
What this covers
This 15-minute Fermilab video has Don Lincoln walk through how two particles can be described by a single wave function and what that means once they are separated. It starts with how entangled spin pairs are made: a zero-spin parent particle decays into two daughters, and because spin is conserved, one must point opposite the other. It then uses a red-and-blue-ball-in-boxes analogy to set out the hidden variables view, in which outcomes are fixed when the particles separate, against the standard view that spin stays indeterminate until measured.
The middle of the video is the Bell's Theorem Framework, laid out with a graph. Aligned measurements and perpendicular measurements give the same predictions in both pictures, with 100% anti-correlation in the first case and 50% in the second. At intermediate angles the predictions split: quantum mechanics follows a cosine-squared curve and hidden variables follow a linear interpolation. John Bell's 1964 prediction and Alain Aspect's 1981 test, plus later work by others, put the experimental points on the quantum curve. The video also sets this against the 1935 paper by Einstein, Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen, and the "spooky action at a distance" complaint.
The more contentious turns come after the experiments. Measurements made within about five billionths of a second across ten feet still show perfect anti-correlation, so the link outpaces light. Yet relativity survives, because the outcome is statistical and uncontrollable, and the correlation shows up only when the two sets of results are compared. The video closes by noting that entanglement can appear at scales as large as people, that it underlies quantum computing and teleportation, and that the interpretations of what it says about reality are all stranger than the theory, with no agreement on which is right.
Quantum entanglement demonstrates that quantum mechanics operates through fundamentally non-local correlations faster than light, definitively ruling out classical hidden variable explanations and requiring a new understanding of quantum interconnectivity.
- Bell's theorem and Aspect's experiments show quantum mechanics predictions diverge from hidden variables across measurement angles
- Measurements of entangled particles exhibit correlations at speeds exceeding light propagation, yet preserve Einstein's relativity through statistical indeterminacy
- Classical intuition about predetermined particle properties is experimentally falsified
This asset isn't compiled yet
You're seeing its claims, ranked. Compile it to build the argument threads, weight them, and check each claim against your library — the full view.
The exact interpretation and meaning of what quantum entanglement reveals about reality remains an open area of scientific discussion, with multiple proposed interpretations, all of which are weirder than quantum mechanics itself and with no agreement on which is correct.
“Another feature of this measurement is that scientists have thought very carefully about exactly what it means. There are some ideas, but all are weirder than quantum mechanics. And, of course, nobody knows if those ideas are right or not.”
Einstein coauthored a paper in 1935 with Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen highlighting the problem of apparent faster-than-light information transfer in quantum mechanics, and called this phenomenon 'spooky action at a distance,' which was one reason he disliked quantum mechanics.
“In fact, he coauthored a paper in 1935 with Boris Podolsky and Nathan Rosen that highlighted this problem. He also called this transfer of quantum information 'spooky action at a distance.' This was one of many reasons why Einstein didn't like quantum mechanics.”
Bell's prediction in 1964 and Aspect's test in 1981, along with contributions from many others, provided experimental methods to distinguish between quantum mechanics and hidden variable theories by examining how measurement outcomes correlate across different measurement directions.
“There is a long history of this, with a prediction in 1964 by theorist John Bell and a test in 1981 by Alain Aspect, as well as contributions by many others.”
Quantum entanglement is a phenomenon where quantum behaviors normally confined to atomic scales can manifest at sizes as large as people or even larger.
“quantum entanglement allows for weird quantum behaviors to be seen on sizes as big as people or even larger”
A classical 'hidden variable' theory proposes that entangled particle properties (like their spin directions) are predetermined at the moment the particles are separated, rather than being genuinely indeterminate until measured, using the analogy of a red and blue ball placed in boxes where the outcome is determined when the boxes are separated, not when opened.
“Well there were some people, including Einstein, who thought that this wasn't so mysterious at all. Suppose you had a red and blue ball, but you couldn't look at them. You grab both of them and put them in boxes and separate the boxes. Later, you look in one of the boxes and see that it contains a blue ball. It will surprise nobody that the other ball is red. The answer was determined at the moment the balls were put in the boxes, not when the first ball was observed.”
Measurements of entangled particles can exhibit perfect anti-correlation even when performed so quickly (within 5 billionths of a second across 10 feet) that light cannot travel between them, implying quantum information travels faster than light.
