What this covers

This is the closing lecture in a Wheaton College history-of-philosophy series, delivered by a philosophy professor who surveys where the discipline stands and then turns to what Christian philosophers might do next. He starts with the lay of the land: the split between continental phenomenology and English-speaking analytic philosophy, which he says is now so loose a label that "analytic" covers almost anything that attends closely to concepts and arguments. He describes how most American departments are analytic with perhaps one token phenomenologist, names a few exceptions, and notes that Rorty and Dreyfus are unusual in working in both camps.

The middle of the talk covers a range of specific developments. He treats applied ethics as a reversal of earlier decades dominated by meta-ethics, and now the largest philosophical industry in the country. He observes that a priori structures and innate ideas have little standing today, and that rationalism has not really continued. He sets scientific naturalism as the dominant outlook, while philosophy of religion has become predominantly Christian, which he illustrates with a 1950s American Philosophical Association anecdote and a list of recent Christian presidents including Alvin Plantinga and William Alston. More contested is his forecast that postmodernism and anti-realism are old skepticism in new dress, yet will still be a major issue for the next decade. He also expects metaphysics, including the mind-body problem, to keep growing, and criticizes naturalism and Whitehead for reductionism about persons, citing John MacMurray's personalism.

The final stretch is prescriptive. He argues that Christian philosophy should be perspectival, exploratory, pluralistic, and holistic, and that bracketing one's beliefs is impossible as well as dishonest. Drawing on stewardship, he warns against crowding into philosophy of religion, noting that about 90% of inquiries about a Wheaton opening fell there, and points instead to metaphysics, aesthetics, science, and virtue ethics as a bridge between philosophical and theological ethics. He ends by saying history is still being made, including by his audience.

Sharpest takeaway

The speaker argues that contemporary Western philosophy is characterized by the divide between analytic and phenomenological traditions, the dominance of scientific naturalism qualified by rising Christian theism especially in philosophy of religion, and that Christian philosophy should develop as a perspectival, exploratory, pluralistic, and holistic tradition engaging key neglected areas like aesthetics and metaphysics.

  • Analytic vs phenomenological divide persists with little mutual understanding but some bridge-builders like Rorty and Dreyfus succeed in both traditions
  • Scientific naturalism dominates Western philosophy generally, but Christian theism now dominates philosophy of religion—a reversal from decades past
  • Christian philosophers should be honest about their perspective rather than bracketing beliefs, and should pursue strategic areas (metaphysics, aesthetics, science) rather than concentrating in philosophy of religion

The claims · ranked29 claims · weighted by value

This asset isn't compiled yet

You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.

0.69

Notable individuals like Richard Rorty and Hubert Dreyfus have succeeded in keeping a foot in both the analytic and phenomenological camps, with Rorty drawing on figures from Wittgenstein to Gadamer to Foucault and Dreyfus at Berkeley working effectively in both traditions.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“there are some notable individuals who succeeded in keeping a foot in both camps one such is Richard Rorty whom we've mentioned before his very postmodern book philosophy and the mirror of nature draws on people ranging from Wittgenstein to gadamer to Foucault very much in both camps and the other end of the country Hubert Dreyfus at Berkeley likewise seems to succeed in keeping the foot in the tomb and being able to interact and work with people in both traditions”

0.69

The primary contrast in contemporary philosophy is between continental European phenomenological thought and English-speaking analytic philosophy, though the term 'analytic' is now extremely loose and refers to any philosophy that analyzes concepts and arguments in detail rather than a specific method like Russell's logical analysis.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“the contrast between continental European thought and english-speaking philosophy which is sometimes put as the contrast between phenomenology phenomenological tradition and analytic philosophy”

0.69

Applied ethics has become a vigorous field in its own right, reversing a period of roughly 40-50 years at the beginning of the 20th century when philosophical ethics was overwhelmingly focused on meta-ethical concerns to the virtual eclipse of applied ethics, a shift partly due to overcoming meta-ethical hurdles and partly due to activism in the 1960s.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“what is in Devine is the meta ethics discussion... the meaning of ethical terms and then of course that was just reinforced by AJ Ayers declaration that such terms have no empirical referent so that if they have no empirical reference then moral judgments have no the factual significance... perhaps 40 or 50 for 40 or 50 years at the beginning of the century the overwhelming attention of philosophical ethics was to meta ethical concerns to the virtual Eclipse of applied ethical concerns but partly because that hurdle was overcome and partly because of the activism of the sixties applied ethics became a vigorous field in its own right”

