
How should Europe react to a future without US protection – and with an emboldened Russia? | DW News
What this covers
This DW News segment runs about sixteen minutes. It opens with a report on the Riyadh meeting between Marco Rubio and Sergei Lavrov, the first high-level US-Russian contact since the 2022 invasion. Neither Ukrainian nor European representatives were present. The report notes that Vladimir Zelensky was not invited and has said he will not accept a deal worked out without Ukraine. It also covers Ursula von der Leyen meeting the US envoy in Brussels to say Europe wants a part in the peacemaking. Two interviews follow: Angela Stent of the Brookings Institution, and the political scientist Eliot Cohen (the transcript renders his name as Ott Coen and Ott Cohen).
Stent describes what Riyadh actually produced. It restored diplomatic contacts, including rebuilding embassy staffing, and it opened talk of economic ties, possible sanctions relief, and a Trump-Putin summit. It did not produce a peace plan. She argues that the Trump administration conceded early on territory, on NATO membership for Ukraine, and on US peacekeepers, and got nothing reciprocal. She links this partly to a view in Washington that the Bush-era NATO offer was a mistake. She also forecasts that European sanctions unity would be hard to hold if the US begins lifting its own.
The wider argument is about what Putin wants. Stent points to the treaties Russia presented in December 2021 as evidence of a long-standing aim to redo the post-Cold War settlement, including influence over former Warsaw Pact states. Both guests treat this as contested ground. They predict that a limited territorial deal would set the stage for another war rather than end this one. Cohen's ideal outcome is a large European force, tens of thousands strong, in Ukraine. He also accepts part of the criticism of Europe: defense spending promises have gone unmet, Germany especially, while Finland and Poland have stepped up. He says he dislikes the Vance Munich speech but grants it made that point. Stent adds the possibility of US troop withdrawals from Eastern Europe.
The US-Russia diplomatic opening under Trump represents a geopolitical realignment that sidelines Ukraine and Europe, prioritizes restoring US-Russia relations over Ukrainian interests, and sets the stage for continued Russian imperial expansion absent a credible European military commitment to deterrence.
- The US made substantial concessions to Russian positions (territorial losses, NATO exclusion, no US peacekeepers) without Ukrainian participation or a coherent end-state plan
- Europe faces a critical test to militarize and defend itself independently as US security commitments become unreliable under Trump
- Putin's long-term ambitions extend beyond Ukraine to redrawing the post-Cold War settlement across Eastern Europe and the former Warsaw Pact
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
Putin has long-term ambitions to redo the post-Cold War settlement and recoup Russia's sphere of influence not only in the post-Soviet space but also among the members of the Warsaw Pact, as evidenced by the treaties Russia presented to the West in December 2021.
“from everything that he has said and done in the past decade at least he has Ambitions to you know redo the postc Cold War settlement and if you look at the treaties that Russia presented to the West in December of 21 really to recoup Russia's sphere of influence not only in the post-soviet space but also among the members of The warsa Pact”
Putin has had long-term ambitions for at least a decade to redo the post-Cold War settlement and recoup Russia's sphere of influence, not only in the post-Soviet space but also among Warsaw Pact members, as evidenced by treaties Russia presented to the West in December 2021.
“from everything that he has said and done in the past decade at least he has Ambitions to you know redo the postc Cold War settlement and if you look at the treaties that Russia presented to the West in December of 21 really to recoup Russia's sphere of influence not only in the post-soviet space but also among the members of The warsa Pact”
Russia presented formal treaties to the West in December 2021 laying out its demands for redrawing the post-Cold War settlement, which included reasserting Russian sphere of influence over post-Soviet states and Warsaw Pact members.
“if you look at the treaties that Russia presented to the West in December of 21 really to recoup Russia's sphere of influence not only in the post-soviet space but also among the members of The warsa Pact”
Europe faces a critical geopolitical test: it must substantially increase military budgets, rebuild its defense sector, and militarize itself to deter Russian aggression independently because it can no longer rely on US security commitments under Trump.
