What this covers

This is a conversation between Sam Harris and Anne Applebaum, the historian and journalist whose latest book, Autocracy Inc, is the occasion. It begins with the claim that Americans have lived so long in stable democracy that they, like fish in water, cannot see how fast it can fail. From there it works outward: how modern autocracies cooperate, why they treat liberal democracy as a threat, and how the West helped build them. Applebaum describes the 1990s engagement strategy, in which trade and investment were supposed to liberalize Russia and China. She cites Bill Clinton's remark that controlling the internet would be like nailing Jell-O to the wall, while China was already building its firewall.

The middle stretch covers kleptocracy and Ukraine. Applebaum traces Vladimir Putin's rise through theft in St. Petersburg, laundered abroad with the help of Western bankers and accountants. She argues that oligarch fortunes came from stripping state assets, and that anonymous shell companies, such as those behind empty Mayfair houses, serve little purpose beyond hiding money. Her remedy is for the West to clean up its own financial systems. On Ukraine she makes several contested arguments. She says the invasion was driven partly by the ideological threat of the Maidan revolution, that early peace was never really on offer, and that a Russian win would unravel the rules-based order.

The final third turns to the United States. Applebaum casts Donald Trump as a transactional figure who admires Xi Jinping and Putin, and describes failure as slow institutional hollowing rather than a coup. She points to planners such as Kevin Roberts of the Heritage Foundation, who would replace agency expertise with loyalists. The two also discuss Elon Musk's donations and the Vance pick, Republican fear of MAGA violence, the weakness of the Democrats, Vichy France as an analogy, and the effects of the assassination attempt. Harris brings in Orwell's reaction to Adolf Hitler to explain Trump's appeal.

Sharpest takeaway

Applebaum argues that modern autocracies form a networked alliance united by shared interests in protecting kleptocratic wealth and undermining liberal democracy globally, and that Trump represents a dangerous embodiment of these autocratic principles within American politics, threatening democratic institutions through gradual institutional decay rather than overt authoritarian takeover.

  • Modern dictatorships (Russia, China, Iran, etc.) operate as a network sharing common interests in money and power, not ideology, and actively work to undermine liberal democracy worldwide as a threat to their rule
  • Trump's transactional self-interest and disregard for democratic norms parallel autocratic leaders, and his presence enables systematic institutional hollowing through partisan capture of regulatory and justice systems
  • Democratic decline follows patterns of kleptocracy preceding autocracy—when leaders use state power for personal enrichment, they must eventually suppress dissent and independent institutions to protect their ill-gotten gains

The claims · ranked42 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.74

Americans have been unaware of how fully democracies can fail and how fast because they've lived in a time when democracy was stable—they're 'fish swimming in water' who don't notice the water because it's been tepid for their entire lifespan.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“we're fish swimming in water, you know, and the water has always been fairly tepid at least in in this span of of anyone's normal lifespan and so we're not really alert to just how fully things can change”

0.74

Elon Musk and David Sacks were primary backers of the J.D. Vance vice presidential candidacy, and nearly simultaneously with Vance's nomination announcement, Musk committed to giving $45 million per month to the Trump campaign, making him one of the biggest campaign donors.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“Musk and were among the primary backers of the Vance candidacy. They were very keen for J.D. Vance to be the vice president almost simultaneously with the announcement of the Vance candidacy. Musk also announced that he would be giving $45 million a dollars a month to the Trump campaign which makes him one of the biggest donors to the campaign.”

0.72

If Putin successfully demonstrates that large countries can invade smaller neighbors without consequences, the entire rules-based international order collapses: countries would no longer respect agreements about trade, property, or investment, would no longer feel obliged to honor alliance commitments, and the Western economic system that benefits American companies and influence would cease to function.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“If he can prove that you pay no price for invading your neighbors, then why shouldn't China invade Taiwan and take over the international semiconductor market, you know, or why shouldn't Venezuela invade Guyana? Why really should any should any state, you know, hold back from using military force to do whatever it wants? And really, why should any state respect American property around the world or American investments? And if that's true, then why should you know, why should Europe, why should our our former allies go along with the trade deals and organizations that we've created according to rules that benefit us?”

