Mind-body problem
The philosophical problem of how mind and consciousness relate to physical matter; if reality is purely material, it is hard to explain phenomena like consciousness and free will.
As defined in John Horgan on Mind-Body Problems
Other definitions
In philosophy, the problem of explaining how non-physical consciousness can interact with and causally influence physical matter, given that consciousness is not found as a localized substance or mechanism in the body
Quantum Physicist Erwin Schrödinger Thoughts on Upanishadic philosophy | Eternal Talks |
Where it comes up · 7
- John Horgan on Mind-Body Problems4 claims
- Quantum Physicist Erwin Schrödinger Thoughts on Upanishadic philosophy | Eternal Talks |2 claims
- A History of Philosophy | 81 Philosophy Today and Tomorrow1 claim
- Nick Lane – Life as we know it is chemically inevitable1 claim
- 369 - Escaping Death1 claim
- 263 - The Paradox Of Death1 claim
- A History of Philosophy | 34 Descartes on God and Nature1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 11Search all claims for “Mind-body problem” →
- While the fact that consciousness exists at all remains unexplained, the contents of consciousness—memories, perception, recognizing faces, understanding speech, feeling emotions—are demonstrably brain-dependent, since damaging specific brain regions removes specific faculties, which makes the NDE picture of an intact English-speaking soul lifting off at death deeply implausible.369 - Escaping Death
- Unlike traditional scientific problems such as photosynthesis or gravity, the mind-body problem—consciousness, free will, meaning—may never have subjectivity removed from it; subjectivity itself is the problem we cannot get rid of, so each individual may have to arrive at his or her own solution.John Horgan on Mind-Body Problems
- What we believe happens after death depends on two fundamental questions in philosophy of mind: the nature of consciousness (the mind-body problem, with rival views of physicalism, panpsychism, and idealism) and the nature of personal identity (whether identity is just psychological continuity through time).263 - The Paradox Of Death
- If feelings are real and evolved, then natural selection must be able to see and act on them, which means there must be something physical about them that confers a selective advantage and is in principle measurable—though we currently don't know what to measure, which addresses Chalmers's hard problem of consciousness (we can't define a feeling in physical terms).Nick Lane – Life as we know it is chemically inevitable
- The mind-body problem arises because if you assume reality is made only of matter—as science strongly implied by the early 19th century—it becomes deeply difficult to account for mind-related phenomena like consciousness and free will.John Horgan on Mind-Body Problems
- Horgan expected the many competing strands of consciousness research that emerged in the late 1980s to eventually converge on a single correct paradigm, but over decades this convergence never happened, suggesting the problem may not have a single objective solution.John Horgan on Mind-Body Problems
- The mind-body problem matters to everyone because, stripped of its esoteric technical apparatus, it is simply the problem of who you are—a question every thinking person asks—and the longstanding assumption that there is one answer that gives life meaning is itself a bad idea that has had harmful consequences.John Horgan on Mind-Body Problems
- Descartes' successors in philosophy have been constantly worried about the mind-body problem and have explored various alternatives to his causal interaction approach.A History of Philosophy | 34 Descartes on God and Nature
- The mind-body problem is a fruitless quest for the place where mind acts on matter or vice versa, because the material world has been constructed precisely by taking the self (mind) out of it, so mind can neither act on matter nor be acted on by it, which resolves the problem by reframing the ontological relationship.Quantum Physicist Erwin Schrödinger Thoughts on Upanishadic philosophy | Eternal Talks |
- The mind-body problem will receive particular emphasis in metaphysical work, with mind-body dualism having articulate philosophical defenders like Richard Swinburne.A History of Philosophy | 81 Philosophy Today and Tomorrow