What this covers
Lex Fridman and Dave Smith conduct a wide-ranging conversation on U.S. foreign policy, war, accountability, and moral consistency. Smith argues that American military interventions, sustained by institutional incentives within defense and intelligence sectors, systematically produce the opposite of their stated aims. The discussion moves across decades of case studies—from drone strikes and the wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, through the Russia-Ukraine conflict, to the Israel-Palestine crisis—with Smith contending that insurgent math explains why bombing campaigns that kill mostly civilians tend to enlarge rather than shrink militant groups, and that a single moral standard must apply to all nations, whether killing civilians is done by Hamas, the Israeli military, or American forces.
Smith's treatment of these subjects hinges on several distinct claims. He examines how certainty masquerades as leadership while doubt reads as weakness, allowing confident but careless thinkers to dominate policy. He draws historical parallels to argue that peace is achievable even between longtime enemies—citing France-Germany, Ireland-England, and Egypt-Israel—and that it requires diplomacy over force. He applies Just War Theory to distinguish legitimate defense from aggressive wars, while denying that even justified wars erase the moral evil of killing innocents. On the Israel-Palestine conflict specifically, he addresses territorial control, NATO expansion and George Kennan's predictions about its consequences, Netanyahu's role in funding Hamas, and the problem of crying wolf with accusations of antisemitism. Throughout, Smith opposes confirmation bias in reasoning about conspiracies and argues that long-form unedited speech—the format of the podcast itself—makes sustained dishonesty nearly impossible.
Smith argues that U.S. foreign policy, driven by a self-perpetuating military-industrial complex, repeatedly produces counterproductive wars whose architects face no accountability, and that consistent moral standards plus diplomacy—not force—are the only durable path to peace.
- Bombing campaigns create more enemies than they kill (insurgent math), so military intervention often produces the threat it claims to fight
- A single moral standard must apply to all actors: intentionally killing civilians is murder regardless of which government does it
- No one is ever held accountable for catastrophic foreign-policy failures, which has destroyed trust in institutions
Killing civilians in military operations constitutes murder and remains evil even when legally justified by war doctrine.
- Targeting innocent civilians is always evil because people cannot be held responsible for the crimes of their government; this was the fanatic's logic of Osama bin Laden who said US civilians were fair game for voting, and it is equally wrong when applied to Gazans who voted Hamas a plurality in 2005.
“I don’t believe civilians can be held responsible for the crimes of their government.”
- If you blow up a building knowing women and children are inside and they die, that is murder in the first degree regardless of stated intent, because in domestic law knowing innocents will die and acting anyway constitutes intent—so 'we were only trying to kill Hamas' does not change the nature of the crime, only marginal sentencing.
“if you know there are kids there and you know they’re going to die, then that’s intent.”
- Because Israel denied Palestinians the right to a government and military, the conflict is not a state-vs-state war but resembles a domestic situation; thus an occupier of land since 1967 takes on an obligation to conduct operations more like a police matter than total war, since we would never accept 'blow up the school' as a response to a school shooter using human shields.
“if you’ve occupied the place since 1967, you almost now take on an obligation that you kind of have to almost conduct this as a police matter.”
- Just wars exist—defending against invasion, like Ukraine's right to fight Russia or the American Revolution—but in pure libertarian theory you never have a right to kill innocent people; an extreme extenuating scenario might mitigate culpability (like saving 20 by killing 1), yet the act remains evil even when justified.
“by perfect theory, no, you never have the right to kill innocent people. There could be a scenario where you were like, “Look, we had to take this military action and some innocent people did die”
- The Houthis survived eight years of a US-backed Saudi invasion, did nothing during the ceasefire, and only resumed attacking ships once the ceasefire broke down—demonstrating that some conflicts have diplomatic rather than military solutions, since a few Tomahawk missiles won't stop people who endured total war.
“They didn’t do anything during the ceasefire. It was only once the ceasefire broke down that they went back to attacking ships”
- Trump's proposed Ukraine mineral deal was principally bullying Ukraine out of resources it may not even have, and functioned as a disguised security guarantee—because a business partnership implies the US would defend Ukraine—which is exactly the entangling alliance George Washington warned against.
“I think it is like bullying Ukraine out of resources... if he was selling it to Zelenskyy, that’s a security guarantee.”