“It will take light ten billionths of a second to travel from one to the other. So now let's get tricky. We'll measure the horizontal spin of one of the two particles and see that it's to the right. Then, five billionths of a second later, we measure the horizontal spin of the other particle. We find, 100% of the time, that it's to the left. And remember that we did it so fast that not even light could have told the second particle the outcome of the measurement of the first particle. That means that quantum information can travel faster than light.”
Although quantum information appears to travel faster than light in entanglement, this does not invalidate Einstein's theory of relativity because the apparent faster-than-light transfer cannot be controlled, and information can only be compared after both measurements are made, so usable information cannot travel faster than light.
“Does quantum information move at speeds faster than light? Yeah- it seems to. But it doesn't invalidate Einstein's theory of relativity because we can't control it. We can make both measurements and the outcome will seem random and we'll only know that the two were opposite when we compare the measurements and that information can be transferred no faster than the speed of light. So that saves Einstein's theory, which is a relief.”
Faster-than-light quantum information transfer does not enable faster-than-light communication because the collapse of the wave function remains statistical and cannot transmit a controlled message.
“First the biggie– no, this does not mean that you can use this to transfer actual information. The collapse of the wave function is still statistical, and it cannot transmit a message. So sorry, we're still stuck with light-speed communication for practical matters.”
Entangled particles with opposite spin can be created by taking a parent particle with zero spin and allowing it to decay into two particles, because spin is a conserved quantity that cannot change; thus if one daughter particle has spin left, the other must have spin right, maintaining the zero total.
“You'd do this by taking a parent particle which, in our example, has zero spin, and let it decay into two particles. Spin is a conserved quantity, which means that it can never change. So, if the parent particle has zero spin, then the two daughter particles have to have opposite spin. If one has a spin pointing left, the other is right. If one is up, the other is down, and so on. When you add the two, you get the zero that you started with.”
Quantum entanglement and non-local quantum interconnectivity have practical applications in quantum computing and quantum teleportation technologies.
“The good news is that this new quantum interconnectivity can be useful in such things as quantum computing and quantum teleportation.”
Experimental measurements of entangled particle correlations across varying measurement angles—shown as black dots on the graph—follow the quantum mechanics predictions and definitively rule out hidden variable theories as complete explanations of entanglement.
“Well these black dots show the measurement and they are quite definitive. Quantum mechanics is correct and the whole idea of hidden variables is completely ruled out.”
Two entangled particles remain connected by a single wave function even when separated by vast distances—feet, miles, or even larger distances—as long as they do not interact with anything else.
“The entanglement doesn't depend on the two particles being close to one another. As long as the two particles don't interact with anything, you can separate them by feet, miles, or even huge distances, and the two particles are connected by a single wave function and the two particles will have opposite spin.”
Bell's theorem predicts mathematically different correlations between quantum mechanics and hidden variable theories when measuring entangled particle spins at various angles relative to each other, with quantum mechanics predicting violations of classical Bell inequalities that hidden variables must satisfy.
“So now we're ready for the final bit, which is to look at all possible measurement directions for the second particle and see if the predictions are different for quantum mechanics and hidden variables.”
A wave function governs the probability that you will find a subatomic particle in a particular configuration, and before measurement, you cannot know—even in principle—what configuration the particle is in.
“the wave function governs the probability that you will find the particle in a particular configuration. Before you make a measurement, you can't know- even in principle- what configuration the particle is in.”
When measuring the spin of a quantum particle, the outcome will always be either in the measurement direction picked or exactly opposite—it cannot be anywhere in between, and any direction perpendicular to the measurement axis is forbidden.
“when you measure the direction of the spin of a particle, you first have to pick a direction and then the outcome will always be either in the direction you picked or exactly opposite. It can't be anywhere in between. So, if you picked a measurement direction to be horizontal, the measurement of the spin direction could be left or right. It couldn't be up or down, forward or back, or any direction except for right or left.”
Prior to measurement, the wave function may say a particle's spin axis could be in any direction, and the most popular understanding of quantum mechanics holds that the spin direction actually is in all directions allowed by the wave function until measurement causes the wave function to collapse.
“prior to the measurement, the wave function might say that the spin axis of the particle could be in any direction- indeed, the most popular understanding of quantum mechanics says that the spin direction actually is in all directions allowed by the wave function. It's only when you make a measurement that the wave function collapses, and the outcome becomes real.”
