
Neil Howe: We May Suffer A Collision of Financial, Social & Geo-Political Crises All At Once
What this covers
This is a long conversation between host Adam Taggart and demographer Neil Howe, co-author of the generational-cycle books on the Fourth Turning. It moves from political diagnosis to historical analogy, then to fiscal mechanics, and finally to portfolio advice. Howe's historical comparisons carry much of the argument. He calls the 1850s the most disturbing parallel: a new third party displaced the Whigs and turned the 1856 and 1860 elections into regional plebiscites. He also points to the 1930s, when democracies fell to fascist and left-wing takeovers, and he says democracy fails when two camps would rather fight than give up what is essential to them. He recasts the American Revolution as a civil war and says old regimes tend to collapse slowly, then suddenly. The 1780s, he argues, were economically worse than the 1930s. He notes that Franklin Roosevelt received no briefing from Herbert Hoover in 1932, a pattern he traces to Abraham Lincoln.
The middle of the conversation turns to money and demography. Howe says the CBO projects that half of non-interest federal spending will go to people 65 and older within a decade, and that a 5–6% of GDP deficit at the top of the cycle goes unchallenged by either party. He expects crisis to push spending toward younger people, as the GI Bill did, in order to motivate sacrifice. He also argues that fertility will not recover without subsidies of roughly $5,000–7,500 per child per year, and that Republicans are naturally the party of higher birth rates. Border policy, defense buildups across high-income countries, and the way fear lifted George W. Bush's approval to 96% after 9/11 also come up.
The last third is more contested and market-focused. Howe reads the yield curve, Fed cuts, and downward payroll revisions as recession signals, and he recalls that William McChesney Martin avoided a recession after the 1966 inversion. He regards higher inflation combined with financial repression as nearly locked in. His advice is to avoid long-term nominal bonds, steer clear of high counterparty risk, and treat passive investing as a concentration risk because of the Mag 7. He expects government to pick winners and losers.
Neil Howe argues that the United States is in a Fourth Turning—a generational crisis period requiring fundamental societal reorganization—and that financial, internal, and external crises will converge to force a massive reallocation of public resources from seniors to younger generations, with significant implications for markets, policy, and personal finances.
- Fourth Turnings occur roughly every 80–100 years and feature regime change, institutional restructuring, and climactic resolution of accumulated tensions
- Current bifurcated political polarization mirrors the 1850s pre-Civil War period and the 1930s pre-WWII era, making democratic governance increasingly difficult
- Public spending is currently skewed toward seniors (half the federal budget to those 65+), but Fourth Turnings demand redistribution toward younger generations to incentivize sacrifice and rebuild infrastructure
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The American Revolution was fundamentally a civil war in which a large share of Americans sided with Britain and Parliament, particularly non-English-speaking colonists who recognized that a new populist English-speaking republic would respect their rights less than the liberal parliamentary regime.
“the American Revolution, although we like to think of it as a revolution against Britain, I think that is the the the the way Americans like to think of it, it was in reality a civil war, right? A large share of Americans sided with the with the uh With the crown. With the crown, with Parliament. Uh, particularly middle America, particularly the non-English speaking America.”
In real economic terms, a Fourth Turning crisis forces large populations away from production (e.g., to war), reducing total output, so real losses must be allocated through political decision-making, not financial manipulation.
“if you're suddenly taking a large share of the population and you're forcing them to to do some massive task...the where you're going to get, you know, who's Suddenly those people aren't going to be producing, right?...suddenly you're going to have just lot less resources being produced. How are you going to allocate that loss?...You're just going to have to say, 'Well, all of you people in the army, we're going to pay you a certain amount'...You're going to reshuffle things like that. I think that's the way we have to think. Think more about the real economy”
The most disturbing historical parallel to the current moment is the 1850s, when a third party (the Republicans) sprung up from nowhere, stole voters mostly from the Whigs, and rendered the 1856 and 1860 elections virtually regional plebiscites on America's direction—directly leading to secession and civil war.