0.72

George Orwell in his 1940 review of Mein Kampf noted that Hitler had something 'deeply appealing' about him—he seemed like 'the martyr, the victim, Prometheus chained to the rock'—and Orwell could not dislike him despite recognizing he would kill him if he could get within reach, a phenomenon that Harris sees paralleled in Trump's appeal despite his obvious unfitness.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Sam Harris

“Orwell...wrote this in 1940...I should like to put it on record that I have never been able to dislike Hitler...The fact is there is something deeply appealing about him...He is the martyr the victim Prometheus chained to the rock the self-sacrificing hero who fights single-handed against impossible odds”

0.69

The 1990s engagement strategy with Russia and China—the belief that business and economic integration would lead to political liberalization and the spread of democratic ideas—was based on optimism about the power of Western ideas and technology that blinded policymakers to the possibility that dictators would use Western systems to enrich themselves rather than liberalize.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“there was an idea at that time, this is the 1990s, that business with autocratic states not only is it politically acceptable, but it might even be good because engagement with with the with the former totalitarian or former you know you know the former Soviet world or in China the former Chinese Communist world was a way of ensuring that they were integrated into the world economy, maybe it would help open them up, maybe it would spread ideas, maybe our ideas would spread to them.”

0.69

Putin came to power partly through stealing: as deputy mayor of St. Petersburg, he stole from the city, sent the money abroad to be laundered, then brought it back to acquire property, buildings, and companies—all with the full knowledge and assistance of Western bankers, accountants, the Frankfurt Stock Exchange, and sometimes Western governments.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“he began as the deputy mayor of St. Petersburg. Some people might remember that. In in that era, he began stealing. And he originally stole from the city. He He Again, I details are in the book. Took the money out of the country, sent it abroad where it was laundered. It was then slowly brought back into the country where it was used to acquire things, property, buildings, companies...it was a whole group of people, his his colleagues. And they did this with the absolutely full knowledge and assistance of Western bankers, Western account accountants, the Frankfurt Stock Exchange, in some cases Western governments.”

0.69

Kevin Roberts, head of the Heritage Foundation, has stated that a 'revolution' is coming that will be 'bloodless as long as the left allows it to be'—a sinister statement indicating threats of violence if leftist resistance occurs, representing ideological planning for systemic change.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“We have Kevin Roberts who's the head of the Heritage Foundation talking about a revolution coming and it will be bloodless as long as the left allows it to be. Whatever which is a very sinister thing to say.”

0.69

Similar corruption and wealth extraction patterns to Russia occur in Africa, Asia, and Latin America, and can be described across many countries; corruption has taken on new forms where large sums are moved out of countries and laundered through international financial systems rather than the traditional form of local bribery.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“I'm picking on the Russians, but actually you could make it you could you could describe that of other places. There there are there leaders in Africa, in Asia, in Latin America who have become rich in the same way or in similar ways. And the international financial system enabled this new form of corruption.”

0.69

Lenin criticized bourgeois democracy as fake and not real because it doesn't bring power to workers or involves false consciousness—this rhetorical strategy of delegitimizing democratic forms is ancient and still used by modern autocrats and far-right movements.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“A Lenin used to talk about bourgeois democracy and he spent a lot of time talking about how it's fake, you know, it it's not real. It's not real democracy. It doesn't bring power to the workers. It's it's based on false consciousness or the or the the political parties aren't real parties...you can hear it coming from coming from modern Russia or you can hear it even sometimes coming from our own far right.”

0.68

Putin invaded Ukraine not only for imperial expansion but specifically because Ukraine represented an ideological threat: Ukraine had successfully conducted the Maidan Revolution in 2014, evicted a corrupt president, and installed democratically elected leaders with more transparent institutions, showing Russians that democratic alternatives were possible for countries similar to Russia.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“the other reason was that the Ukrainians had made a choice a decade earlier in 2014 to evict their corrupt president, who was undermining their political system and changing their institutions, and to replace him with democratically elected presidents and with a more free and open system. And they they had demonstrations where they waved posters calling for an end to corruption and more transparency and the rule of law. And Putin saw that and he thought, "If Ukraine succeeds, if Ukraine becomes a successful democracy, then why wouldn't someone try it in Russia? Countries are very similar. They have lots of lots of intermarriage. Lots of Russians know Ukraine, have been to Ukraine. If Ukrainians could become a successful modern European democracy, then surely someone would want Russia to be the same."”