“this this has been a wakeup call and it was very much symbolized what happened by what happened at the Munich security conference that the different Europeans have to step up um and they have to increase their military budgets and they have to uh you know go back to building up their defense sector”
Europe must increase its military budgets and rebuild its defense sector, things it has been unwilling to do, as a response to the realization that the US won't reliably provide defense protection.
“the different Europeans have to step up um and they have to increase their military budgets and they have to uh you know go back to building up their defense sector which of course they haven't wanted to do”
The US and Russia have agreed to restore diplomatic relations, including rebuilding embassy staff levels, increasing economic relations, exploring removal of sanctions on Russia, and planning political cooperation.
“they're going to build up their embassies again the US Embassy had hardly any staff they're going to talk about increasing economic relations the possibility of removing sanctions on Russia uh and increased political cooperation”
The Trump Administration made major concessions early in the process—accepting Ukraine's territorial losses, rejecting Ukraine's NATO membership at least for the long term, and refusing to provide US troops as peacekeepers—without securing reciprocal commitments from Russia.
“they've made all these concessions to essentially what is Putin's position that Ukraine will have to accept the loss of territory that it will have to say no to Nato membership at least for for a long time and that the US will not provide troops uh in the event of a peace agreement to enforce the peace agreement as peacekeepers”
Europe has failed to defend itself and has failed to spend the money on defense that it promised and has been repeatedly asked to spend; Germany in particular has fallen behind what was promised at NATO summits.
“the Europeans have failed to defend themselves they failed to spend the money on defense uh that they've promised to and that we've repeatedly ask them to uh Germany itself has kind of fallen behind what the promise of the Tien vend”
The Trump Administration has made concessions to Putin's core demands—accepting Ukrainian territorial loss, NATO exclusion for Ukraine, and refusing to commit US troops as peacekeepers—without a coherent plan for how to actually end the war or enforce any agreement.
“so many concessions so early in the process”
Some European countries, particularly Finland and Poland, have been willing to invest in defense and step up, demonstrating that the issue is not European capacity but political will among larger nations like Germany.
“so the first thing that has to happen is Europeans have to decide that they're willing to defend themselves and to invest the resources some Europeans obviously have like the the fins and the poles um and so on”
The US may withdraw troops it currently has in Eastern Europe, as Trump attempted in his first administration, though such withdrawal was planned but did not actually happen then.
“it's quite possible that the US May withdraw some of the troops it has in Eastern Europe now uh Trump tried to do that in his first Administration but uh it didn't happen even though it was planned”
Putin is satisfied with the current diplomatic direction and has effectively been brought 'in from the cold' after being shunned by the West since his 2022 invasion of Ukraine, now being welcomed back by the US despite no detailed agreement on Ukraine having been reached.
“he's very happy and I think they're breaking out the vodka bottles in the Kremlin”
Ukraine's President Zelinski was not invited to the Saudi Arabia meeting and is currently in Turkey; he called for fair peace talks and has previously stated he would not accept an agreement worked out without his country's participation, and he postponed his planned trip to Saudi Arabia until early March.
“one person absent from the meeting in Saudi Arabia was Ukrainian President Vladimir zelinski he wasn't invited and is currently in Turkey for talks with President Reb Ty erdogan and for the inauguration of a new Ukrainian Embassy building in anchora speaking there he called for fair peace talks he's previously said he would not accept an agreement worked out without his country's participation he also said he will not travel to Saudi Arabia later this week as planned he's postponed his trip until early March”
European leaders feel sidelined by the talks; EU Chief Ursula von der Leyen was meeting the US Envoy to Ukraine in Brussels to express that Europe wants to work with Washington to bring about peace, but Europeans were not included in the Saudi talks despite being asked to specify what military support they could provide.
“some other people who feel sidelined are leaders in the European Union while the talks were underway in Riyad EU Chief Ursula felion was meeting the US Envoy to Ukraine in Brussels she told Keith Kellogg that Europe wants to work with Washington to bring about peace Mr Kellogg was in Brussels to meet European leaders the commission president told him that European nations are ready to step up including doing more to arm Ukraine European leaders are ing a diplomatic push to be included in peace talks after Mr Kellogg last week ruled out European participation”
The US and Russia have agreed to restore diplomatic relations and high-level contacts, including rebuilding US embassy staffing, discussing increased economic relations, and the possibility of removing sanctions on Russia.