“the most obvious parallel is to the is to the 1850s, right? When you had a ultimately a a third party which sprung up from nowhere, basically stole mostly from the Whigs, some from the Northern Democrats, and rendered political campaigns in America in 1856 and then in 1860 virtually a regional plebiscite on where America was going. Uh, and that led directly to secession and civil war, right?”
Democracy does not work when two populations would rather fight than give up what is essential to them; this dynamic mirrors the 1930s when fascist and left-wing takeovers swept democracies worldwide, and represents the most ominous parallel to the current American moment.
“I think I uh I uh I qu- quoted a a a a famous essay uh by one of my favorite intellectual historians of written back in 1940 uh on the travails of democracy uh who who basically said uh democracy works best when there's really nothing much to talk about...he said, 'The problem is democracy does not work when you have two populations that would rather fight than to give up what's essential to them.'”
Deficit spending today is equivalent to stealing from the future because spending is financed by borrowing, and the burden falls on future generations who must repay the debt plus interest.
“deficit spending we're basically how are we funding things if we deficit spend? We're stealing from the future, right?”
William McChesney Martin was the only Fed chair to successfully prevent a recession after a yield curve inversion (1966), while yield curve inversions have predicted 11 out of the last 10 recessions (with that one false positive in 1966 being Martin's achievement).
“William McChesney Martin is the only one who did it after a yield curve inversion. There was no yield curve inversion in 1994 and 1995, right? And there were almost no recession indicators flashing red back then. I actually have a show which I do once a month on on sort of the monthly economic indicators, but in 1966, there was we actually had a yield curve inversion. William McChesney Martin avoided a recession. And you go back and look, um, yield curve inversions have predicted 11 out of the last 10 recessions. That 11th, that false positive, was 1966, and that was, uh, that was Martin's doing, so.”
Franklin Roosevelt did not consider joining Herbert Hoover's administration in 1932, and received no briefing from Hoover on the economy, because Lincoln had established the pattern of incoming presidents refusing to legitimize outgoing ones during Fourth Turnings—letting crisis worsen accelerates regime change.
“Lincoln did the same with Buchanan. Uh Buchanan wanted Lincoln to sort of help him in these last gasping moments when the when the South was seceding and so on. And Lincoln basically said, 'No, no. I want everything that bad that happens to be on your watch.' Um all right. So, uh you know, and I take some comfort in that, which is might I might just say, Adam, just to bring this up to date, there might have been a little bit of that in the Republicans' refusal to go along uh with a bipartisan immigration reform bill earlier this year.”
Passive investing and index ETFs create systemic risk because the Magnificent 7 tech stocks are overrepresented in major indices, so if these firms decline the entire broad market declines with them due to herd ownership patterns.
“the the whole problem of passive investing, right?...This also worries me...the representation of the Mag 7 in those equity ETFs is uh it it's outsized relative to the remaining 493 stocks in the S&P...these large uh firms in terms of market cap are are naturally included in the most ETFs. So, if you have people investing a lot of ETFs, they they overlap with all the large, you know, the the large market cap firms, right? Right. So, it's a it's a systemic risk, which is if those few firms get in trouble, everybody goes down with it”
Raising fertility rates to meaningful levels requires 5,000–7,500 USD per child per year, because historically people had children to care for them in old age, but pay-as-you-go social insurance subsidizes old age while leaving childhood costs private—so without matching subsidies to family formation, fertility won't rise.
“We see that in Hungary, we see that in Poland. You're going to talk about several points of GDP. Why? Because one of the reasons why people have kids historically, traditionally is to take care of them in old age. But what we've done in all of the high-income societies around the world with pay-as-you-go social insurance systems is we basically subsidize the cost of growing old, right? But leave entirely private the cost of raising young people.”
Half of the federal budget (excluding interest payments) will be going to Americans age 65 and older within 10 years according to the CBO, and much of interest payments also flow to bond holders who are older, meaning the remaining budget for defense, NASA, national parks, and all other government functions is severely squeezed.
