What this covers

Ziya Tong and Sean Carroll explore how human perception—constrained by both biology and culture—obscures vast territories of physical, social, and moral reality. The conversation begins with sensory limitation: humans perceive only a narrow band of electromagnetic waves and sound, missing neutrinos, dark matter, and microscopic life entirely. From there, Tong expands the argument into constructed systems we treat as natural—property law, mechanical time, surveillance infrastructure—showing how these inventions have become so embedded in daily life that we forget they are chosen arrangements rather than inevitable facts. The core tension animates the entire discussion: science can reveal invisible physical phenomena, but we remain deliberately blind to the supply chains, waste streams, and power structures woven into ordinary life.

The conversation covers considerable ground. Tong details how industrial food systems use chemical blindness—artificial coloring and preservatives—to disguise the origins and freshness of products, and how factory farming itself is hidden geographically from view despite killing 60 to 70 billion animals yearly. She examines how constructed systems treated as natural—like clocks and property rights—reshape ecosystems: mechanical time drives temporal scale blindness that makes mass suffering invisible, while our light-polluted 24/7 cycle has erased the night sky and disrupted animal migration. Legal absurdities surface when corporations receive more protection than rivers. Carroll contributes perspective on why selective attention shapes reality as much as reasoning does, and cautions against romanticizing scientific rebels without evidence. Throughout, both speakers return to a single unsettling observation: the systems sustaining modern life were engineered for extraction at a speed nature cannot replenish, leaving the machinery fundamentally out of balance.

Sharpest takeaway

Tong argues that human perception is biologically and culturally limited to a narrow 'reality bubble,' and that science exposes not only invisible physical and biological realities but also the invisible social, economic, and moral structures (food systems, surveillance, property, time) we have normalized at our peril.

  • Our senses filter out most of physical and biological reality (electromagnetic spectrum, microbes, scales of time/space)
  • We have deliberately hidden where food and energy come from and where waste goes
  • Human-invented systems like property, clocks, and surveillance are treated as natural despite being constructed and often harmful

The argument · threads8 threads · 39 claims
0.85

We cannot perceive vast dimensions of time, space, and scale that structure reality and determine our survival and inequality.

8 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Human cultures vary in temporal scope, and effective ecosystem stewardship requires planning on timescales far longer than typical five- or ten-year plans—exemplified by the Great Bear Rainforest activists' 500-year plan—because ecological systems and the trees within them operate over far longer periods than human lives.

    “when they were working on their project, they didn't come up with a five-year plan or a 10-year plan, they came up with a 500-year plan. Which is when you're thinking about ecosystems actually a far more reflective and vital timescale to be working in”

  • Roughly 100 trillion neutrinos pass through our bodies at every moment, and combined with the constant atomic exchange between our bodies and the outside world (much of our hydrogen dating to the Big Bang), this makes us ghost-like, porous beings rather than sealed-off individuals, blurring the boundary between self and world.

    “100 trillion of them are just flying through our bodies at this very moment, and we are kind of ghost-like figures in a sense that we're so porous”

  • Humans are outnumbered by their own gut bacteria roughly 1.3 to 1 (an update to the popular 10-to-1 figure), and since we are born essentially bacteria-free, we accumulate these microbial 'hitchhikers' through life, which challenges the clear dividing line between self and the rest of the world.

    “I think it's 1.3 to 1, so we are out numbered 1.3 to 1, we're slightly more bacteria than we are human. But yeah, it's incredible because, of course, when we're born, we're born pretty much bacteria-free”

  • The Outer Space Treaty designates space as the one province open to all mankind that has not been divvied up into private ownership, which is somewhat absurd given that only about 0.00067% of humans have ever reached space—highlighting how arbitrary our rules of property are when the only undivided realm is the one almost no one can access.

    “the Outer Space Treaty is the one province that is open to all mankind, and it's like, well, what good is that? Like 0.00067% of us have made it to outer space, but that is the province that we have not actually divvied up”

  • While humans are pitifully bad at conceptualizing large numbers, our machines operate at speeds and magnitudes beyond perception—high-frequency traders work in 'computime' so fast that by the time a person looks at a stock it is like a star that burned out 50,000 years ago, and signals can cross the Atlantic and back roughly six times in the time it takes to say 'go.'