Targeted killings and military force breed recruitment into militant groups, making military responses counterproductive and self-defeating.
- General McChrystal's 'insurgent math'—that 10 minus 2 equals 20—captures how targeted drone bombings that kill mostly innocents (96%) cause groups like Al-Qaeda in the Arabian Peninsula to grow, because every killed civilian has brothers, uncles, and fathers who join the fight.
“He’s the one who coined the term insurgent math, that 10 minus two equals 20.”
- You are fighting in a way that produces more of the thing you are fighting, so the cure is making the patient sicker; the first step toward healing is to stop doing that.
“You are fighting in a way that produces more of the thing that you’re fighting, and so the first step is to stop doing that. Your cure is making the patient more sick.”
- Calling Hamas a death cult rings hollow when the side you support has killed roughly 20 times more people; Israel has killed far more Palestinians than Palestinians have killed Israelis, and there is something falsely 'cleaner' about killing done by a government with sophisticated weaponry as collateral damage, though the innocent dead are equally dead.
“the amount killed by the Israelis on the Palestinian side, versus the amount killed by the Palestinians is 20 to 1 in Israel’s killing more people”
- Even if the official WWII narrative is fully true, its lesson 'appeasement is the failure, war the solution' is weaponized to imply appeasement is always wrong and aggression always good, justifying total war against civilians—when in fact none of the modern enemies labeled 'Hitler' (Trump, Hamas, Putin) come anywhere close in destructive power.
“It still doesn’t follow from that, that therefore in every situation appeasement is wrong, and aggression is good.”
- At the time the US allied with Stalin, he was already a genocidal maniac who had done many of his worst deeds while Hitler had not yet gone genocidal, making the alliance a morally weird decision that only looks better in hindsight given what Hitler later became.
“at that time Stalin was already a genocidal maniac, and Hitler had not gone genocidal yet. So there is a weird dynamic there.”
- World War II and the Civil Rights Movement are the third rails of American politics, where holding any view not officially approved gets you in serious trouble, even though the era can be studied dispassionately as a fascinating exploration of human nature and military strategy.
“World War II and the Civil Rights Movement, I think are the third rails of American politics, if you have any type of view that is not the approved authorized view of how these events went, you’re in a lot of trouble.”
U.S. foreign policy and media serve military-industrial complex profit rather than genuine national security interests.
- Epstein's career is unexplainable outside intelligence connections—going from an unqualified Dalton teacher to a Bear Stearns partner worth hundreds of millions within two years with no traceable source of wealth, then inserted among the highest political and cultural figures—and Acosta's statement that Epstein was 'intelligence' is the key evidence.
“the way his career trajectory tracks is completely unexplainable outside of being connected to intelligence.”
- The argument that dictators can't be allowed nuclear weapons because they might use them ignores that the United States is the only country that has ever actually used them, a fact that should be pointed out rather than dismissed as naive.
““You can’t allow dictators to have nuclear weapons because they might use them.” And I was like, “But we are the only ones who ever used them.””
- All the people who sold the war in Iraq lied us into war after war, bankrupted the country and nearly destroyed the dollar, yet no one lost their job or faced any repercussions—and any business or relationship that failed that catastrophically without consequences would collapse.
“All the people who sold the war in Iraq, they lied us into war after a war. They’ve bankrupted the country, damn near destroyed the dollar and no one loses their job.”
- The military-industrial complex—intelligence agencies, weapons manufacturers, and a parroting media—doesn't just profit from conflict but possesses an apparatus to create the conflict and manufacture the public sentiment for it, as shown by how the Gulf War desire for war was engineered top-down rather than emerging organically from Americans.
“it’s not just that you can make money when there’s a conflict, but you have this entire apparatus to create the conflict and then create the public sentiment for that.”
- If chip dependence on Taiwan's TSMC is the real concern, the response should be a Manhattan Project-style effort to manufacture chips domestically rather than risk war, because Taiwan is not magical and these things can be produced in other places.
“Taiwan is not magical. We can produce these things in other places now.”
Israel's control of Gaza and West Bank since 1967 constitutes occupation, and Netanyahu sustained Hamas to block Palestinian statehood.
- A full blockade of Gaza since 2007 that bars even potatoes and sugar on 'dual use' grounds while allowing cash to Hamas is incoherent; like kidnapping someone and locking them in your basement, once you take total control you take on the responsibility to feed them, and the solution was to let reputable international aid organizations in rather than turn them away.
