factual

Counter-Speech Doctrine Has Failed

Brandeis's 1927 counter-speech doctrine — that the cure for evil speech is more speech and the free market of ideas will self-correct — has proven untrue in the Trumpian age of 35,000 lies and flooded zones, undermining a foundational reason for not censoring; this leaves us in a dangerous place where, if we become outcome-focused, we may respect free-speech rights less.

factualpending

Speaker

Barton Gellman

Evidence Quote

“one of the foundational reasons uh we have for not censoring speech the idea that you can cure bad speech with good speech that just has actually proved not to be correct and that leads us to potentially a very bad place”

Source

274 - The Future Of American Democracy— Making Sense with Sam Harris
Created: 6/14/2026, 1:56:29 AM

Your notes

Loading notes...