0.69

The speaker's current research for the past two or three years (and expected to continue for another couple of years) concerns the objective basis for moral judgments—what objective reality grounds ethical claims—and represents the kind of specific substantive work he encourages in Christian philosophy.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“the things that I'm working on now I may have mentioned this before have been for two or three years will be for another couple is essentially the objective basis for moral judgments what is the basis in objective reality the parentheses and you've been getting some of that stuff that I've been finding along through the year”

0.68

In Western philosophy, scientific naturalism (secular humanism in popular terminology) is the dominant position, though it has qualifications including the recent emergence of postmodernism and anti-realism, and notably Christian theism has become dominant in philosophy of religion—a reversal from 20-40 years ago.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“Western thought and you know it's sort of hard to define what you mean by Western now year or two ago we main west of the Iron Curtain yeah let's still mean it that way Western Europe and Anglo American philosophy in terms of general position is largely scientific naturalism what in pop terminology is secular humanism”

0.66

The history of philosophy is not yet finished because history is ongoing, and those interested in philosophy's future should be prepared in anticipation for what might develop rather than simply predicting it.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 4/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“the history of philosophy is not yet finished it's an obvious statement which may sound a little bit odd when we're finishing the history of philosophy of course that it's not yet finished because history is is going on so let me try and characterize briefly some salient things about philosophy as it is today while at the same time looking towards the future”

0.61

In the 1950s at an American Philosophical Association convention, a Catholic philosopher presenting a Scotist argument for God's existence faced strong skepticism from colleagues who believed something must be wrong with it but couldn't identify what, whereas just ten to fifteen years later, Christian philosophers were openly conducting panel discussions on philosophy of religion—showing a major shift in professional attitudes.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“I remember in the fifties being at an American Philosophical Association convention in st. Louis where a young Catholic layman chip on shoulder type from University of Pennsylvania whose name was James Ross gave a paper called a SCOTUS argument for the existence of God and everybody tried to take him a pieces and pick holes in the argument and he resisted them all and as they audience was leaving the room I heard run philosophers say to another there must be something wrong with it I can't see what it is but it couldn't possibly be true”

0.61

The speaker rejects that innate ideas or a priori structures of the mind/knowledge are significant in contemporary philosophy—while logical truths and possibly other structures are discussed in a priori terms, categorical distinctions and innate ideas are not; even neo-Kantians have pretty well relativized categories, so the general temper of philosophy remains loosely empirical.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“I think I have to say no I think I have to say no that is to say innate ideas just aren't in the the a pre alrigh that's discussed these days is the a priori nature of logical truths of the form a equals a equals not a possibly a pre or I structures of some other sorts but even conte and categories no they are pretty well relativized the neo-kantian direction so no I think the general temper remains loosely empirical in that regards”

0.60

Most philosophy departments in the United States are overwhelmingly analytic in some broad sense, typically with perhaps one token phenomenologist, while a few exceptions like Duquesne University in Pittsburgh and SUNY Stony Brook are overwhelmingly phenomenological, and some departments like Northwestern, Boston College, and Catholic University attempt to maintain balance through effectively separate graduate programs.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“most philosophy departments in the United States are overwhelmingly analytic in some sense or another some broad sense with perhaps one token phenomenologist and there are some exceptions to that there are some a few departments that are overwhelmingly phenomenological perhaps with a token of an analyst to the overwhelmingly Anna a phenomenological come to mind immediately one is Duquesne University in Pittsburgh another one is State University of New York at Stony Brook there are some who try to hold up both Ames Northwestern University for instance though they have in effect two different graduate programs as a result Boston College Catholic University in Washington”