    “by the time a normal person looks at a stock, like a high frequency stock, it's like a star that burned out 50,000 years ago, our computers are working so quickly... what Jeremy Rifkin referred to as computime, a sort of time that is just beyond human perception”

  • Humans have taken the vast dimensions of time and space and chopped them into small human-scaled units we can buy and sell among each other, so that some people's time is worth millions per day (Jeff Bezos) while others earn pennies (a Dalit laborer), and some inhabit ghost mansions while others live in spatial coffins—turning cosmic dimensions into instruments of inequality.

    “we've chopped up time and space, and we've turned time and space, these vast dimensions, into these little measures that we can buy and sell amongst each other... some people today are inhabiting ghost mansions and other people are living in the equivalent of spatial coffins”

  • Because humans suffer from scale blindness, the most effective way to make people care about mass suffering is to tell the story of a single individual; studies show people respond more strongly to one victim than to two, and donate roughly the same amount whether 8,000, 80,000, or 800,000 seabirds are oiled, because as savanna-dwelling 'cave people' we never needed to differentiate among very large numbers.

    “if there's an earthquake and you just tell the story of one person in that earthquake, you're able to get far more people responding to that one person than if it's even two people”

  • By adulthood almost all humans host demodex mites—tiny arachnids related to spiders—living in the roots of eyelashes; they feed on facial sebum at night, lack anuses so they release their gut contents when they die, and they are too small to feel as they crawl roughly 17 millimeters across the face per hour.

    “the demodex mites that are on almost all adults by the time we reach adult age. They're arachnids... they don't have anuses, so when they crawl about on your face every night, they kind of eventually, when they pass, they do sort of explode their internal guts all over your face”

0.71

Industrial systems hide animal slaughter and food production behind distance, artificial disguise, and legal barriers to seeing the truth.

8 pointscentrality 4/5
  • In the 21st century there are cameras everywhere except where our food comes from, where our energy comes from, and where our waste goes—meaning that despite being the most powerful species on earth, we are fundamentally blind to the systems on which our survival depends.

    “in the 21st century, there are cameras everywhere, except where our food comes from, where our energy comes from and where our waste goes”

  • The food wasted in the United States represents so much embedded energy that eliminating it would be equivalent to stopping all offshore oil drilling in the country, illustrating the staggering inefficiency of a food system whose waste we never see.

    “in terms of all the food waste in the States, it's the equivalent of if you just like all the energy and oil... If you just stopped all the offshore drilling in the United States, it would be the equivalent of that”

  • We have industrially hijacked the reproductive systems of food animals—about 95% of pigs and 90% of cows are created through artificial insemination/IVF, and every commercially eaten turkey is artificially bred—turning sentient animals into manufactured products through what one of Tong's friends coined the 'jiz biz' of semen sales.

    “today about 95% of pigs and 90% of cows never really get to do it the old-fashioned way. They're created through in vitro fertilization. In fact, every single turkey that you'll ever eat is something that humans got into the middle of”

  • Ag-gag laws (such as those instituted in Ontario) make it illegal to document abuses inside factory farms, which is hard to justify on principled grounds because a food system should be the most transparent system of all and people deserve to be able to know how their food is made.

    “in places like Ontario, where I live... we've just instituted ag-gag laws, which you may have heard of, which are laws that make it illegal to actually go and document any of this, any of these abuses that are taking place”

  • Wildlife now constitutes only about 3-4% of vertebrate biomass on earth, with the rest being domesticated animals and humans, and we kill roughly 60 to 70 billion animals every year—yet the real blind spot is that we see virtually none of this slaughter because factory farms have been moved far away from us.

    “we have 3%-4% wildlife, and the rest of the vertebrate biomass on our planet is our domesticated animals and human beings... every year now, we kill 60 to 70 billion animals every single year, but when we talk about blind spots... The real issue is that we don't see any of it”

  • Industrial food is artificially colored to fool our instincts about freshness and health—farmed salmon is fed coloring matched to a 'Salmofan' paint chip because their flesh would otherwise be gray, egg yolks are dyed orange, and carbon monoxide keeps tuna red—so the dangerous element is not the process itself but the chemical blindness it creates, which can disguise old or unsafe food as fresh.

    “farmed salmon doesn't eat all the krill... if you didn't actually taint their food source with a particular color, their flesh would be gray... we have ways of sort of tricking the eye”

  • People profess to love animals and eagerly share cute animal images online, but reliably recoil from and unfollow content showing what actually happens to animals behind the scenes, demonstrating a wilful blindness that the book deliberately works around by first establishing wonder at animal intelligence before confronting the food system.

