From the river to the sea
A slogan claiming all the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean for one people; debated here in both its Israeli right-wing and Hamas usages.
As defined in Year Zero of the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Hillel Cohen)
Other definitions
A slogan asserting that all the land between the Jordan River and the Mediterranean Sea belongs to one people; used by Palestinians for Palestine and mirrored by Klein Halevi for the land of Israel.
Yossi Klein Halevi on the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict
Where it comes up · 8
- A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)3 claims
- Is Israel Winning the War in Gaza? (with Andrew Fox)2 claims
- Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)2 claims
- Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer1 claim
- Yossi Klein Halevi on the Palestinian-Israeli Conflict1 claim
- Year Zero of the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Hillel Cohen)1 claim
- 362 - Six Months Of War1 claim
- Ben Shapiro Destiny Debate1 claim
Most important claims · 10 of 12Search all claims for “From the river to the sea” →
- At some point all peoples must decide whether to recover the past or build the future: surviving Polish Jews did not demand their lost houses back but built new lives elsewhere, and progress in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict requires Palestinian leadership willing to honor the past while building a future side by side—whereas the chant 'from the river to the sea' signals an aim to eliminate Israel, leaving Israelis convinced there is no one to talk to.Daniel Gordis on Israel and Impossible Takes Longer
- Slogans like 'intifada,' 'free Palestine,' and 'from the river to the sea' are suitcase words into which different people pack very different meanings, so most chanters do not hold the violent associations Israelis attach to them, and meaning is not fixed but varies by the chanter's conception.A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
- Although Israel has defeated every attempt to destroy it and emerged as the region's strongest country, this never changes how it is discussed by critics: for them it is perpetually 1948, with everything since treated as a temporary injustice destined to be wiped out—structurally identical to the way settler colonialists say North America will one day revert to Native land.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Even the original (more antisemitic) Hamas Charter, in Article 31, states that Jews and Christians can live peacefully under the rule of Islam, so the 'from the river to the sea' aim is framed by Hamas as Jews accepting Islamic sovereignty over the Holy Land rather than as the wholesale expulsion of Jews—and accurate quotation requires reading the charter's internal discrepancies in full rather than citing isolated passages.Year Zero of the Arab-Israeli Conflict (with Hillel Cohen)
- The biggest problem in society is that people sort into separate 'phantom worlds'—different realities for liberals and conservatives even in the same city—and a little information or firsthand cross-exposure dramatically reduces hostility (e.g., support for 'from the river to the sea' fell from 70% to 30% when students were told what it meant), so any rhetoric that encourages sorting is damaging.Ben Shapiro Destiny Debate
- Using Arnold Kling's Three Languages of Politics—liberals see oppressor versus oppressed, conservatives see civilization versus barbarism, libertarians see coercion versus voluntary action—much Western antagonism toward Israel is not Jew-hatred but stems from slotting Israel into the oppressor-versus-oppressed lens while ignoring the simultaneous civilization-versus-barbarism dimension.Is Israel Winning the War in Gaza? (with Andrew Fox)
- Hostility to Israel among particularly young Westerners is a taught pathology rooted in an oppressor/oppressed colonizer/colonized framework that always locates the oppressor as the white European and places Jews at the top of the oppressor hierarchy, which is why they can be taught out of it.362 - Six Months Of War
- Free speech protections should allow people to express any opinion about Israel and Palestine, including that there should be no Jewish state or chanting 'from the river to the sea,' but a line should be drawn at angry mobs that barricade people in buildings or threaten violence, regardless of what slogan they chant.A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)
- Slogans like 'Free Palestine' and 'From the river to the sea' are fundamentally a desire to turn the clock back to 1948 and treat the establishment of a Jewish state as illegitimate—not a call for a two-state solution or right of return, but a wish that the state had never existed and an honoring of those working to unravel it.Understanding the Settler Colonialism Movement (with Adam Kirsch)
- Pro-Palestinian rallies consistently feature themes of 'free Palestine / from the river to the sea' and 'ceasefire' but, as far as Roberts knows, have never paired them with a 'not in our name' condemnation of October 7th or a call to free the hostages, and hostage posters have been defaced and torn down, which Israelis find alienating.A Lively Debate on the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict (with Robert Wright)