NATO expansion
The eastward enlargement of the NATO military alliance to include former Soviet-bloc and former Soviet states, which Russia regards as a threat to its security.
As defined in John Mearsheimer
Where it comes up · 9
- Ukraine, Taiwan and The True Cause of War | John Mearsheimer6 claims
- Trump To Force Ukraine Peace on Europe - John Mearsheimer, Alexander Mercouris & Glenn Diesen6 claims
- How Democracies Fail: A Conversation with Anne Applebaum (Episode #376)2 claims
- Dave Smith2 claims
- John Mearsheimer2 claims
- The Legacy of Stalin's Leadership During World War II and Its Relevance to Today's War in Ukraine2 claims
- 2024 Predictions and Global Power Dynamics with George Friedman1 claim
- How should Europe react to a future without US protection – and with an emboldened Russia? | DW News1 claim
and 1 more
Most important claims · 10 of 23Search all claims for “NATO expansion” →
- NATO Secretary General Stoltenberg admitted Putin sent a draft treaty in late 2021 demanding a written guarantee Ukraine would not join NATO, and NATO refused on principle—meaning, by their own admission, a written pledge not to admit Ukraine could have saved hundreds of thousands of lives, a far better deal than Ukraine will ultimately get.Dave Smith
- NATO expansion into Eastern Europe after the Cold War was rational US policy (preventing Russian dominance in Europe and maintaining Atlantic control), but it violated Russian strategic imperatives (preventing NATO on its border), creating an irreconcilable conflict where both sides were rationally pursuing incompatible objectives based on different geographic and historical constraints.Navigating the Twin Crises of the 2020s | George Friedman
- George Kennan, founder of containment, predicted in 1998 that NATO expansion advocates would keep advocating it until there was a Russian reaction, and then cite that reaction as proof they were right to expand—getting the causality exactly backwards.Dave Smith
- The roles have been reversed: in the mid-1990s, the US suggested moving to NATO expansion rather than indivisible security, creating a hegemonic system where Russia's weakness meant it didn't matter what Russia cared about.Trump To Force Ukraine Peace on Europe - John Mearsheimer, Alexander Mercouris & Glenn Diesen
- Europeans would have been much wiser in the past to have stood up to the United States, and if Angela Merkel and Sarkozy had really resisted NATO expansion into Ukraine in 2008, we would not be talking about US withdrawal from Europe at this juncture.Trump To Force Ukraine Peace on Europe - John Mearsheimer, Alexander Mercouris & Glenn Diesen
- Russia attacked Ukraine because NATO expansion into Ukraine placed a hostile force 300 miles from Moscow, which violates Russia's historical survival strategy of maintaining strategic depth; from Russia's perspective, the attack was a forced defensive necessity, not an act of aggression.2024 Predictions and Global Power Dynamics with George Friedman
- Putin's public position is that Ukraine does not exist as a separate nation but is a fake country, which means the NATO expansion argument is irrelevant to Russian justification for the war; destroying Ukrainian civilians, infrastructure, and cultural artifacts to prove Ukraine does not exist as a separate nation is irrational.The Legacy of Stalin's Leadership During World War II and Its Relevance to Today's War in Ukraine
- Russia's invasion of Ukraine was rational in the sense that it was a logical response to NATO expansion, even if it is not approved of morally or as a policy preference.Ukraine, Taiwan and The True Cause of War | John Mearsheimer
- Trump's relations with Russia worsened during his presidency despite his intention to improve them; by the time Trump left office, U.S.-Russia relations were worse than when Obama left office.Ukraine, Taiwan and The True Cause of War | John Mearsheimer
- The first major tranche of NATO expansion was 1999 when Poland, Hungary, and Czech Republic were brought in; the Russians could live with this.Trump To Force Ukraine Peace on Europe - John Mearsheimer, Alexander Mercouris & Glenn Diesen