First Amendment
The U.S. constitutional provision protecting freedom of speech and the press, invoked by Gawker as a defense for publishing true material.
As defined in Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial
Where it comes up · 16
- Patrick McKenzie — Money laundering, big tech censorship, SBF & Japan2 claims
- Your Mind Has Been Lying to You - Sam Harris (4K)1 claim
- Jimmy Wales1 claim
- Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial1 claim
- Niall Ferguson on Free Speech and Kissinger's Role in the Middle East1 claim
- How the Constitution Can Bring Us Together (with Yuval Levin)1 claim
- 307 - Twitter Elon Free Speech1 claim
- 274 - The Future Of American Democracy1 claim
and 8 more
Most important claims · 10 of 17Search all claims for “First Amendment” →
- Republicanism presumes citizens who embody selflessness, accommodation, restraint, deliberation, and service, but liberal institutions alone cannot produce such citizens; this vision is a precondition for a free society that must be cultivated by pre-modern institutions—family, religion, and certain educational and cultural institutions—which the First Amendment protects but does not automatically fill.How the Constitution Can Bring Us Together (with Yuval Levin)
- Brandeis's 1927 counter-speech doctrine — that the cure for evil speech is more speech and the free market of ideas will self-correct — has proven untrue in the Trumpian age of 35,000 lies and flooded zones, undermining a foundational reason for not censoring; this leaves us in a dangerous place where, if we become outcome-focused, we may respect free-speech rights less.274 - The Future Of American Democracy
- Gawker believed that provided something was true it was fully covered by the First Amendment, and combined this with the high libel standard requiring actual malice and the reluctance of subjects to force the issue, giving them a dual layer of protection.Ryan Holiday on Conspiracy, Gawker, and the Hulk Hogan Trial
- Unlike the US with its written constitution and First Amendment, the UK has no written constitution but rather an evolved accretion of laws and customs, including an unwritten code of decency that has treated free speech as sacred — a protection now being trampled, with no codified document for judges to appeal to even when they condemn censorship as nonsense.382 - The Eye Of Nature
- Universities should be bedrock institutions for democratic citizenship that welcome competing views, and the right response to ideas we hate is counterargument, not suppression (per Justice Brandeis); protest of speakers is legitimate, but shutting down an invited speaker should violate norms—and even for private universities following First Amendment principles, those principles do not permit stopping others from speaking, so prohibiting such shutdowns is consistent with free speech.359 - Getting Used To It
- In Missouri v. Biden, the court accepted a well-supported record that government actors puppeteered tech companies as 'cat's paws' to commit shocking First Amendment violations—including White House officials pressuring platforms tweet-by-tweet and a state demanding YouTube remove a town-hall recording—and an NGO collaborator explicitly wrote that to evade First Amendment concerns they outsourced censorship to hired college students.Patrick McKenzie — Money laundering, big tech censorship, SBF & Japan
- Christian nationalism, as Wilson defines it, is not about fusing church and state; he supports the First Amendment and the separation of church and state, including opposing even hard establishment at the state level, while distinguishing this from the separation of morality and state, which he says is impossible.443 - What Is Christian Nationalism
- Society is being made increasingly ungovernable by a flood of lies on both political sides—right-of-center voices launder Russian propaganda about elections, foreign policy, Ukraine and vaccines, while left-of-center confusion about Israel produces a 'zombie apocalypse' of misinformed students—and although such speech is legally protected, private platforms and civil society organizations still ought to act to contain it, because if liberals stay confused about Islamic extremism the appetite for right-wing authoritarianism will keep growing.367 - Campus Protests Antisemitism And Western Values
- The first Amendment and free speech protections are crucial and sacred for limiting government power, but this is not the same as defending the right to algorithmic amplification that boosts misinformation to millions of people, and the two issues should not be conflated.Your Mind Has Been Lying to You - Sam Harris (4K)
- Taking an Enlightenment position, free speech applies especially to things people say that one dislikes and might be tempted to silence; in a free country everyone, including undergraduates, has the right to express obnoxious views as the price of true freedom, with limits only at explicit threats of violence against individuals.Niall Ferguson on Free Speech and Kissinger's Role in the Middle East