“they're going to build up their embassies again the US Embassy had hardly any staff they're going to talk about increasing economic relations the possibility of removing sanctions on Russia uh and increased political cooperation”
European nations have failed to spend the money on defense that they have promised and that the US has repeatedly requested, with Germany in particular falling behind the NATO defense spending commitment targets.
“the Europeans have failed to defend themselves they failed to spend the money on defense uh that they've promised to and that we've repeatedly ask them to uh Germany itself has kind of fallen behind what the promise of the Tien vend”
Vice President JD Vance gave a critical speech at the Munich Security Conference that, despite Coen's personal dislike of it, made the legitimate point that European nations have failed to spend adequate resources on defense.
“I had uh I disliked very much um vice president Vance's speech at the Munich security conference but he was hammering home one point which is absolutely true which is the Europeans have failed to defend themselves”
Zelensky has previously stated that he would not accept a peace agreement worked out without Ukraine's participation in the negotiations.
“He's previously said he would not accept an agreement worked out without his country's participation”
The Trump Administration appears to believe that NATO membership offered to Ukraine by the George W. Bush Administration in the past was a strategic mistake, and this belief is driving their current priority to end the war by excluding NATO expansion as a possibility.
“some of them uh believed that it was a big mistake for in fact it was the George W Bush Administration to offer UK Ukraine NATO membership at some point in the future although nothing had happened uh to make that happen happen”
A limited territorial settlement in Ukraine would likely just be the stage-setting for another war, not the end of the conflict, because Putin's ambitions extend beyond Ukraine to redrawing the entire post-Cold War settlement.
“this is not despite what the American delegation said the the end of a conflict uh we're seeing here the Revival of Russian Imperial uh objectives and aims and uh if it's a if it's a really bad piece it'll just be the setting the stage for another War”
Russia will likely not accept a limited territorial settlement in Ukraine and declare victory; instead, Putin will seek to eventually redo the entire post-Cold War settlement unless his strategic thinking changes fundamentally.
“it would be very hard to imagine that Putin would have a change of heart and think all right I'll make a peace agreement with them we've got a little bit more territory and we'll accept that and go home and declare Victory I mean from everything that he has said and done in the past decade at least he has Ambitions to you know redo the postc Cold War settlement”
An ideal peace settlement would include a large, consequential European military presence (tens of thousands of soldiers) in Ukraine, not merely American troops or a few observers, to help Ukraine defend itself and preserve European security.
“the ideal solution would be I would like to see American troops in Ukraine but certainly large a large European military presence that is consequential not a few observers but we're talking about tens of thousands of European soldiers and the will to defend help the ukrainians defend themselves”
The main outcome of the US-Russia talks was restoration of high-level diplomatic contacts and planning for a Trump-Putin summit, not agreement on a specific peace plan for Ukraine.
“really wasn't very much discussion today of a peace plan for Ukraine obviously that's very complicated I think the main outcome was this restoration now of high level contacts between the US and Russia and planning for a trump Putin Summit”
It will be very difficult for Europe to maintain unified sanctions against Russia if the US begins removing sanctions, because European governments will face pressure to reopen diplomatic channels, import Russian gas again, and diverge in their Russia policy.
“the interest question is if the US starts to try and remove the sanctions can how you know how long will the Europeans keep these sanctions as well you will already have discussion in Europe about re you know importing Russian gas again uh if things get better”
Vice President Vance's speech at the Munich Security Conference was critical of European defense failures, hammering home the true point that Europeans promised to spend money on defense and haven't delivered, though Cohen disliked the overall tone and message of the speech.
“I had uh I disliked very much um vice president Vance's speech at the Munich security conference but he was hammering home one point which is absolutely true which is the Europeans have failed to defend themselves they failed to spend the money on defense”
Ukraine's President Zelensky was not invited to the Saudi Arabia talks and is currently in Turkey, having postponed his planned trip to Saudi Arabia until early March, signaling his exclusion from the diplomatic process.
