Malthusian trap
The condition in which improvements in technology are absorbed by population growth rather than rising living standards, keeping average welfare roughly constant
As defined in 209 | Brad DeLong on Why the 20th Century Fell Short of Utopia
Where it comes up · 4
- How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)2 claims
- Andrew McAfee on More from Less2 claims
- 209 | Brad DeLong on Why the 20th Century Fell Short of Utopia1 claim
- Robin Hanson on the Technological Singularity 01/03/20111 claim
Most important claims · 6 of 6Search all claims for “Malthusian trap” →
- The Industrial Revolution let humanity escape the Malthusian trap mainly through agriculture: steamships and trains moved fertilizer sources like Chilean sodium nitrate and South American guano to factories and farms, skyrocketing agricultural productivity so that exponentially growing populations could be fed—not simply through trains and factories themselves.Andrew McAfee on More from Less
- Before 1870, slow technological progress (under half a percent per year) was neutralized by population growth, because patriarchal social structures forced women to keep having children to secure surviving sons, producing irresistible Malthusian pressures that meant better technology was offset by ever-smaller farm sizes, so living standards in 1870 were not much different from 6000 BC.209 | Brad DeLong on Why the 20th Century Fell Short of Utopia
- Malthus was broadly correct as a historian—population and prosperity did oscillate in a trap for centuries, as Gregory Clark's UK data from 1200-1800 shows—but he was one of the worst forecasters because he wrote just as the Industrial Revolution was about to break the pattern.Andrew McAfee on More from Less
- Under emulation, if population grows faster than wealth, the world enters a Malthusian regime where most copies live near subsistence, even though total wealth is much larger, and luxuries such as preserving sunsets would be bought only by a small rich minority.Robin Hanson on the Technological Singularity 01/03/2011
- Even after the emergence of urban civilization, it took a couple thousand years until the real escape from the Malthusian trap began, and that escape started only about 300 years ago—a very recent development in human history.How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)
- Population size, not intelligence, determines the level of sustainable technology and cooperation: genetically identical Australian and New Zealand populations diverged because the smaller, isolated New Zealand group of ~20,000 lost bows, arrows, and complex boats—demonstrating that civilization, complex technology, and modern economies require large numbers of people, which only sedentary agricultural living made possible.How We Tamed Ourselves and Invented Good and Evil (with Hanno Sauer)