Marxism
An economic and political ideology based on critiques of capitalism and class relations, advocating for communal ownership and the abolition of class hierarchies
As defined in Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politics | Big Think
Where it comes up · 5
- Barthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism4 claims
- Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politics | Big Think3 claims
- Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory3 claims
- Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel1 claim
- Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “Marxism” →
- Roland Barthes made a decisive break with structuralism and Marxism, organizing his investigations around semiotics (the theory of signs) which drove contemporary French culture toward post-structuralism and post-modernismBarthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism
- Althusser tried to unify Marxism and structuralism as the last of the modernist paradigms—giant deterministic systems shown to operate simultaneously as part of a larger meta-system—but Barthes rejects this, arguing that structuralism and Marxism inhibit and prohibit human freedom and entail totalizing meta-narratives that people no longer believe inBarthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism
- Stalin read widely and appeared to be an intelligent person, but in all his annotations in his books, there is no hint of doubt about Marxism; this suggests that dogmatism of Soviet communist culture (influenced by Lenin) and Stalin's Georgian cultural background both contributed to his ideological rigidity.Tyler Cowen in Discussion With Dwarkesh Patel
- Derrida and Foucault were barely repentant Marxists who were part of the student revolutions in France in the 1960s, but by the end of the 1960s the evidence from the Soviet Union and Maoist China of the devastating consequences of Marxism made it impossible to be apologetic for it, so French intellectuals transformed Marxism into post-modern identity politics.Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politics | Big Think
- Lyotard directly targets Jürgen Habermas's project of founding moral and political legitimacy on the basis of rational consensus achieved through ideal speech situations, arguing that consensus is inherently unjust because it silences alternative discourses.Jean-Francois Lyotard: The Post-modern Condition
- Marxism survives in universities as intellectual shelter for ideas that have collapsed everywhere else in the world; universities function as 'game parks' protecting endangered intellectual species like Marxists from real-world Darwinian competition.Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory
- Utilitarianism and efficiency arguments represent Anglo-American philosophical tradition friendly to capitalism and rational calculation of input-output; pragmatism represents muddle-through approach to the failure of positivism's reductive program.Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory
- Alvin Gouldner, as 'renegade Marxist' and 'Socratic Marxist,' represents the exception: rather than using Marxist apparatus to critique only society, he turns it on Marxism itself, applying Marxian class analysis to intellectuals rather than just bourgeoisie, exemplifying reflexivity.Conclusion: Political, Social and Cultural Criticism and Theory
- Post-modernists respond to the coherence problem by defaulting to a loose, egalitarian Marxism without any real attempt to grapple with the cognitive dissonance, using post-modernism as an intellectual gloss to hide the fact that a discredited economic theory is being used to fuel an educational movement and produce activists.Jordan Peterson: The fatal flaw in leftist American politics | Big Think
- The result of semiotic thinking is a world in which we are all profoundly lonely—we have whole societies composed of atomized individuals all united together through shared myths but not through shared realityBarthes, Semiotics and the Revolt Against Structuralism