Nullification
Political doctrine asserting that states or regions have the right to reject or not enforce federal laws they deem unconstitutional, historically invoked during secession crises
As defined in Neil Howe: We May Suffer A Collision of Financial, Social & Geo-Political Crises All At Once
Other definitions
The claimed right of a state or individual to declare a law null and refuse to obey it on the grounds that it is unjust or unconstitutional.
Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
Where it comes up · 4
- 'Violent, Explosive’ Fourth Turning Is Here: Civil War Or Global Conflict Unfolding | Neil Howe6 claims
- Neil Howe: Fourth Turning Predictions1 claim
- Neil Howe: We May Suffer A Collision of Financial, Social & Geo-Political Crises All At Once1 claim
- Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)1 claim
Most important claims · 9 of 9Search all claims for “Nullification” →
- Lincoln held that rejecting the principle of a constitutional majority—a majority held in restraint by constitutional checks and changing with deliberate shifts in popular opinion—necessarily leads to anarchy or despotism, because unanimity is impossible and permanent minority rule is inadmissible, so secession (like nullification) is the essence of anarchy.Lessons from Lincoln, Then and Now (with Diana Schaub)
- Nullification is a constitutional doctrine, rooted in Anti-Federalist theory and the Virginia and Kentucky Resolutions, that allows states to opt out of federal laws or edicts they reject, existing as a halfway house between full compliance with federal authority and secession.'Violent, Explosive’ Fourth Turning Is Here: Civil War Or Global Conflict Unfolding | Neil Howe
- A nullification crisis would escalate through iterative defiance and federal response: a state or coalition of states refuses to enforce a federal law or regulation, the federal government demands compliance, the states refuse, and the federal government faces a choice between backing down (losing all credibility) or escalating (risking open conflict), creating an unavoidable escalation dynamic.'Violent, Explosive’ Fourth Turning Is Here: Civil War Or Global Conflict Unfolding | Neil Howe
- If Democrats win the 2020 election and implement their policies (taxes, income transfers, Green New Deal), the red zone will likely test the blue zone through nullification or secession, refusing to obey regulations or pay taxes; secession by red states is more plausible than blue zone secession because red states have military/weapons capacity and blue zone would not enforce federal authorityNeil Howe: Fourth Turning Predictions
- The Constitutional amendment process is functionally broken for addressing major national issues during periods of extreme partisan polarization because it requires supermajorities in both houses and state ratifications, and neither party will vote for amendments that disadvantage their current position (e.g., Republicans will never support eliminating the Electoral College because it currently benefits them).'Violent, Explosive’ Fourth Turning Is Here: Civil War Or Global Conflict Unfolding | Neil Howe
- A potential nullification crisis could be triggered by diverse issues including taxation, immigration, education regulation (gender issues), or regulatory enforcement, and the specific trigger is unpredictable, but historically it's remarkable how trivial the surface issues are that precipitate major conflicts.'Violent, Explosive’ Fourth Turning Is Here: Civil War Or Global Conflict Unfolding | Neil Howe
- The primary worry is not the election itself but what happens immediately after—either massive resistance movements if Kamala Harris loses or nullification movements and defiance of federal authority if Donald Trump loses—because the two candidates represent mutually exclusive worldviews.Neil Howe: We May Suffer A Collision of Financial, Social & Geo-Political Crises All At Once
- Howe and Strauss made five major predictions in 1997 about what would occur in the 2000s and 2010s: (1) a major financial crash, (2) a pandemic, (3) Russia invading a former Soviet state, (4) a WMD threat launched by airplanes in New York, and (5) a nullification crisis; the first four have come to pass but the nullification crisis has not yet occurred.'Violent, Explosive’ Fourth Turning Is Here: Civil War Or Global Conflict Unfolding | Neil Howe
- Texas Governor Greg Abbott's border control actions (Operation Lone Star) represent a modern example of nullification—a state claiming authority to enforce its own immigration and border security policies despite federal government objections, setting the stage for potential escalation if multiple states coordinate similar actions.'Violent, Explosive’ Fourth Turning Is Here: Civil War Or Global Conflict Unfolding | Neil Howe