Hidden Variables
Additional elements posited beyond the wave function in some interpretations of quantum mechanics to explain definite measurement outcomes.
As defined in ms_200
Other definitions
A class of quantum interpretations (such as pilot-wave theory) positing additional underlying variables that determine measurement outcomes deterministically.
Holiday Message 2021 | On Disciplines & Cocktails
Where it comes up · 19
- Quantum Entanglement: Spooky Action at a Distance9 claims
- 59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics7 claims
- 241 | Tim Maudlin on Locality, Hidden Variables, and Quantum Foundations4 claims
- 36 | David Albert on Quantum Measurement and the Problems with Many-Worlds3 claims
- The 9 Experiments That Will Change Your View of Light (And Blow Your Mind)3 claims
- 124 - In Search Of Reality2 claims
- 262 | Eric Schwitzgebel on the Weirdness of the World2 claims
- 323 | Jacob Barandes on Indivisible Stochastic Quantum Mechanics2 claims
and 11 more
Most important claims · 10 of 47Search all claims for “Hidden Variables” →
- John von Neumann's famous proof, widely cited as showing quantum mechanics must be fundamentally chance-driven and that hidden variables are impossible, did not actually prove that; Bell found it fell apart on inspection, ruling out only a particular kind of hidden variable, a flaw Grete Hermann had identified within a few years of its 1935 publication but which was ignored.59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics
- John Bell, struck by Bohm's non-local hidden-variable theory, derived Bell's inequalities showing that quantum mechanics requires some kind of non-locality—proving that local hidden-variable theories are impossible, not that hidden-variable theories in general are impossible; the Nobel Committee got this exactly backwards in its press release, even though Bell was actually a strong booster of hidden-variable theories like Bohmian mechanics.Holiday Message 2022: Thinking Really Slowly
- Grete Hermann was the first to point out that John von Neumann's supposed proof of the impossibility of hidden variables did not work, but no one believed her; only Einstein independently appreciated the mistake and pointed it out to David Bohm, who then invented Bohmian mechanics, inspiring John Bell and leading eventually to the entanglement Nobel Prize.254 | William Egginton on Kant, Heisenberg, and Borges
- Einstein, who cared deeply about quantum foundations and read German, recognized that von Neumann's celebrated proof against hidden variables relied on assumptions that might not be true and thus proved nothing about the real world, and conveying this to David Bohm prompted Bohm to construct a working hidden-variable theory (Bohmian/de Broglie-Bohm mechanics) that is explicitly non-local.Holiday Message 2022: Thinking Really Slowly
- The Copenhagen interpretation does not actually attribute wave-function collapse to consciousness; that view was proposed much later by Eugene Wigner and is believed by almost no one. Bohr and Heisenberg tied collapse to measurement and a microscopic/macroscopic distinction, explicitly denying any role for consciousness—and von Neumann's formalism is what forced the wave function to evolve in two incompatible ways.318 - Physics Philosophy
- David Bohm wrote a respected textbook expounding the Copenhagen view, was praised by Einstein for its clarity but persuaded by Einstein's objections that he didn't understand his own book ('I'm back to square one'), and within a year independently rediscovered de Broglie's hidden-variable theory, publishing it as a two-part paper in 1952.241 | Tim Maudlin on Locality, Hidden Variables, and Quantum Foundations
- Von Neumann's widely believed proof that hidden variables were mathematically impossible was not a mathematical mistake but a conceptual one — caught at the time by Grete Hermann but ignored — and Bohm's 1952 theory demonstrated that the supposedly impossible could in fact be done.241 | Tim Maudlin on Locality, Hidden Variables, and Quantum Foundations
- John Clauser, with Stuart Freedman, performed the first experimental test of Bell's inequalities around 1971-72 and found quantum mechanics held (ruling out local hidden variables), yet because he did this as a postdoc without a permanent position, the foundational work damaged rather than advanced his career.59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics
- Bohm's pilot-wave theory is the hidden-variable theory Einstein wanted, but instead of avoiding spooky action at a distance it is riddled with it, so that shaking a magnet would instantaneously affect the position of every electron in the universe; Bell remarked it resolved EPR in the way Einstein would have liked least.59 | Adam Becker on the Curious History of Quantum Mechanics
- Bell's theorem does not eliminate hidden variables; it proves that quantum mechanical correlations between measurements on separated systems can exceed what any purely local theory could reproduce, where 'local' means both that things exist only at local points in space and that signals cannot travel faster than light. Non-local hidden variable theories like Bohmian mechanics remain fully compatible with observation.AMA | May 2021