0.68

Trump's constant stream of lies—including demonstrably false claims like 'Democrats want to abort babies in the 8th and 9th month' and 'Democrats want to kill babies'—creates an epistemological bankruptcy where people screen out lies entirely rather than trying to evaluate them, leading to cynicism, apathy, and political disengagement.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“During the horrible debate with Joe Biden, one thing caught my attention. At one point during the debate, Trump said, "Democrats want to abort babies in the 8th month and the 9th month. You know, they want to abort babies after they're born. Democrats want to kill babies." And I was like, "Wait, you know, that's insane." I mean it but the the repetitive lies are now we we're all adjusting, you know, we kind of screen them out...one of the effects that they have is they mean that we screen everything out”

0.68

The proper solution to combating modern autocratic kleptocracies is to 'clean up our own act' by abolishing the systems that enable wealth hiding—anonymous companies, shell corporations, and tax havens—which serve no legitimate business purpose and primarily exist to hide stolen money.

normativehigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“one of my conclusions is that one of the ways to fight these new regimes is to clean up our own act. I mean why do there need to be any anonymous companies for any reason? I mean I know there are some business arguments, but they're pretty weak when you when you look at them. You know, why why is it legal to hide your money, hide billions and billions of dollars in tax havens? That's done by people who need to do so either because they're hiding from the tax authorities or because the money's stolen.”

0.68

Putin invaded Ukraine with extreme cruelty (occupation, concentration camps, kidnapping children, changing identities) partly as a signal to the world that he does not recognize international rules and will intervene wherever and however he wants, challenging whether the West would stop him.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“He invaded Ukraine in the manner that he did, which meant occupying territory, setting up concentration camps, kidnapping children, changing their identities, using really a level of cruelty nobody has seen in Europe since the Second World War. What he he did that partly to say, 'I don't care about your rules. I don't care about how you think the world should be run. I don't care about the UN Charter, which says that large countries shouldn't invade small countries. I'm going to intervene wherever and however I want, and I'm going to start here. I'm going to do it here, and I'm going to see whether you are going to stop me.'”

0.66

Russian oligarchs became spectacularly wealthy not by inventing better products or working hard, but by stealing assets from the state—assets that nominally belonged to all ordinary Russians, meaning the Russian public was effectively robbed of state property to create billionaires.

causalhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“They became wealthy because they stole assets from the state. You know, or they acquired them very cheaply in some corrupt way. And in effect they were stealing from ordinary Russians because who owned the state assets? I mean everybody owned them. I mean there there's there of course are forms of privatization that are legitimate...But that's not what happened in Russia. What happened in Russia was that in effect the assets were stolen, ordinary people didn't benefit, the state was impoverished and instead a few people became billionaires or multi-billionaires.”

0.65

The instinctive human reaction to dictatorship—even among people who have never lived in democracy, never experienced it, never read John Locke or the US Constitution—is to demand rights, because this is a natural human inclination not dependent on prior exposure to democratic ideas.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“the trouble that they have is that the instinctive reaction to dictatorship, even among people who've never lived in a democracy or never experienced it or never read John Locke or or the US Constitution, the instinctive reaction to people who don't have rights is to demand rights. You know, the instinctive reaction You know, in China, at the very end of the COVID lockdown, you had these spontaneous demonstrations led by very young people who were much too young to remember Tiananmen Square, you know, the democracy movements of the past, who probably had very little contact with the Western world. And yet the language they leaped to almost immediately was the language about free speech.”