0.60

When a philosophy position was advertised at Wheaton, about 90% of inquiries were in philosophy of religion, which the speaker describes as unnecessary given current staffing, demonstrating that stewardship considerations should extend to what is strategic for the whole enterprise of Christian philosophy, not just what is strategic for Christian thought in individual areas.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“if that's the only consideration namely if you advertise a position in philosophy as we've done so recently and begin to immerse these piles and piles of letters of inquiry and V ty and all the rest of it you find that 90% of them are in philosophy of religion which is what we don't need help in at this Junction so that it seems to me the stewardship question has to be not only in terms of what is strategic for Christian thought but what is strategic for Christian thought in the whole enterprise of Christian philosophy at this juncture of history much larger picture”

0.57

Rationalism in the historical sense has not been continued in contemporary philosophy, with some suggesting it continued in Hegel, but pure Hegelians are a rare species.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 81 Philosophy Today and Tomorrow [9g4gP5F7Apo]

“I don't think that that rationalists direction is has been continued some would say it's continued in Hegel but then pure red-blooded hog aliens are pretty rare species these days”

0.57

Applied ethics courses have proliferated in American universities, including business ethics, bioethics, media ethics, and ethics and international affairs, becoming the largest philosophical industry in the country with reliable job availability.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 0/4durability 2/4· Unidentified Speaker — A History of Philosophy | 81 Philosophy Today and Tomorrow [9g4gP5F7Apo]

“now you know what you got business ethics bioethics media ethics ethics and international affairs etc etc etc and so forth but this is true the country across and it's the biggest philosophical industry in the country is applied ethics there are always jobs in applied ethics”

0.57

Postmodernism with its manifestations in anti-realism (in philosophy of science, ethics, epistemology, and religion) and relativism is essentially old hat—ancient skepticism and relativism reworked in contemporary form—so it is unlikely to seriously challenge the dominance of scientific naturalism, though the speaker expects it to be a key issue for the next decade.

forecasthigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“I personally don't expect it to and I don't expect it to because post-modernism pluralism anti-realism relativism a simply old hat with new trim and this it's easter resurrection that is to say we we have a long long history of skepticism and relativism in epistemology going all the way back to the pre-socratics basically the same position reworked in contemporary form with tremendous histological philosophical resources to the contract so i I don't expect this postmodern relativism and anti-realism to become dominant I do expect that it will be the key issue for the next decade perhaps to difference”

0.56

Bob Roberts, a colleague at Wheaton, is at the cutting edge of virtue ethics work, with his research cited frequently in virtue ethics journal articles, and he exemplifies how to incorporate Christian understanding of human nature (sin, grace) while doing rigorous conceptual analysis of virtue concepts in the Wittgensteinian tradition.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“illustrative of that I think is the work of our own Bob Roberts who incidentally is at the cutting edge of what's going on in virtue ethics his work is cited in journal articles all the time where you get his clear incorporation of Christian understanding of human nature sin grace while at the same time that sort of VidCon Stinney analysis of value concepts virtue concepts relentlessly trying to get clear about the virtue and how it functions and its relationship to appropriate emotions and so forth”

0.56

In recent years (approximately 7-8 years prior to this lecture), four presidents of the Central Division of the American Philosophical Association have been Christians, including evangelicals like Alvin Plantinga, William Alston, Alan Donegan, and Nicholas Walter, indicating Christian philosophy's institutional prominence.

factualhigh valueestablishednovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“in the last what about seven eight years seven years four of the presidents of the Central Division American Philosophical Association of the Nevinger have been saving chuckles have been Christians in some cases evangelicals Alvin Plantinga William Alston Alan Donegan a few weeks ago and Nicholas Walter and this so this qualifies the thing one hopes”

0.56

Ordinary people like students and teachers, through stewardship of their gifts, contribute in measure to making both the history of philosophy and the history of their own days—history is made by people like the current audience.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 4/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“that's what history is made history is made by people like you it's ordinary people like us who with the stewardship of the gifts that we have contribute in some measure to making the history of philosophy and they're making the history of our days”

0.55

Christian philosophy should be characterized in four ways: as a perspectival tradition (operating from Christian perspective rather than bracketing theological beliefs), as exploratory (an ongoing process not a finished product), as pluralistic (encompassing diversity of methods and views while remaining self-critical), and as holistic (maintaining a comprehensive Christian worldview rather than working in specialized silos).

definitionhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 3/4durability 4/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“when I talk of Christian philosophy in the past and in the present and in the future I want to characterize it in in four ways a one as a perspectival tradition”

0.55

Naturalism is a reductionist position, and one problem with Whitehead's metaphysics is that he reduces persons to abstract events without categorical distinctiveness, whereas personalists like MacMurray insist on categorical distinctions between persons and other things—a distinction that needs developing in contemporary metaphysics.

factualhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“now naturalism is a reductionist position and one of the problems with whiteheads metaphysic is that he an effect reduces persons to simply can't make some things without any categorical distinctiveness McMurray was making a categorical distinction and I think that was very helpful”

0.55

Husserl's phenomenology's emphasis on intentionality is not so much a structure of thought but a structured way of relating to the other; phenomenology can be regarded as a different kind of empiricism in broad sense, focusing more on inner sense than outer sense, unlike the rationalist direction that has not been significantly continued.

definitionhigh valuecontestednovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“I think I have to say no that is to say innate ideas just aren't in the the a pre alrigh that's discussed these days is the a priori nature of logical truths of the form a equals a equals not a possibly a pre or I structures of some other sorts but even conte and categories no they are pretty well relativized the neo-kantian direction so no I think the general temper remains loosely empirical in that regards and I think that's true in European thought as well at least as far as April your eyes structures of thought are concerned yes Husserl's emphasis on intentionality is not so much a structure of thought but a structured way of relating to the other so I'm inclined to regard phenomenology is a different kind of empiricism and a broad sort that focus is more on the inner sense than the outer sense”

0.52

The key differences between Humean skepticism (influenced by Newtonian science with focus on necessary connection, induction, and moral determination) and postmodern relativism (influenced by relational, organic models recognizing interdependence of life and culture aspects) reflect their different scientific and philosophical backgrounds.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“I remember reading a book written in the 18th century called evenings with the sceptics... it was filled with references to Pierrot of airless and karne ADIZ and all that much but the interesting thing is while it was filled with references to that it was obviously working under the influence of Newtonian science and engaged in a criticism of Newtonian science there were certain key matters which become the focus of attention in the human type skepticism the idea of necessary connection the problem of induction can reason determine what is morally right things of that sort you see now you come on here what's was at work in this was the Newtonian science what work here is a much more relational organic model where we we recognize the interdependence of every aspect of life and culture on other things”

0.52

Bracketing one's theological beliefs and values in philosophy (a phenomenological technique) is not only inhumane but impossible, as even Descartes (who attempted it) could never completely achieve neutrality; intellectual honesty requires acknowledging where one is coming from rather than self-deceptively pretending to neutrality.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“Christian philosophers have given the impression that you do philosophy bracketing your theological beliefs bracketing your own attitudes and values and concerns I think that's not only inhuman I think it's impossible for humans bracketing that phenomenological device remember bracketing suspending judgment something that Descartes attempted just is never completely possible it wasn't for Descartes it wasn't for her son to take a completely neutral position to be completely neutral when in your heart of hearts you're not it's self-deception and so it seems to me that the path of intellectual honesty is to fess up that is to say to be quite straightforward about where you are coming from to admit it”

0.52

For Christians in philosophy, an important issue is the relationship between philosophical ethics and theological ethics, which have historically been somewhat separate: theological ethics has addressed the dynamics of ethical life (sin, grace) while philosophical ethics addressed ethical decision-making (principles and reasoning), but virtue ethics is making a difference by bridging this gap.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“one for Christians in philosophy is the relationship between philosophical and theological ethics the relationship between philosophical and theological ethics and I think for a number of years they have been somewhat separate in this regard the by-and-large theological ethicists have been addressing the dynamics of the ethical life that is to say bringing to bear concepts like sin and grace whereas philosophical ethics has been addressing matters of ethical decision making bringing principles to bear in decision and because therefore the agendas of the two have been different different an agenda for theological ethics than for philosophical ethics there's been relatively little integration of the theology with the philosophy accept certain obvious points like divine command theories or natural law ethics things of that however the the development of virtue ethics is making a difference”