“Um half of the federal budget, excluding interest payments, uh 10 years from now, according to the CBO, will be going to Americans age 65 and older. Mhm. And of course a lot of a lot of those interest payments will also be going to people age 60 I mean, who holds bonds? I mean, Right, exactly. Yeah. So, I mean, but I'm just saying that is the amount of skew. And that means everything else, you know, I'm talking about defense, you're talking about national parks, oceanographic institute, NASA, you know, throwing and throw in the cost of all the bureaucracy. All of the rest of it is all in the remaining part of the budget, right?”
The federal government is running a 5–6% of GDP deficit at the peak of the business cycle when GDP is above its potential, which is irrational and neither political party is calling it out; this suggests either leaders are in denial or they understand it will be resolved by inflation and financial repression later.
“We're already running 5 to 6% of GDP deficit when GDP is actually above its potential. I mean, look at the CBO on that. We're we're at the peak of the business cycle now and we're running these enormous deficits. In what world is this rational? Um but no one calls on it, right? No no neither side it gets called on this.”
The Republican Party is naturally the party of higher birth rates; regardless of demographic subgroup, Republicans tend to have more kids and be less likely to be single, and care more about family policies that foster children—this is an observable demographic pattern.
“the Republican Party is naturally the party of a higher birth rates, and we see that in the data, no matter how you divide up the population, no matter what subgroup you're looking at by age or anything else. You know, Republicans tend to have more kids, they tend to be less likely to be single. And Republicans care more about family life and about, you know, what uh policies that uh foster uh having kids and and forming families.”
Stay away from investments with high counterparty risk like complex ETFs with embedded options; know where your money is going; individual stock investing is safer than broad index ETFs because the latter are heavily concentrated in a few mega-cap stocks (Mag 7) whose systemic risk could ripple through.
“and I would also think about um staying away from uh investments with a lot of counterparty risk. You know, some of the complex ETFs that are out there, some of the you know, I mean the Look, they're they're they're all kinds of uh output and call options and and weird there's these weird ETFs now that are these uh uh these ones that are semi-transparent and they invest in real ass I mean just bizarre stuff and I'm just thinking know where your money is. That's the other thing. Know where your money's going.”
Six months after 9/11 (February 2002), President G.W. Bush's approval rating was 96%—people rally around leaders in crisis; this shows how fear and existential threat override normal political divisions and enable strong leaders to take unpopular actions.
“And then I ask people to recall 6 months after 9/11. Do you know what G.W. Bush's approval rating was in in February of 2002? It was like 96%. super high, yeah. I mean, it was not And you think, how did that happen? You know? Well, it's obvious how it happened. You know what I mean? People were scared. Right. You rally around your leaders, yeah. I mean, that's why they always sort of accuse people unpopular leaders of wanting to start a war just to try to rally the country around them, yeah.”
After World War II, the Fed-Treasury Accord of 1951 ended financial repression by establishing Fed independence and forcing interest rates up against presidential pressure, ending an era where bond holders received negative real returns.
“the Treasury uh, Fed Accord, which lasted all the way up until late 1951, when famously William McChesney Martin, who was Truman's guy at Treasury, came over to Fed and Truman never forgave him, right? For for for declaring independence of the Fed and basically the Fed saying, 'No, wait a minute. To avert inflation, we need to start hiking interest rates”
The Federal Reserve is currently cutting at a rate (225 basis points by end of 2025 according to CME futures) far steeper than the FOMC projects (100 basis points), indicating markets expect a sharp recession and don't have faith in the Fed's soft landing narrative.
“the CME futures is looking at 225 basis point cut, you know, by the end of 2025, not just the 100 points that the that the FOMC is looking at, uh I think is is to the extent to which the markets kind of understand the scheme as well.”
President Biden implemented border patrol procedures through executive order that reduced illegal entries by 50% in July 2024, confirming Republican claims that the tools existed to address the border without new legislation.