“much in the same way that if you kidnap someone and you lock them in your basement and you don’t feed them, you murdered that person... once you do, you take on a responsibility to feed those people.”
- When you've controlled an area since 1967 you can no longer call it an occupation but an annexation, because Israel—not Hamas—is the sovereign and final decision maker over the biggest questions in Gaza, which undermines Israel's claim to be a democracy when millions cannot vote over who rules them.
“when you’ve occupied an area since 1967, you can’t even really call it an occupation anymore, it’s an annexation. You took these lands. You have control of it.”
- Netanyahu, in his own words, sent the Mossad to ensure Qatari cash kept flowing to Hamas in order to 'prop up' and 'bolster' Hamas, keeping the West Bank and Gaza divided so the international community and liberal Israeli Jews couldn't pressure him into a deal.
“the reason for doing this was to keep, his words were, “Prop up Hamas, bolster Hamas,” to keep them in power so that the West Bank and the Gazans were divided”
- The Arab nation-states (Saudi Arabia, UAE, Jordan, Egypt) are essentially ready to normalize relations with Israel and Saudi Arabia would eagerly broker a two-state solution, but their populations are completely opposed to Israel's conduct, so they need Israel to stop harming Palestinians lest their own people rise up against them.
“If the Israelis were like, “Fine, we’ll do a two-state solution,”... I think Saudi Arabia couldn’t wait to broker... they proposed a two-state solution just a few years ago.”
Peace between historic enemies succeeds when occupiers stop oppression, as France-Germany and Egypt-Israel examples demonstrate.
- Indoctrination does not permanently fix minds against peace; just as Soviet and Chinese populations retained suppressed desires for liberty, in Gaza support for Hamas plummeted during peace talks and rose again when talks collapsed or aggressive military campaigns occurred.
“when the peace talks were going on, support for Hamas plummeted, when the peace talks fell apart, support for Hamas went way back up. Every time there’s an aggressive military campaign, support for Hamas goes back up.”
- Peace between historic enemies is achievable: France-Germany and Ireland-England now live in harmony, and Egypt and Israel fought four wars in decades but made a land-for-peace deal in the late 1970s and haven't gone to war since—so an Israel-Palestine solution exists but requires Israel taking its boot off the Palestinians' neck.
“Egypt and Israel went to war four times in a couple of decades... and then in the late ’70s, they made a land for peace deal, and they haven’t been to war since.”
- If you make everyone monsters and not human beings, you cannot do diplomacy or negotiate with them; treating enemies as humans, even when negotiation may not always be possible, is preferable and we could use far more of that thinking.
“If you make everybody monsters and they’re not human beings, well, you can’t do diplomacy with monsters, you can’t negotiate with monsters, but you can with humans.”
NATO expansion toward Russia provoked conflict; written pledges avoiding Ukraine admission could have prevented catastrophic war.
- NATO Secretary General Stoltenberg admitted Putin sent a draft treaty in late 2021 demanding a written guarantee Ukraine would not join NATO, and NATO refused on principle—meaning, by their own admission, a written pledge not to admit Ukraine could have saved hundreds of thousands of lives, a far better deal than Ukraine will ultimately get.
“in late 2021 that Vladimir Putin actually sent a draft agreement to NATO... “You have to put in writing that Ukraine will not join NATO.””
- George Kennan, founder of containment, predicted in 1998 that NATO expansion advocates would keep advocating it until there was a Russian reaction, and then cite that reaction as proof they were right to expand—getting the causality exactly backwards.
“The people advocating that we expand NATO are going to continue advocating it... And then there will be a Russian reaction. And then they’ll say, ‘See? That’s why we were right to expand NATO.’ But they’ll get this completely wrong.”
- No great power in history would tolerate a rival overthrowing its neighbor's government and bringing that neighbor into a hostile military alliance—just as the US wouldn't allow Russia or China to install a government in Mexico, or as the Soviets couldn't put nukes in Cuba—and this would hold true back to Jefferson, not just for neocons.
“if China or Russia ever backed a street putsch to overthrow the democratically-elected government in Mexico... DC would simply not allow that.”