“one person absent from the meeting in Saudi Arabia was Ukrainian President Vladimir zelinski he wasn't invited and is currently in Turkey for talks with President Reb Ty erdogan”
The Munich Security Conference represented a symbolic wakeup call for Europe about the need to militarize and defend itself independently.
“this this has been a wakeup call and it was very much symbolized what happened by what happened at the Munich security conference”
EU Commission President Ursula von der Leyen met with US Ukraine Envoy Keith Kellogg in Brussels to request European inclusion in peace talks, after Kellogg had previously ruled out European participation.
“EU Chief Ursula felion was meeting the US Envoy to Ukraine in Brussels she told Keith Kellogg that Europe wants to work with Washington to bring about peace Mr Kellogg was in Brussels to meet European leaders the commission president told him that European nations are ready to step up including doing more to arm Ukraine European leaders are ing a diplomatic push to be included in peace talks after Mr Kellogg last week ruled out European participation”
European nations were asked to fill out forms detailing what military and security contributions they could provide for a Ukrainian peacekeeping operation, without being included in the actual negotiations that would determine what that operation would look like.
“even though they're not at the table and they've already had to fill out out forms for the Trump Administration uh telling them what they could provide uh in such an if if that in fact happens”
This situation is a real test for Europe and for European statesmen, especially regarding the European willingness to defend freedom in a European home—a fundamental question about whether Europe will take responsibility for its own security.
“the Europeans this is a real test for Europe it's a real test for European Statesman it above all it's a a real test of the European willingness to to defend freedom in a European home”
Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the United States and Russia want to work towards ending the conflict in a way that is enduring, sustainable, and acceptable to all sides, and the US and Russia agreed to appoint high-level teams to negotiate an end to the conflict and improve US-Russia relations.
“America's top Diplomat says Washington and Moscow have taken the first step of what he called a long and difficult journey to ending the war in Ukraine Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the United States and Russia want to work towards ending the conflict in a way that is enduring sustainable and acceptable to all sides secretary Rubio's comments followed a meeting with his Russian counterpart Sergey lavro in Saudi Arabia the two men agreed to appoint highlevel teams to negotiate an end to the conflict and to improve us Russia relations”
The atmospheric quality of the US-Russia talks was very positive, with discussion of future economic collaboration and Trump-Putin summits, even though actual substantive agreement on Ukraine or other issues was minimal.
“the atmosphere though is quite different the atmosphere was uh was very positive uh not just in terms of you know talking about setting up a meeting between Trump and uh Putin but also the Secretary of State uh making very positive comments about the possibility for future economic um collaboration”
If the US removes sanctions on Russia, it will become very difficult for Europeans to maintain sanctions unilaterally, and there is already discussion in Europe about resuming the import of Russian gas if relations improve.
“the interest question is if the US starts to try and remove the sanctions can how you know how long will the Europeans keep these sanctions as well you will already have discussion in Europe about re you know importing Russian gas again uh if things get better”
The talks in Saudi Arabia are really about revival of Russian Imperial objectives and aims, not just a settlement of the Ukraine conflict, suggesting a much longer strategic horizon than a simple peace agreement.
“the the end of a conflict uh we're seeing here the Revival of Russian Imperial uh objectives and aims”
The notion that we should be concerned about what Russia thinks regarding European security decisions is flawed, as the US delegation acted as though Russian red lines are unquestionable constraints when in fact they have been shown to be flexible.
“so first let's not take at face value everything the Russians say I mean this is supposed to be a negotiation one of the things that was pathetic about the American performance was that we were G we've been given concessions for absolutely nothing and we've assumed that they what they call their red lines are their red lines”
It will be much harder for European governments to maintain sanctions on Russia if the US starts to remove sanctions, and the whole edifice of European isolation of Russia is starting to crumble.