“Joe Biden is saying, 'Well, we put into these uh new border patrol procedures, which have brought down illegal entries 50% uh in in July.'...Republicans are saying, 'You know, this is what we always said. They did have it within their means to do this by regulatory, you know, do this by executive order'”
The Fed historically cuts rates right before the next recession begins, and the yield curve typically uninverts just before recession starts, establishing a predictable pattern that appears to be occurring again.
“the inverted yield curve, I mean all of these long-term indicators going red, then the medium-term indicators. Now we see it happening in employment and then the Fed starts to the right? And the Fed always starts to cut before the next recession...typically the yield curve uninverts just before the next...I look at this, and by the way, by when you go into the next recession, the markets always go down”
A higher rate of inflation combined with financial repression is 'virtually locked into the cards'—this means inflating the economy to deflate creditors' claims and forcing large financial institutions (banks, pension funds) to hold low/negative real-return bonds, as France, Japan, and other countries already do.
“I see uh uh a higher rate of inflation combined with financial repression as being virtually locked into the cards right now, right? Um uh basically, if you if you inflate the economy, right, you deflate the claims uh the creditors have, and then you basically require a lot of people to hold bonds. Uh you can do that. You can require banks. You can require a lot of pension funds, right, to just hold them. France already does this. Japan already does A lot of other countries already do this. Uh we'll start doing that in this country.”
Every high-income country in the world is now spending more on defense; Japan, South Korea, and European countries are all ramping up defense budgets; global defense bottlenecks are being hit everywhere and will not be reversed for years—this signals sustained demand for defense manufacturing.
“every country in the high-income world is spending more on defense now. I mean, you know, Japan, South Korea, almost every country in Europe. I mean, everyone's ramping up now. And so, bottlenecks are being hit everywhere. I don't think I don't know about you, Adam. I don't think that's going to be reversed anytime uh you know, this year next.”
In a Fourth Turning, the regime that is being replaced always collapses slowly, then suddenly; this happened to the Republic during the 1780s which was 'one of the most horrible decades economically in American history, probably worse than the 1930s.'
“the 1780s was one of the most horrible decades economically in in American history, probably worse than uh than the 1930s...the Republic never would have survived had it not been for a new Constitution. I think it was on the verge of you know, disintegrating.”
When a Fourth Turning requires survival, government will shift spending toward the rising generation (younger people) and away from the elderly, not out of altruism but because you need to incentivize younger people to sacrifice and defend the regime—FDR did this with the GI Bill, offering housing, education, and highway construction.
“And the reason it becomes a priority is when the regime is in danger and requires everyone to help save it, right? You need to give everyone an incentive. Incentive, yeah. To be on board. Right? So, that's why you need to do it. Now, the you know, you can you can you can take you can take wealth from the wealthy, but from from the non-wealthy, you're going to need them to serve, you know, right? You're going to require sacrifices from them. And the only way you can recapture their loyalty or you know, is to is to give them a reason uh to feel that they're part of the new regime.”
The CES employment birth-death model is countercyclical—negative revisions always come right before a recession, positive revisions after—indicating recent large downward revisions in nonfarm payrolls signal recession risk, while the CPS employment metric shows zero growth over the last year.
“We always We always go into the negative revisions right before a recession. We always do positively revise coming out of the recession. In other words, the birth-death model that the CES employs is totally counter-cyclical...the CPS employment. And that has been moribund, zero growth over the last year in in you know, current population survey employment.”
Market expectations have consistently been for a 'soft landing' where inflation declines without recession, but Howe doubts this is achievable given structural economic imbalances.
“you can see how much faith the markets have in the soft landing”
Avoid long-term nominally denominated assets (long-term Treasury bonds); short-term T-bills are currently safe but will decline fast; long-term bonds will be forced to lose value to resolve the publicly held debt crisis and will see negative real returns.