    “if you try to actually talk about anything to do with what happens to animals, kind of behind the scenes, ooh, people don't like that, and I will instantly lose followers, it happens every time”

  • An autopsy study of chicken nuggets found that a nugget contains very little actual chicken meat, consisting largely of sinew, muscle, and fat, illustrating how meat is deconstructed and delivered in ways that disguise its true content from our senses.

    “I found a study that was with scientists who did an autopsy on a chicken nugget... a chicken nugget is very little actual chicken meat. And it's actually just the sort of sinew and muscle and fat that people are consuming”

0.70

Humans have three distinct categories of blindness: sensory limits, willful denial, and inherited civilizational norms we no longer notice.

4 pointscentrality 5/5
  • Human blind spots fall into three categories: biological blind spots (things we cannot see because of the limits of our senses), wilful blind spots (things we are unable or deliberately unwilling to see), and civilizational blind spots (things inherited and normalized across generations such that we no longer perceive them).

    “the first section really looks at those biological blind spots... the second section of the book really looks a little bit more at our wilful blind spots... And then the third section of the book is more civilizational blind spot”

  • After the BP oil spill, the dispersant Corexit was used not to remove oil but to disperse and thereby invisibilize it; a Florida surfer who fell ill discovered with a UV lamp that the beach glowed orange with dispersant, illustrating that a beach considered 'clean' (only 1% of 1 meter free of oil deposits) can still hide a dangerous reality detectable only under different light.

    “during the BP oil spill, the desire was to use dispersant, not so much to get rid of the oil, but to disperse the oil. And in dispersing the oil, what they were doing was they were invisibilizing the oil, but here was a man who was finally able to see it”

  • The scientific reality bubble is distinct from political or filter bubbles: political bubbles involve differences of opinion, morality, or value among insular groups, whereas the reality bubble is when your perceptual faculties tell you one thing and scientific tools reveal a very different objective reality, and the dangerous mismatch is between perception and fact rather than between opinions.

    “what I'm talking about is a bubble where your perceptual faculties tell you one thing, and then scientific tools and technology can basically envision a very different reality, and when there's a mismatch, that's when you have something that's quite dangerous”

  • We live in a 'reality bubble' where our five senses present one version of reality while scientific tools detect a fundamentally different reality, and because we are not privy to that larger reality, we are in a dangerous position—much like being inside a financial bubble that can crash in when ignored.

    “our entire sort of idea of reality beyond what the human being is able to perceive with our five senses, that scientists have been able to detect a different reality that we are not exactly privy to, and because we're not privy to it, we're actually in quite a dangerous position”

0.56

We voluntarily trade personal surveillance data for convenience despite professing privacy values, creating collective failure to resist control.

4 pointscentrality 4/5
  • Wearable sensors like fitness rings are sold for personal convenience (monitoring sleep, heart rate, location), but the deeper question is who designs these sensors and who owns the accumulated database of our collective sensory knowledge, because that aggregated data can ultimately be used against us.

    “the bigger question is the database and who owns the data of all of our sensory knowledge, our combined collective sensory knowledge today, which is sometimes, of course, used against us”

  • The reassurance 'if I'm not doing anything wrong, why should surveillance matter' misses the point: surveillance is not about what you are doing but about who you are, because if you fall into a disfavored category—Muslim, gay, or holding a certain political alignment—the accumulated data on you can be flipped and used against you when power changes hands.

    “it's not about what you're doing, it's simply about who you are. If you're the wrong category of person, with the flip of a switch... if you happen to be Muslim, if in another country you happen to be gay... there's a lot of data on you now, and that data can be used against you”

  • People fear far-fetched microchip implants in vaccines yet voluntarily spend hundreds of dollars to carry smartphones that track them constantly, and although users can nominally turn off location services, it is unclear how much control we actually have over who gets and uses that location data—state actors, advertisers, and hired security firms all use it.

    “you wouldn't need to be microchipped, you're already carrying the surveillance device in your hand”

  • Although rugged Western individualists in nominal democracies might be expected to refuse constant surveillance, most people in fact trade their data for convenience (e.g. letting Google Maps know their location), producing a collective action problem in which we fail to live up to our own stated privacy values—and that surveilled data has been used to shape opinion and nearly topple democratic outcomes via Cambridge Analytica.

    “most people are like, eh, I'd rather have Google Maps tell me where to go and not undergo the inconvenience of not telling it where I am. So there's sort of a collective action problem”

0.39

Slow-moving environmental crises like climate change and light pollution fail to trigger emergency response because humans perceive only fast threats.