“and the interest question is if the US starts to try and remove the sanctions can how you know how long will the Europeans keep these sanctions as well you will already have discussion in Europe about re you know importing Russian gas again uh if things get better so um I I think it will be much harder for the Europeans to to isolate Russia and you know we had this meeting uh yesterday in France with some of the major European countries talking about how to respond to that but it's really h a wakeup call for them”
The presence of large European NATO troops in Ukraine at the end of a peace agreement is absolutely critical, even without American soldiers on the ground, because without it the conflict will simply be the setting of the stage for another war.
“I think the the notion of European troops including NATO troops being in Ukraine at the end of this is absolutely critical um even if they're not American soldiers on the ground to have a very large European presence is I think absolutely vital you know this this is not despite what the American delegation said the the end of a conflict uh we're seeing here the Revival of Russian Imperial uh objectives and aims and uh if it's a if it's a really bad piece it'll just be the setting the stage for another War”
The US may withdraw troops from Eastern Europe that it currently has deployed, as Trump attempted to do in his first administration though those plans were not executed.
“it's quite possible that the US May withdraw some of the troops it has in Eastern Europe now uh Trump tried to do that in his first Administration but uh it didn't happen even though it was planned”
The American performance in the Saudi talks was pathetic because the US gave concessions for absolutely nothing and assumed that Russian stated 'red lines' are actually red lines without testing them in negotiation.
“one of the things that was pathetic about the American performance was that we were G we've been given concessions for absolutely nothing and we've assumed that they what they call their red lines are their red lines”
Putin appears very happy with the outcomes of the talks and the talks appear to represent him coming 'in from the cold' after being shunned by the West since launching his invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, with Russia now being welcomed back at least by the US.
“oh yes I think he's very happy and I think they're breaking out the vodka bottles in the Kremlin I mean essentially what you had today was an agreement for the US and Russia to restore relations uh they're going to build up their embassies again the US Embassy had hardly any staff they're going to talk about increasing economic relations the possibility of removing sanctions on Russia uh and increased political cooperation so really Putin has come in from the cold having been shunn by the West since he launched his invasion of Ukraine in Fe February of 22 he's now being welcome back at least by the US”
The George W. Bush Administration made a mistake in offering Ukraine NATO membership at some point in the future without action to support that goal, and the Trump Administration views this as a priority error to reverse.
“some of them uh believed that it was a big mistake for in fact it was the George W Bush Administration to offer UK Ukraine NATO membership at some point in the future although nothing had happened uh to make that happen”
Germany's role in European defense is tremendously important because it is the biggest economy in Europe and has the potential to lead, but it has had weak leadership that has been unwilling to exercise this leadership.
“the German role here is actually tremendously important and despite all of its difficulties it's the biggest uh economy in Europe uh it has the potential to lead and I hope that under different leadership than the really weak leadership that it's had uh that it will be able to uh do so”
The ideal solution would include American troops in Ukraine and certainly a large European military presence of tens of thousands of European soldiers with the will to help Ukrainians defend themselves, not just observers.
“the ideal solution would be I would like to see American troops in Ukraine but certainly large a large European military presence that is consequential not a few observers but we're talking about tens of thousands of European soldiers and the will to defend help the ukrainians defend themselves”
Russia has already accepted NATO expansion, as evidenced by Finland and Sweden joining NATO, so European nations should not care overly much about what Russia claims to think about NATO when determining their own security policies.
“the Russians by the way have already accepted NATO expansion what do we think Finland and Sweden being part of NATO uh are a after all so I don't think Europeans as they think about their security should care overly much about what the Russians think”
Ukraine has been fighting a war for European freedom and has borne the cost; it is absolutely time for European states to step up and be willing to stand side by side with Ukraine rather than sit on the sidelines.
“Ukraine has been fighting a war for European freedom and they've borne the cost and it is absolutely time for European states to step up and be willing to stand side by side with them”
The US delegation's exclusion of Ukraine and Europe from peace talks, combined with the lack of any concrete peace plan, represents a shameful day for the United States given the brutality of Russia's invasion and the sacrifices Ukraine and Europe have made.