“you know, avoid long-term nominally denominated assets, you know. Uh, you know, T-bill and chill is fine, you know, if you're investing in short-term treasury assets, I think at least for now, those are fairly safe. Um, and, you know, probably a good choice, you know, given the rate of return. I mean, it'll be different a month from now. Mhm. It'll be going down fast.”
The two candidates represent mutually exclusive social, cultural, and political perspectives that are so different they are 'utterly mutually exclusive,' making compromise and unity impossible.
“they're leading very different social, cultural, political perspectives. I would say so different that they are mutually utterly mutually exclusive, right?”
When a Fourth Turning climax requires regime survival, people will demand and accept centralized government control, wealth requisition from wherever it exists, and mobilization of resources—this is not a choice but a natural emergency response, as seen in WWII when government grew massively to coordinate the war effort.
“once you have an emergency uh once the survival of the regime's at stake uh either internally or externally um you're you're going to you're going to mobilize everybody and you're going to take wealth from everywhere. You know what I mean? That's that's that's kind of the law of nature at that point, right?”
Howe moved to rural America in the red zone and is optimistic because he believes adversity is necessary for societal health; nothing would be worse for America than linear continuation of current negative trends.
“I've moved to pretty rural America um out somewhere in the red zone. Um and it's interesting I uh I'll tell you why I'm optimistic, Adam, is that I think we need adversity to be strong...I think nothing could be worse for America is to have the trends we've now seen continue linearly into the indefinite future. That would truly be a nightmare scenario”
Previously in Fourth Turnings, the federal government was tiny relative to the economy (major corporations were larger than the federal government in the 1930s), so growth didn't require cutting existing programs; today, the government is massive, so any expansion for new purposes requires simultaneous contraction of existing spending.
“what I mean to say is is that uh previously in fourth turnings this the size of government in terms of its material reach was relatively small. You mean you think of how large the federal government was going into the Great Depression? It was tiny, right? It its budgets I think that they were actually a major corporations in America were much larger than what the federal government was doing. Um so when it came time to grow to some extent during the New Deal programs but obviously much more so during World War II uh you didn't have to take away anything. You just had to grow it, right? Right. And there was an open playing field, yeah.”
War gaming scenarios for Pacific conflicts (Taiwan, Spratly Islands) show the US runs out of missiles and ammunition after 8–9 days; current production capacity is nowhere near sufficient; this is a simple non-technological gap that emergency expansion of defense contractors (Northrop Grumman, Raytheon) could address.
“the war gaming scenarios you've seen for a you know, an explosion of a conflict over I don't know, the Spratly Islands or Taiwan or you know, anything in the Western Pacific or anything like that, what they what they war gaming scenarios typically show is that after about eight or nine days, America runs out of missiles. You know, we run out of we run out of ammunitions. Um and and we are nowhere near producing armaments, right?”
Millennials are making a rational bet that large mega-cap stocks (Apple, Nvidia) will be bailed out while small-cap stocks won't, and that if everyone invests together in the same basket, government will bail them all out rather than let a generation fail—whereas Gen X pursued individualistic contrarian strategies.
“Their attitude is, if I invest in some small stock that's somewhere in the you know, the Russell 2000, well, if that stock goes down, the Fed won't even care. You know, they don't even care. But if Apple goes down, if Nvidia goes down, imagine Nvidia goes down by 50%, you know, they'll Jerome Powell have an emergency meeting, right?”
The new playbook (political and civic order) is written at the end of a Fourth Turning during resolution, and then the next First Turning begins and implements that playbook, meaning substantial systemic reconstruction still remains ahead.
“the writing of the new playbook happens in the fourth turning at the end during resolution. Um and then the first turning kind of takes the football and says, 'Okay, we're going to use this playbook'”
The Awakening (late 1960s and 1970s) was a time of extraordinary tumult and violence but did not lead to regime change because the regime itself was working fairly well, so the solution was simply to relax the regime's rules rather than replace them.
