What this covers
John Horgan and host Russ Roberts examine the mind-body problem—consciousness, free will, and the question of who we are—through interviews Horgan conducted with philosophers, neuroscientists, and others who have grappled with these questions. The conversation centers on Horgan's central claim: that unlike traditional scientific problems such as photosynthesis or gravity, the mind-body problem may resist objective resolution because subjectivity is woven irreducibly into it. Rather than converging on a unifying theory over decades of research, competing approaches to consciousness have remained fragmented, suggesting the problem might have no single correct answer waiting to be discovered.
Horgan argues that this irreducibility of subjectivity should be celebrated rather than lamented. He contends that free will and meaning arise not from scientific truth but from the choices we make and the freedom to construct our own understanding of human nature. The discussion ranges across philosophy, psychology, and political economy: Adam Smith's concept of the Man of System illustrates how totalizing visions of human nature lead to destruction; the Enlightenment's worship of Reason, while materially beneficial, carried the dangerous assumption that one correct way of thinking about ourselves exists; modern democracies function as an Anti-Utopia, allowing diverse communities—fundamentalist, Buddhist, psychedelic—to flourish rather than imposing a single vision of the good life. Throughout, Horgan emphasizes that thinkers' supposedly rational positions are shaped by personal crises and identity struggles, making the case that freedom to choose our meaning should trump any claim to have found the truth about human nature.
Horgan argues that the mind-body problem (consciousness, free will, who we are) has no single objective scientific solution, that subjectivity is irreducible from these questions, and that freedom to choose our own identity and meaning should be prized over any claim to have found 'the' truth about human nature.
- Decades of consciousness research never converged on a unifying paradigm, suggesting the problem may be unsolvable objectively
- Single-answer theories of human nature (utopias, ideologies) have historically led to disaster, so freedom should trump truth
- Personal experience and identity crises demonstrably shape thinkers' supposedly rational intellectual positions
Humans naturally seek grand narratives and ideologies to resolve ambiguity into unified answers.
- As Ed Leamer put it, humans are story-telling, pattern-seeking animals who are tempted by utopias, ideologies, and religions to organize their thinking, and there is a strong urge to resolve ambiguous things into a single verdict (the Enlightenment is good or bad) when the honest answer is that it is both.
“I know the insight of Ed Leamer, EconTalk guest, who said 'We are story-telling, pattern-seeking animals.' And we really like those utopias, those ideologies, those religions”
- Although the Enlightenment and the liberation of reason produced glorious material benefits, the worship of Reason and the idea that there is only one correct way to think of ourselves is a seductive and potentially dangerous idea.
“the worship of Reason can be extremely dangerous. And this idea that there's only one correct way to think of ourselves, I agree with you, is a seductive and potentially dangerous idea.”
Attempts to impose systematic control on human affairs ignore people's own desires and agency.
- Adam Smith's 'man of system' in The Theory of Moral Sentiments thinks humanity can be moved around like pieces on a chessboard, ignoring that people have their own modes of motion and desires; attempts to impose one's will on that chessboard tend to lead to death and destruction.
“the man of system thinks that humanity is just like pieces on a chess board that you can move around without being conscious of how--that they have their own modes of motion and their own desires; and the people who try to impose their will on that chessboard do tend to lead to death and destruction.”
- Democracy understood as pure majority rule is dangerous because 52% of the people could vote to brutalize or run the lives of the other 48%; the United States is deliberately a republic, not a majority-rule democracy, and there is a dangerous fetishization of majority rule as 'the will of the people.'
“a sort of worship of Democracy as a majority rule of democracy as "the will of the people" when it could be 52% of the people wanting to brutalize the other 48% or run their lives is really a dangerous thing.”
Impermanence, not transcendent schemes, is what gives life its genuine meaning and value.
- Although permanence seems to be the hallmark of meaning—Alan Lightman doubts anything impermanent can matter since all stars will eventually burn out—the opposite is true: impermanence is precisely what gives life its meaning, because if we lived forever nothing today would matter, so the finitude of time gives life its bittersweetness.
“even though permanence seems to be the hallmark of meaning, impermanence is what gives life its meaning... If we lived forever, who cares what happens today... It's a fact that the time period is finite is what gives life its extraordinary bittersweetness.”
- Scientific schemes for transcendent immortality—uploading into cyberspace, becoming sentient gas clouds surviving heat death, as Freeman Dyson proposed—are desperate attempts by people who don't believe in God to create a substitute God to solve the impermanence problem, and Horgan sees this as a kind of human pathology.
“so many of these scientific explorations--the brain in the box... immortality through the singularity, what you just mentioned of Freeman Dyson's--these are desperate attempts by people who don't believe in God to create a God that's different.”
Markets and biological explanations must be evaluated honestly without confusing regulation with freedom or excuse with causation.
- American health care is an unbelievably highly-regulated market, not a free market—the out-of-pocket share of spending has steadily decreased since 1950 alongside rising quality and expenditure—so its poor results should not be judged as a product of free choice.
“If you look at the proportion of our health care spending that is out of pocket, versus paid by third party, the out-of-pocket portion has steadily decreased since about 1950, coinciding with a massive increase in both quality and expenditure.”
- Science teaches that we have biological urges hard to resist, but if we are not careful this becomes an excuse that erases personal responsibility—as when a scientist who destroyed his marriage by cheating rationalizes it as just biology—so biological explanation must be supplemented with the potential for personal responsibility.
“that's what science teaches us, but if we're not careful it will lead us astray, if we don't add to it the potential for personal responsibility.”
- EconTalk episodes back to 2006 are available on the iPhone Podcast App and via year-specific feeds, and a free third-party app called Economics carries every episode.
“if you search for EconTalk on your iPhone Podcast App, in addition to the regular feed, you will also find individual years' episodes.”