Two subatomic particles can be entangled, meaning both particles are described by a single wave function rather than individual wave functions, such that they are fundamentally connected despite spatial separation.
“it's possible to prepare two subatomic particles so they both are described by a single wave function. That's what we mean by entangled. Two particles and a single wave function.”
When measuring the spin of one of two entangled particles along a chosen direction and finding a specific outcome (e.g., right), the measurement outcome of the other particle along the same direction is 100% determined to be opposite (e.g., left), revealing that quantum information has been transferred between the particles.
“The real weirdness arises when we measure the spin direction of both of the entangled particles. Say we measure the horizontal spin direction of this particle over here on the left and the measurement says it's to the right. Then we know the outcome of the other measurement. It will be- 100% of the time- left. A hundred percent of the time. That means that the information that one of the two particles had a measurement made on it was transported to the other particle.”
When one entangled particle's spin is measured in the vertical direction (finding spin up) and the other's spin is measured in the horizontal direction (perpendicular), the second measurement will yield right and left outcomes with equal 50% probability, providing zero predictive information about which outcome occurs given the first measurement, consistent with both quantum mechanics and hidden variable predictions.
“The first measurement is in the vertical direction and it finds the particle has spin up. When you measure the spin of the second, you measure it in the horizontal direction, and you get right and left with equal probability. The first measurement gives you zero predictive information about the second measurement. It turns out that both quantum mechanics and hidden variables make the same prediction for this scenario.”
When the first particle's spin is measured upward and the second particle's measurement direction is varied through 360 degrees, quantum mechanics and hidden variable theories make different predictions about the correlation strength: at 0 degrees (aligned, measuring downward), both predict 100% anti-correlation; at 90 degrees (perpendicular, measuring rightward), both predict 50% matching probability; but the mathematical functions diverge across other angles, with quantum mechanics following a cosine-squared relationship while hidden variables follow a linear interpolation.
“We will still assume that the spin direction measurement for the first particle is upward and then measure the spin direction for the second particle, starting upward and then slowly spinning the measurement through 360 degrees. This graph shows the predictions of how often the second measurement will be in the direction the second arrow is pointing. If the second arrow is pointing upward, we know that the second measurement is always downward, so that means the second measurement agrees zero percent of the time. If the second arrow is pointing at 90 degrees to the right, the second measurement can be right or left with equal probability, so it will be to the right only 50% of the time. If the second arrow is pointing downward, we know that the second measurement always is downward, so it is in that direction 100% of the time.”
The predictions from hidden variables and quantum mechanics diverge at certain measurement angles, which is the key distinguishing feature that enables experimental testing of the two theories.
“It's very important that we see that the predictions from hidden variables and quantum mechanics are different. This is key.”
The experimental ruling out of hidden variables means that the idea that measurement outcomes are predetermined at the moment particles are entangled is false, confirming instead that when measuring one particle, quantum information is transferred to the other particle at speeds faster than light.
“It means that the idea that the final measurement is already determined at the moment the two particles is entangled is false. It means that when you measure one of the two particles, the quantum information is transferred to the other particle at a speed faster than light.”
When both entangled particles' spins are measured in the same vertical direction, both quantum mechanics and hidden variables predict that if the first measurement finds spin up, the second measurement will always find spin down (100% of the time), with both theories giving identical predictions for this aligned measurement scenario.
“This is very different from if you made the second measurement in the vertical direction, because, if you did, you'd get a second measurement in the downward direction 100% of the time. Again, this is the same for both quantum mechanics and hidden variables.”
Classical physics and hidden variable interpretations simply do not apply in the quantum world; quantum mechanics is the correct framework for understanding subatomic phenomena.
“The bottom line is that, at a minimum, classical physics and hidden variables just don't apply in the quantum world. It's quantum mechanics all the way.”
The hidden variables interpretation, also called the 'technical name' for a more ordinary particle connection, proposes that predetermined particle properties explain observed correlations rather than genuine quantum non-locality.
“The technical name for this more ordinary connection is called 'hidden variables.'”
Quantum entanglement research is a thriving, active scientific field with ongoing discoveries and developments.
“And there is a lot more to learn, which is great, because this is a thriving research field these days.”