“The late 1960s and then late 1970s during the awakening was a time of of of extraordinary tumult in America and disor you know, violence. But it was not it was not going to lead to a regime change, right? Because the regime actually was working pretty well. But and the the solution to the awakening was to simply relax all the rules of the regime”
Fourth Turnings always feature five big cultural shifts: toward convention and authority, toward community, toward equality, toward future focus, and away from individualism—these are not choices but inevitable cultural/social mood shifts driven by the turning itself.
“I think the culture will follow in its fourth turning path uh uh toward toward convention and authority, you know, what what you know, as I mapped out in the book, kind of these these cultural changes we always see in a fourth turning. Uh and toward community and toward equality. Those things always happen, right? Authority, convention, equality, community, uh as well as a new focus on the future.”
The Fourth Turning does not follow an exponential curve of change; violent or scary moments may hit early or late depending on history, but the consolidation, climax, and resolution always occur late—as seen in the American Revolution where violence came earlier and constitutional resolution came later.
“You know, it it varies. And uh it's the the order of change within a fourth turning doesn't admit to a lot of easy patterns. Uh and anyone who's who's read our book will know that there is a sequence of events in a fourth turning. Things have to act in a certain order, right? There is the um uh you know, there is the catalyst, there are the various uh civic regeneracies along the way. Ultimately, there's the consolidation and the climax and the resolution.”
Democracies function better in crisis than in unbroken prosperity; adversity is necessary for strength; nothing would be worse for America than current trends continuing linearly indefinitely—we need these crises to turn things around.
“I'll tell you why I'm optimistic, Adam, is that I think we need adversity to be strong. I'll just say it as simply as that. I think nothing could be worse for America is to have the trends we've now seen continue linearly into the indefinite future. That would truly be a nightmare scenario. You need these crises to turn things around. I think democracies are incredibly powerful when faced with these moments.”
Great leaders like Abraham Lincoln and Franklin Roosevelt were not obviously destined for greatness early in their careers; they grew into their roles because circumstances demanded it—so the absence of obvious great leaders today is not a cause for concern, as history will produce the right person when conditions require it.
“I've often articulated this thesis before. I don't think anyone would have said that Abraham Lincoln and Franklin Roosevelt, you know, at early in their career, anyone would have said that they were going to be great leaders. I mean, these Destined for greatness, yeah. Yeah, exactly. And and some some people you could say Teddy Roosevelt, yeah, you could have said as a young man, that guy was a dynamo. I mean, he was brilliant. He had full of energy. I mean, that guy was amazing, right? No one would have said that of Franklin Roosevelt.”
In 2013 during the Tea Party budget crisis, bipartisan plans to do a haircut on Social Security were actually being considered; today, such proposals are nowhere in sight—this shows how crisis atmosphere enables discussions of structural reform that are impossible in calm times.
“You know what's amazing, in fact, I I I commented up this at the time, even in 2013, you remember the time of the the Tea Party and the and the budget crisis and so on. We shut down government for a while and um but it was amazing. There was enough of a crisis atmosphere at that time that plans actually to do a haircut on social security were actually there. I mean, they were being considered bipartisan by the you know, and today of course, no, they're they're nowhere in sight, right?”
A one-time $6,000 baby bonus funded through deficit spending is fiscally incoherent; you're essentially telling parents their children will have to pay back the bonus plus interest—this conflation of stimulus with pro-natalist policy shows political confusion.
“if you're going to do that through deficit spending, then send a note along with the payment to the parent and said, 'Dear parent, thank your kids and treat them very well because they're going to have to pay all this back plus interest, right?'”
The four turnings are like seasons of a year: First Turning (American High—strong community), Second Turning (Awakening—attacked community, rising individualism), Third Turning (Unraveling—strong individualism, late 1980s–early 2000s), and Fourth Turning (climax and resolution—we are currently in this phase since the GFC with another decade to go).