0.50

Recent developments in metaphysics, which grew out of work in philosophy of language, are likely to remain and grow because metaphysical inquiry becomes self-sustaining once initiated, whereas philosophy of language was needed to legitimize metaphysics after decades of dismissal as meaningless.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 2/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“there are some other recent developments that are likely to remain and grow the interest in metaphysics which I was talking about last time as it has outgrown out of developments in philosophy of language I'm inclined to think that that a met the developments in metaphysics will be self-sustaining rather than being sustained for philosophy of language a philosophy of language is the sort of thing you need to get going after people have been telling you that metaphysics is meaningless but once you get going it becomes self-sustaining you don't need a lot of work in philosophy of language to keep sustain so I expect that metaphysical development to to keep going”

0.48

The mind-body problem will receive particular emphasis in metaphysical work, with mind-body dualism having articulate philosophical defenders like Richard Swinburne.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Philosophy Professor

“with particular emphasis on mind barding relationships mind-body problem where a lot of work has been going on and where mind-body dualism has some very articulate philosophical defendants like Richard Swinburne who was here on campus just a couple of years ago”

0.47

The analytic and phenomenological philosophical camps have little mutual understanding and often mutual disrespect, with this divide becoming particularly politicized in the Eastern Division of the American Philosophical Association, creating a split profession.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Philosophy Professor

“this divide which we've seen historically continues and I think you have to say with little mutual understanding and oftentimes little mutual respect the analytic types often speak with disparagement of the phenomenological and the phenomenological often speak with disparagement of the analytic a pathetic situation in fact in the Eastern Division of the American Philosophical Association Eastern Division being or what should we say Pennsylvania and East it's become quite politicized so that you have really a very split divided profession”

0.43

Philosophy in America is broadly empirical and broadly analytic in methodology, and the speaker advises prospective philosophers that they should not pursue philosophy unless they can stomach analytic work and have a mind for detailed conceptual and argumentative analysis.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“the general picture is that philosophy in America is of the broadly empirical broadly analytic sort and that's the methodological characterization it's in the light of that that I'm inclined to say to people wanting to go on in philosophy don't unless you can stomach a certain amount of analytic stuff and if you can't work in that sort of detail and don't have a mind for it don't go on in philosophy”

0.43

If a person is primarily interested in the history of ideas rather than working with philosophical issues, arguments, and concepts in detail, they should pursue history of ideas rather than philosophy proper, because philosophy is much more minute in its attention even though history of ideas may not be as history-shaping as philosophy.

normativehigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“if what infuses you in terms you on is the history of ideas rather than working with issues and arguments and concepts and so forth then maybe you should go on in the history of ideas rather than in philosophy as such which tends to be much more minut in its attention though frankly I don't think the history of ideas is as history shaping in the history of ideas as is philosophy history shaping in the history of ideas something if you're interested in being where the action is in terms of shaping history its philosophy but if you like to live in the past then the history of ideas okay”

0.43

Applied ethics increasingly emphasizes respect for persons as one of the three main approaches (along with utilitarianism and contractarianism), suggesting a practical revival of Kantian principles, and to ground respect for persons and contrast it with reductionist utilitarianism, one needs categorical distinctions requiring a priori knowledge of some kind.

factualhigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 3/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“in applied ethics the Kantian principle of respect for persons as being reiterated renewed it's perhaps more pervasive in applied ethics these days than some of the old utilitarianism the three main principles or approaches seem to be either utilitarianism or respect for persons or some contract Arian basis I think in order to ground contract and respect for persons and if you like to have a utilitarianism that's not going to say simply maximizing the good for everything cabbages as well as Kings you need some categorical distinctions in terms of a priori knowledge to that extent”

0.39

The speaker once thought a fourth philosophical model might be emerging—a personalistic model influenced by Scottish philosopher John MacMurray, who emphasized the 'I-Thou' relationship rather than the 'I-It' relationship, and created categorical distinctions between persons and other things, but now considers this more wishful thinking as MacMurray is virtually unheard of.

forecasthigh valuespeaker onlynovelty 1/4durability 2/4· Unknown Academic Speaker

“I don't know a few years ago I used to think that there was a a fourth one emerging that I called a personalistic model I I was thinking of the Scottish philosopher John McMurray who now is virtually unheard of so I don't talk so much about it wishful thinking”