“I'll just add my personal view that it's a disgrace I mean it's shameful um given what the ukrainians have been through given what the Europeans have done to support them that we did this really without reference at all to either Ukraine or to Europe and and without any indication of the fact which is that Russia launched a brutal brutal war of aggression which has killed and wounded hundreds of thousands of people has led to the mass criminal behaviors rape torture uh kidnapping of children so I I hate to say it as an American but it was a disgraceful day for my country”
NATO has been extremely dependent on American leadership for its entire existence, but Americans cannot be counted on for the next four years because the Trump Administration has no interest in NATO and lacks capacity for it.
“we have we've had a NATO alliance which has been extremely dependent on American leadership and I'm very sad to to say that I just don't think for the next four years you can count on American leadership um I just don't believe that this Administration has any interest in this and I don't think they have much capacity for it”
There really wasn't very much discussion today of a peace plan for Ukraine; the main outcome was the restoration of high-level contacts between US and Russia and planning for a Trump-Putin Summit.
“and you'll note that there really wasn't very much discussion today of a peace plan for Ukraine obviously that's very complicated I think the main outcome was this restoration now of high level contacts between the US and Russia and planning for a trump Putin Summit”
The Trump Administration does not appear to have a concrete plan yet for how they think they're going to end the war, despite General Kellogg's negotiations with Ukrainians and Europeans who are not even at the negotiating table.
“one has the feeling that they really don't have a plan yet for how they think they're going to end the war as you showed General Kellogg he's got his negotiations with the ukrainians and the Europeans but they're not at the table”
Cohen has very little faith in President Trump and would not rule out the worst possible outcome, though he still hopes for something 'quite bad' rather than 'truly awful'—a large rump Ukraine that remains adequately armed and economically viable.
“I have very little faith in president uh in president Trump you know I think he actually gave a press conference uh today following the um uh the Riad meeting which is quite critical of President s so I would not rule out the worst I mean I'm still hoping that I think and and I think this is what we'll probably end up with is something that's quite bad which which would still preserve a large rump Ukraine uh which would still be able to uh be adequately armed uh and which would be able to recover economically”
German elections and potential leadership change are important because Germany could step up to lead European defense, but current German leadership is weak and unwilling to exercise this leadership role.
“I'm personally I'm hoping that after the German elections that you get a different government which is much more willing to exercise leadership the German role here is actually tremendously important and despite all of its difficulties it's the biggest uh economy in Europe uh it has the potential to lead and I hope that under different leadership than the really weak leadership that it's had uh that it will be able to uh do so”
Trump wants to end the war in Ukraine partly because he believes the war wouldn't have started had he been president, he wants to win the Nobel Peace Prize, and he doesn't want the US to continue supporting Ukraine financially.
“Trump does want to end the war he keeps saying that you know the war wouldn't have started had he been president we know that he'd like to get the Nobel Peace Prize so he would like to stop the war because he also doesn't want the us to go on supporting Ukraine”
Trump wants to end the war in Ukraine partly because he does not want the US to continue supporting Ukraine financially and militarily, and partly because he seeks the Nobel Peace Prize for achieving conflict resolution.
“Trump does want to end the war he keeps saying that you know the war wouldn't have started had he been president we know that he'd like to get the Nobel Peace Prize so he would like to stop the war because he also doesn't want the us to go on supporting Ukraine”
German leadership and political will are critical for mobilizing Europe to defend itself, but the current German government has been weak and lacks the capacity to exercise this leadership role.
“I'm personally I'm hoping that after the German elections that you get a different government which is much more willing to exercise leadership the German role here is actually tremendously important and despite all of its difficulties it's the biggest uh economy in Europe uh it has the potential to lead and I hope that under different leadership than the really weak leadership that it's had”
There is a feeling or concern that Ukraine will capitulate to the same kinds of ultimatums that it could have accepted at earlier, more difficult moments in the conflict.
“I wonder if we didn't give into all these ultimatums at the most difficult moments why is there a feeling that Ukraine will do so”
The day of the Saudi US-Russia meeting was a disgraceful day for the United States, given what Ukrainians have endured and the support Europeans have provided, and the talks proceeded without reference to Ukraine or Europe.