“Four of these turnings sort of constitutes a long human life. So, we go from the first turning, second turning, third turning, fourth turning, like seasons of a year. And in our most recent uh secular season, we've moved from the American high, uh which is strong community, uh to the awakening, uh which was attacked community and and weakening community, rising individualism. Right. The me generation, yeah. Yeah, to to the unraveling, which is really the era of the late '80s, '90s, and early '00s. Uh and that's a period of of of strong individualism. And then now we've entered, since the GFC, the fourth turning, which typically climaxes late. And we still have, you know, another decade to go.”
The primary worry is not the election itself but what happens immediately after—either massive resistance movements if Kamala Harris loses or nullification movements and defiance of federal authority if Donald Trump loses—because the two candidates represent mutually exclusive worldviews.
“I'm thinking worried uh not so much about the election, but what comes after the election, right? Um we're going to have enormous uh uh collapse of uh of expectations by whoever loses, right?”
A Fourth Turning is a generation-long era in which modern societies fundamentally reorganize themselves in terms of their political and civic constitutions, infrastructure, and outer-world community life, occurring roughly once every long human lifetime (approximately 80–100 years).
“Well, it's it's the idea that modern societies um modern societies enter eras generation-long area eras in which they fundamentally reorganize themselves in terms of their constitute their political and civic constitutions, their infrastructure, this their really the structure of that of their outer world community life about once every long human lifetime.”
The bailout playbook will continue but in a constrained-resource environment will become 'top-down designation of who wins and who loses'—some sectors will get haircuts while others stay safe; this allocation will be determined by political/survival necessity, not market logic.
“It's still going to be the bailout playbook and a vast crucial than ever before, but in suddenly an environment of constrained resources, it will be top-down um uh designation of who wins and who loses, right? You see what I mean? It'll be saying, 'Okay, you guys here, you're going to get a haircut. You guys will stay safe, right?'”
Governments in Fourth Turnings fund extraordinary public mobilization through three mechanisms—roughly equally: raising taxes, selling debt, and inflation—seen in the Civil War (North), WWII, and post-WWII financial repression (Treasury-Fed Accord period).
“How do they fund this extraordinary mobilization of the public, right? Right, for for public purposes. I mean, this is this explosion of public spending and marshaling of resources for some huge public purpose. It's usually three things and it's often about equally, you know, they raise taxes, they uh sell a lot of debt, and they they use inflation. And it's uh it's all three of those, right? It was certainly all three of those for the north during the Civil War.”
Boomers invested heavily in tearing down dams and opposing physical infrastructure; they never invested in infrastructure rebuilding that the GI generation did; this means the US infrastructure is among the oldest and most crumbling in the world, setting up Fourth Turning reconstruction boom.
“Boomers never invested in that stuff. They hated it. Boomers idea of of of of civic revival was to tear down dams, you know, physically tear down stuff. Uh so, we've we've never done that. But the rebuilding and reimagining of a new public infrastructure is going to be huge and I think that's going to involve the whole you know, by real, I mean, sort of concrete side of our economy. And what what are the aspect of our of our of our society which has been most neglected, you know, since the GI generation was in its prime? It's the building of communities, right? I mean, look at the infrastructure we drive on. You know, a lot of our airports, I mean, they're oldest in the world. They're all crumbling, they're falling to pieces, you know.”
Kamala Harris is the first presidential candidate never to receive a single primary vote, but no one cares because voters know a team is behind her and trust that team; the focus is on the team, not the individual candidate—this reflects the Fourth Turning shift from individual to collective orientation.
“Kamala Harris is the first presidential candidate we've had, at least in my lifetime, that never received a single primary vote. But but no one really cares. I mean, it's like and I don't think anyone would have cared if it had been Joe Biden in a coma. Everyone knows that there's a team behind her. They trust that team. It's a reliably blue zone team, you know what I mean? That's what matters. I don't think anyone really cares too much what Kamala Harris thinks.”
This is a fear-driven election motivated by fear of the other side taking over; fear is the most powerful motivator; voter participation is at 100-year highs because people feel regime survival is at stake; third-party candidates are pushed into irrelevance ('gutter') when Armageddon is at hand.