0.65

Modern democracies fail not through Nazi-style coups with storm troopers and goose-stepping, but through slow decline: hollowing out of institutions, sham elections where candidates are pre-picked, politicized court systems where judges are partisan, corrupted media owned by oligarchs, and weak opposition alternatives—this is how Hungary, Turkey, Russia, and Venezuela declined.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“nowadays when democracies fall when they begin to fail and this this is true of Russia but it's true of Hungary as well it's true of Venezuela just to take an example from the left from the left they don't fall in the way that we think of Nazi Germany. So there aren't storm troopers on the street and there aren't men goose stepping across the square...That's not how they fall. They fall through slow decline through the hollowing out of institutions through you know elections that aren't really elections because all the candidates are picked in advance or through thanks to court systems that aren't really court systems because the judges are so partisan, everybody knows what they're going to decide. Or through media that's not really media anymore because it's part of some kind of big oligarchic game”

0.64

Many Republicans, including mainstream figures like Mitt Romney and Liz Cheney, were afraid to vote to impeach Trump because they feared violence from MAGA supporters against themselves and their families, and this fear extends down through lower-level election officials who are now targets of MAGA harassment despite doing ordinary, non-political jobs like certifying elections.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Sam Harris

“we know from people like Mitt Romney and Liz Cheney that there were members of Congress who would have voted to impeach him, but they were afraid for their lives and the lives of their families...And it affects people at a much lower level, too. I did an interview a few days ago with Stephen Richer who's Maricopa County election official who was one of the people who certified the election in Arizona after Trump lost in 2020. And he had threats to his life. He had, you know, harassment from people. He had, you know, people coming to his house.”

0.62

Trump resembles modern autocrats described in Applebaum's book because his primary interest is not the well-being of citizens or America's success or values, but himself—he is interested in staying in power and getting rich, and he admires Xi Jinping and Putin because he recognizes them as soulmates who think about power and money the same way he does.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“Trump isn't interested in them. He's not acting in good faith. He is president because he doesn't want to go to jail and because he thinks he might make money...His primary interest is not the well-being of their own countries and their own citizens or the success of the United States or the values that America stands for...His primary interest is in himself...That's what they're all interested in. They're interested in staying in power and that's what he's interested in. That's by the way, why he admires them. He says freely, he said it recently as as we're speaking. He said it a few days ago once again, how much he admires Xi Jinping...That's why he admires Putin. That's why he liked meeting, you know, the dictator of North Korea because they have this they're they're in he recognizes them as soulmates.”

0.62

The contagion of ideas works both ways: while liberal democracy threatens autocrats, the Kremlin's talking points have begun appearing in the mouths of Trump himself and his technology billionaire enablers like Elon Musk and David Sacks, suggesting ideological alignment or shared interest in undermining democratic norms.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“the contagion of ideas goes both ways. And we'll get to the the way in which Kremlin talking points seem to magically come out of the mouths of not just Trump himself, but uh you know, big tech investors who are now his his most potent enablers.”

0.61

The allegation that Ukraine could have ended the war early through a peace deal is false: Russia demanded at the beginning that Ukraine demilitarize and effectively become part of Russia, making any such agreement equivalent to Ukraine surrendering its sovereignty.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“Also, no, there wasn't a moment at the beginning of the war when it could have been solved. The Russians demanded early on that Ukraine give up essentially and and and demilitarize, which would have been effective a Ukraine saying, 'Okay, we we agree we're going to become part of Russia.' So there there there wasn't a moment like that. I mean, these are just these are just false stories.”

0.61

Houses in Mayfair, London are often owned by anonymous shell companies with unclear beneficial ownership, may be empty, and function as Swiss bank accounts or money storage—evidence of how Western property markets serve kleptocratic wealth hiding.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“many cases those houses are owned by anonymous companies. They're owned by shell companies or it's not clear who the beneficial owner is. And many often you'll they're empty. I mean, they may or may not actually be used by anybody. They're they function as sort of Swiss bank accounts. I mean, they're a place for storing money.”

