentham's prison design where unseen observers can watch all prisoners who therefore assume they are always watched—because these firms are potentially aware of almost everything we say, buy, and where we are, and the distinction between private and public power dissolves once the scale becomes large enough.Michael Munger on Antitrust
- Surveillance carries negative connotations but is necessary because supplying justice depends on understanding what has occurred; however, an optimal system needs a mix of surveillance and opaqueness — latitude to misbehave and break laws — to keep the system stable and limit the abuses of power by the powerful, ideally enforced through Madisonian conflict between powerful institutions.Michael Nielsen
- Even under conditions of perfect progress—eliminating all bad cops, giving the best training, culture, and de-escalation methods, and scrubbing dumb laws—we are still guaranteed to have some number of cases each year where a cop kills a civilian in a totally unjustified, tragic way, because there are 10 million arrests annually in a heavily armed society now recorded in a panopticon.207 - Can We Pull Back From The Brink
- Foucault critiques Bentham's panopticon as a system of social control and prison design that, while allegedly more humane, actually represents a new technology of disciplinary power that limits human freedom by forcing habits of diligence, regularity, thrift, and order through constant surveillance.Foucault: Power, Knowledge and Post-structuralism
- Contrary to 1990s Western belief that the internet would be the death knell of authoritarianism, China bet early that the internet could be an instrument both to accelerate technological development and to enhance social control—creating a panopticon in which an online population lets the leadership see what everyone is thinking, solving a problem of governing a vast empire that had bedeviled Chinese administrations for thousands of years—and China was proved correct on both counts.Why China's manufacturing economy is dominating — Arthur Kroeber
- By combining open-source data feeds (satellites, military and commercial aircraft, CCTV cameras), you can create a 'personal panopticon' using only openly available data that provides comprehensive real-time operational awareness of a region.Ex-Google Maps PM Vibe Coded Palantir In a Weekend
- Extreme preventive surveillance might take the form of everyone wearing a 'freedom tag'—a wearable device that records everything around them—which while dystopian could carry layered anonymity protections and side benefits such as far lower risk of dying from cardiac arrest because emergency responders are alerted.151 - Will We Destroy The Future
- If forced to choose between Xi Jinping's surveillance panopticon (1984-style) and a decentralized hellscape with hate speech and blasphemy, Ferguson prefers the middle ground between them rather than at the China extreme; the hellscape is preferable to total controlKindredCast: Recognizing The Patterns In Our Historical Moment with Niall Ferguson & Aryeh Bourkoff