3 pointscentrality 3/5
  • Human machine-made time has knock-on effects on biological systems: by driving climate change, our hyper-productive energy use has shifted plant blooming and insect emergence earlier, creating phenological mismatches so that migrating birds now arrive too late and starve—showing that a seemingly imaginary, poetic construct like time can restructure the temporal systems of nature.

    “when you've got flowers and trees blooming a lot earlier and insects coming earlier, when you actually finally have the bird migration, the birds are all late, right, and so the birds are all starving... that's actually a result of how we have structured our time”

  • Living in a 24/7 light-polluted capitalist cycle has cost us our night skies—when a 1990s Los Angeles power outage darkened the city, frightened residents called the Griffith Observatory about the strange 'cloud' that was actually the Milky Way they had never seen—and turning out the lights would save energy, restore bird migration and insect cycles, and let us recover the humbling experience of scaling ourselves against the vastness of the universe.

    “in the 1990s, there was a power outage in Los Angeles, and all these people started calling the Griffith observatory, freaking out, 'cause they didn't know what that magnificent orb, like cloud was in the sky... the reason was because these people had never seen the Milky Way”

  • Climate change is a 'slow apocalypse' that humans respond to poorly because, unlike a fast-moving threat in a horror movie that triggers nimble responses, slow threats fail to register as emergencies; this explains why our targets are set decades away (2040, 2050) in a disjointed approach that contradicts treating the situation as an actual emergency.

    “that's really one of the greatest challenges is the fact that this is a slow apocalypse that we're witnessing... human beings don't tend to respond quite as well with longer timescales”

0.21

Cellular agriculture and legal rights for ecosystems offer technological and systemic alternatives to current destructive food and legal structures.

2 pointscentrality 2/5
  • Legal systems treat human-invented constructs as more real than natural reality: in the Little Mahoning Watershed fracking case a judge dismissed the idea that a watershed could have legal rights even though the opposing party was a corporation, exposing the absurdity that we grant a corporation more legal personhood than an actual river or ecosystem—whereas places like a New Zealand river and part of the Amazon Basin have been granted rights to defend their own existence.

    “who's fighting us in this court case, it's a corporation, you're trying to tell us that a corporation is more real than a river, or than a watershed, or than an ecosystem”

  • Cellular agriculture can separate the animal from the flesh—as with the company Just, which grew chicken meat in a bioreactor from stem cells taken from a single fallen feather while the unharmed bird walked around—offering a win-win that could place bioreactors in food-scarce regions to produce protein and milk while slashing water and methane footprints and ending animal cruelty.

    “they took some stem cells from a feather that had fallen from this perfect bird, and they manufactured meat with it, they put it in a bio-reactor, grew the cells and grew chicken meat... the perfectly unharmed bird that they're all eating is walking around”

0.07

Artificial intelligence mirrors the human problem of imposing categories on reality, reaching correct conclusions through logic we cannot understand.

2 pointscentrality 1/5
  • Artificial intelligence faces the same problem of dividing the world into common-sense categories that humans do effortlessly, but its pattern recognition is so fundamentally different from ours that we often cannot understand the logic by which it reaches conclusions—even though those conclusions are frequently correct.

    “Its pattern recognition is so fundamentally different than ours that we don't even understand the logic by which it comes to its conclusions, and yet it often does come to the right conclusion”

  • People call to 'fight the system' or 'change the system' without recognizing that the system is our manufactured life support system—a set of efficiency-maximizing machines that freed us from the cycles of nature but became so good at extraction that we are now outstripping nature's ability to supply inputs and recycle outputs, leaving the machine wildly out of whack.

    “we're always like, fight the system, you've got to change the system, but nobody actually asks what that system is, and that system is our life support system... we got so good at it that we are actually outstripping the ability for nature to provide the input”

0.04

Cultural values like Chinese collectivism and Western individualism shape responses to surveillance, technology, and collective action differently.

1 pointcentrality 1/5
  • While Chinese state surveillance and treatment of the Uighurs are genuinely objectionable, a state is not the same as its people, and the prevailing hyper-demonization of China ignores its achievements (such as its 300,000-km bullet train network) and its different, collective, dynastic cultural mindset; that collectivist, conformist culture also explains why the anti-vax/anti-mask 'mind virus' did not spread there as it has in North America.

    “I'm also really against the hyper-demonization of China that I'm starting to see, because China does some amazing stuff too. A state is not necessarily its people”