Let Me Be Forgotten (with Lowry Pressly)
What this covers
Philosopher Lowry Pressly joins Russ Roberts to challenge the dominant theory of privacy as information control. Rather than asking who sees our data, Pressly argues that privacy protects something prior: zones of oblivion—regions of genuine unknowing, ambiguity, and unaccountability that allow humans to be spontaneous, to grow morally, and to remain fundamentally free. The conversation traces why informationalization of life, the freezing of fluid experience into fixed facts, represents a loss not easily captured by standard privacy frameworks. Pressly situates this anxiety historically, linking it to the nineteenth-century invention of the snapshot camera and the birth of privacy as a modern moral right, then tracks how contemporary surveillance and data practices extend this threat into near-total documentation.
The episode moves across philosophy, law, and moral intuition to explore several interconnected tensions. Pressly argues that the information-control model of privacy, dominant since the 1970s-80s, is conceptually mistaken and strategically weak—it accepts that information about us will exist and merely disputes who accesses it, leaving the primary threat unaddressed. He distinguishes Privacy vs Secrecy, showing why being alone is valuable even when not hiding anything, and unpacks Quantification of Human Experience, arguing that treating humans as composed of discrete, knowable data points contradicts the protean, multitudinous nature of personhood. The discussion also engages Accountability and Unaccountability, contending that we need periods free from judgment to rest and to become different versions of ourselves. Case studies appear throughout—the candid photograph as invasive fact-creation, the Arne Svenson art case, and the now-invisible practice of Googling people before meeting them—grounding abstract claims in lived practice. Roberts and Pressly debate whether limits to knowledge are mere obstacles or Productive Limits to Knowledge that give life depth and possibility.
Pressly argues that privacy is not fundamentally about controlling information or secrets but about preserving 'oblivion'—zones of unknowing, ambiguity, and unaccountability—that are necessary for spontaneity, moral growth, and being fully human, and that the modern informationalization of life threatens this good.
- The dominant information-control theory of privacy (dating to the 1970s-80s digital age) is conceptually mistaken and strategically weak because it concedes that information about us must pre-exist.
- Quantifying and recording human experience freezes fluid, protean life into fixed 'facts,' destroying parts of experience that resist quantification.
- Unaccountable, oblivious spaces are required for agency, spontaneity, and the ability to become a different person.
Recording and measuring experiences freezes their fluid, ambiguous character into false fixed facts.
- When you quantify or record something, you tend to freeze it into a fixed fact tied to a point in time, which deflates experiences—like a moving symphony, a poem, or how much one cares for someone—that are essentially fluid, ambiguous, and about potentiality; treating them as measured data points misrepresents their nature.
“when you quantify something, you tend to freeze it”
- We mistakenly treat a remembered 'transcript' of an interaction as fact and information, but a transcript is incredibly ambiguous—it omits the raised eyebrow and cannot tell whether a chuckle was cruel or nervous—and even video evidence is often deeply flawed; appreciating the irreducible ambiguity of human interaction and language is preferable to imagining we possess an objective record.
“a transcript, which we think of as a fact, as information, is incredibly ambiguous. It leaves out the raised eyebrow, it leaves out the chuckle... was that a cruel chuckle, or was that a self-awareness, nervous chuckle?”
Unknown and unaccountable aspects of ourselves are sources of meaning and resist being instrumentalized into information.
- Being accountable is generally a good thing, but it is too big a burden for human beings to bear continuously—we cannot wear that cloak all the time.
“it's too big a burden to bear for human beings to wear that cloak all the time”
- Because the limits of self-knowledge, self-control, and self-determination mean we can never fully account for ourselves—there is no place to stand outside one's life to conduct such an accounting and we all have opaque blind spots—these unaccountable lacunae are not merely failures of introspection but are sources of life's sense of meaning, depth, and a quality resistant to instrumentalization, and this is so not because they are hidden but because something is lost when translated into information.
“these lacuna are not only failures of introspection and self-governance, they're also sources of the sense that one's life has meaning, depth, and a quality essentially resistant to instrumentalization and control”
Live interaction differs fundamentally from preserved recordings because the self is flux, not a static thing to be replayed.
- There is a fundamental difference between being observed live in a conversation and being recorded for later scrutiny: one can welcome being looked at and showing emotion to connect in the moment, but once the interaction can be preserved and replayed, a different thing happens—'I'm on camera'—and one would rather the other person hold a memory of the conversation than a video of it, because the self is the movie (the flux), not the still.
“once you can preserve it and look at it later, that's a different thing... I want to have you have the memory of our conversation, not the video of it. And, those are two different human experiences”
Single recorded moments should not define a person when we know ourselves to contain far richer complexity.
- All humans 'contain multitudes,' so any single moment of weakness, inconsiderateness, or imperfection—especially one that goes viral—should not become front and center and define a person, because we know from our own self-experience that we are richer than any one moment, yet we readily label others by a single observed failing while never receiving credit ('gold stars') for the thousand good moments.
“Any one moment of weakness or imperfection should not be front and center all the time... we don't want to be summed up by one moment when we have a thousand that are on the other side. And, yet, where's my gold star for that, that you're not seeing?”