“I'll just add my personal view that it's a disgrace I mean it's shameful um given what the ukrainians have been through given what the Europeans have done to support them that we did this really without reference at all to either Ukraine or to Europe and and without any indication of the fact which is that Russia launched a brutal brutal war of aggression which has killed and wounded hundreds of thousands of people has led to the mass criminal behaviors rape torture uh kidnapping of children so I I hate to say it as an American but it was a disgraceful day for my country”
The NATO alliance has been extremely dependent on American leadership for the past decades, and under the Trump administration there is no basis for believing the US will provide that leadership for the next four years.
“we have we've had a NATO alliance which has been extremely dependent on American leadership and I'm very sad to to say that I just don't think for the next four years you can count on American leadership um I just don't believe that this Administration has any interest in this and I don't think they have much capacity for it”
Ukraine has been fighting a war for European freedom and has borne the primary human cost of the conflict, which means European states have a moral obligation to step up and provide military support and personnel to defend Ukraine.
“Ukraine has been fighting a war for European freedom and they've borne the cost and it is absolutely time for European states to step up and be willing to stand side by side with them”
A truly awful outcome would involve the worst possible scenario for Ukraine and Europe, worse than merely a 'very bad' outcome in which a large rump Ukraine survives and can be adequately armed and recover economically with European military presence.
“I don't know um you know I have very little faith in president uh in president Trump you know I think he actually gave a press conference uh today following the um uh the Riad meeting which is quite critical of President s so I would not rule out the worst I mean I'm still hoping that I think and and I think this is what we'll probably end up with is something that's quite bad which which would still preserve a large rump Ukraine uh which would still be able to uh be adequately armed uh and which would be able to recover economically”
The US-Russia meeting in Saudi Arabia was the first high-level meeting between the two countries since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022.
“it was the first high level meeting between the two countries since Russia invaded Ukraine one person absent from the meeting in Saudi Arabia was Ukrainian President Vladimir zelinski”
Some level of concessions will have to be made by all sides in negotiations, but the specific nature of those concessions will not be predetermined.
“there has to be concessions made by all sides we're not going to predetermine what those are”
Some European countries, particularly Finland and Poland, have already increased defense spending and demonstrated the willingness to invest in their own security that others have lacked.
“some Europeans obviously have like the fins and the poles um and so on”
Ukraine's membership in NATO is unacceptable as a red line, as stated in the opening claims by what appears to be a Russian negotiating position.
“Ukraine's membership in NATO is unacceptable”
Secretary of State Marco Rubio stated that the United States and Russia want to work toward ending the conflict in a way that is enduring, sustainable, and acceptable to all sides.
“Secretary of State Marco Rubio said the United States and Russia want to work towards ending the conflict in a way that is enduring sustainable and acceptable to all sides”
The US and Russia agreed to appoint high-level teams to negotiate an end to the Ukraine conflict and to improve US-Russia relations more broadly.
“the two men agreed to appoint highlevel teams to negotiate an end to the conflict and to improve us Russia relations”
Zelensky is in Turkey meeting with President Erdogan and attending the inauguration of a new Ukrainian Embassy building in Ankara, calling for fair peace talks from that venue.
“he's currently in Turkey for talks with President Reb Ty erdogan and for the inauguration of a new Ukrainian Embassy building in anchora speaking there he called for fair peace talks”
Some negotiations are currently taking place, with discussion of both Ukraine and other matters including territory and security guarantees.
“I have the impression that some negotiations are taking place now more there again about Ukraine and without Ukraine there is going to be some discussion of territory uh and there's going to be discussion of security guarantees”
Coen expressed skepticism that Trump and his administration will actually achieve their stated goals, given his little faith in Trump's judgment and his own characterization of the admin as having disgraceful approach.
“I don't know um you know I have very little faith in president uh in president Trump”
The American side has better understood Russia's position in negotiations, suggesting Russia believes the US now comprehends Russian red lines and demands.
“I have reason to believe the American side has better understood our position”
This was the first high-level meeting between the United States and Russia since Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022.
“it was the first high level meeting between the two countries since Russia invaded Ukraine”