0.61

The level of violence, fear of speaking out, and fear of physical consequences for political speech in America right now has no recent precedent—possibly requiring historical comparison only to Black Americans' experiences in the segregated South—and represents a new departure in American politics.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“The atmosphere of violence and the the level of fear that people, as I said, not even just at the top of politics, but all the way down the chain, now feel about saying what they think and about doing their jobs in some cases, is something that I don't I I just I can't remember it. I would be I'd be hard-pressed to find a moment in American history. I mean, maybe it's what black Americans experienced in the segregated South. Maybe that maybe you can point to that as a precedent. But that's what you have to go back to in order to find a moment when there was so much violence in the air and so much genuine fear of speaking out”

0.60

Bill Clinton declared that China would never be able to control the internet, saying it was like 'nailing Jell-O to the wall,' in a famous speech at Johns Hopkins during the period he was arguing for China's acceptance into the WTO, but he was wrong—China began developing internet controls and what became known as the 'firewall' at that very time.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“There's a famous speech that Bill Clinton gave right about the time he was arguing that China should be accepted in the W into the WTO, the World Trade Organization. And he talks about haha ha, the Chinese will never be able to control the internet. That's like nailing Jell-O to the wall. And he makes this speech in a room full of foreign policy scholars at Johns Hopkins...and everybody laughs and claps. And of course, he was wrong. And almost almost even at the time he was saying that the Chinese were already beginning to control the internet and already beginning to think about how how they were going to put up with what became known as the firewall”

0.60

There are people around Trump—Kevin Roberts from Heritage Foundation, Steve Bannon, and others whose names are not yet known—who think more systematically than Trump about how to change the American state, and they have been planning specific ways to replace expertise with loyalists in agencies like the EPA.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“We have Kevin Roberts who's the head of the Heritage Foundation talking about a revolution coming and it will be bloodless as long as the left allows it to be...We have people who've been plotting out ways in which they will, you know, replace expertise and knowledge at places like the Environmental Protection Agency and instead put in loyalists”

0.57

When Trump puts someone on blast on social media, naming names, he knows his cult will harass and doxx that person, making their lives never the same, and this is completely irresponsible because the consequences are predictable even if he doesn't explicitly order them—this represents a new level of political violence in America.

causalhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Sam Harris

“he's putting someone on blast on social media, naming names and you know, he knows what his cult is going to do subsequent to that. It's completely irresponsible and it really does seem like a it's taken us to a new place politically in America”

0.55

Harris is not comparing Trump to Hitler because Trump is not ideological and has no grand ambitions beyond self-aggrandizement, making him 'a much smaller figure and far less dangerous' than Hitler, but Trump's psychopathology and the mechanism of his appeal are similar.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“I'm not actually comparing Trump to Hitler. I'm not I don't think Trump is Hitler and you know you can tell me if you disagree but I I I think there's a big difference in the fact that he's not ideological and he has no apparent grand ambitions beyond anything other than his his own self-aggrandizement so he's a much smaller figure and and far less dangerous in my mind even at his worst than someone like Hitler”

0.55

NATO was not on an offensive posture in Eastern Europe; NATO is a defensive alliance that does not invade other countries but defends its members; Russia's withdrawal of troops from the Finnish border after Finland joined NATO proves Russia knows NATO is not aggressive—the claim that NATO expansion provoked Russia is therefore a Russian talking point, not a genuine explanation for the invasion.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“There was also no moment in recent history when NATO was on an offensive posture in that part of the world. NATO is a defensive alliance. It's it doesn't invade other countries. It's a it's there to protect and defend countries. It's its members. It doesn't it doesn't operate on the offensive. And the Russians know that NATO wasn't going to invade them. And we know that they know because for example, recently, they have Finland joined NATO recently, and Russia has recently taken its troops and and equipment away from the Finnish border because, of course, Finland's not going to invade Russia. NATO's not going to invade Russia. They know that.”

0.52

Trump's political opponents misattribute his statements, taking obviously joking statements seriously as if he were genuinely authoritarian, which destroys their credibility when they warn about actual authoritarian concerns and causes his supporters to dismiss legitimate criticisms.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“his enemies take him deadly seriously when it actually seems that he was probably joking right and and his fans recognize that he was joking and then this moment destroys the credibility of mainstream institutions and political opponents who who just aren't in on the joke right?”

0.52

Modern autocracies form a network—not an alliance or axis with a centralized decision-making structure—but rather a group of dictatorships sharing common interests in protecting wealth and undermining liberal democracy, including Russia, China, Iran, North Korea, Belarus, Venezuela, Zimbabwe, and Azerbaijan.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“The book describes not an autocracy, but really a network. It's not an alliance, it's not really even an axis. There isn't a secret room where bad guys get together and make decisions. It's rather a group of dictatorships who share some things in common. And I'm talking about Russia, China, Iran, North Korea and a handful of other smaller ones, Belarus, Venezuela, Zimbabwe.”