- Saying the West provoked the conflict is entirely different from saying the invasion was justified—just as a man who murders someone for spitting in his face is not justified though we'd still explain his act by the spit; Putin pulled the trigger and is fully responsible, yet the provocation explains why the war happened.
“if you say that the West provoked this conflict, that is a very different thing than saying that this invasion was justified.”
- Both Russia and Ukraine were catastrophically traumatized in the 20th century—mass starvation, invasion, the Russian government collapsing twice in 100 years—a societal trauma Americans cannot relate to, which shapes how they experience a war on their border in ways outsiders can't fully grasp.
“The Russian government collapsed twice in 100 years. That’s traumatic. We just simply have never been through anything like that.”
Extreme rhetoric and outrage culture from both sides undermine legitimate discourse and genuine peace prospects.
- Ron Paul was the only congressman of Smith's lifetime whom lobbyists simply stopped visiting because they concluded there was no getting through to him—a sign of unusual integrity and refusal to play politics.
“He was the only congressman of my lifetime who the lobbyists simply stopped visiting.”
- The one China policy has been the official policy of the United States for 50 years, so conflict arises when American politicians assert China has no right to enter Taiwan, contradicting the recognized policy—and declaring Taiwan independent could itself provoke a Chinese invasion.
“the one China policy is the policy of the United States of America and has been for 50 years now.”
- In the Israel-Palestine conflict, the loons on both sides effectively work for the other side: Jew-hating posters smear all Israel critics as antisemites and Palestinian protesters chanting 'Death to America' make people more sympathetic to Israel, each producing the caricature their opponents need.
“there’s so many of the loons on both sides who almost seem like they’re secretly working for the other side.”
- Ron Paul's central thesis is that the highest political value ought to be liberty, and because government by its very nature is an instrument of force and tyranny, the more government you have the less liberty you have.
“the highest political value ought to be liberty. And that the government, by its very nature, is an instrument of force and tyranny. And therefore, the more government you have, the less liberty you have.”
- Everyone asks about Epstein's flight logs and files, but the real question is where are the tapes, since he was clearly taping people to blackmail them; and nothing about a pedophile ring should require redaction for national security.
“Where are the tapes? This guy was clearly taping people to blackmail them. Why does anything need to be redacted for national security?”
- Outrage culture makes it impossible to tell who genuinely hates Jews from who is trolling for a reaction, and labeling legitimate questions or points as antisemitic makes the word meaningless and removes the disincentive for real Jew-haters.
“now you just have no way of knowing who’s saying this just to get a rise out of you, or who really sincerely means it”
- The healthy way to handle online hate is to recognize it as the price of having a great family, career, and audience you love, and to refuse to let the reaction of distant strangers govern your thinking—even though humans are hardwired to treat mass hostility as a mortal threat we never evolved to process.
“if I get all that and then the price that comes along with it is there’s some people who talk shit online, it’s like, that’s a very good price to pay for all of this.”
- Young white men who came of age under intense progressive identity politics, in which faculty, politicians, and Hollywood embraced racialism, were predictably going to start playing the same racial-grievance game themselves, which is one reason the woke racialism was dangerous and wrong.
“you think you’re going to play this and that young straight white men aren’t going to start playing this game too? Why the hell would they not?”
America cannot win conventional war against China over Taiwan and must abandon imperial mentality framing geopolitics as U.S. permission.
- In nearly all war games run, even if nuclear weapons are not used, the US loses a conventional war against China over Taiwan every time, and Americans should shed the empire mentality that frames it as a question of whether they will 'allow' a Chinese invasion.
“in almost all the war games that they’ve run, even if it doesn’t come to nuclear weapons being used... we just fight a conventional war, we lose that war every time.”
- Trump has put a lot of political capital into the claim that he can end the Ukraine war and will look very bad if he can't, so he is highly incentivized to get it done as quickly as possible, likely seeking a big spectacle that sells him best.
“Donald Trump has put a lot of political capital chips into the middle of the table that, “I can end this war.”, and he’s going to look very, very bad if he can’t.”
Long-form unguarded speech reveals authenticity and obsoletes traditional media gatekeeping by forcing political honesty.
- People are so sick of phoniness that authenticity gives a huge political advantage—you can only lie so much before nobody wants the phony voice and phony lies anymore—which is why figures like Jon Stewart, who appear to genuinely believe what they say even when wrong, hold power.