“This is a fear-driven election. It's driven by the fear of the other side taking over. And and we've seen that before. Uh and believe me, nothing motivates like fear. I mean, I hate to I hate to say it. This is an old truism. Um but I think we're seeing it here. And that's why, by the way, we're seeing voter participation rates that are at a 100-year highs.”
Typically after a Fourth Turning, governments distribute huge streams of benefits to veterans for years, with those payments roughly reaching zero by the time the next Fourth Turning begins; the last Civil War pension ended only a few years ago because a Civil War veteran married a young woman late in life, and her pension continued after his death.
“typically earlier and and the same happened with the Civil War and typically earlier one thing you do after the fourth turning is over is you have this huge stream of benefits to all the veterans. So that's been a constant, you know. And typically those payments to the veterans are just about reaching zero by the time you start going into the next, you know, fourth turning. Uh It's interesting in fact I believe only about two or three years ago our last Civil War payment ended.”
The real economy (manufacturing, materials) will be the focus of Fourth Turning reconstruction; materials sector is the 'unsexiest' part of the S&P 500 but Fourth Turnings always rebuild infrastructure; investing in global defense and manufacturing ETFs is prudent because conflict scenarios show the US will run out of missiles in 8–9 days.
“the real side of the economy, and by real here I mean manufacturing and and and materials, right? I'd say materials is probably the unsexiest sector of the S&P 500. You know Uh and yet what do fourth turnings always feature? They always feature reconstruction of our outer world, right? Building up things.”
Howe talks about three types of crises in his book: internal (civil), external (geopolitical), and financial—the question is whether a financial reckoning will break before the others or if they will coincide; he sees higher inflation + financial repression locked in as the likely scenario.
“I guess one one question you might ask Adam and this might interest people and it's a question I ask myself is that I talk about three kinds of crises, you know, in uh whatever chapter it is. We kind of walk through them. One of them is internal, one of them is external, the other's financial, right? Um and the question I often ask is myself is will we have some sort of financial reckoning begin to break before we have one of the other two, or will they be all kind of together, right?”
The Republican Party's refusal to support the 2024 bipartisan immigration bill may have been a political calculation to let Biden/Harris sit on the problem rather than bipartisan cooperation—Trump wanted 'everything that happens to be on your watch' to damage the other party politically.
“There might have been a little bit of that in the Republicans' refusal to go along uh with a bipartisan immigration reform bill earlier this year. I think it was the same instinct. This basically was Trump saying, 'You know what? You've sat on your hands all your administration about doing anything about the border. Now you want our party to provide you with cover. No, thank you. We'll wait until after the election.'”
Lincoln tactfully refused to engage with Secretary of State William Seward's April 1861 memorandum recommending starting a war with Britain, France, or Spain to unite the country, showing Lincoln's superior judgment that such a move would be 'far too little and too late' and his mastery of managing strong subordinates without feeling threatened.
“the um uh the Secretary of State Seward uh under Lincoln, uh that was his response to the secession of the South. And this was uh this was his famous April 1st memorandum that he sent to um to Lincoln...he said, 'You know what you should do? Start a war with either Britain, France, or Spain.'”
Harris campaign is now portraying Kamala as supporting border wall rebuilding and is absorbing Republican key differentiators (not taxing tips, etc.), suggesting a strategy to chip away at Republican vote margins rather than stand on distinct platform.
“I think I think that the Republicans are saying, 'You know, this is what we always said. They did have it within their means to do this by regulatory, you know, do this by executive order. They didn't need new legislation.' Uh no, I'm I'm sure that that's the case and and I think Republicans are are even further consternated right now cuz it seems like from some uh recent uh campaign ads that the Harris campaign has put out that they are now sort of least seemingly portraying that that Kamala is for rebuilding the wall and uh you know, basically you know to to absorb some of these these Republican you know key differentiators right?”