0.52

Trump has comedic charisma that causes many people simply not to take him seriously or to see what an aberrant personality he is—a malignantly narcissistic, arguably sociopathic person who is a black hole of selfishness—and his jokes and norm violations make it easy for people who would be allergic to him to tolerate and support him.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“he has this kind of comedic charisma that causes many people simply not to see or or seeing not to care what an aberrant person he is and is psychologically and ethically and just how his personal vanity how his personal avarice is just absolutely the wrong thing to put in power in this country”

0.52

An American foreign policy conducted purely for personal financial benefit (enriching the president, family, and supporters) rather than national interest fundamentally transforms America from a rules-based democracy into a kleptocratic oligarchy and causes America to lose what makes it unique, eventually eroding rights and freedoms.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“If America is just a transactional power, run by people who conduct foreign policy in their own personal interest, like the Russians do. When Putin does foreign policy, it's not for the benefit of Russians. Ordinary Russians don't benefit from his war in Ukraine. He benefits, and and and it's all about him...If America is led by people like that, people who think American foreign policy is about making me rich or making my family rich or enriching companies who support me, and that's all it is, then I think America begins to suffer in many different ways. We we begin to take on the character of these other oligarchies, these other kleptocracies. We begin to lose some of what makes us unique. We begin to And eventually, I think we begin to lose some of our rights and freedoms.”

0.52

Applebaum is concerned not that Trump would create Auschwitz in America but that institutions designed to balance power and create checks and balances would decline through hollowing, which is already happening and would accelerate under a second Trump term with ideological practitioners now surrounding him.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“So what I'm afraid of with Trump is not that there's going to be, you know, Auschwitz in America. That's not happening. And that's you know, that's that's why Hitler is always the wrong the wrong comparison...But what you will have is institutions that that have been designed and set up you know, as to to balance out power, to to create checks and balances, you will find them declining...It's by the way, already happening.”

0.52

While autocracies feel threatened by democratic ideas globally, those ideas are losing power in the home countries of democracy (US and Europe) where they are taken for granted and underappreciated.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“And it's funny because of course, in the in the home of democracy, in the home of those ideas, United States, Europe, a few other countries, those ideas are less and less powerful. We don't appreciate them. Yeah. But they are very much appreciated by people who live without them.”

0.52

Once the state becomes malignant rather than merely bloated or dysfunctional—once it begins trying to destroy the president's enemies—the level of fear increases significantly and you begin living in a fundamentally different political situation, as Applebaum has experienced.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“once the state becomes not a neutral thing that's, you know, maybe it doesn't work very well a lot of the time or maybe it's too bloated or maybe it's got too much money. But it isn't it isn't malign. It isn't trying to destroy the president's enemies. Once that changes and once it becomes something very different, then as I say, you're you're living in a in a different political situation”

0.51

A Ukrainian friend of Applebaum's has noted that kleptocracy almost always precedes autocracy: once leaders use political power to steal state assets and enrich themselves, they must suppress anti-corruption movements and undermine institutions (courts, media, gatekeepers) to avoid prosecution, creating the conditions for full autocracy.

causalhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Anne Applebaum

“a Ukrainian friend of mine recently was describing to me how kleptocracy almost always precedes autocracy...once you have a kleptocracy, you need to defend it, right? And so there will always be...people who begin to say, "Wait, this is unjust. Why are you able to use taxpayers' money for your own politics, or why are you able to steal, and we aren't?" And and there will be a a transparency movement or an anti-corruption movement...And then the leadership needs to say, "Right, we need to clamp down on this...we need to stop people from being able to have to know what we're doing, and we need to erect walls, and we need to get rid of gatekeepers and ethics monitors, and we need to undermine the court system"”