“People are so sick of the phoniness... You can only lie so much before eventually nobody wants to hear you in that phony voice telling the same phony lies anymore.”
- The shift from 90-minute debates with stupid questions and 90-second answers to a new standard requiring candidates to do long-form interviews where their ideas are poked and tested is a positive development, because it forces parties to run people who can genuinely express themselves rather than guarded figures like Kamala Harris.
“the standard is kind of you’re going to have to do a long-form show where you really have to have... And that I think is long term a real positive development.”
- As corporate media shrinks and internet shows hold the audience, world leaders do long-form podcasts to do an end-around censorship—Putin to bypass an American media blackout of his perspective, Netanyahu because Israel is badly losing the internet battle—since reaching 10 million voters beats reaching 1 million on CNN.
“the corporate media is just shrinking and shrinking and shrinking and... these shows on the internet have the audience.”
- Smith feels obligated to do several debates a year because going on big long-form shows to assert his views creates a duty to test them against someone arguing the opposite, and the career risk of being publicly destroyed motivates rigorous preparation.
“I kind of have an obligation to test myself against someone being like, “No, it’s not like that,” and then showing that I think I can stand up to these kind of challenges.”
- Consuming 40 to 50 hours of someone speaking in an unguarded long-form format creates a genuine one-way relationship where you see into their soul, which is why podcasts can't sustain lying to an audience and why guarded politicians like Kamala Harris reveal their guardedness—the reason she was probably right to avoid Rogan.
“When you consume somebody like that for 40, 50 hours, you do see into their soul. I think there’s almost no way to avoid that.”
Sound reasoning requires radical skepticism toward confirming evidence, historical precedent for change, and progress over nostalgia.
- Modern medical innovation is producing everyday miracles—Smith's son survived open-heart surgery for a congenital defect at three days old that would have killed him 20 years ago—which inoculates against any nostalgia for an earlier era, because in a previous time the child would have died.
“my son had a congenital heart defect at open-heart surgery when he was three days old... it’s something that 20 years ago I would’ve lost my child. And he’s fine.”
- Life having a finite expiration date makes it more precious, and at the societal level death is how new ideas emerge, because people solidify their ideas and become unwilling to change their minds so the next generation must take over—making radical life extension philosophically questionable.
“life itself having a finite amount of time on it I think makes it more precious.”
- Gene Epstein's case for radical optimism: in 1845 predicting slavery's abolition within 20 years, or in 1981 predicting the Soviet Union's collapse within 10 years, would have seemed insane, yet both happened—massive entrenched evils that seemed permanent were swept away, which is grounds for hope about today's seemingly intractable problems.
“imagine you were sitting around in 1845... ‘Hey, in 20 years slavery is going to be abolished across the West.’... And yet we were”
- The flaw in conspiracy thinking is speaking with certainty about uncertain things and presuming a conclusion then working backward, like 9/11 truthers treating the PNAC 'new Pearl Harbor' line as proof of an inside job when it doesn't actually prove anything—the discipline is to be ten times more skeptical of evidence that confirms what you want to be true.
“you got to be really careful about presuming your conclusion and then working backward from there.”
- Anyone who genuinely cares about trust in institutions should be even louder than Smith in demanding the full truth about Epstein, because a covered-up pedophile blackmail ring associated with national security is precisely what destroys institutional trust if concealed.
“if you did care about trust in institutions, then you should be even louder than me talking about you got to tell the truth on this story otherwise we’ll never have trust in these institutions.”
- In 2016 Trump resonated with voters while the Republican establishment hated it and openly conspired to deny him the nomination by raising the delegate threshold so high no one could hit it and re-nominate Mitt Romney; the equivalent disruption of the Democrats would require someone outside three-letter-agency control running a genuinely pro-labor working-class platform.
“They were openly talking about changing the rules at the Republican National Convention to deny him the nomination in 2016.”
- Ron Paul's 2008 and 2012 presidential campaigns laid the groundwork—not directly leading to Trump—for a Republican shift where Trump could tell Jeb Bush 'your brother lied us into war' and have Republicans who twice voted for George W. Bush agree.
“he laid the groundwork for Donald Trump to be able to get up at the South Carolina Republican primary debate and look at Jeb Bush and say, “Your brother lied us into war.””