0.51

Judge Aileen Cannon in Florida is already demonstrating this institutional hollowing: she threw out the Trump documents case (which is 'indisputable'—Trump stole documents, hid them from the FBI, concealed them) on made-up grounds about the special prosecutor's legitimacy, using legal technicalities to block the case, ensuring it won't be resolved before the election.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“Judge Aileen Cannon in Florida...is acting in such a partisan way. She's the one who threw out the case, the Trump documents case. Which is by the way, the one case against Trump which is indisputable. I mean, anybody else would have gone to jail for it. You're not allowed to do that. He did it. He hid documents from the FBI. You know, he he stole them. He concealed it...And she first found a lot of technicalities, then she found a reason to throw out the case on the grounds that the special prosecutor wasn't legitimate, which is a made-up reason”

0.51

Jim Jordan's Weaponization of Government Committee investigated Renée DiResta based entirely on untrue facts (things that didn't happen), and when she tried to demonstrate the facts were false, they weren't interested because the purpose of the hearings was not to find truth (which is what congressional hearings are supposed to do) but to create performance and generate social media narratives—this is already a symptom of institutional dysfunction.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Anne Applebaum

“Jim Jordan's weaponization of government committee. This is a congressional committee that among others investigated another guest on your show, Renee Diresta, for allegedly being involved in trying to censor conservative commentary during the 2020 election. And the whole case against her was literally based on untrue facts, things that didn't happen. And she kept saying, "This didn't happen. This didn't happen. I can show you this didn't happen." And they weren't interested because the purpose of those congressional hearings was not to find out the truth, which is what congressional hearings are supposed to be for, but to create performance”

0.49

A comment suggesting that Trump should win the 2024 election because the MAGA cult will not accept a Trump loss, and that the chaos from contested election results poses a greater danger than a Trump presidency, is no longer obviously crazy—the fact that this argument cannot be immediately dismissed demonstrates how far America has moved from normalcy.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 2/4· Sam Harris

“the comment was essentially the person was saying that he thought that the safest course now would be for Trump to win in November whatever the risks of his presidency because the MAGA cult is such that it will simply not believe him losing especially if he if it's at all a close election...Now, I don't know if that this is true, but the fact that this the fact that I can't immediately dismiss that is a measure of just how deranging Trump has been to our politics”

0.48

The democratic ideal that American elections should be accepted by losers is now in question—Americans are no longer confident that elections will be accepted or that physical safety is guaranteed, a degradation of foundational democratic assumptions.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“the fact that Americans can now contemplate the idea that an election will be and could be stolen. And the fact that Americans are, you know, afraid of the result of elections, physically afraid. I think is, you know, I think again, I think that's new. I mean you have to go pretty far back in US history to find a similar moment.”

0.48

Trump represents a pivot from policy-focused politics (discussing taxes, roads, schools—hard, nuanced questions with no clear right answers) to bombast, identity politics, flag-waving, and red hats, which is easier and more fun for people than policy discussion, and this shift appeals to people who want 'drums flags and loyalty parades' rather than detailed policy debates.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Sam Harris

“he pivots from that to bombast identity politics you know flag waving and red hats and that's a lot easier and more fun for people”

0.45

David Sacks, a venture capitalist with no prior interest in foreign policy, suddenly became an advocate against supporting Ukraine, claiming Biden provoked Russia to invade and rejected peace opportunities—this sudden appearance in a subject he previously ignored suggests either hidden business interests in Russia or alignment with autocratic talking points.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Sam Harris

“David Sacks, who's a venture capitalist and now popular podcaster...he's now, as of I guess two nights ago, addressing the Republican National Convention saying that Biden provoked This is a quote. Biden provoked the Russians to invade Ukraine with talk of NATO expansion, and rejected every opportunity for peace in Ukraine”

0.43

Applebaum observed institutional hollowing in Poland when an autocratic populist government was in charge: when experts and professionals are replaced with party loyalists and 'cousins' or 'flunkies,' the result is very bad government, bad decisions, increased dysfunctionality, misuse of government institutions, and courts being used against enemies.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Anne Applebaum

“this is something by the way I saw happen in Poland um in the years when we had an autocratic populist government in charge there. I lived there part of the time. And when you take them away and you put your cousins or your party members or your, you know, flunkies in their place, what you begin to get is very bad government and bad decisions...you will see this hollowing out, this gradual decline, um this increased dysfunctionality. You know, you could see the use of or the misuse of government institutions.”